If only there was something to put in the middle of this reasoning!
Elon Musk fucked up as soon as he named it "autopilot". He set expectations at autonomous, and released it as a "beta" because that's what you do with some web app, and then when people started using it as an autonomous driving product (because that's what "autopilot" means), they unsurprisingly got killed. But shruggie! Move fast and break things! It's beta! What ya gonna do?
On the other hand, if it was called "driver assist", or "super cruise", or some other thing, then drivers' expectations wouldn't be set at "autonomous driving", and then the'd be paying more attention, and probably wouldn't end up dead.
I'm sorry, but this is all about setting expectations, and Elon fucked this up.
I couldn't narrow down exactly where in life I learned about autopilot systems in aircraft, but I always considered it to be common sense that autopilot doesn't mean "can completely fly itself"
Also Tesla says so themselves: >All Tesla vehicles produced in our factory, including Model 3, have the hardware needed for full self-driving capability at a safety level substantially greater than...
A car is not a web app. It just isn't. This behavior literally wouldn't fly at say Boeing, or anywhere else that makes machines people's trust their lives to.
I think more people are aware of the second point than the first, and that's why the common perception of "autopilot" is more about level-5 driving than cruise control
I'd bet those 3 combined are much safer than Autopilot, which complicates their implementation to offer a marginal convenience of not having to steer (but to constantly have to nanny lest it put you into a ditch)
I think if used properly Autopilot can be safer than most drivers without it, but the crux of the issue is that many people will trust the system more than they should, which could make them more dangerous. We're in a dangerous inbetween state with autonomous driving where it's just good enough to fool some people into thinking it's foolproof when it's not.