News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by vertex-four on Monday September 25, 2017 @09:05AM (#15330070)
The goal of the congestion charge is not to make money off cars in London - it's an attempt to reduce the number of cars in London. The number of cabs is limited largely by the complexity of The Knowledge, while the number of minicabs is rather less limited, so in conspiracy theory land, TfL have motive to ban minicab operators wherever possible.

In any case, it's very unlikely that this is an ulterior motive - there's no reason why the problems aren't exactly what was listed, i.e. mostly administrative failures on Uber's part where other minicab companies are more cooperative with the license requirements.

Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by rahimnathwani on Monday September 25, 2017 @09:41AM (#15330362)
"The goal of the congestion charge is not to make money off cars in London - it's an attempt to reduce the number of cars in London."

Surely the goal of the congestion charge is to, you know, reduce congestion. One way would be to reduce the number of cars simultaneously on the road during periods of congestion. Excluding black cabs from this incentive structure does a disservice to Londoners.

Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by fasteddie on Monday September 25, 2017 @02:58PM (#15333009)
Cabs/Ubers have very different marginal driving decisions than "regular" drivers, and a congestion fee is not an effective policy to target them. If London feels like the cabs are the real opportunity to reduce congestion, which doesn't make much sense to me, the way to do so would be in how they implement their medallion system.
Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by SomeStupidPoint on Monday September 25, 2017 @02:41PM (#15332874)
Not a priori, as a decrease in cab utilization from higher fees might lead to more cars and in fact make congestion worse.

This would be something you had to measure the effect of, due to (possible) non-trivial feedback.

Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by lhnz on Monday September 25, 2017 @09:27AM (#15330239)

  > mostly administrative failures on Uber's part where 
  > other minicab companies are more cooperative with
  > the license requirements.
But TfL inspectors gave Uber the green light ten times [0] including recently before suddenly deciding to ban them. There doesn't seem to be a history of repeated administrative failures here.

[0] https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/tfl-inspectors-gave-uber-...

Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by notahacker on Monday September 25, 2017 @09:45AM (#15330391)
I'm sure that had they used the opportunity to shut down Uber years ago over a paperwork issue, rather than waiting for the Metropolitan Police to write to them expressing concern that Uber's policies of refusing to report crimes and obstructionist approach towards police investigations may have lead directly to people being sexually assaulted, the people still arguing on here that Uber's conduct is above criticism would have been even more outspoken in condemning authorities.

The ten times Uber got the green light in numerous other inspections and fact it wasn't halted early in operations over paperwork (unlike, say Taxify) is far better evidence in support of arguments that the regulators have been extraordinarily flexible and tolerant towards Uber than evidence for the insinuations they're more bothered about hurting Uber than Uber hurting its customers.

Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by lhnz on Monday September 25, 2017 @12:14PM (#15331627)

  > rather than waiting for the Metropolitan Police to write
  > to them expressing concern that Uber's policies of refusing
  > to report crimes and obstructionist approach towards
  > police investigations may have lead directly to people
  > being sexually assaulted
Uber responded by saying that they have a "dedicated unit [...] tackling any incidents [...] run by former Met officers". [0]

This easily verifiable so I think it is extremely dishonest to say that they have a "policy of refusing to report crimes" or 'obstructionism'. This would only be the case if Uber was in some way incentivizing this team to fudge numbers.

I also know many people that feel much safer knowing that their friends and family are able to see where they are on a trip, and like the fact that they can retroactively determine the name and number plate of a driver the next day.

If you are assaulted by a black cab driver and they speed off, you have no way of gathering information about your driver. This lack of transparency makes being driven in a black cab much more dangerous.

  > The ten times Uber got the green light [...] 
  > evidence in support of arguments that the regulators
  > have been extraordinarily flexible and tolerant
  > towards Uber
If Uber was not given the green light then you see it as proof that they are not playing by regulations, but if they are given the green light you see it as proof that they received tolerance and flexibility yet were not following regulations. What information would change your mind?

[0] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2017/08/13/uber-sex-scandal-...

Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by notahacker on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @11:38AM (#15339589)
If the Metropolitan Police write a letter complaining to TfL about Uber's policy of refusing to report certain crimes and obstructionist approach towards police investigations (specifically, refusing to provide information except as formal FOI requests) then this is clear evidence that in the opinion of somebody who has considerably more first hand knowledge of Uber's actions and expertise in police/minicab co-operation than HackerNewsers who like the app, Uber is refusing to report crimes and acting in an obstructionist manner towards police investigations.

What is extremely dishonest is to respond by pretending those claims are an untrue invention of mine, using a line from Uber's press release which in no way refutes the police officer's specific contentions about information not being reported to the police appropriately as justification.

