News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by frgtpsswrdlame on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @02:26PM (#15296779)
I'm kind of split on our current gray area about free speech on the web. It seems like the only way to do good moderation is if it's powered by actual people sitting behind computers and following a well-written policy. But tech companies have proven themselves totally unwilling to pay for that. I'd rather FB just said "we'll never pony up the wages necessary to moderate well so we're just going to make facebook a complete free speech zone."
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by tdb7893 on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:07PM (#15297161)
This seems like a classic catch 22. If they go completely free speech people will complain about all the propaganda on Facebook and some countries will just block it. On the other hand if they do moderation people complain about censorship. There is no actual way for them to win here
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by pjc50 on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:17PM (#15297242)
If they go completely free speech then nobody will be able to read anything over all the spam, and the servers will be confiscated for possession of child porn in a few days.
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by watty on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @04:09PM (#15297744)
I think it's safe to assume that they mean free "legal" speech.
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by pjc50 on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @04:18PM (#15297833)
I'm not sure, a lot of people seem to want speech free beyond even American norms. And "legal where?" is an important question.
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by snakeanus on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @04:11PM (#15297760)
Which is why federated solutions like GNUSocial, NNTP or email win here as moderation can be applied per-node.
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by syrrim on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @04:58PM (#15298174)
Facebook could do the same thing if they wanted. Have the default be heavily censored, have option to disable aspects of it as the user desires. I presume they don't because they don't consider it a catch 22. Having people cry censorship doesn't matter to them, whereas they think hordes would leave or be forced off by governments if they didn't moderate sufficiently.
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by fleitz on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @04:03PM (#15297688)
There's lots of ways for them to win. For the most part people just complain, it's a couple cycles of bad PR and then a very large segment of the internet goes back to enjoying the walled garden.
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by rhizome on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:24PM (#15297309)
They're already doing moderation, though: Rohingya media gets blocked, white-supremacy media is allowed.
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by timthelion on Thursday September 21, 2017 @04:33AM (#15301533)
It has gotten to the point where an American anarchist writing that they want to travel to Yemen to fight imperialism is considered a terrorist and censored, but a white supremacist person saying we should "shoot all those monkeys in St. Lewis" is considered sacred free speech.
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by shallot_router on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:16PM (#15297232)
Yep. People complain about the "adpocalypse" and censorship from YouTube and Facebook, but they're really stuck between a rock and a hard place.

That said, I think they should always err on the side of free speech wherever possible.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by musage on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @04:06PM (#15297713)
We already have the complaints about censorship. What we don't have is sensible moderation.
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by NeutronBoy on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @02:34PM (#15296875)
> I'd rather FB just said "we'll never pony up the wages necessary to moderate well so we're just going to make facebook a complete free speech zone."

They were literally doing this! Then they got slammed for 'censorship', so they got rid of the moderators. Now they're in the position they are now.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by slamdance on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @02:37PM (#15296901)
why are you "split" on having a "complete free speech zone"?
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by frgtpsswrdlame on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @04:07PM (#15297731)
Because I find I prefer the places on the web which pay for good moderation to the places on the web which are complete free speech zones (or as close as they can legally be.)
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by jackmott on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @02:49PM (#15296996)
because so many people are horrible
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by 3131s on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @04:27PM (#15297911)
Censoring them doesn't make them go away. It only removes any hope of turning them into not-horrible people, and in the process many controversial but worthwhile ideas are filtered out.

I think individuals should have the tools to disengage from trolls, harassment, spam, etc. (even if it's a catch-all "block everyone that my extended network has blocked" checkbox, or something similar) but I personally want the option to see the dregs of humanity and actively engage with those people.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by FooHentai on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @08:59PM (#15299749)
The pollution analogy might be useful. Specifically: "The solution to pollution is dilution".

Now, that mantra has been mostly rejected for environmental pollution because there's a far better option: Gather the pollutants, process/eliminate them, and work to eliminate the sources.

Back in our context, hopefully the elimination of people with unsavoury viewpoints is not on the table. We must fundamentally agree that humans being what they are, free thought being what it is, these ideas will never be 'gone'. So accepting that, perhaps "the solution to pollution is dilution" applies.

Apply it and we quickly see how censorship will be counter-productive - Those people, viewpoints and opinions don't go away and instead they concentrate in localized 'hot spots' (or cesspools), where they actually do far more intense and immediate damage. Obvious example: 4chan/8ch. Less obvious example: People's minds.

By avoiding chasing these things into the shadows they remain open to challenge. While the mind of the person you're challenging might not be changed, when its out in the open all others that come past and read that interaction get to judge it on it's merits and make their own judgement call.

