News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No, of that I'm innocent by astura on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @03:54PM (#15553523)
I'll preface this with, I don't know who this guy is and this is the first time I heard anything about this, I am unfamiliar with the allegations.

I am just absolutely shocked by this

>I don’t have employees, I don’t cut checks for investment. None of the women who came forward were ever in a position where I could make or break their careers. Sexual Harassment requires that I have such power.

JFC, does anyone actually believe this? This is absolutely... Shocking. Disturbing... I have no words...

Shouldn't he have consulted with the EEOC before making such a bold statement?

https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/types/sexual_harassment.cfm

>The harasser can be the victim's supervisor, a supervisor in another area, a co-worker, or someone who is not an employee of the employer, such as a client or customer.

It just makes it seem like he has no idea what appropriate behavior is at all. Really takes away from his credibility. Makes me think he's a total creep but thinks it's other people who are the problem.

Also, it stood out to me it seems odd that he used "sexual harassment" as a proper noun.

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by openmosix on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:15PM (#15553754)
The problem is, he is one of the MOST influential people in the tech ecosystem. Yes, he is a "blogger", but in many cases he could make or break a product, a startup or a career. A friend of mine startup was noticed (and acquired) by Facebook because Scoble started blogging about it and that came to the attention of Zuckerberg.

This guy leaves and breathes in tech conferences, as he is a regular invited speaker/guest. I'm sure he had to see, read a million of "code of conducts". The fact he claims "I have no employees... I have no power" is...disgusting.

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by jcahill on Thursday October 26, 2017 @09:10AM (#15558449)
I challenge "one of the MOST influential people" as vigorously as is posthumanly possible.

Off the top, how many people here who are both under 30 and hack on something (hardware, wetware, anything) know who scoble is? I only vaguely remembered his name with effort, and even that may have been by analogy to somebody else.

In fact: the more I look into him, the more the expression "never-was" (as a more extreme form of "has-been") comes to mind. Just step through his wikipedia entry⁽¹⁾ and it'll be hard to disagree with the assessment:

    > 4 Appearances
    >
    > In November, 2013, Scoble was co-keynote speaker with
    > Shel Israel at the 2013 Telstra Australian Digital
    > Summit. Scoble and Israel talked to their book titled
    > "Age of Context: Mobile, Sensors, Data and the Future of
    > Privacy".

read: noise.

    > On April 1, 2008, The Register ran an April fool’s spoof
    > claiming Robert Scoble was actually an IBM bot.

read: a stumbling, college newspaper-esque exercise⁽²⁾ in retrofitting a disposable assignment (april 1) to trash-talk scoble openly. unambiguously dripping with disdain, really.

    > On November 14, 2007, he was a contestant on a game show
    > at NewTeeVee Live […]

at what now?

    > [f]eaturing other internet celebrities such as Veronica
    > Belmont, Casey McKinnon, Cali Lewis, Kevin Rose, Justin
    > Kan, and others.

who? there are two tech names here, and zero celebrities.

    > On November 6, 2006, Scoble appeared as a panelist on a
    > Chinese Software Professionals Association event called
    > "The New Age of Influence: The Impact of Social Computing
    > on Media and Marketing".

read: noise.

    > 5 Milliscoble
    >
    > In September 2008, Follow cost, a website which
    > calculated how annoying it would be to follow anyone on
    > Twitter, invented the milliscoble unit of measurement
    > defined as: "1/1000 of the average daily Twitter status
    > updates by Robert Scoble as of 10:09 CST September 25,
    > 2008." At that time, Scoble was averaging 21.21 tweets
    > per day, so a milliscoble is 0.02121 tweets per day. A
    > person with a milliscoble rating of 1000 will be as
    > annoying to follow as Scoble.

read: further open contempt of scoble as shitposter incarnate.

So what do we have? A guy who had some kind of readership as a microsoft evangelist 13+ years ago, then circled the drain of ~web tv~ for a decade, then landed an Entrepreneur in Residence gig — read: unpaid internship⁽³⁾ — ultimately just circling a slightly newer, slightly shinier drain (VR).

One who, along the way, consciously uncoupled⁽⁴⁾ from all the content streams and personal branding whose maintenance constitute the entirety of an independent writing career. The blogger's own site, at .blog no less, is a contentless placeholder now.

We're left with some sorta phantasm of a now-defunct, still-not-tech personality: a never-was.

If the Ghostblogger of Milliscobles Past can kill your startup, your startup almost certainly didn't need to exist.

