First of all, I've seen Japanese (who are strangers) strike up conversations on occasion in Tokyo: at the coin laundry, at the bakery, on elevators, and so on. It's not like a social taboo or something. But yes, in general, people keep to themselves.
That being said, in my experience, people in New York and Los Angeles also keep to themselves. My instinct is that the apparently introverted nature of people in Tokyo has nothing to do with Japanese culture and everything to do with the fact that it is a big city in a developed country. Perhaps someone from London can bring in another data point?
If my experiences in rural Japan are at all normal, Japanese in rural Japan are at least as talkative as those in the Southern US (where I'm from).
That said I've now moved to a very small town and it is crazy friendly, people will go out of their way to chat to you and be nice (but then again there are plenty of grumpy shop keepers and locals)
So I guess it is the same everywhere - your own little view will be coloured by your own expectations and by how much you are genuinely open to talking to people.
Two weeks before we left we got a dog. We met so many people from the area and the dog was an excuse to start a conversation. Made us feel like we'd been missing out all that time!
It's strange how easy it is to be so alone when there are so many people around. I've also discovered the opposite to be true, and the principle also carries over to large and small schools and large and small companies. When there are few people, they are more relational, but when it's impractical to greet everyone you meet, you may greet no one.
I find this is not really true. This depends a LOT on the context in Japan. If you are in the train or in the street, yeah, it's not the right place to do that. But there are plenty of other places where such interactions happen naturally. Go in a bar? People will start talking to you. Go have dinner in a small izakaya? There's a good chance people will talk to you. Visit a tourist spot? There's a good probability something like that will happen as well. And not just with foreigners, this happens with locals as well.
So, it's far from being black or white. Just like a lot of statements I hear the whole time about Japan.
I specifically said that no, it's not just me. I have seen and heard locals talking about this happening to them a lot. I'd say this happens even less likely as a foreigner because people will just strike a short conversation with you if they can barely speak English and that will stop there. Between locals it can go on for much longer.
I'd like to know what world you live in where this is any kind of option. Maybe "my introvert is showing" but I don't even consider doing this. Is this abnormal?
Very much not the case in the German speaking countries (where i have lived since early 2005). For a time this was one of my top reasons to want to immigrate to Canada (I was already working remotely for a Canadian startup at the time).
Traffic lived up to my expectations though. Driving to and from the hotel was a little stressful.
But being considerate in New York usually looks like staying out of others' way. It might seem like unfriendliness to out-of-towners, but it's a (perhaps counter-intuitive) form of courtesy.
Usually going to meetups and the like can help quite a bit. There's quite a bit of social context that tends to stem from that.
Like you said, breaking the ice helps a lot. I can imagine it's worse in other industries but tech has by far been the most forgiving.
Selection bias -- you meet people who want to go to meetups. Usually those kinds of meetups are quite small, too; I don't know many Japanese people who'd actually like to go to something like that.
One weird thing is that I have many online Japanese friends who have absolutely ZERO interest in meeting in real life; the gap between virtual and real can be surprisingly strong here.
I was actually saying tech is a nice bubble, not denying it exists.
I know enough that go that I've formed a nice community. Whether meeting IRL or not, it probably depends on the "kind" of friend you're considered. Japanese folks tend to put their friends in groups.
[0] https://www.google.co.jp/search?q=関東人が冷たい&aqs=chrome..69i57....
In Japan, you don't just walk up to people and strike
up a conversation. Foreigners might, but native Japanese
largely don't.
To establish some sort of repertoire, you need to share some
sort of acceptable social context with that person: went to
school together, played on a sports team together, work
together, etc.
I'm from the Northeast U.S. (though I've visited friends in a decent number of cities in this country) and this sounds 100% like every place I've ever lived in or visited.Are there really places in the world where total strangers strike up conversations and form friendships with people on the street, on the bus, etc?
I'm 41 and I don't think I've never experienced that and I'm a pretty social guy!
Aside from random "how about this weather?" chit-chat, I don't think I've ever befriended somebody outside of an existing social context like school, clubs, workplaces, online communities, fellow pet owners, neighbors, etc. Closest counter-example I can think of is my mom, who become good friends with a cashier at the supermarket she shopped at twice a week.
Israel, 100%. If you're new in the country, you'll end up getting a lot of random people that you literally meet on the street or in public transportation, helping you with a lot of stuff in your life.
I know several people who have formed "commuting friendships" when they've been on the same train day in, day out which then turned into "real friendships" distinct from the commute.
(Personally I would never strike up a conversation but crippling social anxiety is a bugger like that.)
Sure, the prototypical Japanese work practices might not line up with your culture. I don’t think it gives justification to label them as “insane.”
Consider this: it's not uncommon to see people 'working' nearly twice the hours of the Western average. Yet their GDP per capita is comparable if not equivalent to the Western average.
Since most other economic measures (that is, their standard of living) match up with the West, you're forced to ask yourself, 'Are Japanese people half as productive?' Is that why they have to work twice as much? I'll bet against it. It's because they have an insane work culture.
Also, it’s far too easy to cast stones in glass houses. I have a close friend who is ultra-low-budget traveling around the world who could justifiably call you and me “insane” for pushing forward in our careers (whatever they are).
From my perspective, I don't think it's unnecessary at all. People are dying from 'overwork'. Staff aren't able to leave before their superiors without risking their professional reputation. Because it's extremely unlikely they are actually getting anything done, it's a lie people impose on each other and themselves. And because they are too 'busy', many deplete the energy that would've otherwise spurred procreation - a problem they themselves consider an urgent priority. It's a cultural prison of national self-sabotage.
By counter-point, depression, drug use, and suicide is a serious issue in Hawaii. People are living in “paradise,” yet there is a crisis.
In Japan, you don't just walk up to people and strike up a conversation. Foreigners might, but native Japanese largely don't.
To establish some sort of repertoire, you need to share some sort of acceptable social context with that person: went to school together, played on a sports team together, work together, etc.
And, given that Japanese companies commonly have working hours that would be classified somewhere between "insane" and "criminally negligent", you don't really have time to socialize with anybody outside of your office.
This all goes triple for Tokyo, which has a very cold and sterile personality.
Expats tend to glop together into a tight group -- the "foreigner" community in Tokyo is like a small town in and of itself -- but for the natives, the end result is that there are a lot of very lonely people here.