Without that, folks end up in echo chambers. When newcomers get to those places, they are not exposed to a balance of viewpoints and the opinions they themselves form will tend to conform to the leanings of the echo chamber where they spend their time.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by yongjik on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @09:12PM (#15299812)
> Apply it and we quickly see how censorship will be counter-productive - Those people, viewpoints and opinions don't go away and instead they concentrate in localized 'hot spots' (or cesspools), where they actually do far more intense and immediate damage.

This is an often-repeated theory, but I'm not sure it actually works that way. For example, consider the recent discussion about Reddit's "censorship" of hate subs:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15220305

When you openly engage some people, they decide that their idea is now "normal" and then demand the rest of the society to accommodate them. There's a reason why most scientists refrain from debating creationists.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by otakucode on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:01PM (#15297104)
That would be a problem if it wasn't trivially easy to block them. Otherwise, people being horrible really isn't your problem unless you train yourself to be very conscious of their opinions and to care deeply about them. That's the only way their opinion can get to you. Of course, that training doesn't have to be conscious and a great many people have inadvertently trained themselves to be sensitive to the opinions of horrible people... but no one in the universe can do anything about that except the people themselves. (And no this doesn't remove blame from those hurling insults. I'm talking about how to deal with it yourself. If you're worried about how it reflects on them, and wanting to assign blame, you're still in the wrong mindset. You can control only yourself. Even if you were able to control others, it would make you a horrendously bad person to do so.)
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by ch4s3 on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:10PM (#15297184)
>Otherwise, people being horrible really isn't your problem unless you train yourself to be very conscious of their opinions and to care deeply about them.

I don't buy this. If an internet forum like FaceBook, Twitter, Reddit, or whatever allows increasingly toxic behavior it eventually spills into the real world. For example, unmoderated forums facilitate doxing and incitement. What happens when an online harasser posts someone's home address, work address, and childrens' schools online with a call to real world violence? Should the victim just not care? What if online trolls set about smearing your professional or personal reputation? What if they decide to out you as gay to your parents or in a country where being gay is illegal?

And don't tell me you can simply avoid going online, that isn't practical. Its precisely places like Facebook, Reddit, Twitter, etc where marginalized people can find a supportive community. Also the internet should be for everyone, not just the most horrible, hard, and callous among us.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by otakucode on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @06:22PM (#15298867)
Are we talking about online comments, or real-world harrassment? They are two different topics.
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by ch4s3 on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @11:00PM (#15300277)
I'm talking about three things here, online harassment, how that activity can bleed into the real world, and how it's hard to tell when the second thing is beginning to happen. When does harassment slip into incitement for example? When does brigading by trolls shut down the online spaces of marginalized groups and make them less safe in real life for lack of a digital space to organize? Doxing again, is online harassment that may have nasty effects in the physical world, as does outing people based on their hidden minority status e.g. sexual orientation.

Online and real world harassment aren't two different things is more or less my conclusion. They are different vectors for similar anti-social behavior.

Would you defend someone following another person around every public space they visit screaming in their face as free speech and say the victim should toughen up? I doubt you would, and in fact it probably constitutes several crimes depending upon where you live. You could probably get a restraining order. Blocking online works similarly, but you have to do it site by site, alias by alias which doesn't scale. However, many of the tactics that trolls use scale rather well. So I think platforms have some responsibility here.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by yorwba on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:12PM (#15297196)
Each individual sock-puppet may be easy to block, but in aggregate they can overwhelm any attempts to constrain them individually. If you instead employ a whitelist, you miss out on conversations with people who tried to contact you but couldn't get through because you had no way to distinguish them from trolls.

Offloading contact curation on each individual user doesn't solve the fundamental problem of identifying malicious users, it shoves it where someone else has to deal with it.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by wmf on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:07PM (#15297160)
If you get hit by thousands of trolls at once it's not trivial to block them. Also, in some cases other people see the trolling about you even after you block it.
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by Karunamon on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:13PM (#15297213)
I find that "thousands of trolls" generally amounts to "thousands of members of the public who responded to the statement I shouted out into public". The character of those responses doesn't even enter into it.

Don't get me wrong, I see why it's a pain in the ass to wind up with a popular comment even if the comments are mostly positive (and especially if they're not not), but I think this is better handled by UI and rate limiting on notifications rather than the alternatives.

>in some cases other people see the trolling about you even after you block it.

