News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Logic of Risk Taking by malmsteen on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @04:04PM (#15404058)
tl dr ?
Re:The Logic of Risk Taking by lliamander on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @04:42PM (#15404431)
If, at a casino, there is a 1% chance of going bust, then given N people attending the casino approx 1% will go bust, no matter the size of N.

However, if a single person goes to the casino N times, their odds of going bust approach 100% as N gets larger, because as soon as you go bust you can no longer keep playing.

In any kind of iterated game, concern about tail risks is justified when the tail risk means you can no longer play the game.

Social science and economic research that attempts to analyze the "rationality" of human behavior has thus far failed to take this logic into consideration, falsely portraying people as irrationally "loss-averse". This oversight in the research community is obvious to successful investors, insurers, etc. because the latter have personal investment in the outcome of these iterated situations that the former simply do not. [This is only my attempt at a summary of his argument, not a defense]

[EDIT: spelling mistake]

Re:The Logic of Risk Taking by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @05:09PM (#15404690)
> Social science and economic research that attempts to analyze the "rationality" of human behavior has thus far failed to take this logic into consideration, falsely portraying people as irrationally "loss-averse".

And here’s where he goes off the tracks: even a quick search of Google Scholar will show that it, at best, grossly overstates the case to say that social science (and particularly economics, and even more specifically the subfield of “decision theory” that he calls out) research “thus far” has neglected tail risks in addressing rationality (it's also incorrect to say that there is some kind of consensus result that people vary from rationality consistently in the direction of loss-aversity.)

Re:The Logic of Risk Taking by feulistia on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @09:46PM (#15406223)
As a research psychologist, I found his rant particularly upsetting because the very thing he's ranting about has been dealt with in the social sciences for years and years and years.

One of the reasons this issue keeps recurring is because, taken to its logical conclusion, the "time" probability paradigm (to use his term, there are better terms that have been used) as applied to persons' behaviors, only applies to that single individual, which then leads to a sort of paradox. Although we might want to know the probabilities for Theodorus Ibn Warqa, this is in principle unknowable because there is only one Theodorus Ibn Warqa. So when he is ruined, you can in theory say nothing about Maximillian Samuel Warqa.

At some point you have to invoke a counterfactual of sorts, and use a different person as a substitute, and this is why the "ensemble" probability model is invoked.

Taleb is right that the consequences of a ruin event are different at the individual level, but so what? The cost estimate is different from the probability estimate. It's not like people don't understand this. Maybe in the strawman literature he reads, but not in what anyone else is thinking. What's more typical is a ruin event one way or a ruin event another.

This is difficult stuff if you go beyond the toy gambler scenario he's dealing with. Just for one example:

https://dash.harvard.edu/handle/1/11718181

People wrestle with this not because they're idiots, but because it's more difficult than it seems once you really dive into it.

Re:The Logic of Risk Taking by sp527 on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @05:02PM (#15404631)
Loss aversion is a human bias that has fairly obvious evolutionary origins: fear is a stronger behavioral motivator than risk-seeking tendency because it confers a survival advantage (‘you only die once’).
Re:The Logic of Risk Taking by wjmao88 on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @05:52PM (#15405041)
And ‘you only die once’ is the ultimate form of tail risk.
Re:The Logic of Risk Taking by cholmon on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @04:17PM (#15404175)
"skin in the game"
Re:The Logic of Risk Taking by malmsteen on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @04:26PM (#15404282)
><
Re:The Logic of Risk Taking by zaptheimpaler on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @04:23PM (#15404250)
Taleb trying to sound smart.
Re:The Logic of Risk Taking by tw1010 on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @05:01PM (#15404618)
He seems to have a better grasp of probability than most people (me included). Perhaps he's not the greatest at digesting his ideas into an easy-to-grok form, but he seems to be trying his best. You don't have to listen to everything he says but you also shouldn't dismiss it all because his presentation is lacking in eloquence. I think this is especially true since he has a background he shares with very few other business-esque advice-givers. When you find a person like that, someone outside the norm, you really aught to listen to the person and learn to read between the lines or reinterpret it into a form that you can understand, since finding people at that fringe is hard enough. Requiring that the person be a perfect communicator is too much to ask and you're doing yourself a disservice by ignoring them.
Re:The Logic of Risk Taking by late2part on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @07:07PM (#15405535)
It's my opinion that:

