News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Get Rid of Equifax by newscracker on Thursday September 21, 2017 @10:03AM (#15303486)
> I never consented to have my information in their database,

Don't you think that somewhere in the T&Cs of a loan you took or a credit card that you got or a phone contract you signed up for (or many other things) are lines explaining that your information would be shared with credit reporting agencies? So legally, you would've consented to the sharing of information at those times. If that isn't true, then I'd assume that you should be able to sue the institution that shared your information with all these agencies.

Re:Get Rid of Equifax by yebyen on Thursday September 21, 2017 @10:14AM (#15303604)
You know the point I'm trying to make, and it's disingenuous to point at some line in some far-away terms and conditions, and say "that authorizes Equifax and two other companies to collect and maintain all information on you, in perpetuity, without any option to revoke this grant."

Are they licensed to do this type of work? Shouldn't they need to be? Should that be revokable? What is the process for revoking that permission, and can we get it started already? It just came out that in their response to the breach, they've been linking their "customers" to a phishing site since September 9. It's time to revoke those grants.

Re:Get Rid of Equifax by Frondo on Thursday September 21, 2017 @11:18AM (#15304281)
I know the point you're trying to make, and I'd say more to that point: we already recognize that you can't sign a contract that strips you of some basic human rights. You can't sign a contract that enslaves you, etc.

With the amount of power these organizations and this information has over each of us, individually, I'd go so far as to say there is a human rights issue at stake. People's lives get fucked up through credit bureau mistakes, and what consequence is there for those bureaux?

Pointing to a subclause in a contract to say "well, here's where you let them potentially fuck up your life with no recourse, and everything is legal" suggests to me that our thinking around the power these agencies, and around ownership of information about our lives, have needs revisiting.

Re:Get Rid of Equifax by Consultant32452 on Thursday September 21, 2017 @02:12PM (#15306032)
What's really at stake here? Your ability to take on debt, which primarily benefits the banks. The bigger problem I think we have here is the cavalier nature in which people view debt. Debt is bad for you. Rather than bringing going into debt under the umbrella of "basic human rights" how about a cultural shift away from debt altogether?
Re:Get Rid of Equifax by yebyen on Thursday September 21, 2017 @03:47PM (#15306747)
Now if we could just do something about those housing prices, that might even be possible. (What percent of homeowners do you suppose bought their homes without taking on some debt?)

Paying rent is also bad for you.

Re:Get Rid of Equifax by Consultant32452 on Thursday September 21, 2017 @06:34PM (#15307918)
Getting a home loan is relatively easier, because plenty of banks still do manual underwriting for things the size of mortgages. And if we had a culture that avoided unsecured debt, car debt, etc. then more banks would have to perform manual underwriting because no one would have a credit score. Instead they would have something better: money.
Re:Get Rid of Equifax by yebyen on Thursday September 21, 2017 @12:20PM (#15305006)
I hope that we can start having that conversation! Right now it seems unlikely.

It would not be so controversial if I claimed that Amazon grants customers a revokable license to audio and video content hosted on Prime, but my social security number and credit history evidently is not afforded as much protection under the law.

Re:Get Rid of Equifax by gglitch on Thursday September 21, 2017 @12:13PM (#15304925)
Not to mention that the terms in the contract do not cover all retention and usage policies of the data. The terms are vague.
Re:Get Rid of Equifax by newscracker on Thursday September 21, 2017 @02:23PM (#15306135)
I completely agree that there doesn't seem to be any kind of good oversight on the entities, what they do and how they do it. The entire process and chain of information sharing doesn't seem to be in the best interests of consumers.
Re:Get Rid of Equifax by rootlocus on Thursday September 21, 2017 @10:57AM (#15304054)
> it's disingenuous to point at some line in some far-away terms and conditions, and say "that authorizes Equifax and two other companies to collect and maintain all information on you, in perpetuity, without any option to revoke this grant."

To be fair, I'm pretty sure they can legally do that if this was actually the case.

Re:Get Rid of Equifax by yebyen on Thursday September 21, 2017 @11:08AM (#15304183)
It's a finer point, but if I have authorized Chase Bank to share data with a credit reporting agency, does that mean I have also authorized the credit reporting agency to retain that data? I don't think it does.

