News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A decade after the crisis, The Fed plans to shrink its bo... by joe_the_user on Monday September 18, 2017 @11:11PM (#15281504)
It doesn't matter if the Fed makes a profit. The Fed can print money - the Fed's job is stabilizing the market and the economy, not making money (which it can literally do at a touch of a button).

And as a note, the Fed has stabilized markets very well for the last eight years - at the price of speculative distortions to the real economy.

Re:A decade after the crisis, The Fed plans to shrink its bo... by wallace_f on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @12:49AM (#15281883)
>The Fed has stabilized markets very well for the last eight years

It's very hard to really know this. We can't experiment, and we are a really long way off from accurately simulating the real world mathematically.

The most academically accepted hardcover on the Great Depression (A Monetary History...) stated the Fed was most responsible for it.

The thing about the Fed is that money represents real goods and services. That's real product of labor that does something useful for someone else. The Fed, at face value, tells us it can pull some levers and create an alchemy where it produces more real value in the economy. That is called magic, or economics, and it doesn't really work. Their actual role is to serve as a nanny state subsidy institution for the big banking empires.

There is the Keynesian argument that the Fed needs to mamage aggregate demand, but there's no way to test if that's really true.

Personally, I'd much rather take a money supply controlled by a k-percent rule, get rid of the Fed, and make all those "smartest guys in the room" working in finance go do something useful instead.

Re:A decade after the crisis, The Fed plans to shrink its bo... by nhaehnle on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @09:35AM (#15284426)
> It's very hard to really know this. We can't experiment, and we are a really long way off from accurately simulating the real world mathematically.

Agreed.

> The Fed, at face value, tells us it can pull some levers and create an alchemy where it produces more real value in the economy.

Strawman. Nobody relevant actually claims that.

What many claimed was that QE would increase lending in the real economy, which would obviously boost the economy (because more real economy lending = more spending = more demand = more economic activity). That hasn't really happened, and I hope economists learned the lesson.

> There is the Keynesian argument that the Fed needs to mamage aggregate demand

That's monetarism, not Keynesianism -- the main message of Keynes is for the government to manage aggregate demand via its fiscal policy and budget. Though I grant you that for whatever reason, there's substantial overlap when it comes to what individuals believe.

> Personally, I'd much rather take a money supply controlled by a k-percent rule, get rid of the Fed, and make all those "smartest guys in the room" working in finance go do something useful instead.

The funny part about statements like this is that the money supply that matters for the real economy is managed by commercial banks anyway.

And you do need an institution that acts as a firewall to prevent temporary liquidity issues from turning into full insolvencies via self-fulfilling prophecy (aka bank runs). That institution happens to be the Fed in the US. You can argue about the more political, monetary policy side of things, but having that firewall is really, really critical.

Totally agree on the "doing something useful instead" part, though :)

Re:A decade after the crisis, The Fed plans to shrink its bo... by rsync on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @10:33AM (#15284948)
"What many claimed was that QE would increase lending in the real economy, which would obviously boost the economy (because more real economy lending = more spending = more demand = more economic activity). That hasn't really happened, and I hope economists learned the lesson."

I don't know that they have learned that lesson ..

My understanding is that the failure of institutional lending in response to QE is still considered "a mystery" by mainstream economists, etc.

I personally think that banks are in the same position Apple is in with their x00 Billion dollars hoarded overseas ... they are terrified that the system could come flying apart at any moment and are therefore sitting on cash or reserve assets to protect against this.

Re:A decade after the crisis, The Fed plans to shrink its bo... by gozur88 on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @03:26PM (#15288005)
>My understanding is that the failure of institutional lending in response to QE is still considered "a mystery" by mainstream economists, etc.

As the Austrian school economists pointed out during the crisis, you can print money, but you can't print borrowers - the banks need qualified borrowers to lend to, and in the middle of a financial crisis there aren't as many.

Of course the fed can't allow cascading bank failures, but once the banking system is out of danger pouring in more money won't do much.

Re:A decade after the crisis, The Fed plans to shrink its bo... by wallace_f on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @12:21PM (#15286013)
There is a lot here to discuss and only so much time and space.

>That's monetarism, not Keynesianism -- the main message of Keynes is for the government to manage aggregate demand via its fiscal policy and budget. Though I grant you that for whatever reason, there's substantial overlap when it comes to what individuals believe.

You are right to say that Keynesians and Keynes himself emphasized fiscal policy, but afaik the traditional monetarist view is actually not to engage in discretionary monetary policy at all. Managing AD was Keynes' whole big deal in his General Theory. Before him the groupthink in academic economics was all circled around labor supply and labor price being out of equillibrium with the market.

Then Friedman came along to establish monerarism. He wanted monetary policy along the lines of a k percent rule, and not to try to manage AD (discretionary MP). So no, it's not monerarist, it is in dact Keynesian.

>And you do need an institution that acts as a firewall to prevent temporary liquidity issues from turning into full insolvencies via self-fulfilling prophecy (aka bank runs).

Economists take this as gospel, but I have never seen evidence of this. I have seen evidence it is not true. I'm with Friedman, fractional reserve banking doesn't create value, just inflation and risk.