Pardon my arrogance, but I don't believe it's your place to determine how other people are allowed to talk about you even if you've excused yourself from the conversation. Down that path lay dragons. For a quick example why, sub out "you" and "your" in the previous sentence for the name of any unpopular politician.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by pjc50 on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:19PM (#15297259)
> It's not your place to determine how other people are allowed to talk about you even if you've excused yourself from the conversation

Even if they're discussing whether you should be murdered?

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by Karunamon on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:21PM (#15297283)
Was the reduction to the extreme really necessary? But okay, in that particular case, we have the ToS and laws regarding threatening behavior to fall back on. (And if I've unsubscribed from the conversation, I can't even see it anymore to be threatened by it)

This problem does not require the extreme step of giving the subject of a conversation an unconditional veto on the conversation.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by pjc50 on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:27PM (#15297349)
> Was the reduction to the extreme really necessary?

Well, we started with discussion of genocide at the top of the thread, so it's kind of in context.

> giving the subject of a conversation an unconditional veto on the conversation.

Isn't this the other extreme?

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by Karunamon on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:29PM (#15297366)
I may have misinterpreted your original comment. You said:

Also, in some cases other people see the trolling about you even after you block it.

..which implies it's a negative that you don't have control over the (valueJudgmentOf: comments) about you after you've blocked the conversation. Was this incorrect?

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by pjc50 on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:43PM (#15297496)
Yes, but that's not the same as unconditional veto. This is basically the situation where you'd want to appeal to a third party human.
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by Karunamon on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @04:32PM (#15297951)
That's basically what we have now but with an extra step added.
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by synicalx on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @08:49PM (#15299697)
In a lot of places, that would be illegal.
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by synicalx on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @08:48PM (#15299688)
Genuine question here, unless you're some sort of controversial public figure, how would you wind up attracting the attention of thousands of trolls?
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by wmf on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @09:52PM (#15299984)
It just takes one troll leader to single you out for harassment. Usually they attack famous people but not always.
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by otakucode on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @06:22PM (#15298873)
That is a technology problem. We could easily solve it and probably should.
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by PhasmaFelis on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:24PM (#15297306)
> Otherwise, people being horrible really isn't your problem unless you train yourself to be very conscious of their opinions and to care deeply about them.

Humans are social animals. We care about what others think by default. Maybe you're an outlier, that's nice for you, but please don't think your experience is normal.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by otakucode on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @06:27PM (#15298907)
That is true, and it is a problem that each and every single human being has had to deal with since the beginning of time. It was worse in the past, actually, because the people saying mean things to you were right there and could actually DO things to you in addition to simply espousing ideas or opinions you found offensive! That's why people always taught children to respond with "sticks and stones will break my bones, but names will never hurt me."

That's not an absolution of bullies, and people who interpret it that way are morons. It's a mantra. It is to teach a child that THEY have the control over whether those words hurt them, not the person saying them. By default, yes, we have mirror neurons and we are profoundly social. It evolved to perfectly fit our society of nomads travelling in tribes across a plentiful landscape, where anyone deigning to take control of others would simply be left behind as the tribe walks over the next hill. Wait, we don't LIVE in that type of society any longer. Which makes those evolutionary traits sub-optimal at best and downright dangerous at worst. I'd go with dangerous given the negative impact of cortisol and other stress hormones. Keeping them in check is a burden the modern world puts on us all.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by pjc50 on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:09PM (#15297176)
No, if people are going to try to push goatse or other shock images into my field of vision then I'm going to assign blame to them.
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by watwut on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:17PM (#15297247)
People by default care about what others think. It starts before kindergarten and is normal human psychology. No training is necessary of that.

Neverthess, thinking the issue is just about insults is naive. The actual uncensored (especially anonymous) forum means hardcore bdsm porn posted for fun in the discussion about gardening or child raising. Or very disgusting pic of vivisection of animal. Or calls for another holocaust along with floorplan of your house.

It also means most 'normal' people leave elsewhere due to above. Cause most people dont need above in their lives.

Moreover, insults have meaning and it matters. If you ignore them, you are more likely to become target of bullying or mobbing. Because people parrot what they see and the more you allow it, the more people join on that to look like members of stringet group - to get popular. Or they simply feel it is socially ok.

In the work, it affects your ability to push for ideas, to get leadership position, to get raise, to be trusted and given a bit more autonomy. All of that matters.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by eighthnate on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @09:24PM (#15299862)
There are so many horrible people, so you want these horrible people to be moderators?

If there are so many horrible people, wouldn't you be against censorship and moderation?

[dead]
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by Pulcinella on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:51PM (#15297576)
“and yes, it may interrupt your viewing/reading/research,...”

