News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by nostromo on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:27PM (#15622589)
If you ever wonder, "why is the tax code so complicated?" this is the answer.

Every time there is a proposal to eliminate a specific deduction, credit, or loophole, special interest groups crawl out of the woodwork to fight it tooth and nail.

Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by kristopolous on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:34PM (#15622634)
Ok, but it's far simpler elsewhere. In many places (such as Japan), doing your taxes takes a few minutes and you don't need to pay someone hundreds of dollars to someone who has made a career out of the tax system.
Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by patio11 on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:49PM (#15622735)
you don't need to pay someone hundreds of dollars to someone who has made a career out of the tax system.

You don't. Your employer does [+], because they are responsible for (for the majority of traditionally employed folks) managing your tax returns for you. The prices are, indeed, in the hundreds of dollars per year.

If you do something exotic in Japan, like (to pick an example entirely randomly) sell bingo card creation software over the Internet, you will get intimately familiar with the 青色申告, which is almost exactly as much fun as a US tax return.

My personal tax compliance cost for last year on the Japan side was ~$2.5k; it's cheap at the price because doing a full return given my situation would likely have eaten a solid week.

[+] There are some economies of scale here, but a startup in Japan should budget several hundred dollars for payroll administration, per month, plus another lump-sum due in December for the spike of work caused by the end-of-year adjustment (which is not a tax return per se, but is the closest thing most Japanese people have to a tax return).

There are some irreducibly complex questions in tax, such as the surprisingly difficult "What is income, really?" and the related follow-ups "What type of income is that income given that we've decided we want to treat them differently?" and "When exactly did that income happen, given that we've decided we want to run taxation in an other-than-continuous fashion?" These questions are complicated and nuanced because the economy is complicated and nuanced.

Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by kristopolous on Friday November 03, 2017 @07:09PM (#15622831)
Thanks for the insight. I really like your podcast. (Also, we share a last name! I'm Chris McKenzie. ;-))

What can be done to simplify US taxes isn't a 1 sentence idea ... Unfortunately, having to be cheap on sophistication and explanation is a limitation of the internet discussion format and people's habituated attention spans for it.

Anyway, for a deep dive, I recommend this book by TR Reid who did a longitudinal analysis of tax systems across the OECD, traveling to the countries and interviewing hundreds of people. He gives things a fair play:

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/23/books/review/a-fine-mess-...

Here's his commonwealth club talk for people who only want to give it an hour:

https://www.commonwealthclub.org/events/2017-04-13/journalis...

Again, pleasure to see you and thanks for your time.

Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by chimeracoder on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:40PM (#15622674)
> Ok, but it's far simpler elsewhere. In many places (such as Japan), doing your taxes takes a few minutes and you don't need to pay someone hundreds of dollars to someone who has made a career out of the tax system.

The process of filing taxes is separate from how complicated the tax code itself is.

And to be honest, you don't need to pay hundreds of dollars to anyone in order to file taxes in the US. In fact, you can file your taxes using a form that fits on a single sheet of paper.

You may want to opt for one of the other methods of filing, if you qualify for special deductions that might significantly reduce your tax burden, but most people already qualify for the option that takes "a few minutes".

Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by xellisx on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:44PM (#15622712)
Well the IRS could do your taxes for you and send you a bill/confirmation for you to correct, but companies have lobbied to get an agreement put in place that this will never happen.
Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by chimeracoder on Friday November 03, 2017 @07:09PM (#15622833)
> Well the IRS could do your taxes for you and send you a bill/confirmation for you to correct, but companies have lobbied to get an agreement put in place that this will never happen.

The difference between that and filling out a 1040EZ is negligible. It takes as long to write out a 1040EZ as it would to properly verify the information on one that's already filled out for you.

For people who want to utilize the more complex deductions available - there's no way that the IRS could do that for you. Contrary to popular belief, they don't have sufficient information to do that until you give it to them, and quite frankly you wouldn't want them to have access automatically to all of that.

Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by JBlue42 on Friday November 03, 2017 @07:16PM (#15622861)
They do that though. The past two years I've filed online with their free forms. I knew that I was taking more allowances and would owe. They said "hey, you actually owe us this". And then I sent them a check.
Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by masonic on Friday November 03, 2017 @07:39PM (#15622990)

   this will never happen
This has been the case for many years already.

The problem is, the IRS has no incentive to help minimize your tax. If you really have nothing to deduct, that might not be so bad, but I would have more faith in any of the existing free short-form filing services that already exist.

Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by seanmcdirmid on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:43PM (#15622703)
I had absolutely zero tax obligation in the USA for 9 years, and I still had to file more than a few sheets of paper, taking around a day or so to prepare.
Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by leggomylibro on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:29PM (#15622605)
How about the estate tax loophole? We've got better places to go looking.
Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by drawkbox on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:41PM (#15622682)
Gifting when alive you are taxed at 15k+ or so.

