News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by gumby on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:01PM (#15544773)
Interesting that this BBC article doesn't mention that the concentration camp was arguably a British invention in the first place -- certainly this Russian camp followed the model developed by the Bitish in the Boer war.
Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by NittLion78 on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:09PM (#15544830)
As I've understood things the more I read, the vast majority of mass deportation and mass executions enacted by the USSR and Nazis were largely inspired by the actions taken in the US vs the large native populations.

How those two entities went about pursuing those goals varied, but both were needlessly and mindlessly brutal, just like the act that inspired them.

It can be amazing how awful the acts you commit look when you see another entity perform them on another.

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by sdoering on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:53PM (#15545162)
I am currently listing to the audio book 'Black Earth' from Timothy Snyder. There the author shows the aforementioned links and inspirations for Stalin and Hitler in how the US dealt with the natives.

I am interested in how the analysis will progress further.

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by colanderman on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @06:59PM (#15545943)
Indeed, the entire concept of Lebensraum was rooted in Manifest Destiny. [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lebensraum#Origins

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by cryptonector on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:55PM (#15545176)
Not to detract from what the U.S. govt did to natives, but a more likely explanation is that concentration camps are... the obvious thing to build if you want to isolate a population. I don't think the internment camps in the U.S. during WWII were modeled after Nazi concentration camps, and certainly they weren't in that there were no extermination facilities in the internment camps, thank goodness. A "camp" is just too obvious to suppose it's modeled on some past "invention" of the camp.
Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by user982 on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @05:49PM (#15545532)
"Hitler's concept of concentration camps as well as the practicality of genocide owed much, so he claimed, to his studies of English and United States history. He admired the camps for Boer prisoners in South Africa and for the Indians in the wild West; and often praised to his inner circle the efficiency of America's extermination—by starvation and uneven combat—of the red savages who could not be tamed by captivity." - John Toland, Adolf Hitler: The Definitive Biography[1]

[1]: https://books.google.com/books?id=ZzBkAwAAQBAJ&pg=PT1096&dq=...

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by cryptonector on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @10:27AM (#15550370)
That's not a quote, and there's no footnote or reference of any kind there. Got a better source?
Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by gumby on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @05:22PM (#15545352)
These camps the British deployed in Russia sound as brutal as the ones they had deployed the Natal not so long previously.

Not to defend the US actions in the slightest but their 1940s internment camps were similar to the "villages" they used in Viet Nam in the 1960s (a technique also used by the British during the Malayan Emergency in the 1950s BTW). In a hierarchy of brutality: less than the ones in Russia and South Africa).

(You can be just as brutal without corralling people -- Andrew Jackson and the Cherokee, or Gengis Kahn come to mind as being as evil as, say, Guantanamo. But people have found many ways to be mean to others, and I agree with you that taking one step down that path doesn't automatically make you equivalent to those who have taken many).

But "camp" is like so many things more obvious in retrospect than at the time so be careful of accidental anachronistic bias. In part it exists thanks to technology: it used to be expensive to keep prisoners, so unless they could pay their way (i.e they were nobility) it was simpler just to kill them. The invention of barbed wire and practical guns, as well as, ironically, changing views of the moral worth of people (an increase in valuing life) lead to their development.

You can see the technological aspect in Russia itself: when the Tsars wanted to get rid of someone but not kill them, the victim was simply sent to Siberia. Getting back was so hard they were for all intents and purposes interned there. The Soviets, being more industrially minded, were the ones who set up the Gulag system. (And though it would be facile at this point to say "...and so clearly they got the idea thanks to the British counterrevolutionary efforts" I think that would be an unnecessary stretch).

Or, as one of the great chilling quotes of the 1960s put it: "We had to destroy the village in order to save it"

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by greedo on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @06:46PM (#15545859)
Do you have a link for this type of village used in Vietnam? I've only heard of the Strategic Hamlet program, which was designed to protect rural villages from the VC, not to imprison any Vietnamese.
Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by gumby on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @08:15PM (#15546327)
"protect" indeed. Sort of how the militarized police, NSA surveillance, no fly lists and etc are designed to "protect" the American people?

The Strategic Hamlet program built barbed wire fences and guild posts around existing or purpose-built villages, enforcing curfew, ID checks, etc supposedly by "villagers" but typically by the army. Collective punishment was administered to villages who "failed" to keep out either communists or "communists".

