News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by ggm on Thursday October 26, 2017 @10:01PM (#15565054)
First common mistake: Yes, Australia is geographically huge. No, it is not sparce. it is a highly urbanized economy in terms of geographic concentration of the population. Therefore, the oft-quoted extreme expense "oh, its so much more expensive to do it in OZ compared to ..." is bullshit: its not. There are of course some very expensive locations to service, but thats a USO problem. Overall, the cost of deployment of the CAN is within scale of any other urban economy. Higher than Singapore? Sure. But, comparable per head of population to NZ.

Second common mistake: The argument which led to the MTM replacing FTTP was not about technology. It was about the cost of capital works, and the economic model of recovery. Labor was stupid enough to float a mixed-economy pluralist argument hinting at a future independent non-utility model with zero cost (long term) to the government. This hung them because it allowed the Liberals to go hard on cost recovery and privatization. If the intent had been to reserve a national utility function in layers 1 and 2, and promote competition above this, we'd be in a different conversation.

That conversation was about structural separation of the former monopoly Telco. It was quashed by Labor, in a stupid reactive move. It was floated, and the banking sector indicated a preference. Reactively the union movement and Labor party moved to reject it: if the banks wanted it, it must be bad.

Talk about a huge missed opportunity.

The NZ model, by comparison is gold: structural separation. Crown holdings for the fiber. A pot of money, re-circulating to deploy to the cities, each region re-fills the pot to move to the next town. Far simpler. And.. fibre to (most) homes.

Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by Gatsky on Thursday October 26, 2017 @10:18PM (#15565149)
Yeah this is spot on.

Other comments are blaming the Liberals, but the reality is if you are an effective leader trying to create a huge infrastructure project that you care deeply about, you need to come up with a solution that will last through a change in government, with aligned economic and political contingencies. If you are just governing for fun then you do what Rudd did. It always lets you blame the next government though, as he is doing now.

Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by dalbasal on Friday October 27, 2017 @07:01AM (#15567237)
It's all "damned if you do" or don't regardless.

It's no secret that our political systems have problems, with this sort of thing. Factionalism, corporate interests and other monority special interest, continuity.

Sometimes policies have a chance of being coherent, usually through a small group of "authors" that have a clear idea of what they want to do. This is generally when a governing party gives free reign to some internal group.

The other option is bipartisan commitees & a "wide consulatation approach". This is how the vast majority of australian laws get made. There's an alarm-like flashing oof lights (red or green) in parliament when an attempt is made to do things otherwise (a split).

Anyways, the standard process means compromise. Specifically, comromise between all "relevant" participants. The two big parties, obviously. Several interested factions within those parties, and various corporate interests usually represented by specific industry chambers of commerce or similar. Everyone needs to get something.

Coherence and compromise just don't go together, not when it comes to policy/legislation.

Look at the americans. They've been fiddling with health policy for a decade. As far as I can tell, the more attention the issue gets, the worse it gets.

Anyway, apart from being "pro-internet" labour never really had a solid agenda. The parliamentary end of this sausage factory was basically "the internet is important!!" vs "why spend 100bn on streaming cat vids!?). The hyenas and crows did the rest.

Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by masklinn on Friday October 27, 2017 @06:45AM (#15567167)
> Other comments are blaming the Liberals

Perfectly rightfully.

> if you are an effective leader trying to create a huge infrastructure project that you care deeply about, you need to come up with a solution that will last through a change in government, with aligned economic and political contingencies.

On the other hand, the opposition can either try to work with or lie your ass off and sabotage everything, the latter being exactly what the liberals did with the NBN.

Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by raides on Thursday October 26, 2017 @10:46PM (#15565296)
To the Aussie's credit the infrastructure and the regulations instilled on businesses there have always been Federally imposed.

Since the mid-90s the government has imposed many regulations for control that has impeded much of the free market progress for network infrastructure. Those regulations coupled with needed external transit installations have not helped. For a long period of time the government would pick and choose companies based on their ideals rather than their talent. This has hindered progress from both sides of the fence by liberal and conservative administrations.

I ran a semi successful ISP and consulting company for a decade in the US and I have always enjoyed the tiering system we setup vs other country Infrastructures. It wasn't until recently when the FCC gained control that states started to use the new regulation power to hinder progress. I am still on the fence about the whole thing because the exploitation has not been bad in my area but the horror stores I have heard in other states make me sad. Hopefully it will get back to normal.

Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by ggm on Thursday October 26, 2017 @11:11PM (#15565401)
I'm not personally sold on the baby bell model of regional monopoly. I think the whole FIOS debacle, and what happened when google started offering citywide fibre says a lot about how US telco industry operates. Lobby your way to the people who make rules and then get rules passed to shut down anything which freaks your own monopoly of indifference.
Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by Trav5 on Friday October 27, 2017 @12:52AM (#15565798)
I am curious and not sure what to search for. What are you referring to? Link?
Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by Trav5 on Friday October 27, 2017 @11:03AM (#15569038)
What was the "whole FIOS debacle, and what happened when google started offering citywide Fibre"? Why the down votes? This sounds interesting, but I am not sure what to search for to learn more.
Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by ggm on Saturday October 28, 2017 @03:31AM (#15574331)
I do not live in the USA. What I am told by my colleagues who do, is that the post bell regional breakup created monopolies by location in order to prevent national dominance but give each region a reliable income in a time of voice call logistics. Fast forward to the emergence of fiber as a viable technology: either you live in a location serviced by a telco who is willing to re-engineer to fiber or you don't. Verizon exemplifies the quandary, it's a huge cost, they have to carve out special data models for cable companies to stop them refusing to drop coax, it's impossible to charge sanely, their shares tank. I am sure there are happy customers but there is no clear equality of service. It's a patchwork minefield.
Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by ioquatix on Thursday October 26, 2017 @11:14PM (#15565421)
I'm glad it finally happened in NZ and as you say, it's awesome. I'm rocking 1000/500 - the biggest limitation is international throughput and latency which I suppose they are working on and improving all the time.
Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by montecarl on Thursday October 26, 2017 @11:41PM (#15565552)
We need to get the physicists (general relativists?) working on upping the speed of light. Seriously though, how much larger is your latency than speed of light limitations? 2x?
Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by xoa on Friday October 27, 2017 @12:32AM (#15565728)
TrueNet keeps track of a lot of good ISP performance measures, including one for international latency [1]. Looking at that average latency to the USA at least it seems pretty damn decent, only about 30-60% worse then the theoretical limit imposed by current fiber tech (speed of light in standard silicon glass fiber is about 30% slower then in vacuum), since direct line is about 7000-8000 miles. And of course as a practical matter fibers are not run directly between every destination, so add on extra for that and if TrueNet's numbers are reasonably accurate then everyone seems to be doing a reasonable job given the distance.

I remember reading years ago about interesting research being done to use photonic-bandgap rims to make fibers that would allow propagation approaching vacuum speed [2], and if deployed eventually that could drop latency by another 40-60ms. But at least back then there seemed to be enough loss (3.5 dB/km) that it'd be impractical over long distances without excessive boosters, even ignoring any cost/durability issues of the fiber itself. That may have been improved in the last 4 years though, but I'm not sure if it ever did make it to market (or if there are even plans still in progress for it, raw throughput was impressive too FWIW).

At any rate: the NZ ISPs seem to be offering pretty solid service on that front even internationally, at least in terms of pure latency. If there is increasing congestion or other issues those are just matters of capex, and between the ISP's servers and premise links there might be more lag being added in. But I don't see any glaring core inefficiencies there in terms of the international link part, unless I'm missing something entirely. Looks a lot better then I'd have expected taking a guess based on how it was a decade ago.

----

1: https://truenet.nz/international-latency

2: "Towards high-capacity fibre-optic communications at the speed of light in vacuum": https://www.nature.com/articles/nphoton.2013.45 (DOI: 10.1038/nphoton.2013.45)

Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by ioquatix on Friday October 27, 2017 @06:21AM (#15567084)
So, I do understand there are limitations, but I guess I think that once the data has started to flow, it should maximise available capacity.

However, I feel like `pacman -Syu` should be faster. I don't mind the latency, but the throughput should be better right? I only get 1-2 Mbyte/s average using US servers.

Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by rayiner on Friday October 27, 2017 @07:05AM (#15567257)
Is this pricing accurate: https://ufb.org.nz/pricing-plans? I'm seeing prices like $150/month for symmetric 200/200: https://www.trustpower.co.nz/-/media/files/terms/legal-offer.... That's pretty expensive (about what I'm paying for symmetric gigabit with TV and phone in the U.S.).

