Is that true? Got a reference?
The problem is that external costs like pollution are not being priced into the cost of ICE vehicles by, say, a pollution tax. This limited subsidy is a backhanded way of doing that.
I don't see the issue with rich people benefiting from it, because it's exactly those rich people buying 100K Teslas that are paying for the cost of driving research into better battery technology and cheaper cars so everyone benefits from cleaner air and reduced global warming.
Basically the math works like this:
An internal combustion cars cost X tons of carbon to produce. An an EV costs Y tons of carbon to produce. If you need a new car, it will probably require the same amount of carbon to produce an EV as a combustion car. But if you can drive a used car and extend its life 5, 10, 15 years, you save all the carbon of producing the car (which is where the majority of the carbon cost comes from).
> I don't see the issue with rich people benefiting from it, because it's exactly those rich people buying 100K Teslas that are paying for the cost of driving research into better battery technology and cheaper cars so everyone benefits from cleaner air and reduced global warming.
I love investing in technology. However, there's probably more efficient ways of doing it. Every dollar spent to help the rich could have been spent helping the poor, or the environment, or funding research.
False [0].
[0] https://group.renault.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/fluence...
Page 91, Figure 49: "Comparing carbon footprint of EV and ICE vehicles".
Up to 85% of the carbon footprint of a car comes from driving it. Heck, even a typical hybrid during its lifetime saves roughly 150% worth of its weight in CO2 emissions. Taxis easily double that figure.
Though I can't find a reliable number for how many years that actually is and I'm not sure if the average person who owns an EV would even keep it that long...
A PZEV (very low emission ICE vehicle) is the sweet spot right now in terms of overall environmental impact. It will be a few years before EVs are the clear winner.
So the question is what is the dynamic interplay between different markets for used IC vehicles? Should we be shipping 1995 Camrys to less-developed countries so they can junk their 1985 Camrys?
And then of course note that the 1995 Camrys probably get worse gas mileage than the 1985 Camrys because they have are heavier due to safety features....
Meanwhile the definition of "Camry" has changed - they are a lot larger, more powerful and more refined now. Note, for example the engine sizes going up as the MPG gets better.
Owning a Tesla (the current fad) or Prius (the previous fad) has long been about looking like you are environmentally conscious rather than actually being environmentally conscious. True lovers of mother nature ride the bus, train, or ride a bike.
Owning a Tesla, from what I can tell, is about operating a truly excellent vehicle that happens to be electric.
Just a quick thought from someone that actually went shopping and drove both: The MB S-class beats the Model S in terms of luxury feel. Hands down. The Model S is faster. And quieter. But it does not feel as good as a MB at all. Before you ask, no, I ended up buying neither. I bought a Subaru Forester and an airplane for the same money.
So now EVs are some kind of evil temptress?
I think I can do without reading that source now.
This is crazy, man. I'm just saying it costs less carbon to keep a used car. I'm not accusing EVs of "being an evil temptress".
Obviously if you play with the numbers (CO2 per mile driven, # of miles in life of car, CO2 per new car, expectation for expected reductions in total CO2 reduction by waiting if you want to get fancy) you can get it to tilt in either direction.
Using the carbon offset market, you could offset 760 Tonnes of CO2 with $7500. That's the carbon equivalent of driving an ICE for over 2 Million miles.
Removing the EV Credit now makes no sense; perhaps a better approach is to limit the EV Credit to cars that cost under 50k; this would ensure the credit isn't used on luxury EV's and allow the market to continue to grow.
IIRC to get the full $7,500 it needs to be a full electric with a battery large enough for X miles so the Bolt wouldn't qualify (for all of it).
> Removing the EV Credit now makes no sense; perhaps a better approach is to limit the EV Credit to cars that cost under 50k; this would ensure the credit isn't used on luxury EV's and allow the market to continue to grow.
You also need a tax bill of at least $7,500 to take advantage of the full credit. If your tax bill is only $5,000 then that would be max you could get back.
https://www.edmunds.com/fuel-economy/the-ins-and-outs-of-ele...
Now, I actually don't mean this with any snark, but how is what you're doing any different? This tax credit applies to plenty of vehicles sold for much less than $100,000.
There is a 200k cap on the credit. Meaning mass market EVs do not receive the credit. It exclusively benefits low volume, high margin EVs. Which are exclusively marketed to the rich.
Do you consider $31K to be luxury? Or are you saying that because you aren't really familiar with the market?
As of the end of 2016 Tesla's cumulative sales were ~160k units. Nissan alone has produced over 300k of the Leaf.
The Bolt exceeded the Model S in sales last month selling just under 3000 units.
> There is a 200k cap on the credit.
Meaning if you sell more than 200,000 cars you no longer get the credit. GM sold 10 million ICE cars in 2016. If they were all EV 9,800,000 would not have received the credit.
That's false.
> It exclusively benefits low volume, high margin EVs.
That's also false. It benefits high margin vehicles regardless of volume and high margin does not necessarily mean luxury.
> Meaning if you sell more than 200,000 cars you no longer get the credit.
That's also false. Crossing the 200k mark starts a phase out process that takes a year.
