News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by zip1234 on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @02:04PM (#15229700)
On the other hand, if you know that the technology is not completely infallible, but better than humans in a general sense and will save lives by releasing it, wouldn't you be morally obligated to do so? Wouldn't holding it back even though it would save lives be worse?
Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by davrosthedalek on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @02:18PM (#15229876)
I think people will prefer risking being killed by their own mistakes than by the mistakes of an AI, even if that risk is somewhat higher, maybe even considerably higher.
Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by RandomBookmarks on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @03:05PM (#15230647)
Nope... I am actually happy to admit that I am a below average driver (as driving is sooo boring), and from what I read, the AI is already driving better than me - if used in the conditions it is designed for.
Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by dkonofalski on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @05:54PM (#15233218)
Don't they already have that choice, though? No one is forcing anyone to use Autopilot.

That's my main issue with the parent posts and the self-driving sentiments they're expressing - the person using it was grossly negligent and ignored all the warnings presented. You accept that the technology is in beta and that you accept the risks of that. The person ignoring those warnings is, more than likely, much less safer of driver than Autopilot ever could be.

I just really don't see how this could be pinned as Tesla's fault. We're treading very closely to territory where we absolve people of personal responsibility simply because we have technology that we can blame, even if it's irrational or misdirected blame.

Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by semiel on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @02:59PM (#15230541)
Surely they can not turn on autopilot, if that's the case?

For me, I prefer life over a false sense of control.

Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by erobbins on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @03:39PM (#15231329)
I do. I have no interest in a self driving car. I hate being a passenger in a human driven car too. Give me control of my own destiny!
Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by carlmr on Wednesday September 13, 2017 @04:51AM (#15236574)
Does it matter what you prefer? You're also risking everybody else's lives while driving. Should they have a decision in whether you're allowed to drive?
Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by sol_remmy on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @02:48PM (#15230338)
Disagree. I will have my family use whichever is statistically safer.
Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by davrosthedalek on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @04:03PM (#15231821)
This might be harder to gauge than you think. Maybe a Tesla is much safer on the highway, but less safe in the city, or the other way around. Or less safe on ice, etc. The averaged risk (and we probably won't have anything else for a while) over the whole population might be quite different from that for your actual use.
Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by dlp211 on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @02:07PM (#15229724)
It can't be marginally better than humans, it has to be an order of magnitude or more better. Humans are irrational, and incidents like this erode public trust.
Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by zip1234 on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @02:10PM (#15229763)
I agree, but there is also news about how Tesla's automatic braking features saved people from getting into collisions. I would think that might counteract some of the negative news. See this one from six months ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ndeb1pMAsh4
Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by makomk on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @03:24PM (#15231034)
It shouldn't counteract the negative news because every car manufacturer offers automatic emergency breaking as a feature so it's not a distinguishing benefit of Tesla, it works fine without Tesla's controversial and dangerous Autopilot mode enabled, the main example Elon Musk himself posted of it preventing a collision was in manual mode in conditions totally unsuitable for Autopilot, and the entire industry already agrees that it's a worthwhile safety improvement. I believe it's even going to become mandatory on new cars in the US at some point for safety reasons.
Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by mantas on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @03:19PM (#15230925)
Most manufacturers have automatic braking. But they do not pretend it's "autopilot" nor let user to rely on it. It's just there to save their ass if shit hits the fan.
Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by carlmr on Wednesday September 13, 2017 @04:54AM (#15236585)
Apart from this being a very basic feature in almost every (premium) car manufacturer offers, this is a very grave misunderstanding of human psychology. You can never cancel fear with good news. Otherwise we'd be happy about how safe we are today, not worrying about terrorism (in the US that is, there are countries with legitimate elevated terrorism risks that are scary and actually worrisome).
Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by apeace on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @02:10PM (#15229770)
I think your point is void here, because in both of the cases I mentioned, the car was clearly worse than a human. Who drives into a concrete barrier or the middle of a tractor trailer truck?

If the technology were better than humans I'd agree.

Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by greendesk on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @02:15PM (#15229837)
>>Who drives into a concrete barrier or the middle of a tractor trailer truck?