My eyeballs are not a “free speech zone.” No one has any right to show me whatever they want.

Also, while I am not vegan, I would not describe vegans as horrible people on the level of bigots and nazis.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by nnfy on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:58PM (#15297639)
>No one has any right to show me whatever they want. Sure, but you have no right to look my way and then complain that I'm forcing you to view something you consider offensive, in case that's what you're insinuating.
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by xtreme on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @04:45PM (#15298058)
You can close your eyes. Or cover your ears. Or close your browser tab.
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by pjc50 on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @04:21PM (#15297850)
>you know what sites are legit

Yes, the ones with moderators.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by yahna on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @04:21PM (#15297852)
> is that a reason to strip them of their ability to express their ideas?

Yes. They can go do their shit somewhere.

> Take for example some of the worst - Vegan Cross-fitters.

Because we are talking about annoying people and not those who advocate for genocide.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by jonathankoren on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @02:57PM (#15297077)
Greater Internet Fuckwad Theory.[0]

This experiment has been repeatedly played out over decades. Without moderation, it always degenerates into shitposting trolls.

[0] https://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2004/03/19

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by NTDF9 on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @02:40PM (#15296926)
Censorship is one of those really hard social problems. A completely open web will be inundated with spam, pornography and propaganda. A completely gated web will only serve the gatekeepers.

What really solves the problem is a 3rd party gatekeeper composed of "Council of Wise People".(henceforth referred to as gatekeepers). Movie rating board is an example.

This leads to the age old question, "Who will monitor the gatekeepers?"

This leads to democracy, where the gatekeepers only have a 4 year period and new gatekeepers are elected again.

The government should have been the gatekeepers. But turns out, these gatekeepers care more about their own pockets (filled by the same corps they are gatekeeping).

Humans suck :P

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by dogma1138 on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:05PM (#15297139)
The web is now filled with spam, porn and propaganda...

The problem here is that Facebook seems to be choosing sides.

It worth noting that this might be propaganda to begin with and many of those so called "activists" posts could likely be violating TOS at the least if not actual laws.

What is going on in Burma is terrible but there has been a lot of violence from all factions the Buddhists didn't woke up one day and decided to commit genocide.

Like many current conflicts these aren't black and white and the only truth is that people are dying.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by ch4s3 on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:23PM (#15297302)
>What is going on in Burma is terrible but there has been a lot of violence from all factions the Buddhists didn't woke up one day and decided to commit genocide. Like many current conflicts these aren't black and white and the only truth is that people are dying.

This is a pretty ridiculous reading of events in Myanmar. Rakhine buddhists with the help of the military and police have been persecuting Rohingya since as far back as the end of WWII (the Rakhine and Rohingya fought on opposite sides). More recently since the junta took control in 1962 the Rohingya have been denied citizenship and harassed constantly by the junta. The Rohingya in the past 20 years have begun to push back and formed armed defense groups branded by the government as terrorists. Things came to a head in 2012 (after the 2011 transition to "democracy" began) when the government incited sectarian riots in Rakhine state. The government blamed the Rohingya and began driving them out of their villages in recent years to "fight terrorism". Some Rakhine buddhists have used this as an opportunity to burn those villages and attack fleeing Rohingya.

Yes there are armed Rohingya groups, but they were trapped between an encroaching military and until this year a border with Bangladesh they couldn't cross. The government and Rakhine are absolutely, unquestionably committing genocide. Basically everyone in the world other than the Burmese government and you agrees with this designation.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by kokyawshan on Thursday September 21, 2017 @09:15PM (#15308702)
I live in Myanmar. A regular HN reader and a non-believer. I have never written comments, but there is so much misinformation going on regarding the current crisis. The recent major terror by Islamist group (ARSA) attacks on thirty police outposts left a dozen police dead and a government office and a Buddhist monastery burnt. That was not the first time that happened but the biggest and deadliest we know of in the recent memory. All ethnic groups had to flee, including Rakhine Buddhists, Hindu, Myo, Thet, and Dinet. Very few knew. The international media seems to have slept through that episode and woke up when some Rohingya villages start fleeing once the army arrived to track down the villages where terrorists were sheltered. How many terrorists do you think are needed to attack 30 police outposts at the same time? One instance a Rakhine village was surrounded by hundreds of angry Islamists. Another instance, it is a Hindu village that was brutally attacked.

Video links for the voices of the victims ignored in the media. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yQf4DxgowbY&list=UUBwU9jzFLZ... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4jB8K0pVAe8&list=UUBwU9jzFLZ...