If you don't consider that imprisonment, what is it?

Basically they copied the British "Kampung Baru" (AKA "resettlement") program with even less success than the British. FWIW British ruthlessness in Malaya was more "effective" than the US in Viet Nam -- there were basically no people of Chinese origin left in northern Malaya. A classic "play one side off against another, using troops from yet another outside group" strategy that had been so effective for centuries.

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by jpatokal on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @01:11AM (#15547654)
> there were basically no people of Chinese origin left in northern Malaya

Citation needed. There are tons of Chinese people left in northern Malay(si)a, and cities like Ipoh and Georgetown are majority-Chinese.

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by gumby on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @02:18PM (#15552645)
The Malaysia of today is quite different from the Malaya of the 1950s.

My mother grew up in Ipoh. Her brother was drafted by the British in the 1950s for this campaign (as was typical of British colonial practice, he is not malay, chinese or english). His and his buddys' description of the process was pretty clear: 1 - all bumiputrahs into kampongs. 2 - once that's done you are free to shoot anything that moved (which he said was a euphemism for ethnic chinese), with no consequences.

Allegedly the British were fighting communist infiltration from maoist China, so the shape of your body was proof of your guilt. I have no idea if there really was infiltration and the cantonese/fujianese who spread through the British empire were typically hardly of the communist persuasion.

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by coldtea on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @04:55AM (#15548505)
>which was designed to protect rural villages from the VC

A foreign power from 10.000 miles away, no borders with a country, and no reason to be there, comes there with their army to "protect" the local population?

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by greedo on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @02:33PM (#15552806)
>A foreign power from 10.000 miles away, no borders with a country, and no reason to be there, comes there with their army to "protect" the local population?<

Trying to distill the 50 year old motives of a superpower can be a challenge in a thread, but consider it like this; if the intent of the US wasn't to protect the local population, wouldn't they have done more than this?

To address each point of your argument, distance doesn't really matter in the 20th Century, or earlier. Global actions occur, well, globally. To imply that a country can't have interests outside of it's border isn't a strong argument.

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by gumby on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:57PM (#15554650)
The Soviets and (Communist) Chinese were also operating in North Viet Nam so the idea was that the locals were being protected from those under the influence of an evil foreign power.

You can make up your own mind as to the legitimacy of this (you can probably guess what I think) but my comment is intended as a normative response to your question.

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by Tech-Noir on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @03:32AM (#15548205)
> Interesting that this BBC article doesn't mention that the concentration camp was arguably a British invention in the first place

Probably because the BBC knows that's not even remotely true. The very term "concentration camp" itself derives from the earlier Spanish reconcentrados (reconcentration camps), used most notoriously in Cuba.

The USA not only employed concentration camps - alongside vast amounts of other barbarism, including waterboarding - in the Philippines, as they had done decades earlier against the native American Indians, and even during the American Civil War, but actually forced an act upon that country, the Reconcentration Act of 1903 to forcibly relocate populations into designated areas.

Aside from the USA and Spain using concentration camps well before the second Boer War, the French also used them in Algeria in the 1830s and 1850s.

There are probably other examples, but the first modern era (last ~200 years) concentration camp is perhaps the one established by the Paraguayan military in 1813.

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by tudorw on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:38PM (#15545040)
indeed, "People think it was just the Nazis that operated concentration camps. Britain used them in South Africa, Ireland, Palestine, Malaya & Kenya." https://twitter.com/crimesofbrits
Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by joering2 on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @04:55PM (#15545188)
Whats interesting in recent years it came up that children in Germany were learning about "Polish concentration camps", highly alluding that those places had more to do with polish people than with Germans (that they were of polish evil invention and ran by polish people).

There is also a long "tradition" in Germany to detach Germans from what they did in past. For example, average Dutch will not tell you "Germans start World War 2", he/she will tell you "Nazis Started World War 2". This goes very far. Before that, it wasn't Germans who were slaughtering Europeans, it was Teutonic Order.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teutonic_Order

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by vintageseltzer on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @05:05PM (#15545247)
> There is also a long "tradition" in Germany to detach Germans from what they did in past. For example, average Dutch will not tell you "Germans start World War 2", he/she will tell you "Nazis Started World War 2". This goes very far. Before that, it wasn't Germans who were slaughtering Europeans, it was Teutonic Order.

That seems reasonable. A country's government and its population or cultural identity are different. Especially as time goes on.