It's interesting to note that the compromises made with UFB would not fly in the U.S. Liberals would kill it as a handout to rich people ("if you can't afford to feed your family by the end of the month, you can't afford $75 a month for the broadband service")[1] and conservatives would kill it because it's not available more than 50 km from an urban area.

[1] http://www.crainsnewyork.com/article/20140219/TECHNOLOGY/140...

Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by versteegen on Friday October 27, 2017 @08:19AM (#15567611)
A few months ago I compared ISPs and found that Trustpower were one of the most expensive, especially if you don't get the bundle discount for getting power through them.

Vodafone currently offer 200Mbps unlimited data fibre (don't know what the upload speed is) for $110/month, and unlimited speed (up to 900Mbps, depending on location) for $120/month, and deduct $10/month if you go on a contract.

It's only in the last couple years that you can get unlimited data at a reasonable price here.

A large fraction of the cost of bandwidth in NZ is international transit, because there's only one significant undersea cable connecting NZ, the Southern Cross Cable. I couldn't find current prices, but in 2013 it cost about US$0.10/GB to go through that cable [1]

[1] http://www.strategies.nzl.com/wpapers/2013011.htm

Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by rayiner on Friday October 27, 2017 @09:28AM (#15568033)
Looks like that’s 200/20.
Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by jakelarkin on Thursday October 26, 2017 @11:55PM (#15565613)
hmm apparently the Southern Cross has 3.6Tbps of capacity which I could see being a constraint on throughput if that's the bulk of bandwidth

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southern_Cross_Cable

Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by elementalest on Friday October 27, 2017 @01:38AM (#15565968)
When the Liberals privatised the government owned monopoly telco (now called Tesltra), they didn't properly structurally seperate it in the first place. The government, like NZ, could have gotten the wholesale part of Telstra to start upgrading network infrastructure. If they had done it properly the first time, we wouldn't be in this mess.
Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by will_hughes on Friday October 27, 2017 @07:52AM (#15567494)
> The government, like NZ, could have gotten the wholesale part of Telstra to start upgrading network infrastructure.

They couldn't, though, without a lot more difficulty.

You're missing the context that at the time of Rudd's election and the NBN design/build plan, Telstra was actively hostile towards the government. Solomon Trujillo was the CEO at the time, and actively fought against any suggestion that Telstra might be structurally separated (a-la Telecom NZ's split into Chorus and Spark), or be required to build a nationwide wholesale fibre network.

Telstra under Trujillo was the company that famously gave a last minute 13-page (non-compliant) response[1] to a call for bids to build the NBN, that was effectively a giant middle finger to the government.

Forcing a structural separation when the government own a minority stake in the company[2] would've required either re-purchasing it at market rates, or some kind of legislative change, and thus opening the government up to a shareholder lawsuit. At the time, the CAN and Fibre back-haul networks were considered some of Telstra's greatest assets, those would've been some major purchases.

There were a bunch of bad options, but having been backed into this corner by previous government decisions - there wasn't a whole lot they could've done.

[1] https://www.computerworld.com.au/article/270911/telstra_bann...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telstra#Privatisation

Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by elementalest on Friday October 27, 2017 @09:26AM (#15568025)
You misunderstand, I'm saying that if Telstra were properly separated right from the start (when the Howard government privatised it), the Rudd government could have easily gotten Telstra wholesale to do what Chorus in NZ is doing now. Most of Australia would probably have FTTP by now, or at least FTTN/HFC.

I do agree with the rest of your comment though.

Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by rangibaby on Thursday October 26, 2017 @11:50PM (#15565587)
> The NZ model, by comparison is gold: structural separation. Crown holdings for the fiber. A pot of money, re-circulating to deploy to the cities, each region re-fills the pot to move to the next town. Far simpler. And.. fibre to (most) homes.

Only after A LOT of pain. Broadband uptake was pathetic in NZ until Telecom, formed out of the NZ Post Office and sold to overseas buyers in 1990, was split up into retail (Spark) and infrastructure (Chorus) ten years ago. It's smooth sailing now, but it could have been so much easier.

Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by kurthr on Friday October 27, 2017 @03:28AM (#15566368)
Wait... are you saying that dialup internet was slow until 1990 when ISDN came out? Or that broadband uptake was pathetic until 2007 with the Spark/Chorus spilt?

One of those is really early for any internet, and the other 17 years later, is really late!

Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by rangibaby on Sunday October 29, 2017 @03:18AM (#15578321)
The latter. I think there was literally one overseas internet connection in 1990.