>Strawman. Nobody relevant actually claims that. What many claimed was that QE would increase lending in the real economy, which would obviously boost the economy (because more real economy lending = more spending = more demand = more economic activity). That hasn't really happened, and I hope economists learned the lesson.

We really disagree here. I even think your comment is strangely tautological, don't you think? You said there is no one who thinks the Fed is trying a game of pulling on some levers and creating more value in the economy, but then you went on to describe the Keynesian argument for how the Fed pulls some levers to magically create value (by stimulating AD).

The argument for QE and fiscal policy is the same Keynesian one: by creating easy money, they basically create more AD, which puts to work unemployed, unused resources. So Keynesians argue, those unused resources are now put to work.

But what work are they doing? Is it useful work? Are banks just going to hoard cash, and why flood so much easy money into the banks, anyways?

I think it's really more simple than that. The Fed is just Wall St's nice insurance policy, and economists are just clever priests who justify the actions of the ruling plutocratic class.

Re:A decade after the crisis, The Fed plans to shrink its bo... by nhaehnle on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @04:45PM (#15288651)
> >And you do need an institution that acts as a firewall to prevent temporary liquidity issues from turning into full insolvencies via self-fulfilling prophecy (aka bank runs).

> Economists take this as gospel, but I have never seen evidence of this. I have seen evidence it is not true. I'm with Friedman, fractional reserve banking doesn't create value, just inflation and risk.

Well, the point was about whether a central bank acting as lender of last resort makes sense or not. Fractional reserve banking existed before central banks, and if you have fractional reserve banking, then a lender of last resort is a must. There's plenty of evidence for that (in the form of regular bank runs before central banks, and practically zero bank runs afterwards).

As to whether fractional reserve banking itself should be permitted or not, that's admittedly less clear. Though I'd say that there's a big advantage to having the kind of flexibility in the money supply that comes with letting credit shrink and grow in a decentralized fashion as demanded by the economy.

I find it ironic that Friedman, who is associated with some of the worst and most ideological central planning-bashing, turns out to be an advocate of central planning when it comes to monetary policy! Seems inconsistent if you ask me...

> You said there is no one who thinks the Fed is trying a game of pulling on some levers and creating more value in the economy, but then you went on to describe the Keynesian argument for how the Fed pulls some levers to magically create value (by stimulating AD).

What we disagree about here is mostly whether there's magic involved. My point is that a large part of the underlying theory is sound (though not all of it), and your claim of voodoo is greatly exaggerated.

The question of whether the work being done is useful is an important one. That's why I've always been against (or at least skeptical of) QE, actually, though I think that fiscal policies that often come up in the same discussions could be quite useful. For example, you could just transfer a fixed amount of money every citizen ("helicopter money") to boost the economy, and scale it down if/when inflation exceeds your target. That way, the usefulness of the additional work would be guaranteed, by virtue of being work that the people decide should be done.

Re:A decade after the crisis, The Fed plans to shrink its bo... by wallace_f on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @01:07AM (#15290984)
I agree with you that printing money and giving it equally to all people is a whole lot better than printing money and giving it to banks. The former is just bad government, the latter is outright theft taken from the working class and given to the rich.

I am aware of your point about a lender of last resort and am aware of the history of banking. I think you talked yourself already into understanding my point though: that the Fed's bank guarantees are only necessary because we stupidly allow fractional reserve banking.

By the way Friedman was not an advocate of central planning, even with monetary policy. He even advocated getting rid of the Fed., but when he realized it would take a revolution to do that, conceded they should at least use a hard rule, like I've been saying the k-percent rule, and not use discretionary monetary policy.

Friedman could be cold and harsh at times which earned him controversy, but his expertise in monetary policy was part of why he won the Nobel, and the only reason he is ignored is because they are inconsistent with the profit motive of the financial sector.

Re:A decade after the crisis, The Fed plans to shrink its bo... by neilwilson on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @10:29AM (#15284896)
"The thing about the Fed is that money represents real goods and services. "

It doesn't and never has. There has never been a one to one match between money and stuff. Money is really the emodiment of a human promise, and promises don't always get fulfilled.

The one promise that does, is if you don't pony up the correct currency to pay your taxes you go to jail. And that is what drives a currency at root.

Re:A decade after the crisis, The Fed plans to shrink its bo... by wallace_f on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @02:56PM (#15287733)
No, sorry. In every econ textbook exists the academic definition of money: store of value, unit of measure, medium of exchange.

What is it an exchange of? What is it storing? What is it measuring?

In other words, we use it to help us with exchanging, storing, and measuring real value. This way you don't have to exchange some lines of code for a cow, or store all your wealth in cheese.

Maybe you are thinking that I am saying something about money not being a fiat currency, which wasn't the point here.

Re:A decade after the crisis, The Fed plans to shrink its bo... by 0x445442 on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @11:05AM (#15285255)
"There has never been a one to one match between money and stuff."

Depends on how you define money. In the case of hard assets like gold there is a one to one match because gold represents energy already spent.

