News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by austenallred on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:19AM (#15434528)
It’s not loyalty at all, it’s just people using the best product available to them. If someone creates something better than Facebook people will use that thing and won’t feel any remorse in switching. Until that happens, people will continue to use Facebook, because despite what Hacker News thinks, Facebook adds a huge amount of value to peoples’ lives.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by csydas on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:39AM (#15434768)
I strongly disagree especially in the case of social networks. First movers in such spaces have incredible advantages and one of them is a lock-in effect. Countless follow-up social sites have come and gone that either had feature parity or better offerings than Facebook, but failed to get a foothold because of the fact that everyone already had Facebook. Why switch when everyone can already talk and plan?

SV really isn't as much of a meritocracy as people like to pretend, as so many times just being first to the party and locking people in is enough to keep them there. I'm sure tons of businesses on exchange would love to ditch and move to Google Apps for Business, but the change is just too much of a hassle, even if the features are exactly as desired. Same for Google businesses looking at the MS office world with starry eyes.

The merit often has less to do with a product's success and continued success as much as how efficient they are at locking people in. Going back to Facebook, it's not like there's a way to migrate or exfiltrate your data in any meaningful way to another system.

This is an exaggerated comparison, but the mafia adds value much in the same way, in that often you don't have a choice in the matter. This isn't to say people are forced to use Facebook, but much like a mafia town, it's hard to do business otherwise.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by ameister14 on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:44AM (#15434808)
>I strongly disagree especially in the case of social networks. First movers in such spaces have incredible advantages and one of them is a lock-in effect. Countless follow-up social sites have come and gone that either had feature parity or better offerings than Facebook, but failed to get a foothold because of the fact that everyone already had Facebook. Why switch when everyone can already talk and plan?

Sure, and that applied to Friendster and Myspace and others as well, until Facebook came along.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by scott_s on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:01PM (#15434986)
I don't like the term "first mover", because in practice, I think it's rare for the actual first to win. Friendster was the first friend-oriented online social network. They were the first mover, but the site performed terribly. MySpace and Facebook beat Friendster because they were better at doing what people wanted.

There are other examples. The iPhone was not the first smart phone, but it was better than all of the others when it came out. It dominated for a while, and even though it's no longer the dominant smart phone (I believe there are more Android phones), all smart phones are derivatives of that first iPhone. Google beat Yahoo and AltaVista. Historically, I think it's usually second-movers that win, because they tend to benefit from the first-movers defining the problem, and one of the second-movers solves it better.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by ExactoKnight on Monday October 09, 2017 @05:30PM (#15437642)
Facebook was first in getting real identity on the internet right. The other social media sites before them never understood this well -- many had visions of people taking on avatars of other creatures, or defining their life around one myopic interest (in the case of MySpace: music).
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by aswanson on Monday October 09, 2017 @06:16PM (#15437899)
What do you think Twitter got right? I think real identity was a part of it, but fake identity abounds there as well.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by Animats on Monday October 09, 2017 @02:15PM (#15436146)
Facebook wasn't a first mover. It was more like the tenth large social network. Predecessors included AOL, Myspace, Orkut, Geocities...
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by ExactoKnight on Monday October 09, 2017 @05:42PM (#15437732)
It was first mover in getting real identity on the internet right. Social network is not an accurate term for what made Facebook "right" over its competitors.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by austenallred on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:49AM (#15434867)
In the instance of social networks, when everybody is already using a product, that’s part of what makes it a better product. Facebook wasn’t the first mover, and no one forced you to stay there, but now that we’re all there it is much more difficult to create a product better than it.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by aswanson on Monday October 09, 2017 @06:19PM (#15437914)
Yeah, it's like the end of an evolutionary branch. Slight mutations arent going to get you anything, you have to branch off in an orthogonal direction.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by ajoy on Monday October 09, 2017 @07:20PM (#15438202)
You are right. I don't think there will be another social network like Facebook. But do not in any way assume facebook cannot be toppled. Already the younger generation is not using facebook as much. I have zero loyalty to the company and its product.

