So I'm doubtful the secret sauce of humans had its origin 70,000 years ago.
Did the "secret sauce" of mouse-gui originate in the 70s with Bell Labs or Apple in the 80s? Did the secret sauce of early aggricultural civilization (Hati, Sumer, Hindus Valley..) start the first time a person grew stuff for food or when a larger scale grain economy first emerged?
There is plenty of evidence that paleo-humans from well before that 70k ybp cutoff was special, unique in the animal kingdom. Knowing what we know about people, a lot of that behaviour was almost certainly cultural and probably language-based. Very complex tool use, hunting and gathering methods, shelters, fire. Perhaps even fire-aggriculture practices.
Regardless, 70k ybp (or 40 or 100) the "secret sauce," whatever it is, begins to yield fruit. There are artifacts with symbolic expression, what we'd call art or even politics. The human population grows. We inhabit more (almost all) ecological zones. People get everywhere, including australia by 40-50k ybp. Maybe earlier. Tool invention gets faster...
something happened.
But species are to some extent artificial categories. Sapiens and Neanderthals were close. Genetically compatible and behaviorally similar (as far as we can tell). It would not be unreasonable to define them all as subspecies or ever varieties within a species.
ideology: 1 , science: 1.1 - slight edge
There is a lot we don’t know. The fact that Neanderthal buries their dead with some sort of symbolism, cared for elders, and lived in (small!) groups doesn’t really give us firm answers to these questions.
It is interesting that they actually had larger brains than modern humans, as did the Cro Magnon homo sapiens we have also found).
One interesting idea is that humans ultimately triumphed because we had better social connections, we traveled much further and had much larger circles.
If you can't meet & talk to humans from 80,000 and 60,000 years ago, are you able to say any change happened 70,000 years ago?
Assuming the bottleneck theory is valid to begin with, this was a global ecological disaster - it's not like the Neanderthals sat this one out on another planet : )
First, any theories about this period (the paleo revolution and/or dispersal era in a lot of theories) are very speculative and prone to change. We just don't have that much information. So, the margins are necessarily huge.
So, both these bottleneck narratives are probably over-literal reading of the data we have, at least stated in simple forms. Either way, they point to a single small seed population. There could have been many times more people (neanderthals and sapiens) at the time and later, and they just passed on far fewer genes to 100ky later.
Yuval Harari touches on the question you raise. Sapiens vs neanderthal (and others), and at one point do human behavioural characteristics (or more precisely their consequences) emerge as different. His take is (roughly):
[1] "anatomically modern" sapiens existed for 100ky+ before these behaviours emerge. [2]Findings do not imply a big cognitive or behavioural gap between sapiens and earlier subspecies in this period. [3] there appear to be botlenecks in our lineage, dating to this period [4] The "paleo-revolution" happened in some form, and he believes it was primarily linguistic [5] Our language abilities allow flexible, large scale cooperation that is unrivaled in our clade, and did not widely exist in the lower paleolithic even in sapiens [6] he spends a lot of time on the nature of those linguistic tools. In a nutshell, advanced language allows symbolism, necessary for human-level culture. Trade. Chiefs. Tribes. Gods. Money.
All that could have happened in a single cliffside cove. That seems possible.
His argument/theory is attractive, but these things are far from set in stone. New findings will force all theories to adapt. Some will become unlikely.
I suspect it's more likely that the selection happened between tribal groups, not within them.
Given independent groups with similar challenges, some would have the intelligence and luck to survive, and some wouldn't.
After a challenging event like Toba, tribes/herds with a culture that couldn't adapt or survive would be culled fairly quickly.
Selection doesn't work on the individual level.
There's a serious theory it was this bottleneck where humans were confined to environments without natural preditors (seaside cliffs like those near Cape Town) and where social interaction was a necessity. Those with higher intelligence, particularly social intelligence, would scored more mates in that environment. And thus we had a runaway intelligence arms race that separated modern humans from their immediate hominid ancestors.