News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by tylersmith on Friday September 22, 2017 @12:19AM (#15309369)
This article completely fails to address the main issue: conflating identity and authentication. If credit reports required some sort of attestation of secret knowledge in order to apply for things the issue would be dramatically lessened. A social security number should be no more damaging to know than someone's email address.
Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by semi-extrinsic on Friday September 22, 2017 @01:15AM (#15309552)
What you really need is a standardised login portal for government and private services that deal with personal information. Then you can have multiple service providers for the actual login, e.g. your bank's proper 2FA login, YubiKeys etc. We've had this for years in my country (with ~2% of the population of the US) and it's working great. Typically the SS number is used for identification, and you have password + one-time code on top of that.
Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by tylersmith on Friday September 22, 2017 @01:28AM (#15309609)
I disagree. Centralizing the data and the access control would only create more issues. If somebody got into your account they'd have the keys to your life. We need to embrace decentralizing data and access control along with healthy security habits like proper secret generation and frequent rotation.
Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by hvidgaard on Friday September 22, 2017 @02:13AM (#15309778)
NemId, as it is called in Denmark, is a paper card with many one time keys, or a dongle that creates a new key every so often. Every time you login, or perform a transaction in the online banking, you need a new and different key. If they get access to your keys, which would probably be because you did something stupid like taking a picture of the card, you can revoke access, and there is a paper trail of every single time the adversary impersonated you.

How is that worse?

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by tylersmith on Friday September 22, 2017 @02:47AM (#15309919)
I'm not familiar with the system but centralizing critical data is strictly less ideal than decentralizing it. If your key seed or the central server are compromised everything is compromised.

Revoking keys is great but doesn't help after they've given full access.

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by hvidgaard on Friday September 22, 2017 @04:55AM (#15310395)
No data is centralized. There is a central service that grants access tokens. You can revoke the login name (default is CPR, our equivalent to SSN, but can be changed to anything, mine is for instance), card or dongle seed. It is in essence a public login name, a secret password, and a one time key. It is state of the art security for every single individuals interaction with the government and when applying for financing, banking, ect. Should the central service be compromised, there is a kill switch in the system until the service is secure again.

There is multiple layers of security at play here, including seperated logging entities such that there is no traffic that isn't logged, always leaving a paper trail of what services was used by the adversary. If you want to gain access to impersonate someone, there are others a significantly more effective ways utilizing social engineering. Not to say it's easy, because you need to obtain an official card (sygesikringsbevis), then use that to request a new passport with your photo, hope they do not have old photos in record, then use the passport to change address and then order NemId key card, and hope the person is not reading the mail and text about a new card being send.

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by jon_richards on Friday September 22, 2017 @03:11AM (#15310013)
>Revoking keys is great but doesn't help after they've given full access.

That's true in a lot of infosec, but in identification, you can revoke everything and wait for meat-space verification to start again.

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by tylersmith on Friday September 22, 2017 @03:18AM (#15310041)
Only once you've noticed it. Automated systems could be used but there's always the potential for large impacts before automated systems recognize the issue.

And if the keys are ID related you can easily revoke it. You can't revoke a SSN, fingerprint, DNA, or a face scan.

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by jon_richards on Friday September 22, 2017 @04:07AM (#15310220)
>Typically the SS number is used for identification, and you have password + one-time code on top of that.

Isn't that what this was addressing? The attacker has to get both your password and one-time codes before you change either. All the ID related stuff is used like usernames, not keys.

If an attacker does get both, you presumably go in to a government office, have your fingerprints taken, choose a new password, and get given a new set of codes.

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by will_hughes on Friday September 22, 2017 @01:57AM (#15309723)
> along with healthy security habits like proper secret generation and frequent rotation.

While having the populace in general be security aware would be a great thing, it's barely possible to get them to do even basic shit like not putting credit card numbers and other secret information into an email and sending it to anyone who asks nicely.