____________________

¹ http://enwp.org/Robert_Scoble

² https://theregister.co.uk/2008/04/01/ibm_scoble_nano

³ https://scobleizer.blog/2016/05/17/mental-blocks-resource-co...

⁴ https://scobleizer.blog/2012/07/02/scalable-livin

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by ghaff on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:20PM (#15553797)
I think you overstate his influence even back in the day. But absolutely to the rest of your comment. One of the more cringeworthy parts of a rather cringeworthy post.
Re:No, of that I'm innocent by DonHopkins on Thursday October 26, 2017 @12:17PM (#15560257)
Scoble himself has always overstated and self-aggrandized his own influence, as have so many others in the press, the industry, blogs and twitter (many of them actually trying to suck up to him and flatter him, in order to get a good mention in return -- see "Lesson 5: Reciprocate" below), which contradicts his current ploy of desperately trying to downplay his own influence so he can justify his behavior as "almost but not quite entirely unlike sexual harassment".

https://www.theverge.com/2017/10/25/16547332/robert-scoble-s...

Scoble has been called “one of the most influential players in the [tech] industry,” and one of the “top ten people to know in Silicon Valley.”

https://venturebeat.com/2015/01/28/5-things-silicon-valley-c...

The amount of love the tech community has for Robert Scoble is overwhelming. If the tech community were a country, Scoble would be its ambassador. Not only because we would want him to be, but because he truly knows more about the state of the global tech community than anyone else on planet Earth. I’ve known Scoble for seven years, and I’ve always been in awe of how much knowledge this man possesses about so many startups.

[...]

Lesson 5: Reciprocate

Due to his influential status, Scoble gets many perks from entrepreneurs around the world, just like most influencers do: Free gadgets, access to apps, invitations to visit conferences and stay in nice hotel rooms, and so on. These are usually forgotten by most influential figures in the Valley. However, Scoble never forgets these gestures and always acknowledges them — either through a Facebook post, tweet, or a reciprocal gesture. He doesn’t just take these benefits for granted like other folks of his caliber might.

Entrepreneurs, of course, appreciate this and remember him for it. Many of the activities throughout Scoble’s birthday for example, were contributed by individuals, due to their admiration for Scoble and appreciation of him.

https://www.huffingtonpost.com/richard-lorenzen/the-top-10-p...

3. Robert Scoble

Many people know Robert Scoble for his blog Scobleizer, which he wrote when he was working with Microsoft. Today, Scoble working for Rackspace and their sponsored community site Building 43, which focuses on highlighting and promoting cutting-edge startups and breakthrough technology. If you want to be featured in Silicon Valley, he is the individual to turn to. After all, his influence in the area is long-standing as Scoble grew up in Silicon Valley, just blocks away from Apple’s head office.

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by zaroth on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:22PM (#15553832)
Where does this line of thinking lead? I mean it's one thing to limit any attempts at intimacy in the workplace, but if you're just 'influential enough' then you expand this definition to include anyone in the entire tech sector? This seems clearly illogical.

Again, if there was assault it's a totally different matter. But sexual harassment is a lower bar specifically because of the idea no one should have to work in a hostile work environment. You can't create a hostile work environment if you're not actually working with someone or exerting direct influence over their career?

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by slg on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:26PM (#15554437)
I believe you are looking at this problem the wrong way. Part of that is the fault of the media and all of us on social media that focus on the heinousness of Harvey Weinstein's actions and our immediate move to dehumanize and vilify him. Weinstein was so far past the line that it might cloud were the line actually is. It is only natural for men to look at him and go "I'm not that bad, I didn't threaten anyone, I didn't rape anyone, I didn't proposition anyone I have direct control over, I didn't do any of this at work, etc.".

However the line isn't people being sexually harassed at work, it is people being sexually harassed at all. This isn't limited to drunkenly groping women at tech conferences or asking women you might potentially hire to shower with you. The problem is that your first romantic move with someone shouldn't be a grope or an offer to get naked. Simply don't behave in that manor until you know your actions will be received positively by the other person. It really isn't that difficult to simply treat people with empathy and think of their responses to your actions before you make them. If you do that you will never even get to the point of unwantedly groping someone.

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by zaroth on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @09:08PM (#15555583)
In a perfect world, no one's feelings get hurt in love, and there is no war. We do not live in that world, and as mere mortals we are incapable of creating such a utopia.