1. Taleb is incredibly smart 2. He is not being arrogant or trying to impress (any more than any other writer) 3. He is writing about something that is interesting and not everyone knows

Re:The Logic of Risk Taking by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @07:47PM (#15405780)
On #2, when he mispresents fields that have addressed the effect he is discussing routinely for decades as not merely addressing it inadequately but of missing it entirely, he's either being self-aggrandizingly hyperbolic or stunningly ignorant. Or maybe its a rhetorical trick to get the reader to pay attention because they are getting a nugget of secret wisdom. But certainly plenty of other writers don't play that kind of dishonest game.
Re:The Logic of Risk Taking by feulistia on Thursday October 05, 2017 @01:59AM (#15406931)
I've noticed a formula many seem to follow in drawing attention to ones self as a public intellectual:

1. Find some topic or idea that's interesting and fairly well-accepted but not receiving a lot of attention. 2. Claim ownership over the topic or idea as if the prior literature doesn't exist. Invent new terminology ideally; abandon existing terms to eliminate a trail to prior authors and ideas. 3. Present the idea or topic in a sensationalistic way. 4. When furor inevitably develops about lack of acknowledgement of previous writers and researchers and issues identified by them, frame argument as being about ad hominem critics versus solidity of your own arguments. Sidestep actual criticisms.

Re:The Logic of Risk Taking by ianamartin on Thursday October 05, 2017 @04:28AM (#15407493)
This is a much better description of the phenomenon than I could come up with. I mentioned it elsewhere in the thread, but this is truly better than what I described.

Well done.

Re:The Logic of Risk Taking by late2part on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @09:47PM (#15406227)
He doesn’t blindly accept conventional wisdom.

I don’t see it how you do. That’s okay.

I’ve read a fair bit of his stuff and I like his approach to framing issues, which often ignores conventional wisdom, or phrasing.

Re:The Logic of Risk Taking by jacalata on Thursday October 05, 2017 @01:06AM (#15406780)
The phrase "doesn't blindly accept x" usually has an implication that the subject is aware of x, so you seem to be totally avoiding the argument being made that Taleb seems unaware of work done on the topics he writes about.
Re:The Logic of Risk Taking by late2part on Thursday October 05, 2017 @01:53AM (#15406902)
You are begging the question. I posit that he is aware of it and is presenting it differently than others.

The disagreement is whether he understands A. The issue and B. What others said. The whole of acadamia is full of different perspectives / why not here from Taleb?

Re:The Logic of Risk Taking by dragonwriter on Thursday October 05, 2017 @06:32PM (#15413066)
> You are begging the question. I posit that he is aware of it and is presenting it differently than others.

Flatly stating that an entire field of inquiry has, up to the point at which you are publishing your commentary, failed to recognize and consider the ramifications of a phenomenon on which effect and it's ramifications numerous papers have been published in the field for several decades is not being aware of the factual circumstances and presenting them differently than others. Its either ignorance or dishonesty.

And when you compound that by using the mythical failure as a jumping off point for an explanation (“skin in the game”) for the systematic incompetence that seems necessary to explain how the field could fail to address the phenomenon, this compounds the problem.

Re:The Logic of Risk Taking by pierre_d528 on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @04:38PM (#15404392)
Please, could you elaborate?
Re:The Logic of Risk Taking by RachelF on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @11:49PM (#15406572)
Read his first non-finance book, "Fooled by Randomness".

It is actually well written, easy to read and briefly contains all the ideas in his later books.

His writing quality has decreased hugely since then, but his ego has not.