News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:White House wants to end Social Security numbers as a nat... by BatFastard on Tuesday October 03, 2017 @05:44PM (#15396470)
I am no so keen on the government issuing us other numbers either, but there has got to be a better way.

As for UUID, so now I need to remember a 64 character UUID?

Re:White House wants to end Social Security numbers as a nat... by snuxoll on Tuesday October 03, 2017 @06:11PM (#15396656)
A UUID would be just as bad at the end of the day and be more of a pain in the butt. There's nothing necessarily wrong with having a short-ish identifier, like what we already have on state-issued ID's for referencing a certain individual - but ideally we should move on from this number being a password to being equivalent to a actual identifier. Smart cards are ubiquitous these days (you probably have one in your wallet, assuming you have a debit or credit card on you) - that identifier should be associated a public key and your ID card holds the private key, if your card is stolen the key is revoked and a new one issued.
Re:White House wants to end Social Security numbers as a nat... by s73ver_ on Tuesday October 03, 2017 @06:41PM (#15396823)
Homeless people have SSNs, too, and likely aren't carrying around wallets.
Re:White House wants to end Social Security numbers as a nat... by snuxoll on Tuesday October 03, 2017 @07:11PM (#15396997)
Not to dismiss the point entirely, but this is still an edge case - and one that doesn't justify the continued use of an identifier as a password.

People on HN make jabs at things like fingerprint / facial recognition as passwords all the time, but if you have something you need to keep private it's easy to forgo them and use a proper password instead (even if it's more inconvenient). Even if we replace SSN's with a 1024-character identifier leaks will still happen, because we continue to use the wrong tool for the job - leaving us no better off and just more inconvenienced.

We need a national ID system, ID numbers need to be no more than identifiers, if you need to validate your identity proper two-factor authentication - possession of your national ID card with your private key, and a password only you know - is the only safe way to do so.

Re:White House wants to end Social Security numbers as a nat... by BatFastard on Tuesday October 03, 2017 @11:30PM (#15398090)
I know that SS is not a national ID, but it effectively is. But its an ID with no password, someone thought this was a good idea?
Re:White House wants to end Social Security numbers as a nat... by s73ver_ on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @12:12PM (#15401537)
They thought, "Hey, we need an ID number for this national social insurance program." Then later, someone else thought, "Hey, I need an identifier to check this person's Identity. Oh, they have a taxpayer ID number. I'll use that." And it just kind of piled on and on and on.
Re:White House wants to end Social Security numbers as a nat... by s73ver_ on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @12:13PM (#15401546)
Homeless people are not an edge case.
Re:White House wants to end Social Security numbers as a nat... by snuxoll on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @01:21PM (#15402134)
Going by a high estimate of 600,000 homeless Americans that means .1% of our population is homeless - sorry, but, yes, that is in fact an edge case.

It’s one that needs to be addressed, but sacrificing security isn’t the way to go about it. The number one issue here will be verifying identity for welfare programs and employment, which is already problematic (if you can’t carry an ID card you probably aren’t carrying your social security card and birth certificate either).

Re:White House wants to end Social Security numbers as a nat... by s73ver_ on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @02:07PM (#15402706)
No, it's not an edge case. They are people. And nowhere did I suggest sacrificing security. I said you need to be able to use the system without computers.
Re:White House wants to end Social Security numbers as a nat... by snuxoll on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @06:40PM (#15405359)
“Without computers” is extremely vague. What needs to be done without them, considering the majority of use cases for our existing cases for SSN’s or state ID’s are electronic (even if it is just handing the card to someone so they can copy the details into a computer).

A smart card handles everything pretty well, it acts as a normal physical ID but can also be used to electronically sign things as well (plug it into a terminal at the bank and enter a PIN to verify your identity when opening an account, or use a card reader at home).

Re:White House wants to end Social Security numbers as a nat... by s73ver_ on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @07:30PM (#15405688)
We do also put the SSN on a form quite often.
Re:White House wants to end Social Security numbers as a nat... by mtmail on Tuesday October 03, 2017 @05:47PM (#15396498)
Does the identifier need to be rememberable? I don't know my national id or passport number.
Re:White House wants to end Social Security numbers as a nat... by rabidrat on Tuesday October 03, 2017 @06:53PM (#15396896)
Yes, it needs to be rememberable by the owner. This is non-negotiable.
Re:White House wants to end Social Security numbers as a nat... by zbobet2012 on Tuesday October 03, 2017 @05:59PM (#15396588)
Here's a UUID you could probably remember "officer tell 8 apart country press spring % circus".
Re:White House wants to end Social Security numbers as a nat... by QAPereo on Tuesday October 03, 2017 @07:38PM (#15397145)
Most of us here could, but prepare to be shocked st how much of the general public couldn’t or wouldn’t.
Re:White House wants to end Social Security numbers as a nat... by bitwize on Tuesday October 03, 2017 @06:29PM (#15396743)
Just have your Urbit planet ID be your ID. So, for you, something like yam-fus-kon-gir-lil-zoq-fot-pik-top-kek. Donald Trump gets don-tum.