Therefore countries with low taxes (Ireland but also Luxembourg) attract a disproportionate amount of big companies HQ. Ikea, for instance, is officially declared in Luxembourg.
Why so many people in EU rejoice about the Brexit is because UK has been one of the main force opposing fiscal harmonization (apparently London is a bit of a tax haven for financial service companies) so hopefully this kind of efforts can go forward.
Here is for example an opinion piece by Michel Rocard, a former French PM (left-wing guy, really not a nationalist), before the Brexit: https://www.reddit.com/r/europe/comments/27e68h/what_rocard_...
But at least the will be no more exceptions for participating members of the EU.
The EU was a good concept, but exceptions to members states ( not only UK, but also for Belgium eg. To much debt), made it a lot less usefull
Damned politicians...
Ps. This is not a rant against UK, but against the 'broken' execution of the foundations throughout the years.
Also it's time to send a clear message, you can't get the benefits of you aren't a member
Exceptions on joining, but not participating 100% shouldn't be allowed in the first place
(Not that I have any solutions to these problems, I'm just pointing them out. :) )
If the EU is more concerned about the specific case of internet giants rather than multinational firms in general, they could tax this in a much more practical way by having state run internet service providers charge these content companies for access to their markets.
I wish countries would give up on corporate taxes. They are either easily circumvented, or you need a massive regulatory body to analyze all corporate transactions and determine if they are "fair."
All the same tax revenue can be gained through much better systems that are not trivially circumvented and do not create a perverse incentive for your country's companies to up and move to the nearest tax haven.
> I wish countries would give up on corporate taxes.
I really wish they won't. Right now the small companies pay corporate taxes just fine, it is the big ones that play all kinds of shell games to get out from under their obligations.
Ireland works simply because it is a member of the EU and any EU HQ business can operate anywhere else in EU.
The USA and EU don't because the benefits to their political class have so far outweighed the problems caused by a lack of revenue, and these structures have developed and proliferated rather rapidly. Additionally the political structures required to create collaborative responses have been developed in response to different issues (the necessity of supporting development in Eastern Europe after the collapse of the wall), and the alignments necessary to operate a larger system in Europe are not yet in place.
I do believe that Brexit will facilitate this, but I think that the process will have to go further to include Macron's ideas on a single budget - a greatly expanded take and disperse for the EU. This will require a huge reform of the Commission. I invite everyone to try and engage with the commission in some process or other and then judge what kind of capability you are engaging with.
I hope that the EU will devolve the distribution of central budget items to locally accountable forums, possibly at the sub national level - perhaps six for a country like France, one for somewhere like Greece. Currently I fear that the favour networks that operate in the EU institutions would greatly distort and corrupt any large fiscal rebalancing.
The big issue is that it seems that several of the national level structures in the EU would creak in the face of this kind of new set-up. Spain and Belgium in particular, but even Italy could be pulled apart by the creation of subnational entities with revenue lines independent of the national entity. Also, what would the mechanism of accountability be ? I think that this should vary according to the tradition of the region, but what are the acceptable limits or bounds on this?
Without Brexit this is simply a non-starter, I think that the UK would have been much more compromised than any other EU state by the emergence of this kind of structure, and I think that the English part of the UK would have been a real problem in terms of subnational accountability - the sovereignty of the commons would have gone and I don't see that as politically possible in England (note the other nations are less touchy about that for some reason!)
- Apple France is actually just a distributor for Apple Ireland
- Apple Ireland sells Apple France an iPhone at MSRP
- Apple France makes basically no profit because it sells "at cost"
- Apple Ireland books a profit for an iPhone sold in France
For example if Apple France is really just a distributor, and they buy their products at low margins, then it is what it is
I think a lot of tax agencies simply don't have the muscle to push forward on this
A quote from [1]:
"The president of the European commission, Jean-Claude Juncker, spent years in his previous role as Luxembourg’s prime minister secretly blocking EU efforts to tackle tax avoidance by multinational corporations, leaked documents reveal."