I have seen a drunk driver do exactly that.

Someone who falls asleep might also do that.

[edit] Come to think of it, I have almost caused an accident a decade ago. I was momentarily distracted as I turned to talk to my passenger. I was able to brake in time, as a car in front of me had suddenly stopped. Nevertheless, it was only a matter of maybe one second to avoid running into the other car. Me-a-decade ago might been in a similar accident.

Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by losteric on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @02:44PM (#15230291)
I know one person that drove into a light post in the middle of an empty parking lot. Daylight, sober, not texting, not tired, not stunting - they were looking at the exit and simply didn't see the one light post between their car and the exit. "That light came out of nowhere!"

Human car accidents are not news because roughly 100 Americans die in car accidents every day, out of ~15300 car accidents per day.

Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by chc on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @02:19PM (#15229890)
Also somebody who's been blinded by a bright light, or is suffering from a medical event, or is looking at their cell phone. There are lots of things that cause people to hit objects that should be easily avoidable.
Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by yahna on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @04:22PM (#15232110)
Neither of those people should be using autopilot. It wouldn't save them.

I can also avoid being in either of those situations.

If autopilot is comparable ot an exhausted or drunk driver why do I want to use it?

Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by viraptor on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @02:33PM (#15230095)
> I think your point is void here, because in both of the cases I mentioned, the car was clearly worse than a human.

But separate cases are not really interesting when comparing accident rates. Think of a more extreme made up scenario:

You can either drive yourself and be part of the "1.25 deaths per 100 million vehicle miles" statistic (US), or use an automated car which causes 0.25 deaths - but it spontaneously explodes in that case. No other car would just explode randomly while you're driving it. (It's clearly worse in that way)

Do you want to drive yourself, or take the automated one?

Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by losteric on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @02:35PM (#15230135)
Should we judge performance in every scenario distinctly, or in aggregate?

That is, if the risks of one edge case goes up while the car performs far better in the vast majority of situations, is the car worse than a human?

Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by Turing_Machine on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @05:26PM (#15232942)
> Who drives into a concrete barrier or the middle of a tractor trailer truck?

It happens all the time, dude. Most famously with Jayne Mansfield, but commonly when people are paying attention to their damned phones, or trying to sort out a fight among the kids, or just distracted by their marriage, or work problems, or...

I used to know a woman who drove right into a city bus that was stopped at a bus stop, lights flashing and everything. Fortunately no one was injured in that accident.

Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by mattmcknight on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @03:14PM (#15230834)
Who drove into the rear end of my car two weeks ago on the interstate? A human.
Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @02:16PM (#15229848)
The bar is not infallible in general, just infallible at driving directly into obstacles.

Is it realistic to worry about a car that can't get that right, but is simultaneously safer than a human driver overall?

Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by rohit2412 on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @04:50PM (#15232509)
What if Tesla released autopilot as a completely passive accident prevention driving assist?

Tesla seems to be allowing only two options - one with no driving assistance, and one where they can call it autonomous.

Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by greglindahl on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @05:23PM (#15232904)
Emergency braking is still active even if you don't have autopilot turned on. This is also true for a lot of other cars with Level 2 autonomy.
Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by rohit2412 on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @10:13PM (#15234970)
The statistics being touted for reduced accident include emergency breaking.
Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by greglindahl on Wednesday September 13, 2017 @12:50PM (#15240093)
Yes. I'd like to see AEB broken out of the accident number. Looks like this NTSB investigation did not release such a number.
Re:NTSB: Tesla’s Autopilot UX a “major role” in fatal Model ... by adanto6840 on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @02:08PM (#15229733)
It's a tough thing to weigh however when it's perhaps "better than humans" in 98% of situations, but "on par with" or perhaps even "worse than humans" for the remaining 2%. That's where it gets sketchy to me, at least.

That said, I'm casually in the market for a Tesla (ideally pre-owned) and one of the features I'd require is the latest auto-pilot hardware. I'd definitely make use of it right away too -- but I'd do so with the understanding that it is far from infallible, and that I still need to keep substantially all of my attention trained to the road just as I would in any other non-autopilot vehicle.