Gifting when dead you aren't taxed until 5m or 10m for married. The GOP tax plan doubles that to 10/20m and then removes it after 6 years.

The estate tax was already a huge benefit when compared to the gift tax. What would be nice is if they could up the amount on the gift tax rate if they aren't going to collect any tax on gifting after death (inheritance). This could free up money that will only be in an estate and not used for years maybe even decades.

When you compare the gift tax when alive to the gift tax after death (the estate tax) it is already a massive benefit.

Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by tssva on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:57PM (#15622774)
There is a lifetime $5.49 million exemption from the gift tax. Gifts above $14k are taxed. If you gave me $30k this year, you would not have to pay any taxes on it but your $5.49 million lifetime exemption would be reduced by $16k.
Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by drawkbox on Friday November 03, 2017 @07:24PM (#15622908)
Wow never knew that. I always thought the person receiving the gift had to pay taxes on any amount above the gift tax rate per year if the tax wasn't paid by the giver i.e. 14k currently.

Basically then any money you receive or earn is taxable except loans and gifts up to the gift tax limit, all other money movement is taxed.

Of course winnings are still taxed at normal rates because that is income not gifted per se, I guess I was conflating the two. Example: If you win a car you owe taxes on the whole thing.

So essentially it is the same limit as the estate tax, so I wonder if that also doubles and also goes away in the tax bill.

Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by nostromo on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:44PM (#15622704)
That will never happen because nearly all of our elected officials use trusts to minimize or eliminate entirely the estate tax they would otherwise pay.

The Clintons, Kennedys, Romnys, Bushs, etc...

http://time.com/money/4344981/hillary-clinton-estate-plan-ta...

https://www.forbes.com/sites/carlodonnell/2014/07/08/how-the...

http://www.wealthmanagement.com/wealth-planning/unlocking-mi...

Heck, even Noam Chomspky has used estate planning to avoid paying the estate tax.

https://www.hoover.org/research/noam-chomsky-closet-capitali...

Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by jdavis703 on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:32PM (#15622626)
Everyone thinks someone else's loopholes are better places to go looking. Even I succumb to this thinking, at first I was pretty pissed at the retirement saving plan elimination. But all us voters need to grow up and vote in people who have spines and will make us drink our spinach juice. It'd be really nice to have a tax code so simple it puts TurboTax and their ilk out of business.
Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by blackbagboys on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:36PM (#15622647)
Why do we - ordinary workers and students - have to drink the “spinach juice”? Why not the people who have amassed utterly unprecedented amounts of wealth and power?
Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by JonFish85 on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:40PM (#15622679)
Because there is so much more money in the “ordinary workers and students” subset of society than there is in the top 0.x%.
Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by wahern on Friday November 03, 2017 @07:03PM (#15622800)
I can't tell if you're being sarcastic.

FWIW, in 2011 the top 0.01% earned 5% of national income, the top 0.1% earned 10%, and the top 1% earned 20%. Source: http://ritholtz.com/2011/10/forget-the-top-1-look-at-the-top...

In 2016 the top 25% earned 51% of national income. Source: https://www.statista.com/statistics/203247/shares-of-househo...

Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by mattkrause on Friday November 03, 2017 @09:00PM (#15623267)
All those filthy rich grad students pulling in $20-35k/yr!
Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by sidlls on Friday November 03, 2017 @07:00PM (#15622787)
Not on an individual basis.
Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by jdavis703 on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:44PM (#15622708)
You can eliminate all tax deductions, tax the wealthy, and cut middle class taxes at the same time. All of that requires that everyone in society drink some "spinach juice" though. Of course doing those three things are politically impossible in the current environment, but that's a different problem.
Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by AnimalMuppet on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:44PM (#15622710)
Because, despite all the rhetoric to the contrary, raising other peoples' taxes isn't going to be enough. We're going to have to raise yours, too.
Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by SamReidHughes on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:41PM (#15622686)
Ordinary workers aren't the main beneficiaries of retirement savings plans. It's the people that can afford $20K/yr to save that benefit.
Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by conanbatt on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:40PM (#15622675)
Taxes are that fantastic thing that does good to everyone, specially when other people pay it.
Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by pishpash on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:40PM (#15622676)
Because ordinary workers and students don't or aren't able to effectively exercise political power, ceding the polity to those who do so.
Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by gnicholas on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:34PM (#15622640)
Curious to know what you're referring to. The fact that it doesn't apply to all estates? That's also true of any tax that is progressive.
Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by ensignavenger on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:32PM (#15622623)
It is my understanding that the tax proposal deals with that, too.
Re:GOP tax bill would tax tuition waivers for grad students by topspin on Friday November 03, 2017 @06:32PM (#15622622)
I've never wondered this. The complexity and growth of tax law is a proxy for corruption.