News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by rwmj on Friday September 29, 2017 @03:45AM (#15363473)
Has anyone ever used the FM radio in their phone? I did once but got tired trying to orientate the phone and the headphone cable in a position to get decent reception.
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by Angostura on Friday September 29, 2017 @03:59AM (#15363527)
I used it a lot on my old Nokia brick in the 90s and it was very useful. I listen to radio a lot on my phone via the BBC Radioplayer App these days, I would certainly welcome being able to listen to the broadcast signal and save some data.
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by 5555624 on Friday September 29, 2017 @04:37AM (#15363688)
Yes. If I'm listening with headphones. That's the only inconvenience for me, because it means I need to have my phone in my pocket. I usually don't use headphones when it's sitting on my desk. (I invariably move and pull the phone off the desk.)
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by genericacct on Friday September 29, 2017 @04:17AM (#15363593)
I regularly do, but then again i live in a metropolis where every channel hosts a station; i imagine it's a bit less useful in the country. Also use it as a room monitor with the help of a small transmitter.
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by batiudrami on Friday September 29, 2017 @03:50AM (#15363488)
I used to use mine every day at work. Was frustrating to find that my Galaxy S7 doesn't have one (or it is disabled) - though a little portable replacement was inexpensive.
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by dragonwriter on Friday September 29, 2017 @09:50AM (#15365209)
Galaxy S7 has one; whether it's active depends on carrier, in he US at least (though I think, without checking, that it's only active on Sprint and possibly unlocked phones; the other US carriers only started activating them more recently and didn't go back; I'm pretty sure the S8 and Note 8 have active FM on the major US carriers.)
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by Aaargh20318 on Friday September 29, 2017 @03:55AM (#15363514)
Most radio stations have streams available in much better quality than FM. Why choose FM over streaming ?
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by metaphor on Friday September 29, 2017 @04:05AM (#15363550)
Received signal strength. Despite popular belief, cell service requires cell towers, which doesn't exist everywhere grass grows.
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by Aaargh20318 on Friday September 29, 2017 @05:37AM (#15363914)
Really, what's is the last time you did not have at least 3G reception ? In my country mobile coverage is 99.5%.
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by dagw on Friday September 29, 2017 @05:49AM (#15363963)
Really, what's is the last time you did not have at least 3G reception

Last time I went up into the mountains.

In my country mobile coverage is 99.5%.

What country is that? Even relatively well connected countries like Sweden and Norway have lots of spots out on some islands, deep in the forests or out in the mountains that don't have any mobile connection at all.

Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by Aaargh20318 on Friday September 29, 2017 @06:56AM (#15364213)
> What country is that?

The Netherlands.

That 0.5% is mostly on the borders where there is possibility of interference with networks in the neighbouring country. The problem is also being fixed after a bit of national outrage over the fact that people can't reach emergency services in that 0.5% and the operators had to make promises to quickly cover that last bit too.

Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by dagw on Friday September 29, 2017 @07:25AM (#15364350)
Well the Netherlands is a bit of special case. Small, densely populated countries are trivia to cover in mobile reception
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by metaphor on Friday September 29, 2017 @12:31PM (#15366730)
To the contrary, someone who lives in the Netherlands is quite prototypical of who I'd expect to hold such a naive purview.
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by zaxomi on Friday September 29, 2017 @10:00AM (#15365308)
>Really, what's is the last time you did not have at least 3G reception ?

Last time when there was a power outage. Every cell tower died. When the power come back, it took about half a day before the cell towers where working again.

Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by Aaargh20318 on Friday September 29, 2017 @10:27AM (#15365544)
Cell towers here have battery backups (it's a legal requirement). Also, power outages are extremely rare over here. Average reliability of the power network in my country (the Netherlands) was 99,995% over the last 14 years. The average outage takes about 30 minutes. IIRC cell towers have a 3-hour battery backup.
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by zaxomi on Friday September 29, 2017 @02:20PM (#15367706)
I live in Sweden, and major power outages are rare here too (latest was in 2003 and 1983). Small ones happens from time to time. I was convinced that it was a legal requirement here too, but it turns out that's not the case. Fortunately that will be changed, so from 2020 it will be mandatory here.

