News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by falcolas on Sunday November 05, 2017 @09:32AM (#15629545)
> But they are not falsifiable.

I disagree. Historians are constantly making predictions of events happening today, based on their knowledge of history. Some are accurate, some are not. They can then take this output, and use it to refine the views of history.

This doesn't even cover how history is written by very unreliable narrators, and historians have to do more than learn the "what" to uncover the "how".

Your argument is also somewhat limited to History, when Philosophy, Psycology, and other liberal arts degrees do not have the same limitations.

Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by rayiner on Sunday November 05, 2017 @09:41AM (#15629581)
“Falsifiability” is a word with meaning. If you identify a single counter example to a mathematical conjecture, the conjecture is wrong. That is not true for history, philosophy, psychology, or the other liberal arts.
Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by frankling_ on Sunday November 05, 2017 @10:19AM (#15629774)
Your statement is obviously false (counter example: analytic philosophy produces conjectures that are black-or-white-falsifiable on the exact same basis as mathematical conjectures). Since you are engaging in epistemology, you may appreciate that the above is also an example of what falsification looks like when it is not formal. I'd suggest reading some Popper.
Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by brownbat on Sunday November 05, 2017 @11:44AM (#15630176)
Seconded. I'd add Wittgenstein and Quine to the list.

Two Dogmas would be a good place to end up.

Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by foldr on Sunday November 05, 2017 @10:06AM (#15629712)
You can certainly counterexemplify philosophical arguments.

It's also weird to suggest that no historical claims are falsifiable. That seems to put real history on a par with nutty conspiracy theories.

Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by wolfgke on Sunday November 05, 2017 @10:16AM (#15629756)
> It's also weird to suggest that no historical claims are falsifiable. That seems to put real history on a par with nutty conspiracy theories.

In my humble opinion the scarceness of falsifiability in history is the reason why it is so easy to create nutty conspiracy theories about history vs, say, mathematics or physics.

Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by mcguire on Sunday November 05, 2017 @11:20AM (#15630049)
There are plenty of nutty mathematical or physics theories around.

History is roughly as falsifiable as astronomy or biology.

Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by wolfgke on Sunday November 05, 2017 @12:34PM (#15630490)
> There are plenty of nutty mathematical or physics theories around.

At least for mathematics I have hardly seen any "nutty mathematical theories" (I am a PhD student in mathematics, but not a physicist, so I cannot say anything about physics here). The reason that I see is that for a math text to be considered as solid, it has to contain good, understandable proofs - which are hard to write by "crackpots". To be more precise: On sceptic's blogs I have of course seen links to papers containing "mathematical crackpottery", but I have hardly ever seen those "in the open countryside".

Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by mcguire on Sunday November 05, 2017 @04:37PM (#15631773)
If we were physicists, I'd be tempted to mention "normalization" here.

Ask your favorite well-known professor how many proofs of P=NP, the Riemann hypothesis, or whatever they get per week. Sure, they're all Time-Cube level crazy, but most off the wall theories are, too.

Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by wolfgke on Sunday November 05, 2017 @05:51PM (#15632228)
> Ask your favorite well-known professor how many proofs of P=NP, the Riemann hypothesis, or whatever they get per week.

My PhD advisor actually works in an area that is related to complexity questions that are related to P=NP. So if he would get spammed a lot with this kind of papers, I am pretty sure that I would know. Similar statements hold for other researchers who work on the same floor.

You might object that even though they might work on questions that are related to complexity theory, they are perhaps simply not the people that an "ordinary crackpot" thinks of as target reader for their texts - in other words one has to know a little bit about mathematics to know that the questions these people work on are actually related to P=NP. I will not disagree with this objection.

You may also object that the respective persons are well-known and well-regarded in their respective community, but the general public is not so much aware of them. I also will not disagree with this objection.

Nevertheless I strongly believe that if your claim were true in general, I would probably know.

Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by foldr on Sunday November 05, 2017 @10:22AM (#15629783)
But then why do you judge the conspiracy theories to be nutty, if they are on just as firm an epistemological footing as actual history?
Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by wolfgke on Sunday November 05, 2017 @10:54AM (#15629922)
First: I used your "nutty conspiracy theories" wording.

> But then why do you judge the conspiracy theories to be nutty, if they are on just as firm an epistemological footing as actual history?

But to elaborate on your argument: Because of the dubious epistemological footing indeed "actual history" has not the highest reputation to me. The reason I disregard lots of "nutty conspiracy theories" rather lies in the fact that many "conspiracists" have a tendency to find conspiracies in other topics, too, where falsification is much better possible. Thus I tend to judge by looking at the track record of the respective person.

Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by foldr on Sunday November 05, 2017 @11:21AM (#15630055)
So, you believe that the moon landings weren't faked solely becuase of the credentials of the people who say that it was faked? You believe that the Holocaust happened solely because Holocaust deniers say crazy things about other topics? That seems really, really, off base.
Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by wolfgke on Sunday November 05, 2017 @12:25PM (#15630407)
> So, you believe that the moon landings weren't faked solely becuase of the credentials of the people who say that it was faked?

This is exactly one example for my "where falsification is much better possible" - in this case because of physics.

Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by foldr on Sunday November 05, 2017 @12:40PM (#15630523)
It would not have been physically impossible to fake the moon landings. Physics tells us that the moon landings could have happened, but it doesn't tell us that they couldn't have been faked.

But by picking over the details of a particular example you're missing the point. Surely you don't want to say that you can reject crazy historical claims solely because the proponents of those claims make outragerous claims in other areas too. If you think the moon landings are an exception, for some reason, then let's look at other examples. E.g. Holocaust denial.

Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by fjsolwmv on Sunday November 05, 2017 @08:39PM (#15632955)
That is not true for psychology, biology, chemistry ,or physics either. They all choose some p-value as a boundary for deciding what is real.

Falsifiable means subject to test. It doesn't mean provabe on the sense of math. Only math is provable like math.

Re:Lessons of an MIT Education by azangru on Sunday November 05, 2017 @01:23PM (#15630756)
> Historians are constantly making predictions of events happening today, based on their knowledge of history

Could you provide some examples?