Re:The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem
by groby_b on Friday September 22, 2017 @12:43PM
(#15313717)
We're in the process of figuring out composite keys don't work :)
And yes, State + State ID is a decent substitute for a national ID. Because it is a national ID. Except that some states will implement it in the shittiest way possible, and so we end up with even more of a lowest common denominator than if the states negotiated a standard.
And one could reasonably make the case that in this day and age, IDs fall under the Commerce Clause.
Here's the ugly truth: People are objecting to a national ID because it's an easy-to-parrot talking point. The rational objections are on thin ground. (Basically, the downsides are already existing anyways, we're just not getting the upsides. Because ideological purity. Yes, I mean you, ACLU)
With current technology there's no technical or practical (other than inertia) reason federal services couldn't use state IDs. There's only 50 states, not N states. A 50-case switch wouldn't be that bad. ID requirements between states aren't so disparate that you couldn't get a good enough mapping.
The biggest hurdle to ANY effective ID system for individual people is that ID is a composite key. There are many Joe Smiths in the US. There are many Joe Smiths in a state. There are probably a handful of Joe smiths with the same birth date. There are possibly multiple Joe Smiths born on the same day that look similar and share a zip code.
People don't have unique identifiers other than DNA and even then if you don't do a good job processing it you're not guaranteed accuracy and I don't think we're at a point where we trust any .gov with that level of info about us.
So far we've been able to squeak by with just using really ugly composite keys.