But, even if it is a legal requirement, it will not always work. All that is needed is a major storm that disrupts the normal power, and it will be down for days or maybe even months...

Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by dragonwriter on Friday September 29, 2017 @09:52AM (#15365228)
> Really, what's is the last time you did not have at least 3G reception ?

Every day, at places in and around my work, within a stones throw of the California State Capitol.

Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by rwmj on Friday September 29, 2017 @06:34AM (#15364113)
At my home, now. There is no mobile phone reception here at all, not even 2G.
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by chillingeffect on Friday September 29, 2017 @08:34AM (#15364661)
0. I'm not sure that quality is actually better. Yes, the highest frequencies of FM are lower, but a. Not everyone can even hear well above FM's 15 kHz. b. FM is analog with no lossy compression. Mp3-based radio stations @128kbps are noticeably worse than e.g. 256kbps and CD-quality audio. 256kbps stations are probably undiscernable though.

1. Only radio stations over a certain size. That necessarily means more commercial, less off-the-beaten path material. When I visit Miami, for example, there are many small, interesting radio stations with no internet portal.

2. Discovery. If you don't know what stations are available in your area, there is no simpler way to find out than simply spinning a dial along one axis. And what's the advantage of stations in your area? See #3 :)

3. Relevance of local culture. I like to hear banter, jokes, news, weather and concert listings from around my area.

4. Use of a single device. This is more of a cell phone vs. FM radio question. Of course if your phone has FM radio, you can tune in, but then you can't be on the phone and using your GPS at the same time. In my car I can scan for local stations while the GPS is running on my phone.

5. Tracking. If I'm using FM radio, I'm listening anonymously. If I listen via digital network, that info can be sold to many different countries.

6. Quality of experience. On FM, the transition between stations is nearly instantaneous. On digital wireless networks, there's always buffering, making it longer to find something good.

7. Convenience of calling in to the DJ. I often like to call DJs on local stations and ask them about the music they're playing. This is more complicated when I have to turn off the station and turn it back on when i'm done. It often takes a few minutes for them to respond. I wouldn't want to have to turn off the radio while I'm waiting for them to answer. Of course, this might not work as good on a cell phone - like #4 above, it might depend on the implementation.

Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by Aaargh20318 on Friday September 29, 2017 @10:17AM (#15365446)
> When I visit Miami, for example, there are many small, interesting radio stations with no internet portal.

Isn't it a lot easier to start broadcasting over the internet than over the air ? Operating an FM station is a huge investment. First you have to take part in the FM spectrum auction, which only occurs every couple of years, and then you'd have to bid and win a piece of the spectrum. That alone will cost you millions (last auction in my tiny country an FM frequency set you back 20 million euro for 6 years). Then you need the broadcast equipment, etc. etc.

Broadcasting on the internet, you could do that on a €25 Raspberry Pi if you wanted.

> Discovery. If you don't know what stations are available in your area, there is no simpler way to find out than simply spinning a dial along one axis.

Sure, but you have a handful of stations and they are only available in a small area. With streaming radio you have a choice of thousands of channels available worldwide. It's much easier to discover a station you like and you are not limited to the few stations in range.

> Relevance of local culture. I like to hear banter, jokes, news, weather and concert listings from around my area.

That's personal. Most people I know can't stand the DJ's on the radio who only love to hear themselves talk. It's the #1 complaint you hear about radio. One of the most popular FM stations here is the one that just broadcasts music 24/7.

> In my car I can scan for local stations while the GPS is running on my phone.

In my car I can listen to streaming music on my phone while the GPS is running on my dedicated SatNav.

> Quality of experience. On FM, the transition between stations is nearly instantaneous. On digital wireless networks, there's always buffering, making it longer to find something good.

You don't need to 'tune in' to find something, with streaming you can easily browse through a huge list of different stations and click the one you like. My phone certainly switches streams faster than my car stereo changes stations. With 100+Mbit 4G networks being common, buffering a few kB is pretty much instantaneous.

Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by FoeNyx on Friday September 29, 2017 @04:11AM (#15363569)
Listening to Radio in FM uses passive reception and dedicated chip, and thus has probably much lower power consumption.