My parents used to live in the conflict zone. I have been to the region several times. Tensions can be traced back over decades, but there was sectarian violence between Rohingya and Rakhine. Many of the times, the conflict started with initiating attacks by Islamist terrorists in the community. There were major attacks in 2012, 2014, 2015, 2016 and 2017. The affairs are far from one-sided bullying. That genocide claim is a stretch by a thousand miles. Two of my relatives, Buddhist Rakhines, who used to live there until a month ago, had to run and fled home due to the increasing threats of militant Islamist groups, and they do not ever want to go back the area. The other side of the story was never been heard in the media.

One blatant lie is that of majority Buddhist persecuting the minority Muslims. I wonder if those journalists writing about the issue ever step a foot on the region. There is too much propaganda going on out there. I cannot believe what is going on. What you have to understand is that a conflict is happening in a remote and very isolated land even from other areas in Rakhine State, Myanmar. The sole mode of transportation is by river boats. The population of Rohingya Muslims outnumbers the combined population of Rakhine Buddhists, Hindu, and other ethnic groups by the ratio of six to one. Rakhine Buddhists were the majority in the region half a decade ago. Muslim population tripled since the 1980s. Islamist terror attacks have been more and more frequent.

I am not here to downplay the plight of Rohingya, but framing the complex issue into a simplistic version to drive an agenda and demonizing the other side is evil. I am in the camp of giving citizenship to people who have legitimately lived there for generations. Leader Aung San Su Kyi has been working along with UN to draft guideline for citizenship and resolve this issue. Everyone is suffering. The rise of know-nothing activists, ivory tower commenters, and increasing radicalization in the region have made life very difficult for everyone in the region. The bottom line is that it is not one-sided bullying and people who have been to the region and studied the issue are very much aware of it.

I have never been more disappointed in the integrity of the news media. If you want to learn nuanced and balanced analysis from an outsider who had actually been there and studied the issue, I recommend this article by Jasmine Chia, a Harvard student who did research in Rakhine State. http://thediplomat.com/2016/03/the-truth-about-myanmars-rohi...

How about the interview with a US diplomat who used to work in Burma. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g1MoehFI3io

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by hd4 on Friday September 22, 2017 @02:25AM (#15309829)
>wonder if those journalists writing about the issue ever step a foot on the region.

How about your country starts by letting in international observers to witness exactly what is happening? From all accounts they are being prevented by the Myanmar government from doing so. When you prevent this, you look as if you have something to cover up after all.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by ch4s3 on Friday September 22, 2017 @02:34PM (#15314587)
Let me start by saying that I've had a keen interest in Myanmar for years. I've opposed sanctions and supported open dialogue and normalization of relations. I don't mean to impugn average people of any ethnic, religious, or social group in the country. My criticism is focused on the government and a narrow complicit minority of people in Rakhine State. I also don't mean to downplay the role that ARSA has played in fanning flames in sectarian conflict.

> but there is so much misinformation going on regarding the current crisis.

If it's misinformation, let international observers in to see what's happening. Moreover, are the Rohingya women and children fleeing into Bangladesh with bullet entrance wounds in the backs of their arms and legs misinformation? They got shot by someone, and they say it was the army. Shooting fleeing women and children is very indicative of something like a genocide.

>What you have to understand is that a conflict is happening in a remote and very isolated land even from other areas in Rakhine State, Myanmar

Yes, we've seen maps. Not everyone in the West is totally ignorant of geography.

>One blatant lie is that of majority Buddhist persecuting the minority Muslims.

I didn't say that, and neither does the UN or any news outlet I read. I'd argue that the government is persecuting the Rohingya and some local Rakhine Buddhists appear from numerous reports to be complicit. Self identified Rakhine found at the sites of burning Rohingya villages has been confirmed by the BBC.

>The population of Rohingya Muslims outnumbers the combined population of Rakhine Buddhists, Hindu, and other ethnic groups by the ratio of six to one. Rakhine Buddhists were the majority in the region half a decade ago. Muslim population tripled since the 1980s. Islamist terror attacks have been more and more frequent.

I'm not sure A is necessary and sufficient to prove or lead to B in your argument. As seen elsewhere in the world Muslim population doesn't even correlate with terrorist attack frequency.

> Aung San Su Kyi has been working along with UN to draft guideline for citizenship

Which appears to be bullshit, because it requires documents that displaced Rohingya were long denied, and wouldn't have access to in the event that they fled across the border.