Absent any law that says exactly how they may and may not collect and retain such data, you're probably right that it is exactly what it means. The owners of the data (the banks) authorized them, so they are authorized to have the data.

It does not change the fact that, if true, the law is an ass. I do not grant power-of-attorney to the credit-holders that I do business with. They are not authorized to sign documents in my name. They should not be able to authorize arbitrary agencies to hold my personal data in an irrevocable fashion.

(And if I understand the difference in law between US and Europe, in Europe they would not be able to permanently retain my personal data without any recourse for me to shut it down. But in the US, they may be allowed to do this.)

Re:Get Rid of Equifax by rootlocus on Thursday September 21, 2017 @03:01PM (#15306393)
> It's a finer point, but if I have authorized Chase Bank to share data with a credit reporting agency, does that mean I have also authorized the credit reporting agency to retain that data? I don't think it does.

I think you're placing too many constraints on a hypothetical contract just to support your initial argument. Most likely the contract is carefully written in such a way that it's legal for them to do whatever they wanted to do with your data to begin with. It's pointless arguing over what ifs.

Re:Get Rid of Equifax by yebyen on Thursday September 21, 2017 @03:23PM (#15306557)
Only in America. They could not store personal information about us without obtaining permission in Europe, and we would have the right to revoke it for any reason as well.

This is not normal, it is dysfunctional. I'm not arguing that it's not legal, I'm arguing that they need to lose their license. (Never mind that no such licensing requirement exists. Like I said, it's a dysfunctional system, and I don't know why we don't have more than 3 credit reporting agencies. It sounds like a great gig!)

Re:Get Rid of Equifax by closeparen on Friday September 22, 2017 @05:09AM (#15310438)
>some far-away terms and conditions

Are you claiming that people don't know what credit reporting is when they sign loans? If so, that's a failure of basic financial education on the part of parents and K12. If someone imagines they have the right to delete the records of debts they don't want to pay, that person has been tragically misled about the fundamental nature of adulthood.

Knowing that lenders communicate with each other about your reputation, especially when you'd rather they wouldn't, is right up there with knowing what interest is.

Re:Get Rid of Equifax by yebyen on Friday September 22, 2017 @06:19AM (#15310729)
I'm claiming that we should have the right to tell one of the three credit reporting agencies to get bent and delete our file if they're Equifax in October of 2017. That's not the same thing as "delete the record of debts I don't want to pay." That's completely disingenuous of you to suggest that's what I meant.

There are three credit reporting agencies. Can you tell me why there aren't more? Because from everything I can tell, there is nothing short of purely criminal activity that could actually result in Equifax being required to go out of business. It seems that no amount of negligent behavior on their part can give me the right to say "cease and desist your retention of my record," while I've never so much as signed a document that came from Equifax. I have no direct relationship with them, and I have the right to get a restraining order if a malicious stalker is all up in my shit, so how is this situation any different? What makes them the authority? Because credit banks do business with them? That's nice... I want them out of business! In Europe, I would have this right. Nobody could maintain a file on me that I can't get a legal order for them to delete.

I'm not talking about debt holders. I'm talking about this parasitic company that evidently has no security team, or has chronically underfunded it to the point that we get where we are now, or had simply disregarded their advice umpteen times _after_ it became clear that the situation was very dire.

The struts vulnerability was disclosed months before they patched it. Any security researcher worth a dime could have told them it was a mistake to put up that equifaxsecurity2017 site that was literally (so much that their own Twitter account linked to it 9 times) indistinguishable from a phishing website and make the only way to know it was legit, a link from the front page of Equifax.com.

How did they get such a great gift from the law, if such is true then sign me up to be a credit reporting agency! I know how to build crappy websites and persist database records, it seems I meet all of the non-existent licencing requirements to be a CRA.