It's a strawman that "your first romantic move with someone shouldn't be a grope or an offer to get naked." The reality is that ham-fisted proposals and hurtful rejection are rampant 'out there on the dance floor' and the purpose of sexual harassment policy is not, in fact, a idealized manual on how to behave in love and romance, but rules which apply exclusively in the workplace in order to ensure equality in the workplace.

If you're talking about sexual harassment outside of the workplace, then you're Doing It Wrong. If you're conflating poorly executed romantic endeavor with what is actually assault, that's even worse.

Please understand I'm engaging in the debate not to defend some asshole who I don't know and couldn't care two shits about, but I think there's a deeper meaning & understanding to be had here...

It seems to me, only from what little I've read about the man, that Scoble quite clearly is a jerk and an ass, and he owes quite a few people quite a few apologies. That much I most certainly am not debating!

I feel like we're on the cusp of a great wave of progress in the area. But I think if mere jerks and assholes are the new target, the inevitable backlash could set the whole movement back a decade.

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by slg on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @11:34PM (#15556164)
I was not referring to sexual harassment in the legal sense. I was referring to it in the literal sense of harassment of a sexual nature. For example cat calling a woman on the street might be legal, but that is still literally sexual harassment and shouldn't be acceptable. If you use empathy as your guideline for your own personal behavior, the actual code of conduct for your employer or whatever professional environment you are in is irrelevant because you will already be abiding by a higher standard.
Re:No, of that I'm innocent by zaroth on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @11:45PM (#15556201)
This is what entirely missing the point of sexual harassment policy looks like. Sexual harassment policy is a workplace equalizer. It's literally not about men acting like gentleman or having a higher standard.

If you're talking about harassment in general, umm... people are obnoxious to each other constantly and perpetually. Kumbaya let's make it all better? I don't think so!

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by slg on Thursday October 26, 2017 @02:07AM (#15556745)
Agree to disagree then. I think this is a symptom of a larger issue and I think it is a disservice to only try to remedy the symptom rather than looking for larger change.
Re:No, of that I'm innocent by TarpitCarnivore on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:29PM (#15553902)
> You can't create a hostile work environment if you're not actually working with someone or exerting direct influence over their career?

Quinn's story was not at a 'work environment' so does it have any less impact? Why are you letting him adjust the narrative to define what he feels is harassment?

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by openmosix on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:54PM (#15554172)
Let's also not forget that it was a conference. A very laid back-camping kind of conference, but a conference. In today's standards - where you can't join a project or visit/talk to a conference without accepting a CoC - this would still be considered an extension of the workplace, or at least be classified as a "professional setting". We are not talking rocket science: if you are in a professional setting, getting overly drunk, make out in public and then proceeding to random groping - is NOT ok. You can have him redefine the narrative however he wants, he still a serial sexual offender.
Re:No, of that I'm innocent by zaroth on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @08:50PM (#15555522)
Read back to the context of my question. Two drunk people coming together to "make out" at a camp out -- this is a "conference" like Burning Man is a conference -- if this is in and of itself is creating a "hostile work environment" I think that words are losing their meaning.

I don't really care what kind of narrative Scoble is trying to make. I have no knowledge of the specifics of his situation or his encounters, and couldn't care less about passing judgement on him.

But I was very curious about this idea that, which seems to be stated throughout this thread, someone can become so influential in an industry that any non-professional contact they have industry-wide could be sexual harassment.

And again, and again, I have to say, if there was assault that is just a completely different issue entirely.

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by rcade on Thursday October 26, 2017 @08:34PM (#15564570)
I don't know where you're getting the idea it's not a conference. Here's a link to a photo set from Foo Camp 2010, where the incident occurred:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/deanputney/sets/72157624362235...

Burning Man it ain't.

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by zaroth on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:00PM (#15554229)
Quinn's story sounds like assault and has nothing to do with sexual harassment. To me that just muddies the waters.
Re:No, of that I'm innocent by emodendroket on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @07:37PM (#15555231)
Surely he doesn't intend to say "I'm not guilty of sexual harassment but rather sexual assault."
Re:No, of that I'm innocent by zaroth on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @08:57PM (#15555545)
Not at all. Sexual harassment describes different behavior than assault, and is not a crime. The same behavior which may be sexual harassment in one context could be entirely appropriate in another context. And all that is to say, there is a necessary context to sexual harassment.

Scoble claims that any sexual advances he made lacked the necessary context to be considered sexual harassment. He may not even be wrong.

