Re:South Pacific landmass may have been closer to land level...
by ChuckMcM on Thursday September 28, 2017 @03:03PM
(#15359851)
I enjoy (as humor) the articles where this is discussed as a plot by New Zealand to be declared a continent. I imagine if there were people from Pluto living among us they would be telling us how planet like Pluto is :-)
But humor aside, where do you draw the line? Nearly all of the Mojave desert in the US was clearly a sea floor based on the fossils found in its sandstone rocks. But we're not going to call it an ocean. It was an ocean, and then things moved around and now it is a desert. Zealandia was a continent but now its the seafloor around an island.
Lets say we call it a continent, does it suddenly make it all the territory of the government of New Zealand? Does that mean they control fishing and mineral rights for hundreds of kilometers beyond the shores of their island? Where does that lead?
Re:South Pacific landmass may have been closer to land level...
by seszett on Thursday September 28, 2017 @03:16PM
(#15359938)
> Lets say we call it a continent, does it suddenly make it all the territory of the government of New Zealand? Does that mean they control fishing and mineral rights for hundreds of kilometers beyond the shores of their island?
Probably, yes. France extended its EEZ last year with new evidence that the land around Kerguelen island forms an underwater "continent" as well. I imagine if this finding about Zealandia gets confirmed, both New Zealand and France (from New Caledonia) will want to extend their EEZ there as well.
Note, the extension is from 200mi (the eez) up to 350mi -- so NZ wouldn't get the entire continental area.. and in that extended area, they only get exclusive rights to the soil and subsoil (so things like oil, etc... but no exclusive fishing rights).
Re:South Pacific landmass may have been closer to land level...
by craftyguy on Thursday September 28, 2017 @04:28PM
(#15360449)
If you go far enough back, South America and Africa were 1 continent. Go even further and, at several times, there was only 1 continent on Earth. Go even further back and there were no continents. So maybe we should just to away with the notion of having continents in the first place.
Re:South Pacific landmass may have been closer to land level...
by ChuckMcM on Thursday September 28, 2017 @04:40PM
(#15360542)
That would be the ad absurdium argument :-). But the EEZ[1] argument is the one that is in play here. Generally the 'oceans' are international water, and what is under them is not claimed by any country.
There are economic and strategic assets here, whether it is oil or methane clathrates, fisheries, or places to establish forward operating bases, these things are 'easy' to claim in your 'own' territory and 'hard' to claim in international waters. Step 1, redefine them to not be international waters. See the South China Sea and now Zealandia ...
Re:South Pacific landmass may have been closer to land level...
by craftyguy on Thursday September 28, 2017 @06:19PM
(#15361246)
Ad absurdium arguments are my favorite :)
Totally understand the implications of EEZ, but at some point you have to draw the line else the line will become increasingly more arbitrary as countries try to fuzz the boundaries of what a continent is and is not. Why does any country get to lay claim on a chunk of seafloor that has been uninhabitable for land animals far longer than humans have been around as a species?
Re:South Pacific landmass may have been closer to land level...
by rgbrenner on Thursday September 28, 2017 @10:24PM
(#15362318)
Why does any country get to lay claim on a chunk of seafloor that has been uninhabitable for land animals far longer than humans have been around as a species?
Re:South Pacific landmass may have been closer to land level...
by leggomylibro on Thursday September 28, 2017 @01:28PM
(#15359087)
How cool - it's also interesting that there are a handful of massive undersea plateaus marked on one of the articles' maps.
I wonder if it'd be possible to build a sealab on one of them; it looks like there are often small atolls nearby, and it could be a good environment for testing concepts related to building and maintaining livable underwater environments.
Re:South Pacific landmass may have been closer to land level...
by contingencies on Thursday September 28, 2017 @03:22PM
(#15359979)
Isn't it funny that an American journal publishes an article with Australian scientists about a continent they term Zealandia after New Zealand in turn named after a place in Holland where much of the landmass and water is currently controlled by France?
I have pity on the Chinese national geographic toponym bureau for having the tedious task of translating this for national linguistic unity.