Re:Get Rid of Equifax by brango on Thursday September 21, 2017 @10:06AM (#15303508)
Oh yeah, so you do have a choice if you want to live in a cave.
Re:Get Rid of Equifax by dmoy on Thursday September 21, 2017 @10:16AM (#15303627)
What is a reasonable alternative to credit agencies? Most countries I know use similar (or sometimes the same, like the UK) agencies, though sometimes with a caveat that they only log defaults or other stuff you mess up.
Re:Get Rid of Equifax by yebyen on Thursday September 21, 2017 @10:20AM (#15303667)
The alternative is the two other credit agencies that haven't (as far as we know) given up all of our personal information to hackers, and who haven't responded to the news of the breach by linking some of their customers to a parody/phishing site that was nearly indistinguishable from their own (very bad) breach response website.

There is no way out of this (the cat is out of the bag) but we can go on about our lives without Equifax. They need to be unplugged.

Re:Get Rid of Equifax by dmoy on Thursday September 21, 2017 @10:31AM (#15303777)
Ok sure but all of your objections above (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15303289) can be applied to the other two agencies as well. They collect all your info also. I'm personally not super optimistic about their security.
Re:Get Rid of Equifax by yebyen on Thursday September 21, 2017 @10:34AM (#15303808)
Me either! That's absolutely a valid point. And I am terrified that this breach will ultimately result in the end of the credit system as we know it, but right now taking such a position is still scare-mongering. (Very reasonable scare mongering, mind you, but maybe cart before the horse.)

We can't just unplug all three agencies and shut down the credit industry, but why can't we shut down Equifax? Take the drivers' license and the car keys away from the drunk driver.

They are the ones that let the cat out of the bag, they should no longer be allowed to collect our personal information. There is no reasonable argument that can be made that Equifax in particular, should be allowed to go on making money off of our personal data with the negligent failure that they have created for us and admitted to, after what all has happened.

Edit: When Sonny Vleisides plead guilty to Felony Mail Fraud in 2007, he was forbidden to engage in loan programs, gambling or gaming activities, telemarketing activities, investment programs or any other business involving the solicitation of funds. He went on to found the company called Butterfly Labs in 2010, a company that took pre-orders for Bitcoin mining equipment (in many cases soliciting funds for hardware that didn't exist, until it did).

Many people argued that this model was a direct violation of the terms of his supervised release. He stood in front of a judge in 2014 that said there was a "strong smell" of fraud with respect to his company.

Equifax it seems gets to skip the whole "plead guilty" thing and just announced their negligent failure directly to the world. When does Equifax get their 14 months in jail followed by a supervised release? Never, apparently, they just go on about their business and no charges are filed. It's absolutely ridiculous in my humble opinion. Maybe I'm the one who is being unreasonable, expecting that the wheels of justice can turn more rapidly than one can reasonably expect.

It's not exactly parallel, I'm stretching to draw parallels obviously, but there should be some parallels in the arena of legal action here. Has anyone argued that Equifax wasn't negligent in the circumstances leading up to the breach? What about in their actions since then? How much further does it have to go before we can get the FTC or US Marshals involved and shut the place down?

Re:Get Rid of Equifax by dredmorbius on Thursday September 21, 2017 @11:02AM (#15304118)
"In at least 40 other countries — including Belgium, France, Germany, Italy and Spain — credit reporting can be done by a public credit registry. It is usually operated by a central bank that already oversees the financial institutions that feed information into the reports. These reports tend to be more accurate because the operators have a legal right to demand data from banks as well as a mandate to ensure it’s correct and that errors are fixed. Data on late payments and defaults are erased once a consumer has settled up."

From the article.

Re:Get Rid of Equifax by dmoy on Thursday September 21, 2017 @11:50AM (#15304648)
Right but surely a public credit registry would have the same risk of being hacked, no? At least in the US, we have government run data get hacked on a routine basis. That seemed to be G(G?)P's concern.

At the end of the day, whether it's a private or public credit agency, they're still collecting all your data whether you want them to or not (modulo going full Thoreau and removing yourself from the economy), and still could get hacked and have all that stolen.

Re:Get Rid of Equifax by scott_s on Thursday September 21, 2017 @01:21PM (#15305591)
> Right but surely a public credit registry would have the same risk of being hacked, no?

No, I disagree. A public agency would have the same value as a target. But its incentives would be better aligned (no profit motive), which could result in better practices and less actual risk.