News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Virginia has decertified its most hackable voting machines by umanwizard on Friday September 08, 2017 @11:55PM (#15205485)
Why the fuck do we need to vote on machines, anyway? I don't understand this.

Many other countries use paper ballots, including highly developed ones (e.g., France, UK...)

Re:Virginia has decertified its most hackable voting machines by rdtsc on Saturday September 09, 2017 @12:07AM (#15205517)
Usually governor has a friend who just happens to own a company which makes and sells voting machines. All of the sudden the state "needs" voting machines.
Re:Virginia has decertified its most hackable voting machines by cmrajan on Saturday September 09, 2017 @12:58AM (#15205625)
Voting on the machines per se is not the problem, rather the current system is. In India electronic voting machines are exclusively used for all state and national elections and were kept deliberately non-networked by design.IIRC the technology is being 'exported' to other countries as well. http://www.firstpost.com/india/evm-tampering-why-india-stand...
Re:Virginia has decertified its most hackable voting machines by cafard on Tuesday September 12, 2017 @08:53AM (#15226843)
Because it is part of the American mind to believe in technology. (Often a larger part, the less that one knows about the technology.)

One thing I will say is that the US often has a lot more offices on the ballot than some other counties. In Washington, DC, a ballot can include Advisory Neighborhood Commissioner (somebody representing an area of a maybe twenty blocks), city council member, school board member, mayor, non-voting delegate to congress, and depending on the year "shadow senator" and president. In other places one may have county commissioners, judges, sheriffs, etc. That does make for a lot of tabulation.

Re:Virginia has decertified its most hackable voting machines by jlgaddis on Saturday September 09, 2017 @12:07AM (#15205514)
Because we're becoming lazier with each passing day?

I do think we need paper -- a "hard copy" -- at some level, whether for the ballot itself or just a verifiable audit trail. I think 100% electronic voting would be fine so long as there's an audit trail that matches the (electronically) talkied results perfectly. I don't think dealing with millions of paper ballots would be any more advantageous than that -- you'd have to distribute and collect them (although that would happen at the centralized polling places), a few people would have to hand tally them (to ensure everyone's numbers match up), and then securely store them (via very strict "physical security" procedures/protocols) until, at some later point, they can be properly destroyed.

Logistically, electronic voting with a paper audit trail would be much easier, would require fewer people (i.e., election workers -- who are already in short supply), would give us results much quicker, and would be easier to verify/authenticate later (in the event of disputes).

Re:Virginia has decertified its most hackable voting machines by umanwizard on Saturday September 09, 2017 @12:10AM (#15205523)
Yeah sure there are some rube goldberg schemes you can concoct like printing a hard copy or whatever, where electronic voting might be secure.

But... why? What is the point of adding all this complexity? What problem is electronic voting solving?

Re:Virginia has decertified its most hackable voting machines by jlgaddis on Saturday September 09, 2017 @12:17AM (#15205534)
Sorry, after posting my comment, I went back and elaborated a bit and just so happened to address the questions you asked in the meantime.
Re:Virginia has decertified its most hackable voting machines by umanwizard on Saturday September 09, 2017 @12:26AM (#15205547)
> Logistically, electronic voting with a paper audit trail would be much easier,

Putting a piece of paper in a box is something everyone understands how to do, even elderly people who have never touched a computer -- how is electronic voting easier?

> would require fewer people (i.e., election workers -- who are already in short supply)

They are? I can't believe it would be more expensive to hire a few more election workers for one day than we're paying for these machines.

> would give us results much quicker,

France uses paper ballots and results are known within hours.

> and would be easier to verify/authenticate later (in the event of disputes).

This is not realistic. We are never going to go back and change an election result whether or not records of the votes were saved. Cf. Florida 2000.

Re:Virginia has decertified its most hackable voting machines by stenius on Saturday September 09, 2017 @12:36AM (#15205577)
Even with electric voting, there are 2 witnesses who's duties are to just watch the election IIRC. FYI: I've done this before and got paid about $10 an hour to do it several years ago while I was in college.

Part of the witness duties should be making sure the votes for that polling location are counted accurately and there is no way to do that with electric voting systems. It's just a black box you have to trust.

Re:Virginia has decertified its most hackable voting machines by hdctambien on Saturday September 09, 2017 @01:13AM (#15205664)
Hanging Chads. See: the year 2000.
Re:Virginia has decertified its most hackable voting machines by umanwizard on Saturday September 09, 2017 @02:00AM (#15205764)
Hanging chads were a problem because we tried to use machine-readable ballots. That's the whole point.

Here's a better system: you go into the voting booth. They have some envelopes and stacks of preprinted ballots, each with one candidate's name. You take a ballot for the candidate you want, and put it in the envelope. Then you come out of the booth and drop the sealed envelope in a box.

After polls close, they open the box and all the envelopes, and count the ballots, in the open. Anyone can go watch. If an envelope is empty or has more than one ballot inside, the vote doesn't count.

Re:Virginia has decertified its most hackable voting machines by dragonwriter on Saturday September 09, 2017 @02:11AM (#15205788)
> Here's a better system: you go into the voting booth. They have some envelopes and stacks of preprinted ballots, each with one candidate's name. You take a ballot for the candidate you want, and put it in the envelope. Then you come out of the booth and drop the sealed envelope in a box.

Works well for elections with one race; those with a dozen offices being elected and an equal number of ballot measures make that... impractical.

Re:Virginia has decertified its most hackable voting machines by fabian2k on Saturday September 09, 2017 @02:37AM (#15205847)
This is the system used in Germany, all votes are hand-counted. And it's also used for very complicated local elections that allow very fine-grained votes for individual candidates.

In extreme cases you get huge ballots with this system, see e.g. (http://www.faz.net/aktuell/rhein-main/frankfurter-wahlzettel...) for Frankfurt with a ~0.9 square meter ballot.

Counting by hand still works even for those over-complicated ballots.

Re:Virginia has decertified its most hackable voting machines by dragonwriter on Sunday September 10, 2017 @01:06AM (#15210747)
The size of the ballots isn't the issue; the issue with “provide pre-marked ballots from which the voter chooses the one matching their preferences and discards the rest” for multi-race elections is the number of pre-printed ballots that have to be given to each voter to take to the booth and select from.

With 5 offices with 6 candidates each and 10 yes/no measures (a fairly modest ballot for a California election) this would require each voter be handed a packet of nearly eight million ballots to choose from.

This is clearly not practical.

Re:Virginia has decertified its most hackable voting machines by germanier on Saturday September 09, 2017 @08:07AM (#15206700)
I don't know about that specific one but elections with complicated rules and multiple votes (where you can "kumulieren" and "panaschieren") are usually counted with the help of software where the election officers manually enter every ballot into the computer after inspecting it visually and have to trust that the displayed end result is correct (although there are some manual consistency checks).
Re:Virginia has decertified its most hackable voting machines by thanksgiving on Saturday September 09, 2017 @06:22AM (#15206396)
Re:Virginia has decertified its most hackable voting machines by nerfhammer on Saturday September 09, 2017 @01:01AM (#15205633)
It needs to be advanced and expensive to show how important we think it is.