I referenced the UN fact sheet on "What is Sexual Harassment" in another comment but perhaps I should quote it directly;

Unwelcome sexual advances, requests for sexual favors, and other verbal or physical conduct of a sexual nature _when_ (emphasis added):

· Submission to such conduct is made either explicitly or implicitly a term or condition of an individual's employment, or

· Submission to or rejection of such conduct by an individual is used as a basis for employment decisions affecting such individual, or

· Such conduct has the purpose or effect of unreasonably interfering with an individual's work performance or creating an intimidating, hostile, or offensive working environment.

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by emodendroket on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @10:42PM (#15555952)
To me, hairsplitting about whether the conduct technically counts as sexual harassment is more or less beside the point and even getting into it makes the allegations sound more, rather than less, credible.
Re:No, of that I'm innocent by zaroth on Thursday October 26, 2017 @01:41AM (#15556629)
Maybe I misunderstood the purpose of this thread. I didn't think this was about assessing the specific allegations at all, but precisely about understanding the definition of sexual harassment.
Re:No, of that I'm innocent by DonHopkins on Thursday October 26, 2017 @12:30PM (#15560383)
It's the willingness of so many men to split hairs in order to defend a pig that is so offensive and threatening to women.
Re:No, of that I'm innocent by openmosix on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:29PM (#15553905)
If you are the keynote speaker of a conference, DO NOT flirt with other attendees or other coworkers, regardless of the line of report. There are code of conduct left and right for a reason. Saying "they were not my employees" does not excuse you from using your influence, in a work-related setting, to approach someone else for sex matters.
Re:No, of that I'm innocent by zaroth on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:49PM (#15554128)
Focusing on the conference aspect is not particularly helpful in understanding the expected framework here...

I assume there's nothing magical about a conference environment. In some cases the alleged harassment is occurring at bars where everyone is drinking alcohol. In another case it's a long-standing online chat relationship.

Where is the Harvey-esque influence peddling? I mean in that case is was more like straight-up blackmail.

Sometimes a guy will flirt with a girl and the feeling is not mutual. This happens quite frequently and it's not illegal or even wrong. Being an influential or powerful man (or woman!) doesn't make this wrong or illegal unless there is something more to it...

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by jsmthrowaway on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:31PM (#15553934)
Even simpler than that, really: treat a conference and the outside social stuff that rides along as a work environment regardless of your status or role. You’re not at a knitting convention. You’re meeting professional peers. I had to fuck up to learn this, and I think it’s extremely important.

Q: Would I do $thing if this were at my office?

A: No.

Done.

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by zaroth on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:57PM (#15554196)
I think I might be misunderstanding you. People absolutely should not be expected to live their whole lives like they are at the office. What defines outside social stuff that rides along as a work environment?

How far outside your social sphere are you supposed to be meeting or getting introduced to actual people who are interesting to you as a peer and potential romantic partner?

So it sounds like it's back to what I said earlier -- there's basically no social environment related to the tech industry where you think it would be alright for someone who happens to be influential in the tech sector to flirt with someone? But this seems to absolutely not be the definition of sexual harassment under the EEOC.

To try to remove some of the moral righteousness from it, lets assume we're talking about a single male, no wife or girlfriend, who is a well-known tech executive and blogger.

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by ghaff on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:12PM (#15554320)
I don't think anyone here is talking about "flirting." Although I think it's also fair to say that the closer you get to being "in the office" the more caution is probably called for.
Re:No, of that I'm innocent by noonesays on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @07:20PM (#15555135)
> I don't think anyone here is talking about "flirting."

Literally three comments up from your own comment:

> If you are the keynote speaker of a conference, DO NOT flirt with other attendees or other coworkers, regardless of the line of report.

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by ghaff on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @07:31PM (#15555199)
Fair enough. I did not see that and would actually disagree with it for appropriately non aggressive values of flirting. (If you’re a high profile keynote speaker specifically though, caution is increasingly called for.)
Re:No, of that I'm innocent by zaroth on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @07:52PM (#15555298)
Greer's account of Scoble flirting with her at a hotel bar (drinks in both hands, touched her leg) is quite the counter-point.

It appears like that moment had a lasting and significant impact on Michelle. [1] The repercussions as Michelle tells them are certainly terrible. I feel badly for Michelle and want to understand better what she experienced from her perspective.