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by tomohawk on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @05:55PM (#15545565)
Germany was arguably the most educated, enlightened, and cultured country of that time. Look at all those Nobel winners. They chose to take on the garments of Nazism. It was Germany that killed all of those Jews, Gypsies, handicapped, Christians, and anyone else who opposed them. Trying to say "that was just this crazy political party" just doesn't cut it.
Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by jdietrich on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @06:46PM (#15545862)
It's a fine line. The important thing is to emphasise that there was nothing unique about Germany or the Nazi party. What happened there could happen anywhere. If you emphasise the Germanness of the Holocaust, you risk casting it as a uniquely German phenomenon.

The German people didn't suddenly become evil in 1931, nor did they suddenly become good in 1946. They were perfectly ordinary people who were complicit or active in perpetrating awful atrocities. It happened there and it could happen here. There are people in your life who would, in the wrong circumstances, be perfectly capable of kicking people into cattle cars or gas chambers. They're not psychopaths or monsters, they're just people who do what they're told. That's the awful reality; blaming some aspect of the German character is an easy get-out from confronting that awfulness.

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by joering2 on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @02:10AM (#15547895)
Well written, +1

One could even argue that it did indeed happened "here". Take a look at recent Iraq invasion under President Bush. Least at least 8 years, at cost of 150-650 thousands (!!) of lives lost, about 110,000 civilians included... and what happened other than few street riots and march under White House? Nothing! Absolutely nothing! Average American family continues to live average american life and even as we still don't know why this war was started, life goes on :(

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraq_War

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by JPLeRouzic on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @02:28AM (#15547958)
I am not German, but thanks for writing that. Demonizing people is unfortunately the norm, making a well balanced judgment is very rare. Many, many thanks for your writings here.
Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by coldtea on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:04AM (#15548553)
>The German people didn't suddenly become evil in 1931, nor did they suddenly become good in 1946.

No, they were part of an "superior race" culture both before 1931 and after 1946.

(Not to mention their role in WWI as well).

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by JPLeRouzic on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:23AM (#15548632)
From the middle of the 19th century, there was a myth in the western world about being a "superior race". For example in France Jules Ferry [0] said "it is a right for the superior races, because they have a duty. They have the duty to civilize the inferior races."

It went much further than skin color differences, my own ancestors in the Western part of France, were called "animals like people" by Parisian politicians during the 19th century.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jules_Ferry#Colonial_expansion

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by jdietrich on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @07:58AM (#15549314)
See also Kipling and the White Man's Burden. White supremacy was the norm across the western world.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_White_Man%27s_Burden

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by JPLeRouzic on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:44AM (#15548737)
For those who admire Victor Hugo (a French writer of 19th century), he wrote a lot about Africa and their inhabitants (and also of inhabitants of Brittany and Vendée). His views on "inferior people" are absolutely terrifying:

"In the nineteenth century, the white man made true men of black people ; in the twentieth century, Europe will make a world of Africa."

http://www.imagesetmemoires.com/doc/Articles/B29paulhachugo....

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by nebula on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @12:59AM (#15547601)
Did Nazis persecute Christians? My knowledge of German history is very limited, but I remember reading that church supported Hitler.
Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by olavk on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @03:29AM (#15548193)
It complicated...Nazisms did not persecute Christians in general and considered Christianity a part of the German culture. Atheists were persecuted, and so where members of sects like Jehovah's Witnesses. They wanted a church which was subservient to the state, and members of the clergy which opposed this or criticized the party were persecuted just like other political enemies. But the mainstream churches (Germany have both Protestant and Catholic) cooperated with the Nazi government.

Some Nazi ideologues were negative towards Christianity, but in general the system were positive towards "German Christianity".

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by baud147258 on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @07:52AM (#15549277)
Yes, especially with the condemnation of Nazism with the Mit brennender Sorge encyclical, which was distributed in 1937.

Not at the level of the Jew, but Christian organisations were suppressed and many priests were deported in camps.

See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nazi_persecution_of_the_Cathol...

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by coldtea on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @05:03AM (#15548545)
You'd be surprised.

There are such things as continuity of state, and also a continuity of culture.

Especially if post-WWII it never sat well with the locals that they lost the war, or that they were in the wrong.

Token gestures like making "mein kampf" illegal post-facto are a dime a dozen.

