News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Segwit2x Bitcoin Fork Suspended by xiphias on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @03:32PM (#15656672)
SegWit was a soft-fork block size increase with other scaling improvements. I'm strongly against having any hard fork in Bitcoin. The last Ethereum hard fork (when half of the devs wanted to cancel it because of the bug that was found) showed how dangerous it is. At this point Bitcoin is worth so much, that it's better to not touch it at all without a formal proof that the network is not harmed at all.

The biggest difference Segwit2x would make in centralization is the fact that block propagation latency is already very slow, and if it gets to over 10 minute for the whole network, the network can split.

Bitcoin is an amazing store of value, and those of us who hold the currency wouldn't accept any risk of increased centralization just because non-holders want low transaction fees (that can be very easily be created by a centralized system)

Re:Segwit2x Bitcoin Fork Suspended by lawn on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @03:42PM (#15656789)
Hard forks aren't dangerous. Monero has scheduled hard forks all the time. It's the best and cleanest way to upgrade.

> The biggest difference Segwit2x would make in centralization is the fact that block propagation latency is already very slow, and if it gets to over 10 minute for the whole network, the network can split.

Yet there's no research to remotely suggest a meager increase to 2MB would have any effect. Compact blocks and Xthin (and recently Graphene) also improves on this immensely.

> Bitcoin is an amazing store of value, and those of us who hold the currency wouldn't accept any risk of increased centralization

Typical black and white thinking. Bitcoin must have a primary use case that's not a store of value otherwise it will crash down when no new money is injected.

> just because non-holders want low transaction fees

Yeah because non-holders are the ones who want to use Bitcoin as was always intended. Pure holders are only in for the speculation.

The title of Bitcoin's whitepaper is "Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System" not "Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Store of Value System".

Re:Segwit2x Bitcoin Fork Suspended by ChrisClark on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @04:03PM (#15657005)
> The last Ethereum hard fork showed how dangerous it is.

The last hard fork was on Oct 15, 2017. It did not split the chain, it went smoothly and added great new features. Ethereum has had many hard forks. Only the DAO one was controversial. Using hard forks to upgrade the network is smooth and works great.

Re:Segwit2x Bitcoin Fork Suspended by xwvvvvwx on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @04:13PM (#15657098)
What are the technical reasons that mean bitcoin has such a long time between blocks? Other large chains (Ethereum, Litecoin) have significantly lower confirmation times.
Re:Segwit2x Bitcoin Fork Suspended by wmf on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @04:45PM (#15657389)
Lower block times increase orphan risk and increase the size of the chain (because there are more block headers), but I suspect Satoshi pulled 10 minutes out of the air and now it can't be realistically changed.
Re:Segwit2x Bitcoin Fork Suspended by xwvvvvwx on Wednesday November 08, 2017 @04:52PM (#15657461)
now it can't be realistically changed

why?