News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by sschueller on Thursday October 12, 2017 @10:07AM (#15457987)
When are we going to address the elephants in the room?

Just the tube alone:

  - largest pressure vessel in the world. How do you keep it at near vacuum?
  - Thermal expansion over such a large distance, especially if the top of the tube is warmer than the bottom.
  - Safety, how does an evacuation look like if the tubes are sealed?.
There are many more. Some how I feel like this is a "pipe" dream. Lots of marketing, very little engineering.
Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by dmix on Thursday October 12, 2017 @10:19AM (#15458096)
> Lots of marketing, very little engineering.

It started as a technical whitepaper, not a marketing campaign, and multiple companies are building experimental models. I don't think this critique is accurate or fair. There have been far worse vapourware and hype-only concepts that haven't gotten close to hyperloop's tangible progress.

No tech can be perfected from the planning stage either, it takes talent, money, and time - and you can't get those things without a bit of hype, the key is keeping it balanced.

Regardless the concept seemed feasible enough to some very smart people and people with money to spend, where they see it's worth the R&D.

I don't really see what the big risk or downside here of exploring this? Considering the rewards could be very high if it does work and otherwise there has been little innovation in transportation in 50yrs, it's not like there are some obvious alternatives are being neglected.

Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by TremendousJudge on Thursday October 12, 2017 @10:25AM (#15458142)
>it's not like there are some obvious alternatives are being neglected

A high speed train like the ones they've had in Europe for a long time? You know, the ones that regularly reach 300 km/h? If that's not fast or flashy enough for you, what about Maglev? It actually exists, and the tracks are extremely expensive even though they don't even have to maintain low air pressure

Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by dmix on Thursday October 12, 2017 @02:12PM (#15459951)
> A high speed train like the ones they've had in Europe for a long time?

I don't see what the US political inability to build infrastructure has to do with my comment. Plenty of countries are still building highspeed trains and iterating on that model... and plenty of non-US countries are looking into hyperloop, the first ones to adopt it will likely be outside of the US, as that's where most innovation is these days. And regardless there's always plenty of room for new ideas.

Unless you think these billionaires should be backing American transportation mega-projects instead? There's plenty of roadblocks there outside of access to capital, where a highspeed train will likely cost 2-3x the initial projections, even if a private company does it. Not to mention the US is a car-heavy market. It seems like a risky project for any non-government entity to take on as it will be packed full of political risk and direct involvement either way...

The US rarely builds major projects anymore except in the defense industry. And almost every major defense project of comparable size ends up being billions over budget or cancelled.

Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by Robotbeat on Thursday October 12, 2017 @01:33PM (#15459647)
We have natural gas pipelines that have to maintain a far higher pressure difference, and they are in the same order of magnitude in diameter. They're not expensive. Way less than high speed rail lines per mile.
Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by scott_karana on Thursday October 12, 2017 @03:37PM (#15460673)
No, the whitepaper came after the start, which was Musk publicly bragged about how he and his engineers could do the rail project better.

"More marketing than engineering" seems accurate to me.

Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by Filligree on Thursday October 12, 2017 @10:10AM (#15458013)
The pressure tube doesn't need to be at near-vacuum. By the drag equation, air resistance is proportional to pressure; merely cutting pressure by 90% would reduce air resistance by the same amount, and that's trivial with perfectly ordinary pumps.

Serious vacuum pumps are not required. This is not to say that keeping it airtight won't still be a major engineering problem, it just isn't as near-impossible as near-vacuum would be.

To cope with expansion, you'd need to use sliding plates--which, yes, will make it harder to keep the air out. That's going to be an interesting challenge.

Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by wlesieutre on Thursday October 12, 2017 @10:17AM (#15458081)
Doesn't the Hyperloop concept rely on not having a perfect vacuum? It's supposed to suck in air on the front and blow it out the bottom as an air cushion. Without the air cushion you just have "maglev in a vacuum" instead.

I'm sure that's also a fast mode of travel, but like you said, the vacuum part of it takes a lot of money.

Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by Robotbeat on Thursday October 12, 2017 @01:39PM (#15459690)
Does the vacuum part take a lot of money? I would think that if anyone knows, it'd be someone like Elon Musk who has built a spacecraft company from the ground up.

For many of Elon Musk's projects, I get the idea that Elon is mostly just bringing broad, multi-domain knowledge to bear on industries that have been siloed for a very long time. So everyone scoffs at a long vacuum tube and using turbomachinery, etc, but for someone with a physics background with extensive knowledge of the spacecraft environment, turbopump rocket engines, and all the subsystems and ground testing systems that enable all this, it really isn't far-fetched at all. Most physicists (of the experimental kind, i.e. those who have to have hands-on knowledge fabricating things in addition to theoretical background) that I've talked to understand his ideas and think they're fairly reasonable.

People seem to base most of their criticisms on the fact that it's different than what we already do without a fundamental, first-principles understanding of the system.

Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by wlesieutre on Thursday October 12, 2017 @04:43PM (#15461169)
A real vacuum (or very close to it) would be expensive, yes. That's what Musk designed the hyperloop to avoid; it works with a "low pressure" tube instead. His original hyperloop proposal paper outlines this in the intro:

http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/hyperloop_alpha.pdf

Another extreme is the approach, advocated by Rand and ET3, of drawing a hard or near hard vacuum in the tube and then using an electromagnetic suspension. The problem with this approach is that it is incredibly hard to maintain a near vacuum in a room, let alone 700 miles (round trip) of large tube with dozens of station gateways and thousands of pods entering and exiting every day. All it takes is one leaky seal or a small crack somewhere in the hundreds of miles of tube and the whole system stops working.

However, a low pressure (vs. almost no pressure) system set to a level where standard commercial pumps could easily overcome an air leak and the transport pods could handle variable air density would be inherently robust. Unfortunately, this means that there is a non-trivial amount of air in the tube and leads us straight into another problem.

The "another problem" being that if you just do low pressure, it means your pod has air in front if it and has to pushing that air around (or if that air has nowhere else to go in the forward tubing, trying to compress it, because not enough of the air can squeeze around the pods at the edge of the tube). That's what the hyperloop is getting around by sucking air in the front and blowing it out the bottom. Working as an air cushion is something of a bonus, and if everything works out right it also lets you avoid the expense of maglev.

Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by The_Double on Thursday October 12, 2017 @10:16AM (#15458076)
I haven't done any work on hyperloops. But expansion seems to be a problem already solved by industry a long time ago: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metal_expansion_joint
Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by MrBuddyCasino on Thursday October 12, 2017 @10:34AM (#15458233)
Sounds promising:

- Resistance to high and very high pressures

- Large movement absorption

- Early leak indication (in case of damage) via standard check hole

- Complete burst resistance

- Possibility of permanent leak monitoring in critical media

Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by bjl on Thursday October 12, 2017 @10:33AM (#15458217)
Metal expansion joints can't hold a vacuum.
Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by MrBuddyCasino on Thursday October 12, 2017 @10:36AM (#15458253)
Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by Faaak on Thursday October 12, 2017 @10:12AM (#15458038)
The CERN LHC tube is a 27km circle of vacuum and near-zero temperature, and they don't seem to have a problem with that (granted, they had some but it's solved now).

Frankly, yes, there may be issues, but I'm confident that the Human race will be able to overcome those.

Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by ginko on Thursday October 12, 2017 @10:15AM (#15458067)
The LHC's vacuum pipes are 6.3 cm in diameter..
Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by eutropia on Thursday October 12, 2017 @10:53AM (#15458397)
Yeah, LHC's is the largest in the world at just 15,000 cubic metres -- equivalent to about 1 km of hyperloop tunnel (assuming 14ft diameter mentioned in the Boring Company's FAQ)
Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by iamgopal on Thursday October 12, 2017 @10:21AM (#15458112)
What, really? What's with all those mega photos we see everywhere ?
Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by delecti on Thursday October 12, 2017 @12:36PM (#15459206)
This picture shows a cross section of part of the LHC. Those two yellow lines sticking out are the actual tubes. Everything else is equipment to manage the particles (detectors, containment, magnetic propulsion).

And for a sense of scale, a human can comfortably stand in that tunnel next to it.

Image: http://www.tut.fi/cs/groups/public_news/@l102/@news/@p/docum... From here: http://www.tut.fi/en/about-tut/news-and-events/tut-and-cern-...

Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by Analemma_ on Thursday October 12, 2017 @10:23AM (#15458131)
Most of that is the magnets around the beam tube, with the associated power and refrigeration equipment. The beam tube itself is quite small.
Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by konschubert on Thursday October 12, 2017 @10:23AM (#15458134)
Those are the detectors. And the magnets around the tubes.
Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by TremendousJudge on Thursday October 12, 2017 @10:21AM (#15458117)
What about building a high speed train? Proven technology, works in a lot of countries. LA to SF in 2 hours. Is it really that bad?
Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by drzaiusapelord on Thursday October 12, 2017 @11:05AM (#15458499)
Someone made the argument that in the US our rails were built by men half killing themselves for low wages and with very few safety standards. That means a modern buildout is much more expensive than it was historically and the political will to build that budget is difficult or impossible.

Hyperloop is a run around that problem. Largely autonomous/low staffed boring that's non-union labor, non-public sector can make a lot of progress quickly. There's no public sector union demanding x amount of jobs, x amount of pensions, and other expensive regulations or union concessions. Musk's Boring Company thinks it can build tunnels for a fraction of the cost privately without much public sector regulatory weight and they might be right.

HSR is the saner idea, but without Congress funding it, its just not going to happen. Obama made a big push for it during the stimulus but more conservative states decided against accepting the money for both ideological and financial reasons. Once enough states say no, then the rail can't go very far, and the project eventually died:

First, Tea Party conservatives in Florida and wealthy liberal suburbanites in the Bay Area began questioning their states’ plans. Then, just as Joe Biden was calling for $53 billion in high-speed-rail spending over the next six years, a crop of freshly elected Republican governors turned down billions in federal money for lines in Wisconsin, Ohio, and Florida. Finally, Republicans in Congress zeroed out the federal high-speed rail budget last month.

http://www.slate.com/articles/technology/technocracy/2011/12...

Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by dschep on Thursday October 12, 2017 @12:01PM (#15458937)
Re: unions, there are sandhogs unions, wouldn't they be relevant? Ex: http://www.sandhogs147.org/
Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by gok on Thursday October 12, 2017 @11:41AM (#15458774)
It'll be more like 3 hours, and it will end up costing around $100 billion. It would be dramatically cheaper and faster to subsidize free plane tickets between LA and SF for the next 50 years.

HSR works well in places with high density and competent infrastructure construction strategies. California has neither.

Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by dx034 on Thursday October 12, 2017 @11:57AM (#15458898)
Trains have a much higher capacity. Most people currently drive the distance which leads to more accidents and a lot of lost time.

$100bn is too expensive to make sense but I don't understand why it should cost that much. There are not that many tunnels needed, esp. if you start/end north of LA and south of SF. European rail projects are also expensive but still a fraction of the cost.

Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by bmh_ca on Thursday October 12, 2017 @10:18AM (#15458087)
I love how you've capitalized "Human", as if to say there were some other race competing to complete the Hyperloop. :)
Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by jandrese on Thursday October 12, 2017 @11:31AM (#15458707)
Thermal expansion is at least easy to manage if your system is kept near 0K in operation. It's only an issue when the system is turned off.
Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by jfindley on Thursday October 12, 2017 @12:08PM (#15458973)
It's easy to come up with reasons why something won't work.

But, usually, it's more productive to start with the understanding that other people are smart too, and that they may have thought of these problems. In this particular case, I believe that the original white paper addresses these points. I'm not a structural engineer, so I've no idea if their solutions are valid and I'm not saying that it's never okay to criticize, but this reads to me as if you may have fallen into the trap of forgetting that the people who designed this are very smart people, and thus likely thought of the obvious problems.

Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by logicallee on Thursday October 12, 2017 @10:54AM (#15458402)
Out of curiosity, have you ever built anything big? I say this because the tone of your comment is dismissive, however it seems quite low-effort. I can translate your criticisms into criticisms of building subways in 1863:

  - if you build a subway it will be the biggest underground railway ever built.
  - Rocks.  They could fall in front of a subway car and cause a huge accident.
  - safety.  what if all the lights and power go out?  Also how would anyone breathe down there.
And my criticisms seem stronger, not weaker, than yours. Today all cities with robust subway systems benefit hugely from them and all of these issues have been resolved.

The criticism you've offered seems equally low-effort, so this is why I'm curious if you've ever helped design and build any large-scale project.

I don't like gratuitous negativity on HN and it's against the rules here.

Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by M4v3R on Thursday October 12, 2017 @11:16AM (#15458584)
Also, planes are a terrible idea. I mean how do you evacuate people from them if something goes wrong? I think this whole airplane thing is just vaporware.
Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by batiudrami on Thursday October 12, 2017 @11:02PM (#15463003)
That isn't exactly a solved problem though. Almost all of the time it's "everyone dies". We just have failure rates low enough and it's convenient enough that people accept it.
Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by TeMPOraL on Friday October 13, 2017 @01:14AM (#15463426)
This is normal. You either handle failure gracefully or ensure the failures are very rare.
Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by KekDemaga on Thursday October 12, 2017 @12:06PM (#15458966)
The question isn't "will this ever work?", the question is (while keeping with your airplane analogy) is Elon Musk's design closer to the Wright brothers airplane or Da Vinci's ornithopter. I'd guess the latter personally.
Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by logicallee on Thursday October 12, 2017 @01:45PM (#15459749)
The Wright brothers had a bicycle shop, whereas Da Vinci was more of a painter.

The main thing Musk has in common with the Wrights is running an electric car transportation company and sending private rockets into space via SpaceX.

I think you should revisit whether that makes it more Wright brothers or Da Vinci.

Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by eradicatethots on Monday October 23, 2017 @02:19AM (#15531080)
What are you arguing? You wouldn’t take the position that it’s guarenteed to succeed, that seems absurd to me. The person you replied to only made the point that it could fail. And in your reply you actually took the opportunity to degrade artists and thinkers, which seems cruel and unnecessary.

You’ve found a flaw, I think a pedantic one, in the example they gave.

Here’s an example that is less flawed, and I think if you had considered their point rather than sought minute flaws you could see this yourself: the palm note vs the iPhone. Hopefully, even if my analogy is not literally flawless, you can take my point.

Also, sorry for spamming you, something you wrote struck me and I wanted to see what else you wrote. Hope you don’t mind this.

Re:Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’ by dx034 on Thursday October 12, 2017 @11:59AM (#15458919)
The question is if we want to accept the risks. In the early days of subways, trains, planes and cars, accidents were frequent and many people died until we figured out the safety aspect. Today's society is much more risk averse. I don't think the general public would accept several fatal crashes before the system is safe.