News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by pg_bot on Saturday November 04, 2017 @09:47PM (#15627771)
This is one of the reasons why I turn off all auto-* features in software that I use. From a UX perspective I want the program to do exactly as I command instead of trying to "help" me out.

I've had problems like chrome autofilling to an old address so a package gets delivered to the wrong location, or having to constantly edit text messages back to what I originally wrote because the program decided I was wrong.

When designing anything, if you think that you are doing someone a favor by doing work ahead of time please stop.

Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by inetknght on Saturday November 04, 2017 @09:53PM (#15627790)
> chrome autofilling to an old address

I completely disable autofill in the first place. As an added bonus, sites can't have hidden fields that get autofilled with my information either.

Second, I'd strongly argue it's your fault for not looking at what Chrome filled into the fields.

> if you think that you are doing someone a favor by doing work ahead of time please stop.

To be fair, they probably are doing some people a favor. I just think that things should be opt-in instead of opt-out though.

If things don't get opted into, then perhaps you should look to see why. Maybe people just don't know about it. Time to create some quick tutorials then.

Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by pg_bot on Saturday November 04, 2017 @10:06PM (#15627827)
It is often the case that I type faster than the UI can respond. So if I am tabbing through form fields and the last one changes everything above the viewport without me noticing it's an easy mistake to make. I usually won't double check shipping addresses because I typed the correct thing in the first time. At the end of the day it is on me to catch these kinds of things but I am sure you can understand my frustration.
Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by inetknght on Sunday November 05, 2017 @01:40PM (#15630829)
The only UI that is too slow to respond on modern hardware is a UI which is so laden with shitware. There's absolutely no other reason for a UI to be too slow to respond to typing; whether it's a terminal application, a native application, or a browser GUI.

A GUI that changes what you've typed into some field (especially when you're not looking) is a prime example of UI dark patterns and shitware.

Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by ej_campbell on Saturday November 04, 2017 @10:48PM (#15627943)
Seriously? Typing on glass without auto-correct is painful. Do you really think it was a bad idea for designers to design that feature?
Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by yorwba on Saturday November 04, 2017 @11:46PM (#15628105)
I type on glass without autocorrect. I use that bar of predictions above the keyboard, which occasionally suggests words that slightly differ from what I typed, and if I made a typo, I'll gladly accept the correction. But I'd never use a "feature" that changes what I typed after I already moved on to the next word. I wouldn't call it painful, but maybe I'm unusually good at hitting the intended key most of the time.
Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by andrewaylett on Sunday November 05, 2017 @09:28AM (#15629529)
Google's keyboard recently added the ability to auto-correct a word back, which I find really useful when I'm using swipe typing -- usually I'll fix as I go anyway, but I'm not infallible and if I expected a swipe to give me the right word, I might not otherwise notice until I go back to proof-read before hitting send.
Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by pg_bot on Saturday November 04, 2017 @11:10PM (#15628008)
Yes. The computer should never do something that I haven't explicitly told it to do. You can design the same exact feature but I need to trigger it, the machine should not be making decisions for me.
Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by ej_campbell on Saturday November 04, 2017 @11:26PM (#15628054)
> When designing anything, if you think that you are doing someone a favor by doing work ahead of time please stop.

And you think that is the right call for the majority of people?

Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by pg_bot on Saturday November 04, 2017 @11:35PM (#15628078)
Why would you ever want to trade accuracy for speed?
Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by ec109685 on Sunday November 05, 2017 @01:49AM (#15628434)
Because the OS can guess correctly more often than a typical user can type correctly. You can always proof read its work at the end.

Also, in addition to auto correcting words, your phone also auto corrects individual key presses based on the word you are typing. The same physical impact on your screen will register a different letter based on the letters that come before it.

So part of your “typing on glass accuracy” is dependent on a designer designing that feature that “does work ahead of time”.

Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by bambax on Sunday November 05, 2017 @03:27AM (#15628680)
> Because the OS can guess correctly more often than a typical user can type correctly. You can always proof read its work at the end.

No. Certainly not on a desktop, where I type much faster than any suggestion can appear (esp. infuriating on IDEs); usually not on a phone either, where "corrections", while sometimes faster than me, are always wrong.

Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by c0nducktr on Sunday November 05, 2017 @09:25AM (#15629512)
Are you the typical user?
Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by Fnoord on Tuesday November 07, 2017 @05:58AM (#15642386)
I use SwiftKey (without cloud predictions) and if you press spacebar that's the equivalent of "explicitly telling it". The thing is that usually, the auto correct is correct so when you see it is not you click on the word you (according to the computer) "made up", et voila.
Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by bambax on Sunday November 05, 2017 @03:24AM (#15628676)
Why people use autocorrect is beyond me. Chats with my friends are littered with addenda where they correct what autocorrect corrected, it's insane. Just type what you mean to type -- a spelling mistake isn't the end of the world.

But changing a word for another makes a sentence unintelligible and blocks or at least seriously slows down communication.

Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by simias on Sunday November 05, 2017 @05:16AM (#15628862)
I touchtype at around 90WPM on a keyboard and swipe/glide typing (which obviously relies heavily on autocorrect) is the only thing that makes inputting text on a smartphone somewhat almost bearable for me. Otherwise I feel like I'm trying to type with mittens while drunk.

It's reasonably fast, I don't have to aim for tiny boxes with my fat fingers and it takes care of accents when I type in french. The correction algorithm is also getting better (albeit still far from perfect); sometimes it'll correct the previous word based on what I enter next. If you want me to disable this you'll have to give me a full size keyboard as a replacement.

Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by bambax on Sunday November 05, 2017 @06:46AM (#15629029)
> you'll have to give me a full size keyboard as a replacement

It seems to me, speed is only an issue for long texts, and why would people type long texts (or lots of small ones) on a phone? Can't that wait until they're in front of a proper computer?

> If you want me to disable this

I don't want you, or anyone, to do anything ;-)

I simply find it strange that people rely on autocorrect, and then send a second message immediately afterwards, to say correctly what autocorrect got wrong. It seems it would be faster, and better, to get it right the first time than the current sequence of "type, send, proofread, retype, resend".

Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by simias on Sunday November 05, 2017 @12:26PM (#15630419)
Even writing a ~100 char text manually on a phone is extremely frustrating for me. And well, sometimes you try to be fast and you hit "send" before you take the time to proofread correctly.
Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by hateduser2 on Sunday November 05, 2017 @11:04AM (#15629966)
That’s not really the current sequence though. That only rarely happens to me. Autocorrect is probably good for me actually.
Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by majewsky on Sunday November 05, 2017 @08:52AM (#15629354)
> Chats with my friends are littered with addenda where they correct what autocorrect corrected

Survivorship bias: You cannot see the (usually much larger) number of words that were correctly autocorrected.

Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by computerex on Sunday November 05, 2017 @11:26AM (#15630079)
An incorrectly autocorrected word is far worse in terms of negative user experience than a misspelled word not autocorrected. I say underline the word in red and leave it to the user to tap the underlined words to trigger autocorrect.
Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by snarf21 on Sunday November 05, 2017 @09:40AM (#15629578)
I don't think that it what he is saying. I agree with him and the point is that a misspelled word is not going to inhibit the communication between two friends. Changing a joke/inside/slang word to something the phone thinks is "correct" does inhibit communication. They are arguing that auto correct is worse in this context. (Although, it makes more sense in an email or document editing setting)
Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by pgwhalen on Sunday November 05, 2017 @11:16AM (#15630026)
This is ignoring the fact that autocorrect can fix massively incorrect words. If you’re off by half a centimeter for a while word it could be complete gibberish if not for autocorrect.
Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by hocuspocus on Sunday November 05, 2017 @07:16AM (#15629094)
I can't speak for Apple keyboard but the only Android app I ever bought is SwiftKey (before it became free). Recent versions of Gboard are also pretty good it seems.

Auto-correct mishaps happen (especially when using multiple languages at the same time) but are fairly rare. It's a trade-off, it makes the majority of my typing much quicker and accurate, but I have to be careful about a few things.

Edit: as a non-native speaker, I don't really make spelling mistakes in English, either I know a word or I don't, so that's not a reason for me to use auto-correct.

Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by akvadrako on Sunday November 05, 2017 @04:57AM (#15628838)
I have learned to type much faster with autocorrect by working with it and understanding the limitations. I'm not a very good speller, but as long as I get enough letters correct, the phone will do the rest. And for long words I often skip a few letters, because I just need to be close enough.
Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by comex on Sunday November 05, 2017 @04:45AM (#15628818)
I use autocorrect because it lets me type sloppily enough that I would make a lot of spelling mistakes without it, frequently making words unintelligible. Of course, I could type reasonably accurately if I slowed down, but in theory, with autocorrect I can type faster and still end up with the right text most of the time. Yes, miscorrections happen, more often than I'd like, but not enough that avoiding them would be worth even a small speed penalty; virtual keyboards are slow enough as they are.