Not having WIFI or 4G available is also a good reason.

Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by Aaargh20318 on Friday September 29, 2017 @05:38AM (#15363920)
> Not having WIFI or 4G available is also a good reason.

Because WIFI and 4G being down at the same time is a thing that happens ?

Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by tjoff on Friday September 29, 2017 @06:37AM (#15364131)
Yes, outside cellular coverage there is rarely any wifi coverage either...
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by Aaargh20318 on Friday September 29, 2017 @07:01AM (#15364234)
I'm outside of wifi coverage for maybe 30 minutes a day, on my bike ride to/from work and a visit to the supermarket. 3G/4G coverage is practically 100% (actually 99.5%), only when you get close to the national borders there are some white spots because they aren't allowed to broadcast too far over the border and interfere with networks in Germany or Belgium.

There actually was a bit of outrage over that last 0.5% a while back due to emergency services not being reachable in those areas and the mobile operators had to make promises to cover those areas as well. So yeah, coverage is pretty much total.

Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by tjoff on Friday September 29, 2017 @10:22AM (#15365502)
Well, if your country don't have any sea or mountains or any other remote area I guess that is "nice"...

Also, big difference between emergency service and 3/4G suitable for audio streaming.

Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by batiudrami on Friday September 29, 2017 @04:22AM (#15363621)
So this is a pretty niche problem but my preferred radio station is a national broadcaster based on the east coast which is delayed for FM broadcast on the west coast (where I am), while the internet stream is live.
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by Aaargh20318 on Friday September 29, 2017 @05:40AM (#15363928)
So the internet stream is even better than the FM stream.
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by batiudrami on Sunday October 01, 2017 @10:38PM (#15381367)
Not if you want to listen to a specific program at a specific time, or if you move between your desk and your car on FM (as you'll hear the same songs), or if you want the local news broadcasts which are embedded in the west coast stream, or even just if your mate has a propensity to text you to talk about how great that song just was.
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by richardknop on Friday September 29, 2017 @05:09AM (#15363807)
Data is expensive. Why pay telco companies to stream FM? Enable it on the phone and you can do it for free.
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by Angostura on Friday September 29, 2017 @04:00AM (#15363529)
Not on an unlimited data plan?
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by Aaargh20318 on Friday September 29, 2017 @05:40AM (#15363931)
You don't need a data plan for wifi.
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by Angostura on Friday September 29, 2017 @11:56AM (#15366401)
I use listen to radio when I'm out and about, gardening, running, etc.
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by Yaggo on Friday September 29, 2017 @04:59AM (#15363779)
With good headphones, the ~30-15000 Hz audio frequency range of stereo FM feels somewhat limited, thus I prefer streaming over mobile data network.
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by btschaegg on Friday September 29, 2017 @06:30AM (#15364102)
I did once, on my last phone (a Samsung Note 2), because I wanted to record a specific event I knew about beforehand. I was actually impressed by how well that worked. From the whole "headphones as antenna" setup I'd always assumed FM radio to be rather dodgy...
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by dplgk on Friday September 29, 2017 @10:41AM (#15365675)
I use FM receiver in my S7 to wirelessly listen to audio from TV. In my TV, I plug in an FM transmitter. Much less BS to deal with than Bluetooth.
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by dtech on Friday September 29, 2017 @04:06AM (#15363556)
I used to before mobile internet and music streaming were as ubiquitous as they are today.
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by pjmlp on Friday September 29, 2017 @05:39AM (#15363921)
The meaning of ubiquitous is very country specific.

Even here in Germany, ubiquitous is not a term I would use for mobile Internet access when traveling between major cities, let alone when I am on the countryside.

Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by dvhh on Friday September 29, 2017 @04:51AM (#15363740)
Quite useful to learn language when you live in a foreign country
Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by pjmlp on Friday September 29, 2017 @05:37AM (#15363915)
Yes, since my Symbian devices.

All my WP and Android devices also have FM radio.

Re:Apple reminds the FCC that it can’t activate imaginary iP... by dagw on Friday September 29, 2017 @05:19AM (#15363840)
Has anyone ever used the FM radio in their phone?

Not since ~2001-2002