Educating people on why 'healthy security habits' and 'key rotation' doesn't mean locking the front door and hanging their housekeys differently is pretty much a non-starter.

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by tylersmith on Friday September 22, 2017 @02:06AM (#15309753)
As people continue to get their money stolen they'll slowly come around to utilizing good security.
Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by groby_b on Friday September 22, 2017 @02:22AM (#15309812)
No, they won't. They'll stop using tech as much as they can.

That's basic UX. If you make the experience shitty, people will avoid it. No amount of experts waving their hands wildly will help that.

If you can't wrap up your healthy habits and your key rotation in a simple device/card/whatnot that people can carry around and use just like a key, your security measures have already failed.

"Because I said so" doesn't work on kids, it sure as heck doesn't work on adults.

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by tylersmith on Friday September 22, 2017 @02:37AM (#15309871)
> No, they won't. They'll stop using tech as much as they can.

That's doubtful, especially as technology becomes increasingly ubiquitous. For systems like SS force users to use it so opting out isn't currently even an option.

> If you can't wrap up your healthy habits and your key rotation in a simple device/card/whatnot that people can carry around and use just like a key, your security measures have already failed.

Who said we won't?

Seat belts were also avoided for a long time but eventually people have realized they're a good idea.

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by groby_b on Friday September 22, 2017 @02:48AM (#15309923)
> Seat belts were also avoided for a long time but eventually people have realized they're a good idea.

I take it, then, you were not around in the 80s :) People did not "realize" seatbelts are a good idea. We made people wear seatbelts, using quite draconian laws and relentless PR.

> Who said we won't? [... wrap security habits into a handy device]

You'll have to explain to me how that jives with your idea of decentralizing data and access control. A key/security device will need to be manufactured - and there are only a few commercial entitites that can and/or will do that. And if you think they won't centralize key management, I admire your optimism.

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by tylersmith on Friday September 22, 2017 @02:55AM (#15309948)
Firstly, thanks for the discussion. I enjoy it.

I was not around in the 80s, but I know that campaigns to support seat belts and the potential outcomes of not doing so had eventually gotten people to be much more careful.

Regarding devices, things like the Ledger or Trezor Bitcoin wallets could easily be adapted to allow users to control their own data securely and simply. There's no reason end users need to understand what's going on in the background. They just know you have a secure usb device you use to authenticate yourself.

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by will_hughes on Friday September 22, 2017 @03:17AM (#15310039)
"could easily be adapted to allow users to control their own data securely and simply"

If you can solve the UX problems associated with those, you'll win a lot of praise.

To be clear, even something as simple as contactless payment/transit cards are still too difficult for many people to manage.

I had to physically take a wireless payment terminal out of a taxi driver's hands when he insisted on trying to do a contactless payment by taking the card in one hand, the reader in the other, and then as if he were playing a game of 'slap', slapping the credit card against the terminal and then immedidately pulling it back up and away. He repeated this several times, cursing each time the terminal displayed the message 'Read Error'.

I've repeatedly seen people of all ages: try to press contactless cards against screens, wave cards back and forth at varying distances from the reader, and all manner of other behaviors. And we're talking with basic cards that have no option for input here.

Key rotation that requires installing software, using a computer, etc - it's all going to be far too complex for many to understand.

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by tylersmith on Friday September 22, 2017 @03:21AM (#15310057)
I am neither a UX nor hardware expert so that's all taken with what you called "optimism".

Key rotation doesn't need to be so complex if the afore mentioned hardware devices are built correctly.

Overall I hope security-absolutists like me can work with more socially in-touch people like you to build solutions that can become mainstream.

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by will_hughes on Friday September 22, 2017 @04:38AM (#15310335)
I'm hardly socially in-touch. I just observe people's interaction with technology both at my job (Devops), and in the wider world.

If you want to have some idea of the challenges - read reddit's Tales from Tech Support[1] subreddit. For a non-IT focus, the Just Rolled Into the Shop[2] subreddit has a similar theme - that people refuse to read instructions, educate themselves, or even listen to basic instructions on things.