Especially since most of the post-WWII political and business establishment, in the highest positions, were fervent nazi party members and high ranking officials before 1945:

http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/from-dictatorshi...

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by greedo on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @06:52PM (#15545902)
Your comment is a perfect example of what the parent was commenting on. The notion that a few select Germans misled the rest of Germany and brought upon the Holocaust is unfounded. WW2 and the Holocaust began because of a confluence between the German government, it's citizens, and its culture.
Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by amigoingtodie on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @09:34PM (#15546697)
I could be misinterpreting your comment. Are you saying the the citizenry in Germany were complicit in the facilitation of the Holocaust?
Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by amigoingtodie on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @08:06AM (#15549350)
I read through each of those articles.

It indicates a systematic desensitization that occured over time.

Additionally, the article that purports current-day Germany as the heaviest anti-semetic place in Europe, with a few anecdotes, mentions Berlin's thriving Jewish population - one of the few places in the world with such an increase.

I do see many parallels to the current behaviors in the US, unfortunately.

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by coldtea on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @11:18AM (#15550824)
>Additionally, the article that purports current-day Germany as the heaviest anti-semetic place in Europe, with a few anecdotes, mentions Berlin's thriving Jewish population - one of the few places in the world with such an increase.

Isn't that orthogonal? There was a huge Jewish community in Germany leading to 1933 as well -- up to 1940 or so.

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by greedo on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @02:15PM (#15552613)
I'm going to assume a charitable interpretation of your question and simply reply "yes."
Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by darklajid on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @03:34AM (#15548211)
When I was in school, concentration camps were always described as German (no references to Polish or anything). My kids aren't old enough to go to school, but I doubt that this changed tbh.

Yes, Nazis are mentioned when that time is discussed, but never in my experience to avoid a connection between this country and the deeds done.

German national pride, patriotism, is very very low (I personally don't feel any attachment to this country apart from the fact that I know some places and speak the language).

> "For example, average Dutch will not tell you"

How are the Dutch involved now? Is that a weird "I know 'German' is 'Deutsch' in German" mistake? Or are you randomly talking about people from the Netherlands at that point?

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by wozer on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @02:16AM (#15547911)
> Whats interesting in recent years it came up that children in Germany were learning about "Polish concentration camps", highly alluding that those places had more to do with polish people than with Germans (that they were of polish evil invention and ran by polish people).

Source? I really don't think anything like this is taught in German schools.

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by joering2 on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @12:24PM (#15551494)
Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by wozer on Thursday October 26, 2017 @08:20AM (#15558189)
Well, it's bad that the term has been used in the media. Probably more carelessness than evil intent, but you never now.

However, I have never heard it used in schools. German children will learn in school that these camps were German.

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by middus on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @06:37PM (#15545813)
How do the Dutch come into play here? I am confused.
Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by greedo on Tuesday October 24, 2017 @06:49PM (#15545877)
Daniel Goldhagen does a good job of illustrating the involvement of everyday Germans in the Holocaust in his book "Hitler's Willing Executioners."[0]

This book has received a lot of criticism from historians but it contains a lot of fascinating information.

[0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hitler%27s_Willing_Executioner...

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by eighthnate on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @10:31AM (#15550402)
Concentration camps ( the terminology ) derives from the spaniards' use of concentration camps in cuba ( Reconcentración policy ). But the spaniards got the idea of concentration camps from the US with our use of concentration camps on the natives in the early 1800s and onwards. We just called it a "reservation" rather than a concentration camp.

The first modern concentration camps were created in the 1830s and natives/africans were the first peoples put in concentration camps.

https://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concentration_camp#Native_...

The british are generally credited with creating the first death camp in the 2nd boer war.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Boer_War#Concentration_...

We know the nazis admired what the US and britain was able to accomplish with concentration camps and they took it to another level. Though today, concentration camps are associated with nazi germany, it existed more than 100 years before ww2 and it's been used to wipe out populations for 100 years before the nazis came into power.

Every major power ( every european colonial power, russians/soviets, americans, japanese, etc ) used concentration camps to some degree in the 1800/1900s. Some have even argued it was the greatest tool of war in the 1800s and 1900s before the atomic bombs were invented.

Re:Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia by vacri on Wednesday October 25, 2017 @12:20AM (#15547435)
The US's corralling of the Cherokee into camps predates the First Boer War by 40-odd years (1830s).

Still, I find it hard to believe that the 'concentration camp' is that recent an invention.