To quote the article you linked: "It is clear that anti-Muslim propaganda has become part of regular nationalist discourse", which is sort of the crux of my criticism. The government leverages anti-muslim propaganda to legitimize the persecution of the Muslim population.

*EDIT: Also, that you for adding your perspective to the discussion. It is rare in the rest of the world to hear perspectives from ordinary people in your country. I hope I haven't come across as too harsh, or combative. I do fundamentally agree that it is a messy complicated situation that is too often painted as a simplistic narrative.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by kokyawshan on Saturday September 23, 2017 @02:55AM (#15318538)
Thank you for your point-to-point rebuttals. That is what I like about HN.

I did not mean to personally accuse you of lying when I wrote the sentence. I meant to point out what many major media (BBC, Guardian, CNN) are insinuating. I apologize that I came across that way. >One blatant lie is that of majority Buddhist persecuting the minority Muslims.

Also, I am not implying that population of Muslim correlates with the frequency of terror generally everywhere in the world. All I am pointing out is what is happening in troubled Maung Daw region. I am not in the camp that attacks Islam as a whole and formulates a general theory. The issue is more complicated than a simplistic correlation.

I disagree with your following statement. >The government leverages anti-Muslim propaganda to legitimize the persecution of the Muslim population.

There are many Muslims in the other regions of Myanmar. Even in Rakhine state, there is another minority Muslim group, Ka-Mann, in the middle of the state. Ka-Man Muslims were recognized as an ethnic group by the government, and there was no alleged religious persecution of Ka-Man. If you visit Yangon, the biggest city in the country, you will see that there are several Mosques in downtown, and there are a lot of Muslim communities that are peacefully coexisting with Buddhists, Christians, and Hindu for a very long time. Unlike what media is portraying, the extremist monks, like U Wiyathu who was on the cover of Time magazine as Burmese Bin Laden, are unpopular in the country. This Rohingya issue is being mischaracterized by the media. Those in agenda-driven media who are framing this as one are fanning the flames. There are unverified accusations dumped on Rakhine Buddhists and the army who we do not support. We all are hoping unbiased international investigators to dig the truth out.

I agree 100% with you in letting international journalists and observers in and let them investigate and report without hindrance. That is what many people, including me, have been asking for years. There are several journalists from BBC, NYTimes, and some major news organization in the region. I do though want to point out one thing that many people in the region and the country as a whole are very distrustful of international media. There is resentment among Native Rakhine, and they feel that they have been framed and unfairly demonized for a particular agenda or narrative by these major news organizations. I am one of those people very much bothered by the narratives and very selective coverage of BBC and Guardian. I am all for welcoming international journalists and observers from all political spectrum and ideologies. People can have biases, but they need to be open about it.

I am ignorant of many things in the world. I just happen to know a bit about this particular issue since my grandparents, Rakhine Buddhists, lived their entire lives in the troubled region, and I happened to hear a lot of brutal heartbreaking stories from the other side ignored in the media. It is just a very odd moment in life when you became very cynical about everything in the media. I do not want to live my life that way.

I am aware of my background and bias. All I want to do is to point out that there are a lot more to the story than a very simplistic version painted in the media, just as you mentioned.

Thank you for your engagement. I appreciate your input.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by ch4s3 on Saturday September 23, 2017 @10:48AM (#15319974)
That's very interesting. I'll have to do a bit more critical reading on the subject, it seems even messier than I believed.

Again, thanks for sharing your unique and illuminating perspective.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by zhemao on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @04:21PM (#15297855)
> the Buddhists didn't woke up one day and decided to commit genocide

Germans didn't wake up one day in the 1930s and decide to exterminate the Jews either. That doesn't mean the Jews were at all to blame for their persecution.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by NTDF9 on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:15PM (#15297225)
>> The problem here is that Facebook seems to be choosing sides.

There is ALWAYS choosing sides. When FB decides to block pornography, they are choosing a side. When FB decides to mark some posts as spam, they are choosing a side.

Could they have a platform with ZERO choosing of sides? Technically, yes!

But, do you know what that would look like? My guess is more and more spam posts.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by Karunamon on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @04:31PM (#15297938)
Moderate the 'spam' per-user rather than globally. The main problem that I and most other users have with the anti-free-speech practices is bad categorization. Give users the tools to moderate their own experience (with defaults, so long as they can be disabled, and heck, disable the ability to change them in more repressive countries) and you basically have the problem solved.

