News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by SeanLuke on Sunday October 29, 2017 @03:37PM (#15580960)
I don't understand. How is this not a straightforward violation of the Interstate Commerce Clause?
Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by mikeash on Sunday October 29, 2017 @03:43PM (#15581007)
The 21st Amendment (which repealed prohibition) explicitly grants states the right to regulate alcohol imports and possession.
Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by avar on Sunday October 29, 2017 @04:04PM (#15581102)
Even if that weren't the case, it says:

    [The Congress shall have Power] To
    regulate Commerce with foreign Nations,
    and among the several States, and with
    the Indian Tribes;
I.e. not that the Federal government must regulate interstate commerce, merely that it has the power to do that, and even if it said that the commerce must be regulated it could still be regulated to the effect that you couldn't e.g. sell across state lines.

But yes, the reason the regulation is different for alcohol than for other goods is ostensibly the 21st.

Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by mikeash on Sunday October 29, 2017 @05:57PM (#15581656)
I’m not sure what you’re saying here. It’s not that the feds must somehow regulate interstate commerce, it’s that the states can’t. The 21st carves out an exception.
Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by avar on Monday October 30, 2017 @06:26AM (#15584045)
I'm pointing out that the states forbidding commerce across state lines is not a violation of the commerce clause per-se. Rather it's a violation of how the federal government has chosen to use the rights it's granted by the commerce clause.

I.e. it's just the academic point that it's not inevitable that the Federal government uses the power of the CC to enforce free trade between states, that's just how it's chosen to implement it.

I.e. there could be an alternate timeline of the US where the CC enforces the ability of individual states to impose interstate tariffs up to some threshold, similar to how the EU manages agriculture quotas within the single market.

Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by mikeash on Monday October 30, 2017 @12:03PM (#15586049)
Meaning that, pre-21st, the states could have regulated this if there was a federal law saying they could? Or perhaps merely if there was no federal law saying they couldn't?
Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by avar on Monday October 30, 2017 @04:57PM (#15588813)
I may be wrong about this, but my understanding of the CC is that if say Nevada were to enact a law saying that sales to California were subject to tariff they wouldn't be found to be in violation of the CC. Instead they'd be found in violation of some federal code that the government could enact because of the CC.

I.e. the CC isn't some clause saying that free trade between states must be respected at all cost (sans the 21nd). Otherwise why would there be a federal drug law on the basis of the CC? That's a prohibition of the sale of certain goods on the back of prohibiting sales across state lines on the back of the CC.

Hence the indirect reply to SeanLuke upthread. This is not a violation of the CC, but of some federal statute enacted on the basis of the CC.

The distinction matters because if the CC isn't an amendment that ensures free trade the federal government could just as well use it to ensure trade restrictions between states as free trade, which it mostly does today.

Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by tomohawk on Sunday October 29, 2017 @08:27PM (#15582378)
When interpreting a text, and it appears that two statements appear to be in conflict, the more specific statement is to be followed.

The interstate commerce clause gives Congress the power to regulate (make normal) commerce between the states, removing the power of states to impose tarrifs or other barriers to trade. This was a big problem at the time. The 21st amendment specifically makes an exception to this general clause in the case of intoxicating spirits.

Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by CalChris on Monday October 30, 2017 @12:16AM (#15583044)
In the case of Amendments, it isn't the more specific but rather the more recent. So the 21st carves out an exception in the Commerce Clause, Article I, Section 8, Clause 3.

Otherwise, yeah, the Articles of Confederation weren't working.

Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by neekburm on Monday October 30, 2017 @10:23AM (#15585173)
This was the crux of state regulators' arguments in Granholm v. Heald, and it failed there.

From Wikipedia: "The context of the 21st Amendment, they wrote, was to return to the status quo that existed before Prohibition, making it clear that the states had the power to regulate alcohol however they wished, including banning alcoholic beverages entirely within the state if desired. Before Prohibition, the states did not have the power to violate the Dormant Commerce Clause, and the 21st Amendment was not intended to grant them this power."

Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by jayess on Sunday October 29, 2017 @04:20PM (#15581188)
But also see "dormant commerce clause."
Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by sandworm101 on Sunday October 29, 2017 @09:10PM (#15582506)
I spy a law student. The DCC is the stuff of conlaw nightmares.
Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by the_watcher on Monday October 30, 2017 @10:18AM (#15585145)
Alcohol has existed outside the Commerce Clause since Prohibition, as outlawing its sale was done via Constitutional amendment, rather than legislation. Same with repeal. Amendments supersede reserved Congressional authority. The result of this is that regulations on the sale and distribution of alcohol operate entirely differently than any other American industry (and is particularly vulnerable to regulatory capture). For example, try buying a Texas beer (in a store or bar) outside of Texas not called Shiner or Lone Star. It's very difficult, as Texas laws make it difficult to impossible for craft brewers to export across state lines. The biggest fans of those laws? Shiner and Lone Star.
Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by wyager on Sunday October 29, 2017 @04:14PM (#15581155)
You can’t “violate” the interstate commerce clause; it grants powers, doesn’t limit them.