So if GM managed to produce and sell 10 million ICE cars in the United States in 1 calendar year, the buyers would all receive a tax credit.
As yet, no manufacturer has reached 200k sales in the United States. Again Nissan leads the pack but has yet to reach the 200k mark.
Way too much I'm sure, but that's besides the point. The lowest tier there is one of the most important imo. Because you're absolutely right, buying used combustion cars is what credits like this should be targeting, imo. Conceptually at least, I clearly know nothing of what I talk about.
http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/whats-differenc...
So setting aside whether this is fair or unfair, people that owe more taxes clearly get a bigger benefit from the credit.
https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f1040.pdf
But lots of people don't end up paying $7500 in income taxes.
Also, you don't need to take it all one year. Tax credits carry forward up to 10 years.[1]
[1] Disclaimer, I am not an accountant
That accounts for 3% annually.
That being said, I think you're on the right path as only 35% came from renewables (15%) or nuclear (20%).
So the 1% is accurate if the power generation remains static but renewables and nuclear are growth sectors. A bunch of reactors are allegedly coming online in the next decade. Wind and Solar are also growing quickly.
For those of us in Southern California, even if electric cars aren't "carbon neutral", they are still a win for two reasons.
1) Electric cars that are stopped don't burn energy. Now, with the new engines that can turn themselves off and on quickly, that's becoming less of an issue, but there is still some amount of idling in any combustion engine.
2) The pollution involved with electric cars is concentrated, industrial point-source. This is FAR easier to mitigate than the diffuse, individual pollution sources represented by combustion cars.
Sure, things today may be a wash in terms of overall emissions in many areas, but as time goes on and dirty power plants are shut down and cleaner sources brought online, the emissions due to EVs increases.
I'm seriously evaluating buying an electric car like the Bolt (though the cheap interior is a bit of a turn-off for a longer commute) or the Ioniq EV (much nicer, though with less range) since many employers are offering EV charging at work. That'd make my out-of-pocket operating costs basically negligible (other than occasional air filter and tire rotations), which is nice.
I'd love to see the tax credit turned into a point-of-sale reduction in price so more people can benefit, rather than just those with a >$7500 tax bill.
In what is already one of the most expensive states to live in the per gallon gas tax increased by 40% on Wednesday. That means that the total state and federal taxes come out to about 77 cents [1] per gallon. While 77 cents doesn't seem like much, consider that the average cost per gallon of gas in California is around $3.10 [2], which puts the effective tax rate at around 25%.
A 25% tax rate is absolutely insane in a country where you need a car to get around. Take into account the 53 cents per mile the IRS uses as its estimator of the cost of driving a vehicle [3], the average one-way commute distance is about 8 miles [4], and the average fuel economy for California drivers is around 24 miles per gallon [5], this works out to about $10 per day in just regular vehicle expenses, or around $300 per month.
For the poor in California this is just another example of how expensive it can be to be poor.
[1]: http://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/business/energy-green/sd...
[2]: http://www.californiagasprices.com/Prices_Nationally.aspx
[3]: https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/2017-standard-mileage-rates-for...
[4]: https://www.marketwatch.com/story/here-are-the-typical-commu...
[5]: http://www.latimes.com/business/autos/la-fi-hy-cars-fuel-eco...
Seems the bigger driver of the $300 is the need to rely on a car.
how is that fair. I am taking it because it is there and financially it makes no sense not too.
this is pure gift to those well off. it has nothing to do about protecting the environment. it was a gift to GM initially and because a gift to not only the well off but any manufacture who wanted to take it.
it needs to die.
Unless your electricity is generated by burning peat, in terms of CO2 emissions, this is false.
Of course, the correct solution to the emissions problem is to reduce the number of miles Americans drive. But you'll never hear a House Republican say that.
> Critics say electric vehicle buyers tend to be wealthier than average Americans and do nod need subsidies.
I love how this gets buried at the bottom after an avalanche of criticism. A free $7500 for the rich and an additional $7500 in revenue for manufacturers. Say what you want about the American political system, it is a master class in manipulation.
"But the environment!"
Assuming someone who buys a $100,000 car is unwilling to spending $107,500 for the same vehicle. Yes the environment would suffer, that is also assuming electric cars (in their current state) are less impactful than fossil fuel vehicles (which isn't the case). In fact, used internal combustion cars should be given a subsidy if you care about the environment.
"But the poor can't afford these cars without it!"
The poor can't afford it with it. How many bolts do you see driving around? I've lived in Asheville NC, Nashville TN, and Portland OR. I've seen 3 bolts total and hundreds of $100k Teslas driving around.
If you're poor, you probably live in an apartment without an electric car charging station. You probably can't afford a new car so you buy used which is exclusively internal combustion. So how does this tax credit affect you at all?
---
I'm intensely fascinated by conversations and how they are framed to manipulate opinion. Depending on your political slant, you could have easily framed this as "tax breaks for the wealthy" or "an attack on green energy" or "supporting domestic manufacturers" or "hurting domestic manufacturers".
It's all bullshit and I can't stand it anymore...