Truly, we dwell in a post-national mire of bureaucrats! We need more solid continents!
Re:South Pacific landmass may have been closer to land level...
by jdmichal on Thursday September 28, 2017 @04:32PM
(#15360475)
I'm assuming low. Just looking at the first map in the article, the one zoomed in to Australia and New Zealand... The Tasman Sea looks to obviously separate the two masses for most of what would be their shared extent.
Also, just because continents are touching, does not mean they aren't separate. Europe, Asia, and Africa are all one continuous land mass. (The Suez canal technically separated Africa from Asia, but it certainly doesn't cut through the depth of the entire continent.) And we're only one Bering Strait away from connecting all that to North and South America.
Re:South Pacific landmass may have been closer to land level...
by vorg on Thursday September 28, 2017 @11:08PM
(#15362471)
That makes Australia, Zealandia, and Antarctica be one continent. Since all three names are 4 syllables long, with the stress on the second, in English, perhaps it should be called Stralantarc.
Re:South Pacific landmass may have been closer to land level...
by gus_massa on Thursday September 28, 2017 @09:34PM
(#15362128)
Continents are made of light rock floating over heavy rocks. So they are floating, like ice cubes in a glass full of jelly. But continents are not floating over water.
In this case, the light rocks are no vey tick, so the thin layer of water that we call ocean can cover them. I like this image: https://goo.gl/images/aqCBJL
But humor aside, where do you draw the line? Nearly all of the Mojave desert in the US was clearly a sea floor based on the fossils found in its sandstone rocks. But we're not going to call it an ocean. It was an ocean, and then things moved around and now it is a desert. Zealandia was a continent but now its the seafloor around an island.
Lets say we call it a continent, does it suddenly make it all the territory of the government of New Zealand? Does that mean they control fishing and mineral rights for hundreds of kilometers beyond the shores of their island? Where does that lead?
Probably, yes. France extended its EEZ last year with new evidence that the land around Kerguelen island forms an underwater "continent" as well. I imagine if this finding about Zealandia gets confirmed, both New Zealand and France (from New Caledonia) will want to extend their EEZ there as well.
Note, the extension is from 200mi (the eez) up to 350mi -- so NZ wouldn't get the entire continental area.. and in that extended area, they only get exclusive rights to the soil and subsoil (so things like oil, etc... but no exclusive fishing rights).
There are economic and strategic assets here, whether it is oil or methane clathrates, fisheries, or places to establish forward operating bases, these things are 'easy' to claim in your 'own' territory and 'hard' to claim in international waters. Step 1, redefine them to not be international waters. See the South China Sea and now Zealandia ...
[1] Extended Economic Zone
Totally understand the implications of EEZ, but at some point you have to draw the line else the line will become increasingly more arbitrary as countries try to fuzz the boundaries of what a continent is and is not. Why does any country get to lay claim on a chunk of seafloor that has been uninhabitable for land animals far longer than humans have been around as a species?
United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Convention_on_t...
It's true this is unfair to marine animals, but that's really their fault for not attending the meetings when the treaty was signed.
I wonder if it'd be possible to build a sealab on one of them; it looks like there are often small atolls nearby, and it could be a good environment for testing concepts related to building and maintaining livable underwater environments.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SEALAB
Things quickly get challenging with depth.
I have pity on the Chinese national geographic toponym bureau for having the tedious task of translating this for national linguistic unity.
Truly, we dwell in a post-national mire of bureaucrats! We need more solid continents!
But France is still in the picture since New Caledonia also sits on the plateau of Zealandia... New Caledonia itself named after Scotland!
Also, just because continents are touching, does not mean they aren't separate. Europe, Asia, and Africa are all one continuous land mass. (The Suez canal technically separated Africa from Asia, but it certainly doesn't cut through the depth of the entire continent.) And we're only one Bering Strait away from connecting all that to North and South America.
In this case, the light rocks are no vey tick, so the thin layer of water that we call ocean can cover them. I like this image: https://goo.gl/images/aqCBJL