(It, along with “necessary and proper”, have been used to justify just about every activity the federal government has done.)

Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by hexane360 on Sunday October 29, 2017 @04:54PM (#15581363)
So many people get this backwards, although I think some of this is the Constitution's fault. Originally it was a list of rights the government had, with the understanding that the states retained the rest. Then the bill of rights added a few civil liberties, i.e. rights the government specifically did not have. Theoretically this shouldn't make a difference, because anything not listed in the constitution was already unconstituional. Of course in practice we've read between the lines a lot with the original constituion, so it makes some sense that we also set some hard limits to what we can't do. But still, it makes it really confusing and leads to a lot of "interesting" legal beliefs by people who aren't familiar.
Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by wildmusings on Sunday October 29, 2017 @06:13PM (#15581765)
>Then the bill of rights added a few civil liberties, i.e. rights the government specifically did not have. Theoretically this shouldn't make a difference, because anything not listed in the constitution was already unconstituional.

I don't think this is true even for the strictest originalist interpretation possible. Without the Bill of Rights, Congress and the President would have much more expansive power in their creation and especially enforcement of law.

The Constitution does not establish a process for the federal government to investigate, detain, try, and punish people for violating its laws, though it is clear that it must have those powers. The major function of the Bill of Rights is to draw lines around those powers, lines that perhaps existed in the common law, but that could have been altered by Act of Congress in the absence of a constitutional provision.

There are also parts of the Bill of Rights which do constraint Congress's enumerated powers. For example, even under a strict originalist interpretation, the Commerce Clause would allow Congress to take actions that abridge the freedom of speech, religion, and assembly. It could prohibit the publishing of certain newspapers across state lines, for instance. The First Amendment prevents that kind of thing.

Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by jacobolus on Sunday October 29, 2017 @06:59PM (#15582020)
If I recall correctly, Madison’s original position was that the content of the Bill of Rights (and more besides) was already implied by the Constitution, and that the document was superfluous and possibly harmful if it led to people considering rights not explicitly mentioned to not also be part of the Constitution. He changed his mind, however, as a pragmatic gesture toward unity and compromise with the Anti-Federalists.
Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by wildmusings on Sunday October 29, 2017 @09:23PM (#15582538)
The position that he and Hamilton took was somewhat incoherent in my opinion, since the Constitution did list rights, like the prohibition on ex post facto laws and bills of attainder, and the guarantee of habeas corpus except in times of insurrection.

Hamilton made an interesting argument in Federalist 84, that rights like freedom of the press and of speech are too vague to belong in a legal document, since their interpretation would necessarily be determined solely by political winds. Compare to the more concrete prohibition of ex post facto laws, for example. Nevertheless, the majority of the Bill of Rights turned out to be more like those concrete provisions. The First and Second Amendments are the most notable exceptions, and his predictions have partially panned out. Thankfully, it's been for the better anyway: freedom of speech as we know it would not exist without the First Amendment.

Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by Spooky23 on Sunday October 29, 2017 @07:38PM (#15582195)
He was very wrong. The sedition acts made it pretty clear that without explicit protection, the government can and will abuse its powers.
Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by hexane360 on Tuesday October 31, 2017 @06:45PM (#15597305)
>For example, even under a strict originalist interpretation, the Commerce Clause would allow Congress to take actions that abridge the freedom of speech, religion, and assembly.

>The Constitution does not establish a process for the federal government to investigate, detain, try, and punish people for violating its laws, though it is clear that it must have those powers.

These are great examples, and I think they cut straight to the heart of the issue. Would the ideal solution be to rewrite the Constitution as a truthful, detailed, and exhaustive list of the powers the government does have, or would it be best to list only restrictions to the government's power? Or is a mix necessary, despite the inherent contradictions?

Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by goialoq on Monday October 30, 2017 @04:07PM (#15588425)
People seem to forget this all the time, even though it's obvious. The Constitution is an atrociously written document, by modern standards of technical writing. The 18th Century predates the modern notion of technically precise writing. Look at Newton's writings, for example.
Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by wildmusings on Sunday October 29, 2017 @05:13PM (#15581438)
Your interpretation is the reasonable one, but the people who matter (a majority of the Supreme Court), don't agree. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dormant_Commerce_Clause

Justice Thomas and the late Justice Scalia, and others before them, shared your view.

Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by stult on Sunday October 29, 2017 @06:16PM (#15581783)
States can violate it. It's called the dormant commerce clause.
Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by amigoingtodie on Sunday October 29, 2017 @05:22PM (#15581479)
...and fungibility, and states-secrets.
Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by kazinator on Monday October 30, 2017 @02:02AM (#15583340)
How can anyone not understand something without which an iconic, key piece of American culture would have had no basis?

I'm thinking of Smokey and The Bandit, of course.

Re:Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines by coldtea on Monday October 30, 2017 @08:28AM (#15584471)
Thanks to them having been born in a future that doesn't even know what Smokey and the Bandit is, and where Pedro Pascal is their Burt Reynolds.