Better still - do a 'ride along' with someone who does hands-on IT support for a few weeks.

I suspect the only way we will get it if Apple decides to make an ID platform that integrates with the iPhone.

[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/talesfromtechsupport [2] https://www.reddit.com/r/Justrolledintotheshop/

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by tylersmith on Friday September 22, 2017 @04:49AM (#15310374)
I've done a fair amount of tech support in my career. The divide in our thoughts seems to be that I'm not thinking of a system that will be quickly popular and adopted, but rather one that is secure and eventually wins over users. Users may be reluctant but as they continue to suffer from data loss they'll slowly learn to use proper security regardless of the UX hurdles.
Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by dsfyu404ed on Friday September 22, 2017 @08:48AM (#15311652)
[2] is basically an enthusiast sub and filled likewise filled with unrealistic expectations of normal people. The mechanical equivalent of "what kind of neanderthal doesn't run no-script?"

[1] is better because it's real stories.

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by conanbatt on Friday September 22, 2017 @10:01AM (#15312212)
Milton friedman talks quite a bit about the seatbelt debacle which he was contemporary for.

A report-book was written by Ralph Nader called Unsafe at any speed, talking about motor accidents which prompted some outcry and political action that ended with the seatbelt legislation and other safety features.

Some time after the book was published, it was shown to have inaccuracies and wrong statistics.

https://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/27/automobiles/50-years-ago-...

MF on it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-M90XvQD8eE

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by Spivak on Friday September 22, 2017 @10:01AM (#15312207)
In just the same way that if someone compromises your email they can probably take control of all of your online accounts.

If you have to have many accounts to access government services people are just going to use the same password for all of them and never rotate them. A single authentication service used by all gov't services would be a huge gain for security.

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by zo1 on Friday September 22, 2017 @06:14AM (#15310689)
This is essentially a new form of luddism. The world is moving forward, with systems evolving by consolidating, grouping and analyzing every aspect of us, our world, and the things we do. Centralization is the answer to so many of our world's ills. Everything from crime, to poverty, to inequality, to disaster-relief. You name it, they can all benefit from a centralized store of all of humanity's knowledge. That is the entire point of the web: connected and cross-referenced knowledge.

Fighting that is fighting progress due to fear. And blanketly decrying "centralization" of data because of the fear that it may get lost doesn't address the problems. We should move our society forward, but we should do it while solving the individual security concerns piecemeal and as they happen.

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by trapperkeeper74 on Friday September 22, 2017 @01:59AM (#15309727)
Basically, the US needs a national ID "card" with PKI system... not to rob people of their privacy but to free them from the tyranny of marketplace anarchy which resulted in the absence of global unique person identifier de-facto globbing onto a number meant for pensioner and disabled benefits. Basically, it should be illegal to use SSNs for anything but Social Security. Taxes should have a tax ID for taxes alone. Instead, secure public key systems to authorize or refuse requests with authenication and nonrepudiation, using a public identifier that can be shared widely but isn't also a magic access authorization detail.

As it happens, IIRC, circa 2000, US schools and universities had to change their databases and systems to not use SSN's as student IDs because of identity theft problems extending from this very core problem.

The US through law must deleverage SSNs and make them public-safe, and promote/mandate a real PKI non-profit system for authentication and authorization for the greater good.

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by groby_b on Friday September 22, 2017 @02:27AM (#15309835)
Good luck. There's a significant part of the US that gets their panties in a bunch whenever you mention something close to a national ID - which this would be.

So, instead we have an extremely crappy national ID in form of SSN cards, but I'm fairly certain that same crowd would also be happy to end social security - so at least they're consistent.

