Re:Ask HN: Startup CEO giving employee grief for quitting
by foepys on Monday October 02, 2017 @11:31PM
(#15389894)
This annotated be emphasized enough. Unlimited vacation time is a fraud and leads to employees taking less vacation days. Peer-pressure is insanely strong and employees directly, compare their performance to others.
Re:Ask HN: Startup CEO giving employee grief for quitting
by isaaclyman on Tuesday October 03, 2017 @09:00AM
(#15392068)
That is not always the case. My last job had unlimited PTO and some of us took 20+ days per year.
Re:Ask HN: Startup CEO giving employee grief for quitting
by richardknop on Tuesday October 03, 2017 @12:18PM
(#15393527)
20+ days is nothing to write home about with unlimited PTO. Many jobs in Europe have anywhere between 21-25 (or even 28) paid vacation days per year. As a standard. I'd imagine in order to justify unlimited PTO you would have to be able to take at least 30-40 days per year without any issues.
Re:Ask HN: Startup CEO giving employee grief for quitting
by tudelo on Tuesday October 03, 2017 @10:00AM
(#15392444)
20 days does not seem like an extravagant ammount
Re:Ask HN: Startup CEO giving employee grief for quitting
by isaaclyman on Tuesday October 03, 2017 @10:01AM
(#15392448)
Around here anything above 15 is a lot.
Re:Ask HN: Startup CEO giving employee grief for quitting
by bartozone on Tuesday October 03, 2017 @12:29PM
(#15393624)
Yeah, anytime I take more than 10 days off in a year, I know that I'm pushing above the average. And that counts days around the holidays too. Every year I plan to take one vacation in the summer for a long weekend, or a full 5 days off in a row if I can.
Re:Ask HN: Startup CEO giving employee grief for quitting
by tudelo on Thursday October 05, 2017 @08:49AM
(#15408688)
What is around here? I ask as a (outside of DC non govt) worker with plenty of days (23-24 not including any holiday)~. Might want to avoid that area :)
Re:Ask HN: Startup CEO giving employee grief for quitting
by e59d134d on Tuesday October 03, 2017 @11:40AM
(#15393143)
This is so sad 20+ days is considered great for unlimited PTO??
Re:Ask HN: Startup CEO giving employee grief for quitting
by literallycancer on Tuesday October 03, 2017 @05:32PM
(#15396388)
Funny, most places in Europe the law requires at least 20 days, some places it's even 25 or more.
Re:Ask HN: Startup CEO giving employee grief for quitting
by handbanana on Tuesday October 03, 2017 @01:22PM
(#15394123)
I have unlimited and I am taking 35 days off this year. Not including the 9 days paid holidays I get. I took around 30 last year and had 10 paid holidays. My previous company gave us 24 days PTO, no paid holidays (we could choose which holidays we wanted to take off but we'd have to use PTO). At that company I consistently took off 30+ days total.
I am in the US, both are US companies. I could not handle having less than 40 days off a year and make it clear before hiring that I am going to take plenty of time off. Yes I am productive, no I do not work long hours (~35 a week at both places)
Re:Ask HN: Startup CEO giving employee grief for quitting
by isaaclyman on Tuesday October 03, 2017 @07:18PM
(#15397042)
Impressive. What area/industry are you in that you can find accommodations like this?
Re:Ask HN: Startup CEO giving employee grief for quitting
by handbanana on Tuesday October 03, 2017 @10:42PM
(#15397918)
Developer for 2 relatively small Saas apps (< 50k users). Not in remotely the same industry as each other. One privately held, one not. I don’t think it’s industry specific or particularly common, but I’ve had a couple of job offers and seen/heard of other places with comparable benefits. A lot of it is company culture and negotiation. If a company already provides 28 days and you interview well, you can likely get that increased.
Re:Ask HN: Startup CEO giving employee grief for quitting
by SamReidHughes on Monday October 02, 2017 @10:07PM
(#15389574)
PTO payout is state by state and I’d bet pretty unusual, but California and Massachusetts have it.
Re:Ask HN: Startup CEO giving employee grief for quitting
by sgk284 on Monday October 02, 2017 @11:11PM
(#15389838)
27 states + D.C. treat earned PTO as wages that must be paid out (one or two states do allow employment agreements to opt-out of this).[1]
Even when working in non-required states, I've always had an employer pay out (e.g. at Microsoft in WA).
Re:Ask HN: Startup CEO giving employee grief for quitting
by cwilkes on Tuesday October 03, 2017 @01:26AM
(#15390376)
I’ve always had employers pay out PTO in WA except for my last one, but they did give me some severance ... but I know they don’t pay it out as a rule.
I’ve heard that in the retail sector it is somewhat common not to pay out. That to me is akin to stealing: the employee earned those hours and the employer is refusing to pay.
In any traditional salaried role with a fixed amount of PTO an employee is paid out for any remaining PTO when they leave. "Unlimited" policies are a mess, for among many other reasons, because they allow companies to skimp out on paying time earned.
There is nothing unethical about what the employee did. They earned that time and/or value, and were compensated for it in the only way the company allowed them to be compensated for it. If the company wants a different set of incentives then they should change their vacation policy to a real one.
Your CEO, on the other hand, absolutely acted in an inappropriate way and, assuming they continue not to pay the employee, is acting illegally. Not all startups are like this but it is admittedly amateur hour at most of them.