Re:Identity Theft, Credit Reports, and You
by whitenoice on Saturday September 09, 2017 @07:35PM
(#15209673)
Curious, can you not ask them to produce the other letter then? As they signed the green card.
Re:Identity Theft, Credit Reports, and You
by LurkersWillLurk on Saturday September 09, 2017 @07:35PM
(#15209675)
Is the date that the green card was bought recorded by USPS? Basically, how exactly does writing the tracking number within the letter prove that the letter was mailed with that envelope?
Re:Identity Theft, Credit Reports, and You
by dredmorbius on Saturday September 09, 2017 @07:49PM
(#15209713)
Under civil law in the United States, the legal burden is not "irrefutable proof", but "preponderance of evidence".
If you produce copies of a letter with a given return receipt number indicated on it, the return receipt stub, and the received receipt, and the opposing party claims that "this could have been faked", then, unless your credibility is otherwise impeached, you have established a preponderance of evidence for your claim.
Re:Identity Theft, Credit Reports, and You
by Stratoscope on Saturday September 09, 2017 @10:36PM
(#15210270)
It sounds like several of you know more than I do about this, so I'm curious... I'm in the habit of using Priority Mail for things like this, because I can print out a mailing label at home and get a tracking number with delivery information.
Assuming I put the tracking number in the letter as you suggest, is there still an advantage to using certified mail and a green return receipt instead? Or is Priority Mail equally good?
Re:Identity Theft, Credit Reports, and You
by ams6110 on Saturday September 09, 2017 @11:46PM
(#15210468)
Priority Mail AFAIK doesn't require a signature for receipt. It does provide tracking, but that's less rigorous proof than the actual return receipt.
Re:Identity Theft, Credit Reports, and You
by Stratoscope on Sunday September 10, 2017 @01:38AM
(#15210849)
Thanks. Priority Mail does have a signature-required option, which makes me curious whether that is as good as a return receipt.
Also: 1) Get the actual green-card form beforehand; 2) type the green-card serial number above the inside address of the letter; and 3) keep a photocopy. Otherwise the recipient could claim that the signed green card, confirming receipt of the mailing, was for some other letter, not the one you sent. As a baby lawyer filling in for a more-senior associate at a court hearing, I had an opposing counsel make just such a claim to a judge; the judge gave the opposing counsel the benefit of the doubt. (The opposing counsel was later disbarred for unrelated reasons.)
Example of such an inside address:
--begin--
--end--