Re:A decade after the crisis, The Fed plans to shrink its bo... by cirgue on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @12:25PM (#15286053)
People want gold not because it took energy to mine, but because other people also want gold. Gold is like any other currency system, except that the process that controls supply is basically stochastic (and there is a small industrial demand for the commodity itself, but this is negligible).
Re:A decade after the crisis, The Fed plans to shrink its bo... by smaddox on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @02:30PM (#15287448)
If you define money as hard assets, you don't understand money. I suggest reading "Debt: the 5000 first years".
Re:A decade after the crisis, The Fed plans to shrink its bo... by phkahler on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @08:09AM (#15283889)
>> And as a note, the Fed has stabilized markets very well for the last eight years

That's debatable. I'd say they prevented some much needed corrections from happening. The housing bubble is back - prices have recovered to 2006 levels or higher. People are less able to afford things at those prices. Also, home prices vary inversely with interest rates and rates are still near their lows with really only one direction to go.

Re:A decade after the crisis, The Fed plans to shrink its bo... by rtpg on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @12:55AM (#15281898)
I think it's more to counter the idea that the bailouts cost money.

If bailouts are effectively revenue-neutral there's a whole line of arguments against intervention that disappear. Though of course, like you said, there are distortions

Re:A decade after the crisis, The Fed plans to shrink its bo... by dmichulke on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @02:42AM (#15282300)
> the Fed has stabilized markets very well ...

> ... at the price of speculative distortions

That's really all there is to say and the main argument against Central Banks.

PS: A nice analogy would be: They got rid of the hens by burying them in eggs.

Re:A decade after the crisis, The Fed plans to shrink its bo... by santoshalper on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @10:09AM (#15284710)
The Fed can't print money without devaluing the money already in print. The federal government can make money off a transaction and use it is as additional revenue.

Not really arguing "should" here, nor am I arguing that the supposed profits were real. Just pointing out a big difference between the federal government generating revenue and the federal reserve printing more money. If this were not true, then why would would have taxes? The Fed could just print money any time the government needed to spend it.

Re:A decade after the crisis, The Fed plans to shrink its bo... by neilwilson on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @10:33AM (#15284953)
"The Fed can't print money without devaluing the money already in print. "

Yes it can. Banks do that all the time. Money grows and shrinks to ensure all the transactions that are worth completing gets completed.

It's a dynamic system.

"If this were not true, then why would would have taxes?"

You have taxes, so you have to create output and hand it over for the currency the taxes are denominated in. That's how output is transferred to the public sector.

The public sector then creates the money necessary for you (and everybody else transitively) to pay those tax demands.

When government spends it will create the taxation that balances that spend to the penny for any positive transaction. It's a simple geometric progression.

Unless somebody in the chain decides not to spend all their income. We call that saving.

The maths is straightforward... https://medium.com/modern-money-matters/the-function-of-gove...

Re:A decade after the crisis, The Fed plans to shrink its bo... by dredmorbius on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @08:05AM (#15292752)
This answer ... misses some critical points, and skews pedantic.

The Fed cannot net print money without devaluing what's in circulation. Inflation is literally the fact of more money chasing fewer goods. More money => more inflation.

The question then becomes "how might money leave the system?" There are several ways.

Taxation, if you subscribe to MMT, is money leaving the system. (Government spending is, as with Fed policy, creating money.)

Increasing or decreasing the overall amount of consumer and business debt increases or decreases the money supply.

Increasing or decreasing the overall value of financial assets -- stocks, bonds, derivatives, real estate, commodities -- by increasing or decreasing collateral and balance sheets, increases and decreases the money supply.

Money going into savings, particularly off-shore accounts (where it's not otherwise available to the financial system) is effectively withdrawn, through the mechanism of reducing the velocity of money. Other factors effecting money velocity do likewise. (This is, essentially, how often a given dollar is transacted.)

The more accurate answer would be that: "The Fed can't print money without devaluing the money already in circulations, unless there are offsetting withdrawals to they money supply".

Re:A decade after the crisis, The Fed plans to shrink its bo... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @02:42PM (#15287579)
> The Fed can't print money without devaluing the money already in print.

Well, the way this actually happened is that a few trillion dollars simply evaporated in 2008. The Fed "printed" a few trillion dollars to keep the few trillion that evaporated from destroying the whole system. That few trillion that the Fed created didn't devalue the money already in print; instead, it kept things the same.

Now, you could argue that the few trillion needed to be destroyed to undo the devaluation that had happened by its creation. That's a reasonable argument. But doing it very fast can cause a lot more damage than doing it slowly.

Re:A decade after the crisis, The Fed plans to shrink its bo... by dredmorbius on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @08:06AM (#15292764)
The trillions evaporating decreased the money supply, which would have a deflationary effect.

The Fed's action countered that. Inflation would have been negative in the absence.

The Fed increased inflation relative to the non-intervention case.

Re:A decade after the crisis, The Fed plans to shrink its bo... by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @12:59PM (#15295933)
You sound like you think you're disagreeing with me. But what you're saying is what I was trying to say as well.
Re:A decade after the crisis, The Fed plans to shrink its bo... by dredmorbius on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @09:36PM (#15299917)
It was not clear to me that that was your message. Perhaps I said it more clearly and in fewer words?