The application of robotics in industry is still very much more akin to industrial automation than it is true autonomy. There's a ton you have to take into account to design a system that works well. In practice, this means that traditional automation is typically still the better solution than full autonomy.
Orders of magnitude in complexity difference and a much more hostile environment to survive in.
I am not really comfortable writing this but seriously, if you have to ask this question I am actually happy you did not receive funding (but I am obviously not happy that you ended up homeless), that was not a prototype, it was not even a proof of concept. It was maybe a small step up from a toy. Sonar as a sensor may give you a little bit of input data but your arduino does not have the processing power to extract meaningful information about its environment from that data nor does that sensor give you sufficient information that you would use to pilot a couple of tons of steel through an environment inhabited by fragile humans.
It's sort of sad to see.
going to be fun watching them deal with snow. though their approach has tended towards detail mapping. someone is going to figure out a break through in marking roads or perhaps they will get sensible and start with limited access highways first.
[0] - https://www.flirmedia.com/MMC/CVS/Tech_Notes/TN_0001_EN.pdf
Self-driving cars are at the intersection of numerous solved domains, yet integrating these remains strangely difficult for the largest companies in the world.
Snow is not just increased visual noise. Just off the top of my head, with no experience in self-driving cars and limited experience in computer vision:
Snow (on the ground and street and curbs) is a vastly lower-contrast visual environment where numerous traditionally distinct features of the landscape are covered by a blanket of white.
Snow is a more dangerous and difficult-to-stop-in environment, with totally different physical dynamics. Recognizing pedestrians (and their intentions), road blocks, debris, etc. is probably already a challenging problem, and with snow it's not only more difficult, it needs to be done from a much farther distance to give adequate stopping time.
Along with snow there are issues with recognizing icy patches and other especially low traction sections on the road and adjusting control inputs accordingly.
I can't tell if you've never driven in snow or never even attempted a basic computer vision or robotics task in your life, or both.
Computer vision is not solved.
Sensor fusion is not solved.
Predicting human behavior is not solved.
I also don't get that tone from the article, either.
There's a difference in environment. How can you seriously think "Well if they have self-driving robots in controlled warehouse scenarios, what's the novelty of self-driving robots in unpredictable and often treacherous real-world public road scenarios?"
1. What evaluation metrics should we use to measure the advancement of self-driving technology?
2. How can we measure the public's level of acceptance for these technologies, and what impact does media coverage (positive or negative) have in that respect?
For example, I would not personally gauge that SDCs are in early alpha. However, I live in a suburb of Phoenix, where Uber, Waymo, and Cruise [0] are all conducting extensive testing; I usually observe between 15 and 30 distinct SDCs during my 20-minute commute. I expect this familiarity has (by design, I'm sure) made me more comfortable with SDCs than most. I also assume that the environment is somewhat simpler than other metro areas, as we have very little precipitation and a mostly grid-like street layout.
My judgement of these cars is that they approximate the behavior of an extremely stodgy, overly conservative, but ultimately very alert driver. For example, they respond well to being cut off, dealing with late light changes, or unpredictable pedestrian behavior, while dealing poorly with things which require decision-making, such as making a right on red, or preemptively changing lanes to avoid the frequent stops of a bus. In other words, they've been optimizing for safety, and not trip efficiency; I think that this is probably the right order of priorities at this stage of development.
Given this, I would be comfortable taking driverless trips around town, on surface streets; I would therefore classify the current state of development as early beta more so than early alpha. However, this is a subjective assessment, not based on any objective metric.
At the same time, I read the news too, and I think we are observing the clash of two competing agendas. On one hand, you have the tech companies painting an overly-rosy picture of development, probably to soften up the market to increase (eventual) penetration.
On the other hand, you have overly-pessimistic outlets preaching various types of doom (job loss, trolley problem, etc) in order to drive clicks through fear, or (cynically) to poison the market and buy time for later technical entries to catch up to the leaders.
Both of these tactics will have varying levels of receptivity with different groups, roughly corresponding (I expect) to the Rogers adoption curve [1]. Therefore, I expect we'll continue to see both optimistic and pessimistic coverage for quite some time.
[0]: In this order of development progress, in my opinion
Why are companies going through the great expense of constructing full-size mock-ups if the domain problems haven't been solved on smaller mock-ups? Is there a fundamental difference between a 400 lb self-driving robot and a 2-ton self-driving robot - beyond the advertising novelty of being inside the car? Edit: If both robots are outside on a driving track, not in the Amazon warehouse.
And if "snow-vision" and other problems have been solved with smaller robots, or in other domains, why do news articles like this treat the topic as though it's entirely foreign and to be feared, instead of helping readers associate these concepts with existing concepts to drive acceptance?