News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Finding UX in the Trash by dguo on Sunday September 17, 2017 @09:10AM (#15269435)
The author did say: "UX is turning those four bins into two (or one!) and signing up with a single stream recycling vendor."
Re:Finding UX in the Trash by lucideer on Sunday September 17, 2017 @12:39PM (#15270410)
Regardless of what's easier or what will have to be done anyway, this isn't a UX solution. It's kicking the can down the road. Good UX solves problems at the point of user interaction. Avoiding the problem only to dump it on a backend engineer or data scientist who's then got to make do with bad source data (my best guess at the equivalent to recycling contractors in this analogy) is not good UX, it's just laziness.

If it is easier for the data scientist to sift through and correct bad data than it is for a UX professional, it absolutely makes sense to have the data scientist do the work. But the UX doesn't get to take credit for that decision.

His follow through after the initial bad analogy is then frustratingly vague; he just hand waves at Apple and gives no concrete examples of solving UX problems.

Re:Finding UX in the Trash by catnaroek on Sunday September 17, 2017 @10:33AM (#15269776)
And he's wrong. It is far easier to get everyone to classify their trash. Separating trash that has been put in a single trash bin is far more complicated later on. “It allows people to think less” isn't an excuse for making shit worse in every other possible imaginable respect.
Re:Finding UX in the Trash by archagon on Sunday September 17, 2017 @11:12AM (#15269965)
Well, except for the fact that half the people won't bother and the job will have to be done at some point anyway.
Re:Finding UX in the Trash by uoaei on Sunday September 17, 2017 @12:04PM (#15270232)
That is a strong assertion.

It takes a bit of culture remapping, but certainly doable.

Want good examples? Spend some time in Germany or Sweden.

Re:Finding UX in the Trash by lobster_johnson on Sunday September 17, 2017 @04:28PM (#15271526)
Making humans change their habits is extremely difficult, though. Scandinavia and Germany are outliers — and I say that as a Scandinavian (who has spent a lot of time in Germany).

Here in New York, I recently lived in a building where people would, on a weekly basis, discard pizzas, soiled napkins and rotisserie chicken carcasses in the recycling bin. This was a modern building with just two different recycling bins (one for plastic/metal, the other for paper/cardboard). It's amazing how little people care.

In my current NYC neighbourhood, there are no recycling bins at all, and people have to sort and bag their recycling and put it on the street one night of the week. Not surprisingly, almost nobody bothers. Other than myself, I've only observed bags from my neighbour next door. The US can be pretty infuriating/depressing sometimes.

Re:Finding UX in the Trash by 0xF2 on Sunday September 17, 2017 @10:44AM (#15269829)
Author here. The point here is not the trash, I go by those bins twice a day and can affor to think a few more seconds if I am carrying something unusual. Plus it makes you feel like you are part of a bigger cause to put near-zero effort to help save the planet.

The point is software. There I should not spend a fraction of a second thinking, because that does not happen twice a day. It happens every 15 minutes if we are talking about me looking at my phone. UX thinking there makes a real, tangible difference.

Re:Finding UX in the Trash by tyingq on Sunday September 17, 2017 @11:49AM (#15270138)
The analogy might work better if you went into why the idea of reducing to one or two bins was the best solution. Is that better than, for example 3 bins "aluminum cans", "plastic bottles" and "everything else"? By what measure?

Without the background, it just sort of sounds like "consult your UX people for the answer, always...we're never wrong".

Re:Finding UX in the Trash by carwheel10 on Sunday September 17, 2017 @03:17PM (#15271206)
What do you think of my solution posted above?
Re:Finding UX in the Trash by 0xF2 on Sunday September 17, 2017 @05:58PM (#15271921)
I like it better than reading different signs in every office I visit.

In the US the problem however is that recycling collection is not standardized. Each city does it differently, which gets in the way of the standardization you propose. We would need a Federal standard (or at least an agreement by the relevant industry association) to help there.

Re:Finding UX in the Trash by carwheel10 on Saturday September 23, 2017 @10:07AM (#15319782)
Not necessarily although a federal standard would help. A single big state like California could implement it and the standard would propagate itself from there.
[dead]
Re:Finding UX in the Trash by sslayer on Sunday September 17, 2017 @11:46AM (#15270118)
Exactly - Removing options and "thinking" for the user removes freedom. I agree that is okay to "hide" options and "think" for the user, as long as those options utimately can be "unhidden".

I want my UX to be intuitive and easy to use, but what If I want to customize my UI for my own experience?

Re:Finding UX in the Trash by jaxn on Sunday September 17, 2017 @02:28PM (#15270957)
Who gets to define the options that are available? Shouldn't the developer of the software get to decide what their software does and doesn't do? You want me to spend money developing and supporting options that I would rather not build & support?
Re:Finding UX in the Trash by Qwertious on Monday September 18, 2017 @06:27AM (#15274659)
> Shouldn't the developer of the software get to decide what their software does and doesn't do? You want me to spend money developing and supporting options that I would rather not build & support?

In the long term, yes - the customer decides, because it's the customer providing the money. Now, there's the whole "the customer is NOT always right, because the customer is often a clueless moron" problem, but ultimately, it's the customer's money to spend (or not spend).

Re:Finding UX in the Trash by 0xF2 on Monday September 18, 2017 @12:30AM (#15273418)
The designer in the software team gets to decide what is available. Software that has no design has in itself been designed, but the choices were made by a developer instead.

There is nothing inappropriate about one vendor making choices. to continue the Apple example, they make 8 of the reasonably complete smartphones you could choose to buy. If you were forced to buy Apple's phone, that would be another matter, but you get to choose.

Re:Finding UX in the Trash by carwheel10 on Sunday September 17, 2017 @03:19PM (#15271220)
It's even better if we move the problem of classifying from the person throwing trash to the time of manufacturing of the article. You could mark each article with #1, #2 or #3 and standardize each bin to be called bin #1, #2 or #3.

The person then simply matches number on article to the number on bin and throws, dead simple.

See my comment above for detailed description of this.

Re:Finding UX in the Trash by glandium on Sunday September 17, 2017 @07:12PM (#15272218)
Those labels exist, at least in Japan. They're not numbers, though. http://www.barcode-net.com/products/recycle/img/ex-img_recyc...

The problem is when items have multiple labels, because they're not made of one thing. The simplest example is Saran wrap, where the box is "paper", and the part to cut plastic is either "aluminium" or "plastic" (there are brands that make it in paper so that it's easier, though). And both parts go in different bins. Bottles can have 3 parts: plastic cap, PET bottle, paper label. All in different bins.

Then you add rules where things need to be clean, which mean in theory, your toothpaste tube needs to be cut open, and cleaned, before putting it in the bin.

And different cities have different rules.

Re:Finding UX in the Trash by carwheel10 on Sunday September 17, 2017 @09:40PM (#15272787)
9 labels is too many. Also, those pictures are kind of hard to match.

It needs to be dead simple: number of labels = number of bins available. Maybe number of labels can be more than number of bins by 1 or 2 at most.

Secondly, use numbering instead of icons. Numbering is dead simple to match, icons require effort to match on the box against the picture on bin.

In the case of saran wrap: the box should clearly say #2 for box and #3 for contents (saran wrap). That would resolve the case you mentioned.

Re:Finding UX in the Trash by glandium on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @12:24AM (#15281760)
The fun part is: in many cities, you actually have to separate almost all 9 categories.

As for the salan wrap, the point is that it's not a box vs contents problem. The box itself needs to be broken up (removing the cutter part) before being thrown away.