As Sam Harris points out, "beginning meditators often think that they are able to concentrate on a single object, such as the breath, for minutes at a time, only to report after days or weeks of intensive practice that their attention is now carried away by thought every few seconds. This is actually progress. It takes a certain degree of concentration to even notice how distracted you are."
Amazingly, most of us are unable to even recognize (with any precision) when we're thinking. And that's a crucial first step in discovering what's beyond thought.
Thus his argument are about "separable consciousness", and we don't know if real consciousness is "separable consciousness".
Has anyone seen a good argument that p-zombies are logically possible, that goes beyond being some form of "I can string these words together, and they form a grammatically-correct sentence?"
Keep in mind that Chalmers is a property dualist who thinks there is some additional law of nature binding consciousness with informationally rich physical processes (not necessary brain activity).
The p-zombie argument isn't circular, but it can be attacked on other grounds.
For example, if we were to start thinking about the state of no thought — just pure awareness — we’d understand less about what we’re trying to examine.
Thought is an amazing gift, but it’s limited. It would appear we’re reaching that limit when we start thinking about consciousness — hence the wildly varying thoughts on it.