That was certainly unwanted sexual contact. Was it sexual assault? Possibly. Was is sexual harassment? Possibly! All unwanted sexual contact is not actually automatically sexual harassment. [2]

[1] - https://www.buzzfeed.com/doree/woman-accuses-robert-scoble-o...

[2] - http://www.un.org/womenwatch/osagi/pdf/whatissh.pdf

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by ghaff on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @08:08PM (#15555368)
I think that goes way beyond casual "flirting" in most people's book. Obviously people differ, signals get misread, and tolerances vary. I'm aware of one "code of conduct violation" report based on a Tshirt that made me roll my eyes--as well as the eyes of quite a few women I know. But that doesn't seem like a particular edge case as reported.
Re:No, of that I'm innocent by zaroth on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @09:17PM (#15555633)
Touching someone's leg is considered flirting, is it not? Honestly, I did not mean to mis-characterize it.
Re:No, of that I'm innocent by ghaff on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @10:03PM (#15555806)
No. I would not have said so Clearly it varies based on how well you know and your relationship with a person. But randomly in a semi-professional context?
Re:No, of that I'm innocent by zaroth on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @10:06PM (#15555818)
It was clearly inappropriate, that's not what I'm asking. Inappropriate flirting is a thing. If I read in a book, "she touched his leg" I would call that flirting.

I feel like there's something I'm missing because, as recounted, his actions had such a strong and lasting impact to Greer.

Maybe this Scoble dude is just a nuclear style creep and just having to sit next to him is torturous. But that seems highly unlikely. I've never met the guy! I don't recall ever hearing him speak or watching a video of him even. So...

If I'm understanding the story, 4 people at a hotel bar drinking, one touching someone's leg. And what that led to, or possibly even caused -- I think it's fair to describe it as incredibly damaging? Obviously we want to avoid people being hurt like that. So, we construct social mores and civil law to try to prevent it from happening, and punish a small subset of offenders very harshly.

I'm a little stunned by all of it.

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by TarpitCarnivore on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:40PM (#15554046)
Let's go even more simple: Just be a decent human being

What you do and don't do should not be tied entirely to work relation situations.

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by zaroth on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:59PM (#15554217)
Decent human beings make unwanted sexual advances all the fucking time. We can't read each other's minds after all.

This is why we go to the trouble of defining a "sexual harassment" standard in the workplace, which holds coworkers to a higher standard of care than what is expected outside of the workplace.

Obviously we are not supposed to live our lives interacting with every other human purely professionally.

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by countryslicker on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:42PM (#15554542)
Wow. Mind reading is not required. You've watched too many movies that go from strangers to married with children in 90 minutes. How about spending weeks, months, and even years building a relationship? Talking->dating->holding hands->... Spend more than 5 minutes on each stage. I know it seems old-fashioned, but it can really reduce the degree of offense when you misjudge the stage of a relationship.
Re:No, of that I'm innocent by zaroth on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @07:30PM (#15555191)
Very condescending reply and ad hominem isn't necessary, but I think is reflective of the strength of the argument.

Dating is messy, complicated business. People get hurt. There is no magic ritual or length of time that will prevent that.

But I think the ivory tower condescension that if only men would follow this or that prescriptive approach is extremely damaging and even perpetuates the problem.

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by SAI_Peregrinus on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @11:23PM (#15556127)
Harassment is a pattern of undesired behavior. One advance is OK, but if you're turned down you DO NOT MAKE ANOTHER to that person. Just accept it and move on.

Really that's it. It applies everywhere. It applies to non-sexual harassment as well.

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by countryslicker on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:30PM (#15554455)
Does your office serve alcohol? Does your rule of thumb extend to what you eat and drink? What kind of clothes you wear? Whether you stay or leave?

I think it would be great if it did. But then you would have to significantly restructure conferences to conform. Many of the official events of a conference are blatant violations of workplace behavior.

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by zaroth on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @07:46PM (#15555273)
Since drinking an unspecified amount of alcohol can render a woman (but not a man) incapable of consenting while possibly also giving the outward appearance of consenting, no absolutely don't serve alcohol at the workplace when women are present.

Now of course this is an absurd statement, but are their elements of truth in it? Quinn's account is Scoble and another woman were "making out" and that both were drunk. There was no question at all of Scoble's capacity to consent but Quinn felt she or her friend was able to determine the woman (who she doesn't know and apparently didn't talk to) was not able to consent, and claim that Scoble was minutes from raping her.

So, in short, a dumpster fire.

