News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by adrianN on Saturday September 09, 2017 @04:08PM (#15208928)
The meme that man's creations will eventually kill their maker is at least as old as the jewish Golem. They're classic tales warning of hubris. Whether it's automata or summoned demons doesn't make much of a difference I think.

What's interesting to me is that as technology progressed, the gap between fiction and fact keeps narrowing. Take for example Der Sandmann. While true artificial intelligence is still far away, I think we'll see animated sex dolls in the next ten or twenty years that rival the capabilities Olimpia displays. As we already have a small number of people that prefer dolls to humans, I wonder where the tipping point will be where, say, about as many people are gay as are robophile.

Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by ChuckMcM on Saturday September 09, 2017 @05:01PM (#15209138)
I thought the twitter list of ethical questions about sex robots was fascinating in the ways it asked some very real questions about this.

The change that I continue to watch for is not when robots are used to do an undesirable job, but instead they are used to do a desirable one. I suspect the first hints of that are programs that write sports copy for newspapers. I have known a couple of sports writers over the years and they really liked what they did, and would (and sometimes did) do the job for free.

Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by tialaramex on Saturday September 09, 2017 @06:38PM (#15209520)
Heavy automation definitely does away with jobs that people liked doing, but that's been true since the industrial revolution.

Most train drivers like driving trains, something like London's DLR doesn't have train drivers (a human _can_ drive the train, but when they take over it deliberately goes slowly for safety reasons, so this is not normally used in paying service). A five year old (or a twenty-something going on five years old) gets to sit at the front and pretend they're driving, which is fun for them but it's not a job any more.

Some people enjoy operating a simple mechanical loom. Some expensive cloths are still today "hand woven" with such a loom because the legal protection for the name of the cloth mandates that they be produced this way. Probably everything else you have that was woven is woven automatically by a machine because machines produce the same quality as a skilled weaver but in enormous volume and more quickly.

The question is never whether machines will displace people from jobs, but about whether new jobs will come into existence (in large numbers) to replace those jobs. It's not "Can a machine do my job?" so much as "Is there anything I could get paid to do that a machine couldn't do?".

Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by visarga on Sunday September 10, 2017 @12:56AM (#15210721)
People say automation will kill many jobs, but often forget that when that day comes, we'll also be much more empowered.

Now we can use neural nets and all sorts of mechatronics to create our own automation and bots. Software's free and hardware is cheap. What will so many people with so much free time on their hands, and with needs that are unfulfilled, do?

Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by freeflight on Sunday September 10, 2017 @04:09AM (#15211284)
> Software's free and hardware is cheap.

Imho that hardware part really depends on scale. As nice as the thought might be, I doubt there are enough resources on Earth for a future where 8 billion people live a leisurely first world lifestyle in their smart homes with IT gadgets all around them, while robots take care of all the manual labor that needs to be done.

All that hardware requires resources and those resources are finite, at least on that little piece of rock we like to call Earth. As of right now that's pretty much the current ceiling for humanities progress and it ain't a very high one.

Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by adrianN on Sunday September 10, 2017 @03:59AM (#15211257)
The train conductor that has been driving trains for twenty years is very unlikely to pick up the latest AI framework and become a software engineer.
Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by jon_richards on Saturday September 09, 2017 @11:29PM (#15210424)
The comparison I like to use is horses. Horses used to be used for all sorts of things. When steam engines first started pumping water out of mines, they were given a "horse power" measurement of how many horses they could replace for the job, but they still couldn't replace horses for everything. It didn't take long for other, specialized machines to replace almost every other need for a horse. Now they are essentially novelties. You'll occasionally pay extra for a worse experience because it's fun and novel. The exact same will happen with human interaction. It's already started with "hand woven" and the like.
Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by 0xBA5ED on Saturday September 09, 2017 @11:40PM (#15210458)
This has been my thought. There will probably be markets for businesses with "human staff". It's along the same lines as getting business for being environmentally friendly.
Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by everheardofc on Sunday September 10, 2017 @07:42AM (#15211783)
>"Is there anything I could get paid to do that a machine couldn't do?".

