- no central language approval body (no Academe Anglaise)
- Hollywood, the BBC and the World Service.
> the Chinese just don't seem that interested in spreading their culture and ideology farther than they can directly benefit from?
Traditionally the end of Chinese outward-looking culture is attributed to the end of the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treasure_voyages , but I'm sure it's more complex than that.
Given the overhead of learning new languages, in an era of mass communication the world's auxiliary language ought to be even more of a winner-takes-all market than search or social, but French, Spanish, Chinese, Arabic and Russian have a headstart and a very dedicated user base.
Not sure how big an advantage the lack of central language body is though: on the one hand it means that people using it in an idiosyncratic local way as an auxiliary language aren't subject to foreign third parties insisting they're doing it wrong, and can inject other shared vocabulary and adjust to each others' fluency level. But on the other hand there's nobody influential to promote any attempt to fix English's confusing irregularities and dreadful orthography(ies) and lack of authority to appeal to doesn't stop people being terribly snobby about "correct" English.
Spanish has more native speakers than English, but when you include people using secondary languages, there are more English speakers in total than any other language.
False. It has happened. Chinese culture has spread to neighboring countries, but that's almost a millennium ago. Ever wonder why in the Unicode BMP there's a huge block of "CJK ideographs"? It's because historically the Japanese, Korean, (and Vietnamese) all use Chinese characters in their communication. Sure their respective languages are very different but the script is the same. And at that time China had plenty of influence over these neighboring countries.
Not entirely. There scripts are the same enough (and large enough) that the designers of Unicode wanted to combine them into a single character set. God help you if you actually want to combine these languages within a single text. The writing systems are different enough that to get a good result, you need to use a font that was designed for the language you are reading.
It's interesting that nothing like this seems to happen for any other language and culture combination, most notably Chinese for this article. How much of the lack of ability for Chinese to spread as a culture is just how damn hard it is to learn Chinese as a non-native? Or is it that the Chinese just don't seem that interested in spreading their culture and ideology farther than they can directly benefit from? Or is the fact that they aren't interested in that based on them knowing and even taking pride in their language and culture being particularly impenetrable? Related to this article, it seems notable that movements within China to radically simplify the language never seem to pick up much steam. Sure, it would be insanely complex to do on a logistical level, but even above that, it seems like nobody is much interested in it.
It reminds me a little of thinking about AIs. They say that an AI will only want to do what it gets programmed to want to do. It may become smarter and more powerful, but there's no reason for it to change what it wants to do. Changing what it wants to do would itself be an action, and it has no reason to take that action, because it isn't part of what it originally wants to do. It seems similar that cultures sort of evolve to care about some things and not care about other things, and efforts to make them care about something they don't care about at best have quite the uphill battle.