But the next big social network or software that connects may not look anything like Facebook. It will be most likely be unrecognizable as a social network even.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by sidlls on Monday October 09, 2017 @12:01PM (#15434988)
Merely creating something better than Facebook is barely even the ante. Much more than that is required to convince somebody to use Facebook (Google, etc.). Marketing, some appreciable fraction of their userbase also using the would-be competitor, etc. is the absolute minimum requirement to play their game.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by toomuchtodo on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:20AM (#15434540)
> If someone creates something better than Facebook people will use that thing and won’t feel any remorse in switching.

"If you don't want someone doing cocaine, make a better cocaine!"

> Facebook adds a huge amount of value to peoples’ lives.

https://academic.oup.com/aje/article/185/3/203/2915143/Assoc...

"Face-to-face social interactions enhance well-being. With the ubiquity of social media, important questions have arisen about the impact of online social interactions. In the present study, we assessed the associations of both online and offline social networks with several subjective measures of well-being. We used 3 waves (2013, 2014, and 2015) of data from 5,208 subjects in the nationally representative Gallup Panel Social Network Study survey, including social network measures, in combination with objective measures of Facebook use. We investigated the associations of Facebook activity and real-world social network activity with self-reported physical health, self-reported mental health, self-reported life satisfaction, and body mass index. Our results showed that overall, the use of Facebook was negatively associated with well-being. For example, a 1-standard-deviation increase in “likes clicked” (clicking “like” on someone else's content), “links clicked” (clicking a link to another site or article), or “status updates” (updating one's own Facebook status) was associated with a decrease of 5%–8% of a standard deviation in self-reported mental health. These associations were robust to multivariate cross-sectional analyses, as well as to 2-wave prospective analyses. The negative associations of Facebook use were comparable to or greater in magnitude than the positive impact of offline interactions, which suggests a possible tradeoff between offline and online relationships."

Facebook is toxic.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by austenallred on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:29AM (#15434643)
I hate to be the person saying “correlation != causation,” so instead let’s just agree that “the people who liked more things on Facebook self-reported to be less happy” is not a very rigorous way to analyze how Facebook affects human happiness levels.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by p-funk on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:42AM (#15434799)
Doesn't it follow, regardless of causality, that if Facebook were just as good as face-to-face social interaction, then there would be no difference in happiness levels between people who use Facebook and those who don't? If Facebook had a positive impact on people's lives, then there would be a similar positive correlation in using Facebook compared to seeing someone in person.

Maybe there isn't enough proof to say "Facebook is toxic", but it certainly seems true that Facebook is not as good as real human interaction.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by austenallred on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:54AM (#15434913)
I don’t think anyone is making the argument that Facebook is as good as face to face interaction. They’re also not mutually exclusive. That’s part of why this is so difficult to study.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by lordCarbonFiber on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:33AM (#15434686)
You've got your correlation v causation mixed up there in interpreting those results. It's just as likely that negative well being means people take more shelter in digital interaction as opposed to the opposite (which is why the paper is careful to avoid actually suggesting causality).

Given that loneliness and isolation actually is toxic [0], for many it's not that online interactions are replacing offline interactions; they're the only interactions these people can get.

[0]http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/174569161456835...

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by KekDemaga on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:28AM (#15434630)
>For example, a 1-standard-deviation increase in “likes clicked” (clicking “like” on someone else's content), “links clicked” (clicking a link to another site or article), or “status updates” (updating one's own Facebook status) was associated with a decrease of 5%–8% of a standard deviation in self-reported mental health.

>Facebook is toxic.

Or alternatively mentally ill people like Facebook.

Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by _jal on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:56AM (#15434939)
That implies a rather high mental illness rate. High enough that I start wondering about what the baseline is.
Re:Dear Silicon Valley: America’s fallen out of love with you by canjobear on Monday October 09, 2017 @11:47AM (#15434837)
If Facebook is filled with mentally ill people then it would be surprising if it weren't toxic.

It's a vicious cycle, so correlation becomes causation!