So:
> I think a lot of tax agencies simply don't have the muscle to push forward on this
No. They do. They're just prevented from doing so by the "socialists" (hah !) Europe "elected" (just pointing out that the leadership of the EU commission, the only organisation with real law-giving power in the EU aren't directly elected at all).
[1] https://www.theguardian.com/business/2017/jan/01/jean-claude...
2.Give intellectual property rights to one company in one country with low taxation like Ireland or a state like Maryland.
3. Make all the subsidiaries pay arbitrary patent-copyright-trademark rights to the company in Ireland-Maryland-Singapur so all the profits become zero in the different countries while transferring all those profits away.
This will get a lot worse before it gets better.
http://www.bendlawoffice.com/2011/08/01/reasons-to-incorpora...
The reason to register in Delaware is because of business friendly courts there. I don't believe there is a tax advantage
Delaware has a corporate tax rate of 8.7%, California has 8.84.
So yes no one is incorporating in Delaware becuase of taxes, WA, TX, NV and a few others have zero corporate tax.
Not sure how state tax rates interact with the federal one though
But most importantly to the (joke) argument that we're the last communist country there's a massive popular adhesion to the points listed above and for some reason a deep seated mistrust of the wealthy.
As for the communist thing, ah I didn't realize it was a joke argument, thought it was a serious one
Corporations, such as Microsoft, which are headquartered in states with nicer bodies of corporate law frequently choose to incorporate in their home state, such as Washington.
I see profit as the 'value added' by a particular activity. At least 90% of the value created by Google, Facebook and Apple was created in California. Therefore the vast majority of worldwide income generated by these companies should be subject to the tax rates that apply in California - not Ireland, not Germany, not Spain. So Google, etc should be paying more tax - but they should be paying it to the US government, not the EU. If there is ever an EU Silicon Valley then the EU can tax the worldwide profit of those EU companies.
Personally I would like to see a rule that intellectual property is fixed to the place where it is produced and forever taxed in that jurisdiction - just like land. If you write a book or develop a new drug or software then that IP stays where it was developed.
I'm trying not to be snarky but I need to say wtf.
FB & google don't make money from IP, they make money as service providers, connecting merchants on the advertisement hype train to our eyeballs.
They take money from local and transnational businesses, and present ads, aggregation and search services to individual, local, users.
How is this California related profits when I see ads for $smallbusiness in my french town? Because they host the servers there? Please. To be fair I'd concede Amazon may be different with regards to where the value they create resides but I'm sure you'll feel the same way I do when the tech giants step away from Silicon valley and it looses the sweet sweet techmonies.
This not about IP rights, corporate liberties or socialism, it's about realising when you're defending the fire that's roasting you. 'Cause google and fb don't give a F about US vs EU further than how they can leverage them to lower operating costs.
Her toys are nicer than the family who live at the manor have ever seen, let alone owned.
She's kind of a loud mouth, keeps telling the peasants and the Baronial family that they need to change, that their ideas about life, culture and fairness are all wrong.
How does this story end.?We note that the Barons have swords, pikes, bows and arrows, a long track record of setting fire to houses and decorating them by hanging up the occupants. Perhaps though, this time, they'll simply chillax and go to the seminars that the new woman is running.
If they use option a. I expect that the next peasant in charge of the farm will be much less ostentatious, opinionated and will adopt all of the shiny new practices introduced by the last farmer. They probably won't invent many new ones... but then again are there lots of new ones to be invented now?
This is about taxing EU-wide profits in EU countries proportional to the revenues generated in that country.
At the moment, many big tech companies use bookkeeping tricks to make it look like all their profit is generated in, for example, Ireland, while the revenue is generated in other EU counties.
Unfortunately, Ireland has special tax rates for these companies (the legality of which is contested), so their EU-wide effective tax rate is often ~1%.