I don't think this necessarily points to any inherent flaw with the competition, either. The goal of a debate participant is not to discover the "truth," it is to defend the side of the debate you are assigned (and over the course of several rounds against multiple opponents, you will inevitably find yourself alternating between sides). It's similar to arguing in a courtroom: as a defense attorney, your goal is not to discover the "truth," but to get a "not guilty" verdict for your client, even if you believe (or know) them to be guilty.
When I was in debate (mid-90s) most research was on paper - you'd have a brief with cut out photo copies ("cards") with the words to read underlined. If you weren't at one of the big schools, you were at a disadvantage, as the debaters themselves weren't seeking any truth in their research; they had teams who just cut every card imaginable. The goal, as in spreading, was just to overwhelm your opponent. (More baffle them with bullshit than dazzle them with brilliance)
It made it cannoying for those of us who were actually trying to organize a club around debating issues.
And you do debate issues, just very very quickly and efficiently.
Anyway, there are other comments I've made that would allow someone to attach my real identity to this profile.
the best at any highly competitive activity - when assembled together - will talk primarily about that thing.
When did it become socially acceptable to behave in this manner?
So indeed, there is nothing for which everything is X.
This is a discussion on high school debate, so please take this comment in that light (with a grain of matter).
My best friend growing up is a near mystical figure in the insular LD debate community and has coached a lot of nationally successful debaters, including his younger sister who won the TOC and is considered the most dominant LD debater ever as far as I know. Aside from him, at one point another close friend was #1 ranked in the country (he had the most TOC bids that year) and another won Novice Nationals. I was naturally good at it as well (I quit literally hours after winning the Novice state tournament), but I absolutely hated debate for all the reasons listed -- "spreading", abstruse philosophical critiques that always devolved into nuclear war, and the barely intelligible speed-talking that even motivated the dorkiest of debaters to practice circular breathing. I had to find a new friend group (for a while, we're still all close) because these guys talked about nothing except for debate.
> High school debate today is basically an intellectual game, not an exercise in truth-seeking.
I couldn't agree more, and I have said nearly the exact same thing to many people that are unfamiliar with high school debate.