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by tylersmith on Friday September 22, 2017 @02:43AM (#15309904)
Would there be a point to a national ID outside taxation? Is that the only reason a State would need to have identifiers for its citizens? Credit can be managed without centralized identities so what is the nessecity of a State ID?
Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by dsfyu404ed on Friday September 22, 2017 @09:13AM (#15311825)
State IDs manage state administered stuff. E.g. your driver's license. Pretty much every state has a ID that can stand in place of a license for ID but doesn't have anything to do with driving.

With current technology there's no technical or practical (other than inertia) reason federal services couldn't use state IDs. There's only 50 states, not N states. A 50-case switch wouldn't be that bad. ID requirements between states aren't so disparate that you couldn't get a good enough mapping.

The biggest hurdle to ANY effective ID system for individual people is that ID is a composite key. There are many Joe Smiths in the US. There are many Joe Smiths in a state. There are probably a handful of Joe smiths with the same birth date. There are possibly multiple Joe Smiths born on the same day that look similar and share a zip code.

People don't have unique identifiers other than DNA and even then if you don't do a good job processing it you're not guaranteed accuracy and I don't think we're at a point where we trust any .gov with that level of info about us.

So far we've been able to squeak by with just using really ugly composite keys.

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by groby_b on Friday September 22, 2017 @12:43PM (#15313717)
We're in the process of figuring out composite keys don't work :)

And yes, State + State ID is a decent substitute for a national ID. Because it is a national ID. Except that some states will implement it in the shittiest way possible, and so we end up with even more of a lowest common denominator than if the states negotiated a standard.

And one could reasonably make the case that in this day and age, IDs fall under the Commerce Clause.

Here's the ugly truth: People are objecting to a national ID because it's an easy-to-parrot talking point. The rational objections are on thin ground. (Basically, the downsides are already existing anyways, we're just not getting the upsides. Because ideological purity. Yes, I mean you, ACLU)

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by dboreham on Friday September 22, 2017 @11:04AM (#15312807)
The air travel system in the US is run by the Feds. They require identification documents from passengers. This creates a defacto need for a national ID, although at present the issue is being fudged by use of state-issued driver's licenses (which the Feds won't accept as usable in the case of several states).
Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by jononor on Friday September 22, 2017 @06:10AM (#15310660)
I have used my national ID for:

- Applying for university

- Managing my student loan

- Registering a company

- Delivering taxes

- Changing health provider options

All online (various different services). This is in Norway. Actually the electronic state ID systems supports multiple identity providers, I mostly use the one from my bank. Which them also covers all my banking needs.

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by walshemj on Friday September 22, 2017 @09:20AM (#15311881)
The UK manages well enough with out a national id (seen as to Gestapo).

And if the USA had national ID it would be used to harass BME citizens ala Sherif Joe

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by MarchHare on Friday September 22, 2017 @06:19AM (#15310728)
The same crowd also appear to be the ones worried about voter fraud, so they're consistency has limits.
Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by Spivak on Friday September 22, 2017 @10:08AM (#15312270)
You should at least present their argument charitably if you're going to call them hypocrites. They have no issues with state IDs which is what would be presented at the polls since you vote in your state's elections.

Look, when the ACLU is against national IDs you have to at least admit that the idea is worth discussing. https://www.aclu.org/other/5-problems-national-id-cards

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by groby_b on Friday September 22, 2017 @12:45PM (#15313740)
Uh, no. The ACLU has many merits, but no, their ideas are not implicitly worth discussing. They're also the ones in favor of Illinois Nazis.

They represent both the best (a strong belief in an ideal of humanity, and a fervent desire to make the world a fair and open place) and the worst (ideological purity über alles) of the left.

And I say that as a card-carrying ACLU member :)

Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by screature2 on Friday September 22, 2017 @01:45AM (#15309668)
absolutely agree. SSN started life as a unique identifier, that's how it should have remained. It's a pretty terrible super secret password.
Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem by tylersmith on Friday September 22, 2017 @02:49AM (#15309927)
It's unfortunate that asymmetric cryptography wasn't around when the SSN system was built.