Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by wastedhours on Monday October 09, 2017 @07:32AM
(#15432972)
Distance from pieces of the infrastructure also doesn't always help, I live 100m from the cabinet, and 500m from an exchange in a large development, but they've not managed to lay fibre apparently (guessing investment in Zone 1 London isn't the best political/PR decision for Openreach...), so it's only ADSL "up to 16Mb", but rarely top 2-3.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by zimpenfish on Monday October 09, 2017 @04:50AM
(#15432339)
> if you're using VDSL, which most UK households are
It's been a while since I was in the UK internet industry but I think most of them are using ADSL with VDSL generally only used for fibre or "business class" connections.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by maaark on Monday October 09, 2017 @07:05AM
(#15432848)
Any broadband package over "up to 20Mbit" will be VDSL. I'd say that's a majority, nowdays.
Re:Internet speed guarantees must be realistic, says Ofcom
by zimpenfish on Monday October 09, 2017 @08:27AM
(#15433232)
https://www.ispreview.co.uk/index.php/2017/04/ofcom-2017-stu...
> a little over half of the country still subscribe to the much slower and less reliable ADSL (up to 8-20Mbps) based pure copper line services.
This article is about the UK, where most people with broadband Internet get it via their telephone line, ie VDSL, and so aren't subject to congestion in the last mile.
In most cases this means their "speed" is a property of the VDSL standard, the length and quality of copper cable in the ground between them and the VDSL node (a relatively new bigger green street cabinet for most of them, vaguely near their older smaller "BT" cabinet).
VDSL works basically the same way as your ancient "analogue" telephone modem, except with way, way higher frequencies and more sophisticated encoding because it wasn't designed to cost $10 and work over actual telephone calls, just make it for about a mile down a copper cable to a $$$$ specialist box.
Short, high quality telephone cables can easily support the same sort of bandwidth you regularly see from say, 100baseT, ie 100Mbps. But very long, poor quality ones will do much worse, VDSL needs to tweak things to give those poor souls some sort of service, while also delivering a really good service to people who are closer, as automatically as possible. Higher frequencies get smushed worse over distance, so the closer people get a wider _band_ of frequencies, more literal _bandwidth_. The consumer equipment and the big green box in the street negotiate how best to get a signal between them, then if necessary the big green box throttles this down to an agreed speed, the actual "maximum" which may be higher than the advertised "Up to..." speed in countries where a regulator demanded such a pointless change to advertising.
The end result is usually if you live 100 metres from the cabinet, you get nice fast broadband and it doesn't matter which ISP you pick. And if you live two miles from the cabinet you get shitty ADSL at 1Mbps and can't watch Netflix and again, it still doesn't matter which ISP you pick.
So in a way the irony is that ISPs advertise speed at all. Speed has almost nothing to do with your ISP if you're using VDSL, which most UK households are. Imagine if car manufacturers started advertising the quality of roads you can drive on. It's the same roads for all manufacturers - who cares?