Every story and comment from the Hacker News API, in a layout borrowed from 2001.
A comment on Human Beings Almost Vanished from Earth in 70,000 B.C. Parent comment
I suspect it's more likely that the selection happened between tribal groups, not within them.
Given independent groups with similar challenges, some would have the intelligence and luck to survive, and some wouldn't.
After a challenging event like Toba, tribes/herds with a culture that couldn't adapt or survive would be culled fairly quickly.
Selection doesn't work on the individual level.
I suspect it's more likely that the selection happened between tribal groups, not within them.
Given independent groups with similar challenges, some would have the intelligence and luck to survive, and some wouldn't.
After a challenging event like Toba, tribes/herds with a culture that couldn't adapt or survive would be culled fairly quickly.