I don't want these companies making the "disappear this" judgment calls anymore. They've shown that making those calls dispassionately and objectively isn't all that important to them.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by zeveb on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:16PM (#15297233)
Well, there's also the problem that it's very difficult to change your 3rd party gatekeeper to one you trust & agree with, and the gatekeeper function is tied up with a lot of unrelated stuff (maybe I like the policing of Dallas, Tx. but the community standards of New York City, the firearms law of Vermont, the health care of Canada, the food policy of France & the speed limits of Germany — there's no way to get all that in one bundle).
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by snakeanus on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @04:16PM (#15297806)
> A completely open web will be inundated with spam, pornography and propaganda

I doubt that. In fact, from my experience in a "completely open" I would say that this is false.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by yahna on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @04:23PM (#15297867)
You create 2 sets of gatekeepers who have the job of not only gatekeeping, but also taking the other group of gatekeepers down.

Keep both honest.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by NTDF9 on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @06:30PM (#15298934)
You mean like Republicans vs Democrats?
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by otakucode on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:04PM (#15297127)
Why is it you are alive? I mean, it would be trivially easy for anyone to kill you. You have to work to keep yourself alive. Some random person walking up to you on the street and pushing a little blade into your neck is all it would take to end you. Or start your house on fire while you're asleep. Or a million other things.

But... you're alive. Laws don't stop crime, they can only punish it afterwards. Deterrence doesn't work, there are still plenty of crimes under even the most capricious regimes that hand out death penalties for the slightest infractions. So why are you alive?

Because no one is willing to kill you. They're able. They're ALL able. Every single person, young or old, you have ever met or walked past could have killed you. Every last one of them was able. But not one has been willing. Humans aren't as bad as you might be tempted to think.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by pjc50 on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:15PM (#15297228)
The force multiplier arithmetic of the internet changes this. Almost all people are fine, but some are not. It was only last week that we had some idiots put another bomb on a tube train, for example. On the internet, if you can attack once you can attack everywhere. If you could put a bomb on every train at once with ctrl-c ctrl-v, we'd probably all be dead.

America has a mass shooting every week. If the real world was as reprisal-free as the internet, and people could just keep shooting, how many casualties would there be?

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by otakucode on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @06:20PM (#15298845)
Don't use the word 'force' when no force is involved. On the Internet, if you "attack", you send words or pictures. You send ideas. A bomb blows people apart. You do not have to, either intentionally or accidentally, train yourself to respond negatively to a bomb. A bomb blows you apart no matter who you are. An idea does not. Only you can control how you react to any given idea.

And I don't think it's likely that if everyone could cause indiscriminant destruction it would be likely to occur because that is already the case and has been for a very long while. Killing people is NOT hard. Just look at what people do with a car when they want. How many cars are there? How many angry, desperate people with access to them? And how common is it for them to drive it into a crowd and kill and injure people? Run the numbers. You're more likely to die from being hit by a meteor, so concern yourself with that instead.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by abiox on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @07:30PM (#15299295)
> Only you can control how you react to any given idea.

this is a bit simplistic. receiving information is a physiological process and not purely a cold and analytical affair. that's why a particularly vicious insult can drive some into a fit of violent irrational rage.

> And how common is it for them to drive it into a crowd and kill and injure people? Run the numbers. You're more likely to die from being hit by a meteor, so concern yourself with that instead.

there is a tremendous amount security work that contributes to this. many billions of dollars (possibly into the trillions, worldwide). a lot of dissuading machinery in legal and social systems.

however you quantify them, the dangers people face are not a simple consequence of unwilling perpetrators.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by graphitezepp on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:32PM (#15297407)
I'm down with the whole "lets be optimistic and say humans are good" mindset, and of course MOST people are not interested in causing serious harm to there peers. But the mere fact that someone hasn't put themselves at extreme risk to kill you isn't very convincing in the face of societies large scale corruption. Humans, at least when it comes to producing sustainable organizations that behave altruistically, indeed suck.
Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by otakucode on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @07:24PM (#15299260)
What extreme risk? I mean, I'm a skinny weakling. I've pretty much always been a skinny weakling. I've had threats, but always been able to talk my way out of things. I don't really base my personal view so much on the fact I've never been in a fight, or that I live in the world with the lowest incidence of violent crime since the advent of agriculture or any of those sorts of things. I base it on neuroscience. We're built to NOT hurt people. We have to be pushed pretty far to be made to hurt people, and even then we usually can't go through with it. Mirror neurons work. They reflect what you do to others on yourself, and it doesn't feel good at all. If you're trained to kill on reflex, as soldiers are, and your body goes ahead and does it before your conscious mind can catch up... once it does, that causes a neurological cataclysm that manifests as PTSD and can take years to recover from.