For years Telecom managed to get away with doing nothing other than charging exorbitant fees. It's just a coincidence the decision to unbundle came immediately after these comments in 2006:

> What has every telco in the world done in the past? It's used confusion as its chief marketing tool ... customers know that's what the game has been. They know we're not being straight up.

– Teresa Gattung, Telecom CEO

Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by phire on Sunday October 29, 2017 @06:18AM (#15578763)
In my option, New Zealand internet didn't really get good until 2011.

That is when Chorus was finally 100% separated from telecom.

From 2006-2011, Chorus were inducing congestion in the ADSL backhaul to put non-telecom ISPs (particularly ISPs with all the high-bandwidth power-users) at a disadvantage. An ISP could buy unlimited bandwidth to the outside world, and give each customer ADSL 2+ connections of upto 24Mbit, but the backhaul between Chorus and the ISP to terminate all those ADSL connections was rate-limited to roughly 64kbps times the number of connections that ISP had.

If all an ISPs customers went online at the same time and started downloading, everyone's throughput would drop to 64kbps.

And Chorus would absolutely refuse to sell any extra backhaul bandwidth.

It was in the best interest for all ISPs to have a healthy base of non-skilled users who barely used their ADSL connections, just so the rest of their users wouldn't get too congested. It was also around this time ISPs implemented various perks to encourage power-users to only download at night time.

This all stopped in 2011, and the bandwidth caps that all ISPs were offering suddenly shot up.

Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by robocat on Thursday October 26, 2017 @10:54PM (#15565340)
My main issue is that the investment enables digital consumption, without much impact on production.

For example, a flaw I had with the NZ rollout: it was deployed to citizens before businesses. It feels kind of sad as a business owner when your business remains on VDSL while the suburbs are getting fibre (although lovely to get Netflix at home on fibre!).

Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by ggm on Thursday October 26, 2017 @11:09PM (#15565394)
This is a totally valid point. I'm on the consumers side, so to me it made sense to bulk out the build for eyeballs but not enabling SMEs to leverage high bandwidth was silly. The stuff they did in Wellington making a city heart fibre ring some years back had lots of upsides.
Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by indemnity on Friday October 27, 2017 @12:20AM (#15565688)
In NZ: At work we have 100mbps fibre shared by 50 people, at home quite a few of us have 1gbps fibre. It’s kind of amusing how bad our work internet situation is compared to consumer internet.
Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by rstuart4133 on Sunday October 29, 2017 @08:18PM (#15582349)
Actually, the first mistake is saying the NBN was Rudd's idea.

The problem was created by the Libs in 1997, when they privatised a government monopoly, Telstra. Telstra promptly morphed into natural shape of private monopolies everywhere: a bloody great rent seeker, beholden to no one. They sat on the existing copper network assets, milking them for all their were worth and showing not the slightest interest investing to upgrade the asset when new technologies arrived. (The contrast with their actions in the mobile sector, where they didn't have a monopoly could not be more stark. We have a world class mobile network, and were the first to phase out 2G.)

10 years later, the prime minster who created this mess was still in power. It was only 10 years later, but by then it was obvious even to him something had to be done because we had this headline: “Australian Prime Minister John Howard on Monday announced a 2.0 billion dollar (1.68 billion US) plan to provide fast and affordable Internet access across the vast country”. http://www.smh.com.au/news/Technology/n/2007/06/18/118201899... Notice this was several years before Rudd "had" the same idea.

Turned out 1.68 billion was a bit of an underestimate, so it went nowhere. We've are now spending 20 times that amount to extract ourselves from the mess he created. I do hope the $14B they earned from the sale of Telstra (which is several times less than the cost of the fix) was worth it at the time.

Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by adrianratnapala on Friday October 27, 2017 @01:11AM (#15565869)
> There are of course some very expensive locations to service, but thats a USO problem.

I don't know what the acronym USO means. But I do know that the expensive locations are politically important because there is pressure for the government to build various things out in just those locations. They political lobbying arises precisely because those locations are so expensive that the locals wouldn't pay for it themselves.

Re:How Australia's $49B internet network came to be ridiculed by dsymonds on Friday October 27, 2017 @01:36AM (#15565960)
In this context, USO means Universal Service Obligations, namely that approximately everyone can get access.

https://www.acma.gov.au/Industry/Telco/Carriers-and-service-...