As for changing my mind, I'd probably start with the need to refute that basic prima facie evidence that Uber isn't viewed as respecting a minicab firm's obligations by the relevant police official. You can't really counter that by pointing out circumstantial stuff like them having their own investigation team or passing inspections of how they comply with other regulations, that's not how proof works. And yes, an extraordinary claim like "actually it's the regulators who've repeatedly refrained from using many possible excuses to shut down Uber over the five years it's spent deploying Greyball and suing them over regulations it doesn't want to follow who are the ones most likely to be wilfully misinterpreting the letter and spirit of regulations here" probably needs evidence a little more extraordinary than their self-exculpatory press release.

In the mean time, Uber has taken the uncharacteristic step of apologising and acknowledging they "need to change".

Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by lozenge on Monday September 25, 2017 @02:40PM (#15332866)
If their "tackling" of incidents involves not reporting crimes to the police, can that really be called "tackling"? The fact it is run by former police officers is irrelevant if all they do is decide whether or not to retain a driver.
Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by lhnz on Tuesday September 26, 2017 @08:35AM (#15338051)
That is true. If crimes are being reported to them which are not reported to the police, that is a problem.
Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by monkeyprojects on Monday September 25, 2017 @09:52AM (#15330441)
They wanted a 5 year licence back in May but were given a 4 month licence and a requirement to resolve the issues that there were. 4 months later the issues are still there so what else could TfL do?
Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by gsnedders on Monday September 25, 2017 @09:45AM (#15330387)
Then why did they only get a four month extension four months ago instead of the five-year one applied for?
Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by cjrp on Monday September 25, 2017 @09:58AM (#15330500)
Well prior to this their license was only renewed for 4 months (rather than the normal 5 years), so that suggests there may have been a warning.
Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by efsavage on Monday September 25, 2017 @10:06AM (#15330567)
> The goal of the congestion charge is not to make money off cars in London - it's an attempt to reduce the number of cars in London.

Initially, yes. But it's now a revenue stream, and it's really hard for governments of any philosophy to gracefully accept a loss of revenue.

There is also the Shirky Principle: "Institutions will try to preserve the problem to which they are the solution"

Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by tomp on Monday September 25, 2017 @09:19AM (#15330164)
> it's an attempt to reduce the number of cars in London

Not sure if that's true. I think it's mainly to reduce the polution in central London. Otherwise, electric/hybrid cars wouldn't be exempt but charged the same amount!

Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by Brakenshire on Monday September 25, 2017 @09:42AM (#15330372)
> Otherwise, electric/hybrid cars wouldn't be exempt but charged the same amount!

That's an anomaly I'd say. The congestion charge was introduced in 2003, at that point electric cars were a curiosity, a fraction of a fraction of the market. I'd expect within 10-15 years the exemption will be removed.

The purpose was partly to reduce pollution, but as a secondary effect of the primary aim to reduce traffic:

https://londontransportdata.files.wordpress.com/2011/07/inne...

Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by Nursie on Monday September 25, 2017 @09:28AM (#15330248)
>> I think it's mainly to reduce the polution in central London.

I lived in London when it was launched, it was also to do with making the city centre flow again, so that those who actually needed to be there could travel in a reasonable amount of time.

Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by konschubert on Monday September 25, 2017 @10:09AM (#15330593)
You mean, the ones who have money to pay the congestion charge. :)
Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by _h_o_d_ on Monday September 25, 2017 @10:13AM (#15330639)
Correct. Until we have a better economic system, this is how authorities often make incentives.
Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by Nursie on Monday September 25, 2017 @10:12AM (#15330632)
Well yeah, but as with all things in life, taxes and capitalism - money and motivation get used interchangeably because government has no imagination!
Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by vertex-four on Monday September 25, 2017 @09:21AM (#15330179)
Ah, true. I do think we'll see a congestion charge on electric cars as they become more popular, though - London plain and simple doesn't have enough space for personal road traffic.

Edit: Hmm. London's own stuff claims that it was originally largely intended to reduce use of personal vehicles, and then in 2008 the Mayor implemented the current system of charging based on pollution. Again, I suspect it'll go back to charging for electric vehicles once people actually own electric vehicles.

Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by misnome on Monday September 25, 2017 @09:31AM (#15330273)
I'm not sure the two aims are in conflict. I'm pretty sure that consumer electric cars were pretty much nonexistent when the congestion charge was first implemented.
Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by barrkel on Monday September 25, 2017 @09:34AM (#15330295)
That's not a contradiction. There's also a separate scheme to reduce London pollution (LEZ), and there's an extension of it currently starting up (ULEZ). They have overlapping aims.

For example, bus lanes were made for busses, despite cyclists and motorcycles (on most red routes) being able to enter them.

Re:Understanding Uber: It's Not About the App by _h_o_d_ on Monday September 25, 2017 @10:12AM (#15330628)
It is reasonable to believe that these goals are both in mind! Edit: there's a new Diesel charge coming in soon, to reduce the extra pollution from these vehicles entering central london, for cars as well as lorries. In all the communications emanating from politicians and TFL it seems that numbers and pollution are both problems to be solved. Note also the new 'Boris' buses were designed as hybrids to improve air quality, even though in practice they don't work well and run on diesel mostly.