…On the other hand, my teenage younger sister has always used her phone with autocorrect disabled (just because she doesn't like the capitalization), and she types pretty quickly. Maybe it's just a matter of training yourself with autocorrect off, and eventually you can type accurately while keeping the same speed. But I'm not sure. There's no doubt that training would help, but can it make up the full difference, compared to a user well-trained with autocorrect on? (…And for that matter, if I care about speed so much, shouldn't I switch to a swipe-style keyboard? But that's a separate discussion.)

Anyway, the fundamental problem is that without the tactile feedback of a physical keyboard, it's much easier for your fingers to get misaligned, so the relative positions of the taps might be reasonably correct but the absolute positions are totally messed up. Even though you can see when you make a typo, humans have pretty high latency in responding to visual feedback, and you only get the feedback after the fact (whereas on a physical keyboard you can feel if you're in the wrong place before you've actually pressed down on the key). It seems more efficient to just type the whole word at once, and even if you were misaligned, most of the time autocorrect will figure out what you meant. (Especially if you keep going with the sentence, which can change previous words after they were seemingly finalized. I used to go one word at a time, stopping to correct any word that turned out wrong, but after I learned to trust autocorrect a bit more I realized that some of those corrections were unnecessary. This applies especially to the word "its", which autocorrect likes to change to "it's" but will often change back when appropriate.)

Actually, I make typos on physical keyboards too - which I'd like to think is just a side effect of being a fast typist, though I'm probably less accurate than most - but my impression is that those are more often timing rather than positioning related, and I can often tell they've happened by feel alone, letting me hit option-delete to redo the word immediately without waiting for visual feedback to go through my head...

Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by nyhc99 on Sunday November 05, 2017 @11:14AM (#15630017)
I find it infuriating that autocorrect constantly subs out correctly spelled words with other words it thinks I meant to type. It would be understandable if their suggestion made more sense contextually than what I typed, but that is frequently not the case. When I start typing "I had" it likes to change it to "I has" as if I'm some kind of a cat meme. Where is that even coming from? I can guarantee it's not coming from analyzing my past typing.
Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by EGreg on Sunday November 05, 2017 @08:05AM (#15629205)
When you dictate to the phone, this happens inevitable. For example I can't get the phone to type "culled", only "called" or "cold". And so on. But these are minor compared to some other issues.

Would be nice to be able to have an escape word and spell the previous word by letters. Or get out into some control sequence :)

Maybe there should be an app for that!

Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by thesauri on Sunday November 05, 2017 @07:54AM (#15629172)
I have used the same keyboard, SwiftKey, for the past couple of years. Whenever I write a new word that is unfamiliar to the keyboard it is saved to a personal dictionary. By now, it knows very well what words I use and the autocorrection rarely fails. It is instead quite handy as it corrects my mistypings when writing quickly.
Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by SquareWheel on Saturday November 04, 2017 @09:53PM (#15627791)
Chrome has a settings menu to edit existing addresses, if you need to remove an old address.

chrome://settings/autofill

Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by thsowers on Saturday November 04, 2017 @09:54PM (#15627792)
> When designing anything, if you think that you are doing someone a favor by doing work ahead of time please stop.

Can see validity in your other points, but I don't think this is always true. For example, I find it useful when looking up classical musicians on youtube to see what works they are most famous for playing

Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by pdkl95 on Saturday November 04, 2017 @11:39PM (#15628091)
Offering to do something is usually fine, as long as you do it carefully and stop of the user closes your offer in frustration ("stop bugging me, I have work to do").

On the other hand, assuming know what the user "really" wants to do and doing that work ahead of time without asking first is arrogant and frustrating. If this also breaks existing behavior, it's also teaching people to treat your software as unreliable, possibly hostile, unpredictable toy they they should avoid when possible.

Tools need to be reliable, and that includes reliably following the user's orders.

Re:If you type the letter “i” and it autocorrects to an “A” ... by pg_bot on Saturday November 04, 2017 @10:00PM (#15627814)
I should clarify predicting what I am about to do is fine, but correcting what I've done is wrong. As long as I maintain control it's ok.