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by rcade on Thursday October 26, 2017 @08:50PM (#15564661)
Three other witnesses have come forward and said that they were concerned the woman was too drunk to consent. Artur Bergman's account: "Me and my friend realized we had seen Scoble appear next to her repeatedly during the evening. Pouring more and more alcohol for her. After seeing this for a while we felt we had to intervene and help her get away."

https://twitter.com/crucially/status/921317876169977857

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by tptacek on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:35PM (#15554488)
It leads to professionals treating their work as if it was a profession.
Re:No, of that I'm innocent by emodendroket on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:04PM (#15553629)
Yeah, I'm in pretty much the same place, with no idea who this guy is or what he's accused of, but I feel like this statement is having the opposite of the intended effect on me.
Re:No, of that I'm innocent by donohoe on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:13PM (#15553730)
If I'm reading it right, is he saying he is not a "sexual harasser" as opposed to just a simple "sexual assaulter"!?

He should have taken his lawyers advice.

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by t0mbstone on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:04PM (#15554251)
If someone is your co-worker and you flirt with them and engage in a voluntary affair with them, is it sexual harassment?

What about when you are their boss, and in a position to fire them or affect their career if they don't engage or flirt back?

One of these can definitely be interpreted as sexual harassment (the situation where the person feels they have to accept the proposition or fear losing their job).

On the other hand, the situation where the two co-workers are on equal footing would only be considered sexual harassment if the flirting is unwelcome and continues even after it has been made clear that it is unwelcome.

The key difference is the fact that it is impossible to retrospectively prove or disprove whether or not the relationship was actually consensual, when one person is in a superior position and can making hiring/firing decisions or affect the other person's career.

Or at least that's my interpretation of the point that I believe Scoble was making.

He wasn't in a hiring/firing position or superior position to affect the careers any of the women when they engaged in the illicit behavior with him. It was consensual behavior between peers, and as such, does not automatically count as sexual harassment (even if he was being an unethical slimeball and cheating on his wife).

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by zaroth on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:18PM (#15553777)
It can be any of those people, true. But EEOC also says;

harassment is illegal when it is so frequent or severe that it creates a hostile or offensive work environment or when it results in an adverse employment decision (such as the victim being fired or demoted).

So I think he is responding to the second half of that definition, meaning it's not totally irrelevant.

For a client or customer's harassment to be illegal it would have to be "so frequent or severe it creates a hostile or offensive work environment".

Note that "offensive work environment" certainly doesn't mean someone was offended once.

Let me caveat this with I have read absolutely none of the accusations levied.

I do think that sexual harassment should be defined carefully. In some cases what people are describing as sexual harassment is actually assault and I think the two should be carefully distinguished.

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by jsmthrowaway on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:14PM (#15553743)
Don’t worry about not having heard of Robert Scoble. After this, you almost certainly never will. Going forward, anyone who supports him, finances him, gives him a platform, or even acknowledges his existence positively is themselves culpable for unleashing such a horrific, unapologetic person upon our industry.

I almost vomited reading this abhorrent statement in its entirety. I’m still stunned, and very little about sexual impropriety in SV stuns me any more. This is a whole new level that I didn’t even think possible, and one of the sibling comments correctly points out that we will be talking about this for years, and years, and years.

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by dominotw on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:08PM (#15553664)
I think the implication is that victims would have gone to law enforcement if he has no power over them, i.e no consequences for going to law enforcement.

I don't understand why they cant report harassment to law enforcement if its ' unlawful to harass a person '. Thats the only way to get justice in our society.

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by UncleMeat on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:33PM (#15553949)
In my experience, most women have done this a couple of times and found it both painful and useless. This leads to apathy.

Yesterday my partner was harassed by a doctor. I asked if she wanted to file a complaint or report it to somebody. She simply looked disappointed and said that no it would be a pain and almost certainly accomplish nothing. Better to not see this doctor again and try to schedule appointments with female doctors when possible. This is because this sort of thing has happened to her dozens of times in her lifetime, reporting it has never worked, and she already has enough on her plate. She didn't want this to be the state of things, but was resigned to it.

Yes, this person will likely continue to be an asshole. But after people try so many times to do the right thing and are rebuffed we cannot keep expecting them to do the same thing over and over. It becomes one more thing to feel guilty about in these sorts of scenarios.

Re:No, of that I'm innocent by dominotw on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:37PM (#15554008)
>, most women have done this a couple of times and found it both painful and useless. This leads to apathy.

Whats the alternative though. How do we fix this.