News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by angrygoat on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @11:50AM (#15401379)
I'm quite excited about Risc-V as a platform - particularly security and trust-wise. It's great to see that we'll be getting competitive CPUs soon.

Open hardware, implementing an open architecture, which can run open source software with reproducible builds. A huge win when we're facing pervasive surveillance hard-wired into current commodity systems.

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by Nokinside on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @02:50PM (#15403239)
Security and trust-wise RISC-V means nothing.

RISC-V is just open instruction set. Below the instruction set is microarchitecture.

Some have developed low performance free microarchitectures for Risc-V but same applies to other instruction sets also. You can develop open and secure X86 microarchitecture if you want.

High performance microarchitecture costs hundreds of millions of dollars to develop. Someone may develop competitive RISC-V CPU someday but it will not have open microarchitecture. AMD and Nvidia are examples of fabless companies who develop and sell proprietary microarchitectures. Thinking that someone develops open platform that competes with them is not realistic.

SiFive Coreplex IP is good for microcontrollers and alike and relatively transparent but there are similar microcontroller cores available from ARM with similar transparency.

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by solomatov on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @11:54PM (#15406586)
>High performance microarchitecture costs hundreds of millions of dollars to develop. Someone may develop competitive RISC-V CPU someday but it will not have open microarchitecture. AMD and Nvidia are examples of fabless companies who develop and sell proprietary microarchitectures. Thinking that someone develops open platform that competes with them is not realistic.

I am sure that they same argument should have worked for OSes 30 years ago. I think it will go the same way as it was with linux but much faster. There're a lot of small and not so small players who aren't able to develop microarchitecture themselves but quite eager to take their part in open source project.

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by tfha on Saturday October 07, 2017 @02:34PM (#15424988)
I'm not sure that works as well for hardware. Every fab is different. Imagine if you had to rewrite the whole Linux kernel for every CPU on the market.

Getting high performance requires tuning carefully to the exact fab, and fabs change and upgrade on like a two year cycle.

To the best of my knowledge there's no equivalent to the C language for fabs. You have to port the whole chip every time

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by solomatov on Saturday October 07, 2017 @04:28PM (#15425529)
The same argument can be applied to the hardware. We have a lot of different hardware, it's all different, and every pice of hardware needs its own driver. In practice, drivers are created by hardware vendors and often they are open source.

Of course, production processes are more complicated than this, but there's a degree of decoupling of the processor together with its architecture from the production process.

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by throwaway613834 on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @03:03PM (#15403402)
> You can develop open and secure X86 microarchitecture if you want.

Apparently there are patent landmines you have to traverse first.

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by Nokinside on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @04:06PM (#15404084)
Instruction set can't be patented. Intel tries to patent ways to implement and functions those instructions carry.

RISC-V will have less problems with those kind of patents, but it's impossible to design high-end microarchitecture without cross-licensing.

I may sound negative, but I'm actually positive about RISC-V in embedded and IoT arena. People just attach too much hype for the architecture.

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by throwaway613834 on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @06:35PM (#15405341)
> Instruction set can't be patented. Intel tries to patent ways to implement and functions those instructions carry.

ionno, try telling that to Microsoft. This wasn't welcoming: https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2017/06/intel...

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by bitwize on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @07:28PM (#15405675)
Intel owns patents on the Itanium ISA and aspects of the x86 ISA. If you still think instruction sets can't be patented, just try challenging Intel about it in court. There will be a smouldering crater left where you once stood once the lawsuits are over with.
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by verall on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @06:46PM (#15405400)
> Instruction set can't be pantented

This is simply false, as far as Intel is concerned. You can't even emulate x86 (therefore infringing 0 hardware patents) without expected heavy litigation from Intel.

AFAIK the actual x86 patents have expired but none of the extensions have (x86-64, SSE, ...)

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by Nokinside on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @07:49PM (#15405787)
Intel naturally tries to threaten and extend patents as much as they can. But they ISA itself can't be patented.

If you look their actual patents, they are all patents on implementation details or attempts to patent functions that instructions do.

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by em3rgent0rdr on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @08:58PM (#15406076)
> "Intel naturally tries to threaten and extend patents as much as they can. But they ISA itself can't be patented."

It is practically impossible to implement these extensions, such as SSE variants, without intel being able to make a case against you. So even if theoretically the ISA can't be patented, for all practical purposes they have the legal power to effectively prohibit a 3rd-party from implementing an x86 core.

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by microcolonel on Thursday October 05, 2017 @01:15AM (#15406798)
x86-64 is AMD's IP, not Intel's. The proper name is AMD64.
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by em3rgent0rdr on Friday October 06, 2017 @12:07AM (#15414351)
"AMD64" is simply a Trade Mark. But the problem being discussed is the separate IP issue of patents.
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by monocasa on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @03:19PM (#15403590)
And those landmines even blew up in Nvidia's face.
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by sigjuice on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @12:49PM (#15401828)
I wish I could share your optimism :/ Nothing stops makers of RISC-V SoCs from adding their own Intel ME equivalents. Also, the CPU is just a small part of a computer, so "RISC-V" doesn't automatically translate to "open hardware" or "open architecture".
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by microcolonel on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @01:13PM (#15402059)
> Also, the CPU is just a small part of a computer, so "RISC-V" doesn't automatically translate to "open hardware" or "open architecture".

It is a prerequisite to it though.

update: Also, they already have something acting in the role of the ME on this machine, marked E51 on the chart. I don't think it does the high level application type stuff that the ME does, but I would think it handles power management and other core duties of the ME.

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by cmrx64 on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @07:27PM (#15405660)
it's owner-programmable, which is a plus.
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by sweden on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @12:30PM (#15401687)
Open hardware? Open architecture? SiFive's solution is neither of those.
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by baobrien on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @03:11PM (#15403493)
The SiFive coreplexes themselves are based on the UCB-BAR Rocket core generator, which is open source. Most of the SiFive founders worked and still contribute to Rocket.
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by javajosh on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @12:39PM (#15401744)
Okay, one of you is getting downvoted, but I'm not sure which one, yet.
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by monocasa on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @12:15PM (#15401563)
> particularly security and trust-wise

Towards that end, has there been work on a TileLink IOMMU yet?