News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google and the Resurgence of Italian Design by ungzd on Saturday October 21, 2017 @11:09AM (#15522074)
> Central to Olivetti’s philosophy — and also to the designers that it hired — was that technology needed to be humanistic, not domineering

Today's Google is very bad at this. Their every product is creepy, cold, dumbed-down and surveilance-based. Maybe they are trying to somewhat fix that by visual aesthetics? Their hardware surely look great, and UIs in Android look good too, but UIs in their web apps look dull and authoritarian.

Google Photos is just "we exfiltrate all your photos and use machine learning on them". Its UI is like designed for monkeys. Compare that to Flickr or their old Picasaweb. Few buttons, no functionality except "we get your photos now you can look on them". I have lots of photos dated in future (from old camera which had bad clock) and there's no way to fix it (except to edit date on each photo).

Google+ was so cold and dead and creepy. Modern Youtube is just a stupid TV. Most "account settings" pages look like I'm viewing them on giant phone. They are saying "you don't need desktop computer, just use phone, you need only play and pause buttons". Their design is highly political. It feels more like eastern bloc's high modernism, not like Olivetti.

Re:Google and the Resurgence of Italian Design by CydeWeys on Saturday October 21, 2017 @01:23PM (#15522596)
It's weird to me that you're choosing Google Photos as your example, as that's one of my very favorite apps of all time. Possibly #1. It does its job amazingly well, it solves an important and hard problem that has bedeviled me for over a decade (photo storage/indexing/retrieval/querying across multiple devices), and it's slick.

Picasa and Flickr were more about photo sharing, and required way more involvement to use. Google Photos is about managing your collection of photos across all devices and the web, and it's amazing at it.

Re:Google and the Resurgence of Italian Design by fjsolwmv on Sunday October 22, 2017 @03:40PM (#15528525)
When you hate a company, it's easy to make up reasons to hate their products, especially if you aren't worried about using an internally consistent decision algorithm.
Re:Google and the Resurgence of Italian Design by agildehaus on Saturday October 21, 2017 @11:52AM (#15522232)
> I have lots of photos dated in future (from old camera which had bad clock) and there's no way to fix it (except to edit date on each photo).

You've been able to batch edit timestamps for over a year.

https://plus.google.com/+GooglePhotos/posts/3ABHACR7QhA

Re:Google and the Resurgence of Italian Design by ungzd on Sunday October 22, 2017 @03:57PM (#15528610)
In order to do this I have to select photos for specific day and there's no way to do it. On my computer these old photos are in directories named with date, one directory per day, but in Google Photos this information is lost, they are entirely random (these photos really have random dates, camera clock was randomizing each time I switched it on).

Simple script would solve that but Google Photos has no public API because public APIs are so 2006. There's no way to reupload photos with fixed EXIFs too.

Re:Google and the Resurgence of Italian Design by ajross on Saturday October 21, 2017 @01:15PM (#15522566)
> creepy, cold, [...] and authoritarian [...] designed for monkeys [...] highly political

You lost me completely. The complaint about photo dates seems reasonable. The rest sounds like the description of a video game enemy and not software UI design.

Re:Google and the Resurgence of Italian Design by icebraining on Saturday October 21, 2017 @11:52AM (#15522231)
I have lots of photos dated in future (from old camera which had bad clock) and there's no way to fix it (except to edit date on each photo).

Select the photos, click on the "more options" button (the three dots), then on Edit Date & Time. There you can change their dates, and even choose between setting a fixed datetime for all or keep the relative time differences between each other.

Re:Google and the Resurgence of Italian Design by remir on Saturday October 21, 2017 @05:03PM (#15523610)
I disagree. Google is much more "humanistic" today than it was years ago when they had a more "bare bone" design approach.
Re:Google and the Resurgence of Italian Design by ungzd on Sunday October 22, 2017 @04:05PM (#15528655)
"Humanistic" in sense "marketed for the masses" and "knows what you need and what you don't need". Old Google was more "technical" but more neutral.
Re:Google and the Resurgence of Italian Design by pokemongoaway on Sunday October 22, 2017 @06:43AM (#15526094)
You made me realize it might be dangerous to have pictures of sensitive documents in Google Photos, even with dual factor authentication... There's not much info on the extent of this "machine learning."
Re:Google and the Resurgence of Italian Design by jdc0589 on Saturday October 21, 2017 @01:16PM (#15522572)
> Their every product is creepy, cold, dumbed-down and surveilance-based.

Aside from the always on listening for "ok google" crap that can (supposedly) be disabled, is there anything else you are referencing? Im genuinely curious.

Re:Google and the Resurgence of Italian Design by agildehaus on Saturday October 21, 2017 @02:08PM (#15522786)
Echo does this, as does the upcoming Apple Homepod, yet nobody complains about it every Apple/Amazon thread like they do with Google.

How else do you build a home assistant? It's not sending your data to Google during this period. If it did record/transmit, that would be a fairly easy thing to detect, yet nobody has.

Re:Google and the Resurgence of Italian Design by zitterbewegung on Saturday October 21, 2017 @02:16PM (#15522822)
You could build a home assistant to respond to something after a button press.

Alexa records everything after the wake word. You can see it in the alexa app.

Re:Google and the Resurgence of Italian Design by dannyr on Saturday October 21, 2017 @02:31PM (#15522883)
Good luck using an Assistant where you have to press the button before you can use it.

Major reason why these Assistants are successful is operating them hands-free.

Re:Google and the Resurgence of Italian Design by phailhaus on Saturday October 21, 2017 @02:38PM (#15522931)
> Alexa records everything after the wake word.

...yes? I mean, that's obvious. How else is it supposed to respond to you after you ask for something?

Re:Google and the Resurgence of Italian Design by jononor on Sunday October 22, 2017 @09:04AM (#15526621)
Robots reading all your emails, analyzing all your images and documents? Tracking your searches, your video watches, and most non-search webpage visits too (via embedded Analytics)?
Re:Google and the Resurgence of Italian Design by eradicatethots on Saturday October 21, 2017 @11:53AM (#15522236)
It sounds to me like you are projecting this authoritarian idea into these uis

Truly, what more ui should a photos appo have? Any addition would just be clutter.

Compare to iOS photos ui- they’re very similar, but you wouldn’t call iOS photos authoritarian, because it’s not your goal!

Or maybe I’m missing something authoritarian about these uis

Re:Google and the Resurgence of Italian Design by ungzd on Sunday October 22, 2017 @04:02PM (#15528644)
iOS photos is something like ACDSee or Windows Explorer, not like Flickr. Maybe it syncs something, but it's primarily local photo viewer.