Work for free or even pay for the privilege of working. See some short distance truck drivers working 20 hours a day making losses on some weeks after paying for their truck lease and other costs that were externalised from the employer to the employee. You can't exploit a robot but you can exploit a human.

Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by AndrewKemendo on Sunday September 10, 2017 @09:27AM (#15212127)
You can't exploit a robot but you can exploit a human.

That's a bold philosophical statement about the nature and uniqueness of man.

Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by neilwilson on Sunday September 10, 2017 @02:14AM (#15210982)
New jobs always come into existence. Everybody needs something to do with their day, and a job is just the work you do during the day.

The question is

(i) who is going to pay you to do your work during the day, and (ii) will the rest of society accept that it is work of a type that fulfils the reciprocity requirement.

Without both of those the machines won't be ordered to produce anything by those who run and operate them.

We expect to receive something of value in return for the machine's output.

Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by freeflight on Sunday September 10, 2017 @03:55AM (#15211253)
> The change that I continue to watch for is not when robots are used to do an undesirable job, but instead they are used to do a desirable one.

Like working in high-finance? A sector that's been overtaken by algorithms pretty much the earliest among all the industries. Imho "the machines" have already "won", humans are mostly mere cogs in a whole collection of systems which see planet Earth as a gigantic perpetual "economic engine" in need of constant acceleration, or else it might come crashing down all around us.

Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by chuckdries on Sunday September 10, 2017 @06:45AM (#15211643)
Got a link to that twitter list?
Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by ChuckMcM on Sunday September 10, 2017 @11:07AM (#15212494)
Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by QAPereo on Saturday September 09, 2017 @05:27PM (#15209239)
I think that intelligent people have always observed that human beings are their own worst enemy most of the time. Outside of extreme cases like the great plague of Europe, human history has mostly been a history of humans being the major threat to other humans. People noted how warfare was democratized with the advent of the pile head crossbow, and it's true they panicked. The same thing kept happening, warfare kept becoming broader, the means to kill increasingly democratized, and every step along the way people panicked and thought that this was the end.

Then we developed nuclear weapons, and everyone finally realized the end was in sight, no need to panic, the threat was finally existential and real. Our response to this realization was to mutually stockpile enough nuclear weapons to destroy most human life and all human civilization many times over. Still, like the crossbow nuclear weapons have not totally destabilized society, and now intellectual people are looking for the next threat, and for the first time all of them are potentially world ending. That doesn't mean the world will end, as we've seen many times in the past, but as you say the gap is narrowing, and we're never going back to a time and we don't have the means to actually end it all.

I think people worry about robots because it's the most comfortable thing to worry about, compared to nukes and climate change at least.

Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by chongli on Sunday September 10, 2017 @09:35AM (#15212160)
The next great threat will take the destructive potential of the nuke and democratize it like the crossbow. Perhaps it'll be some sort of biotech. Maybe a "desktop 3D printer" for synthetic organisms. This could allow somebody with little more than a high school biology education to download a template and "print" some weaponized anthrax.

I have no idea how we'll survive that.

Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by petra on Sunday September 10, 2017 @10:02AM (#15212247)
In that kind of world, deep surveillance and maybe mind control seem like the only option.

Or an alternative(maybe): all technologies will be inside highly regulated environments.building a 3d printer from scratch is really hard.

Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by chongli on Sunday September 10, 2017 @10:13AM (#15212286)
building a 3d printer from scratch is really hard

It definitely is right now. Suppose for a moment that a 3D printer were invented that could turn raw materials into perfect copies of itself. Suppose also that the raw materials could be automatically extracted from household and electronic waste. A machine that can turn garbage into copies of itself and other objects with similar complexity to the original machine.

The only remaining obstacle would be software (and data files). If we are to assume that machine learning and AI progress in parallel to the development of such a machine, it's difficult to see how we could ever prevent somebody from putting the pieces together.

Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by QAPereo on Sunday September 10, 2017 @10:36AM (#15212370)
Change your paradigm from tech to biology, and you just described an engineered pathogen. I don't know about 3D printers, but gene sequencers and the rest of the tools needed for a garage-plague are nearly here on a global scale.
Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by chongli on Sunday September 10, 2017 @12:55PM (#15213043)
My original point about the 3D printer was meant to be an analogy. You are right about the approaching danger. I don't know what we'll do. We may end up in a society under permanent quarantine. An Orwellian nightmare with justification.
Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by howlin on Sunday September 10, 2017 @12:37PM (#15212937)
The other option is to decentralize. As long as there are no major population concentrations, there are no super desirable terror targets. That could keep the casualties small and containable. I suspect the million-plus metropolis will be going out of fashion once the threats are better understood.
Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by petra on Saturday September 09, 2017 @05:18PM (#15209204)
In a sense technology have already conquered sex: in japan ~15% of young males say they "have no interest in sex",probably because of porn and the complexities of human relationships.

As for the meme about man's creations killing their maker, with an ever growing power of technology, statistically, isn't it just a matter of time ?

Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by freeflight on Sunday September 10, 2017 @04:40AM (#15211366)
It's phenomena like hikikomori, social shutouts who can't cope with the immense pressure of Japanese societal hierarchy, which has become a far more viable lifestyle (than it already had been) due to advances in technology.

Along with that came the emergence of the "herbivore men" in Japanese society, partly also a reaction to the immense pressure put on Japanese men to be "successful" in an economy that can't supply "successful jobs" to everybody. Japanese men pretty much invented that whole mgtow-thing before it became popular.

The scary angle is a comparison with John Calhoun's Mouse Utopia experiment [2].

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hikikomori

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herbivore_men

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Z760XNy4VM

Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by sillysaurus3 on Saturday September 09, 2017 @08:32PM (#15209853)
That 15% figure seems dubious. It's a primal desire. It may have just been a polite response.
Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by falcor84 on Saturday September 09, 2017 @09:55PM (#15210112)
I would argue that the actual primal desire is for sexual gratification, while sexual intercourse is just one way to do so. The way I see it, masturbation is perhaps the quintessential hack, in the sense of achieving a desired outcome while bypassing the "designed" mechanism.
Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by sillysaurus3 on Saturday September 09, 2017 @10:15PM (#15210193)
That's probably true. Many animals can't.
Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by eanzenberg on Sunday September 10, 2017 @02:16AM (#15210989)
Those acts aren't nearly equal.. if they were there'd be no humans to speak of.
Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by freeflight on Sunday September 10, 2017 @04:23AM (#15211323)
These acts are pretty much equal in terms of biological reactions and processes. Your hormones/instincts don't care where you "put your load", they only care that you did and normalized hormone levels.

It's also not something unique to humans, lots of other animals hump inanimate objects due to reproductive drive/hormonal urges, some primate species are actually quite infamous for their "lewd behavior".

Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by stephengillie on Sunday September 10, 2017 @07:48AM (#15211807)
A lot of people have had a dog hump their leg.
Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by dageshi on Sunday September 10, 2017 @02:48AM (#15211070)
Japans population is declining and has been for a while now...

In a country where they have a word for the extremely socially withdrawn (Hikikomori), I could believe that 15% number. Not because those people wouldn't want a partner but simply because they believe their chances of getting one are 0% (and in their mind it's not worth trying).

Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by Animats on Saturday September 09, 2017 @04:58PM (#15209122)
I wonder where the tipping point will be where, say, about as many people are gay as are robophile.

Now that's a interesting observation.

It might happen in China first, which has about a 1.3 to 1 ratio of marriage-age men to women and a big electronic gadget industry.

Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by eanzenberg on Sunday September 10, 2017 @02:15AM (#15210983)
Really though, sex dolls? Anything that's been engrained into our reptilian brains over 3.5 billion years of evolution will be the last thing an artificial process can mimic.
Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by drewrv on Sunday September 10, 2017 @02:33AM (#15211032)
I would bet on a technology that appeals to that reptilian brain while limiting negative consequences. Artificial sweeteners are certainly popular.
Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by IanCal on Sunday September 10, 2017 @03:45AM (#15211217)
There's a pretty large market for inanimate blocks of silicone shaped like various body parts already.
Re:Robots Still Haven’t Taken Over: A brief history of machi... by omginternets on Sunday September 10, 2017 @07:26AM (#15211745)
That same reasoning could be applied to motion pictures.