The 'producing sustainable organizations' changes the topic completely. Human beings, as individuals, are absolutely and fundamentally different from human beings as a group. America went to war with Vietnam in the 1960s. That is a true statement. Even though there were tons of protestors who had no desire to fight Vietnam. Talking about groups and about people as individuals is starkly and completely different. People in groups can be easily driven by 'mob mentality', especially if they have been trained to be especially susceptible to this by things like team-based competitive sports in their formative years. Acting in a group 'disables' a great deal of a persons individual moral code. The same is true of people in a position of subservience. "I was just following orders" makes sense to the person pulling the trigger because they earnestly feel no moral responsibility for their actions - it's how they protect themselves. It's a dangerous defense that needs to be consciously acknowledged and resisted by all people. Failure to do so makes people very dangerous. And it is not an easy thing to do at all.

Organizations also pretty much always form to facilitate some form of control. And control is poison. It is inherently harmful, regardless of either the aim, intention, or end result of it. It is also, I think, cumulative. There's no one law that turns a country into an oppressive regime, it's an accumulation. And it doesn't matter if every single one of the restrictions is "for your own good". Unless the 'good' produced by the restriction outweighs the cumulative damage it does by inflicting the control upon each individual in the society, it is overall harmful. People often ask ridiculous questions like "Why should X be legal?" which pre-supposes that everything ought to be illegal unless there is a 'good reason' to permit it. They ask "Why should you be allowed to X?" as if every action a person takes needs to be justified as beneficial in some meaningful way. It's a very dangerous mindset that has undone many societies in the past. And control poisons not just the people being controlled, but those dishing it out as well. I'm uncertain whether their damage is greater than the damage to those controlled or not. As far as I know it's not been studied and that sort of thing would be hard to quantify. I mean, prison guards are killing themselves in massive numbers and always have for a reason, obviously, but the prisoners are tattooing themselves, joining gangs, and fighting as well, so which is having more harm inflicted? They're both responding in pretty extreme ways (ways identical to how people in oppressive nations, in oppressive cults, in high-control prisons everywhere, and increasingly in American high schools respond).

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by abiox on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @07:21PM (#15299238)
> Laws don't stop crime (..)

is this statement based on some kind of study?

> Deterrence doesn't work, there are still plenty of crimes (..)

not terribly convincing... 'crimes happen' doesn't seem to sufficiently demonstrate that 'deterrence doesn't work'.

> Humans aren't as bad as you might be tempted to think

some aren't. some are much, much worse.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by otakucode on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @07:28PM (#15299288)
>is this statement based on some kind of study?

It's based on the law. They punish crimes after they have been committed. Where is the law that doesn't say "if you murder, you go to jail" but instead sets things up so you physically can not murder?

>not terribly convincing... 'crimes happen' doesn't seem to sufficiently demonstrate that 'deterrence doesn't work

Yeah, the part you cut out is the important bit. Sure you could argue 'oh well people are willing to steal a pair of shoes because they only get punished with 3 days in jail so they make a value judgement' if that's what we were talking about. But it's not. I pointed out the case of extreme punishment, death, not even THAT being capable of preventing the simple stupid crimes like stealing a pair of shoes.

>some aren't. some are much, much worse.

'Some' are individuals. I was speaking of humans overall. They're two very different things. Individually humans are impossible to predict, in groups they're among the most predictable things around. 'America went to war with Vietnam in the 60s' is not false simply because there were a bunch of protestors that opposed it. A statement about a group is not a statement about all of the individuals within it, and language would be incapable of functioning if that was the standard you attempted to apply.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by abiox on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @07:38PM (#15299337)
> Where is the law that doesn't say "if you murder, you go to jail" but instead sets things up so you physically can not murder?

is the only way to prevent murder a physical impediment?

does talking an attacker out of their plans count as preventing a murder?

> I pointed out the case of extreme punishment, death, not even THAT being capable of preventing the simple stupid crimes like stealing a pair of shoes.

again, you seem to be suggesting that 'deterrence doesn't real' because crime still exists. it seems you're presenting deterrence as an all-or-nothing dichotomy.

> 'Some' are individuals. I was speaking of humans overall.

indeed, and that's the point. pointing to a vague generalization about humans doesn't keep your kids safe.

Re:Facebook is 'silencing' Rohingya Muslim reports of 'ethni... by NTDF9 on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @03:11PM (#15297191)
Killing other humans. It's not necessary in an abundant society. In a mismanaged/unequal/resource crunched society, like Somalia, it happens routinely.

You give far too much credit to humans following the rule of law. There's a fine balance between humans using their abilities for their own desires.