News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by grondilu on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @03:53PM (#15186607)
In the long term, we're all dead.

Call me selfish, but I personally don't worry about the future of humanity in thousands of years. I'm sure most people don't either.

A kid born in the year 10,000 is a stranger to me. Sure, people can feel concerned about his fate, just as people can feel concerned about a stranger in a foreign country, but most people just don't. We're all selfish bastards.

Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by hwillis on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @04:28PM (#15186867)
I genuinely feel horrified by that. Like, it legitimately alarms me in the same way I'd be alarmed to find out everyone else in a room with me is a psychopath. I'm not very personally frightened to think that most people would be fine with me being hurt- it's not an imminent threat.

I still feel a deep discomfort from the idea that people could just be okay with people suffering. Obviously this is more acute with people in other countries than people who do not yet exist, and I have some allowance for laziness. But... people are genuinely fine with the idea that people starve to death? That's horrifying.

Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by mmirate on Thursday September 07, 2017 @10:07AM (#15191946)
On the contrary. I can't imagine experiencing the emotions of all the people in 10000AD; at our current population growth rate, 10000AD will witness an unfathomable number of human beings! Being concerned about all those people is far too much emotional stress for any one mind.

(Of course, experiencing others' emotions can in general be debilitating. Obviously, then, experiencing trillions of others' emotions would be trillionsfold worse.)

Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by hwillis on Thursday September 07, 2017 @01:02PM (#15193720)
I mean for people you havent and never will meet; I can somewhat understand for people that dont actually exist yet.

I'm not thinking of personally being aware of them and i can even rationalize not finding strangers to be tangible. I understand the bystander effect and all that. There are any number of ways I can accept not doing anything, but the idea that someone could legitimately just not care is deeply unsettling.

Like, for the bystander effect to apply a person has to care and then think "someone should do something". Its the idea that someone can instead just not care even superficially that is disturbing.

Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by notyourday on Thursday September 07, 2017 @01:41PM (#15194074)
> Like, for the bystander effect to apply a person has to care and then think "someone should do something". Its the idea that someone can instead just not care even superficially that is disturbing.

To me, the idea that someone think "someone should do something" about that "something" is disturbing.

But this is HN, the place where those that make $100k/year a more wax poetically about the plight of poor people in third world countries while munching on the cheese and drinking the wine thinking that it is the waxing that counts.

Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by ThomPete on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @06:47PM (#15187758)
Thats the wrong way to look at it IMO.

The question is before you even start throwing the moral gauntlet on other people, what are you doing about it? Now you might be doing something but then the question is whether you are actually doing something about it.

There are plenty of arguments for why ex. doing NGO work or sponsoring a child is doing more harm than good and actually hurting. So I wouldn't be so fast to cast judgement.

I don't think you find many people who don't care about other people suffering intellectually. The question is whether they are choosing to suffer more others to suffer less.

Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by hwillis on Thursday September 07, 2017 @01:12PM (#15193811)
Thats a tu quoque fallacy[1] and also fails on a couple levels to address what I mean.

First off I'm not making a moral judgement, and I'm not talking about actions at all. I'm not even trying to judge them at all. They made an assertion about humanity and i find that assertion alarming, but i didnt try to reflect it on them and stayed as impersonal as I could.

Its the intentions i was concerned about, not the effects. They were describing people who dont even care intellectually- thats freaky to think about.

[1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tu_quoque

Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by ThomPete on Thursday September 07, 2017 @01:38PM (#15194050)
The point I was trying to make is maybe you and the parent aren't that different you just talk about it different ways.
Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by dionidium on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @05:34PM (#15187314)
Consider that apathy and ambivalence are an enormous improvement over the abject animosity, antipathy, and aversion in-groups have felt toward out-groups for most of human history.

This represents improvement.

Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by stdbrouw on Thursday September 07, 2017 @04:03AM (#15189905)
> I still feel a deep discomfort from the idea that people could just be okay with people suffering.

But future people don't exist. If a nuclear holocaust wipes us all out, they will never exist, and hence will never suffer. So really it depends on whether you consider "the continued existence of the human race" to be a moral imperative or whether you don't.

Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by NiklasMort on Thursday September 07, 2017 @08:05AM (#15191019)
The state of the world proves to you that basically everybody is a "psychopath". We are all self obsessed and our empathy barely reaches to our next door neighbor. The world is a mad house, is this really news to you?
Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by akvadrako on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @05:44PM (#15187360)
You shouldn't be alarmed about people being psychopaths, because as you see empathy doesn't get you very far. To reliably care about the far future, it has to be a rational decision, not an emotional one.
Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by Zhyl on Thursday September 07, 2017 @05:52AM (#15190311)
You may be interested in this article [1] by David Wong (author of 'John Dies at the end'). It pretty much sums up the attitude in the parent comment and why, to a greater or lesser extent, we are all subject to it.

[1] http://www.cracked.com/article_14990_what-monkeysphere.html/

Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by glenstein on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @05:32PM (#15187297)
You've put your finger on a very important point. It's a point that some of the most important ethicists (Parfit, Singer) in recent history have focused on, namely the deficit in empathy we have for individuals who are distant from us whether it be in space or time.

Progressing beyond this is one of the important moral challenges faced by humanity.

Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by default-kramer on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @05:45PM (#15187366)
But trying to empathize with someone who is going to live thousands of years from now seems like designing software based on speculative requirements changes. You end up with a custom DSL for a custom rules engine and only 2 rules ever got written with it. Except that predicting what humanity will be like in 1000 years is harder than predicting what your software will be like in 10 years.
Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by HillRat on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @06:31PM (#15187669)
A rule I would consider would be that any decision should, all else being equal, maximize the degrees of freedom available to other persons relative to other exclusionary options. Obviously, this would require quite a bit of further discussion and fleshing out as to its precise meaning, but I'd take it as a starting point for philosophical analysis.
Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by glenstein on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @07:33PM (#15187992)
True, we can't make predictions in the form of hyperparticularizations. But we can make predictions in broad strokes about industrialization and ecology and how our current behaviors will serve the welfare of future generations in those respects.
Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by dharma1 on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @06:38PM (#15187705)
Empathy, thinking about the near-term future or past, worrying - all products of evolution, traits that have helped us enough in the past to have been selected for.

There has been no evolutionary pressure to develop much of a concern beyond one or two generations.

And evolution hasn't equipped us with reward pathways or cognitive capacity to solve many of the problems now facing us and our surroundings - because those problems are new

Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by jolmg on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @05:48PM (#15187386)
I guess I can sort of understand the sentiment of not caring much for the individuals of humanity, but there is a difference between that and not caring about humanity as a whole, as the species, as the beings that, as more time and generations go by, understand more about the universe and find ways to do what was previously thought to be impossible. Doesn't it excite you what humanity might accomplish with more time? Doesn't it disappoint you that they might lose everything they've accomplished through millenia of work simply because of carelessness of previous generations?

I believe humanity could survive longer if people only cared enough to prepare for disasters they know will come, even if it's multiple generations into the future. This is like humanity is one big human procastinating. Some things can only be accomplished if you prepare for them with time.

Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by nkurz on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @05:57PM (#15187456)
Call me selfish, but I personally don't worry about the future of humanity in thousands of years.

Well, how many years ahead are you willing to worry? 10? 100? It sounds like you might be saying that you don't put much weight on the future of humanity on any timescale, and worry only about things that affect you personally. If so, then yes, I'd say that is the definition of selfish.

I'm sure most people don't either.

It might look this way, but what makes you sure that this is true of "most people", rather than just some people in some societies?

We're all selfish bastards.

I don't think this is true.

Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by VeronicaJJ123 on Thursday September 07, 2017 @07:53AM (#15190929)
> , but what makes you sure that this is true of "most people",

The climate change bandwagon is joined only by tiny Europe and some parts of America. We Indians or our Chinese neighbors don't care much about global warming and will never care of course unless until we can guilt trip the rich nations into giving us money to do something in that case it is a good deal at the expense of people like you.

India + China is approx 1/3rd of world population. I think that should qualify for "most people".

Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by grondilu on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @09:38PM (#15188541)
> Well, how many years ahead are you willing to worry? 10? 100?

Let me reverse the question : how many years ahead is enough for you not to worry? A million years? Fifty billions? Do you worry about the ultimate fate of the universe[1]?

It's pretty clear to me that, all other things being equal, events tend to matter less and less as they are occurring further and further into the future. That's why, for instance, most young people don't worry much about death, unless they're told it will happen soon.

I don't have an accurate way to measure it, but to me, once you start talking about thousands of years, it's such a far future that I don't worry about it.

> but what makes you sure that this is true of "most people",

People are anxious or obsessed about many things, but I very rarely hear anyone whining about the future of the World in geological time scales. There is of course the famous exception of the young Woody Halen in Annie Hall[2], but it's a comical scene precisely for this reason : most people don't worry about these stuff.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultimate_fate_of_the_universe

2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Pa34orcwwA

Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by nkurz on Thursday September 07, 2017 @01:35AM (#15189351)
Let me reverse the question: how many years ahead is enough for you not to worry?

A fair question. I'm not worried by the heat death of the universe, as I'm fairly certain that any action I take during my life will have no effect on it. I can't really picture the difference between a million years and a billion, so they don't really concern me, although I don't have a logical explanation for this.

My actual concerns vary between the 100 to 10,000 year time frame. I'm periodically incapacitated by my inability to find a convincing counterargument to the Great Filter theory, whereby the reason we haven't ever ever encountered aliens is because all civilizations collapse before achieving interstellar travel. While I'm doubtful that I can personally do anything to prevent this eventuality, when I do have hope, it's that I can make it slightly less likely or less catastrophic.

There is of course the famous exception of the young Woody Halen in Annie Hall[2], but it's a comical scene precisely for this reason : most people don't worry about these stuff.

Thanks for the link, although I find it more bittersweet than straightforwardly humorous. Having had similar failed conversations with psychological professionals over the years, I sympathize with young Alvy. I can say from experience that trying to explain your concerns about the 1000 year time frame doesn't go over any better.

Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by nsxwolf on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @06:10PM (#15187545)
Let's put it this way - I won't sacrifice something my child needs for the benefit of someone who will be born in the year 10000. I care about that far future person in an abstract way. Maybe I'll buy an electric car and feel a bit better about those future people. But I definitely care more immediately and viscerally for the here and now.
Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by Pica_soO on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @08:47PM (#15188341)
I welcome your honesty.

Its also one of the reasons, why i like family fathers and mothers so much- even though most of them vote conservative. There is something selfish, that wants to see that the selfishness last forever. Thats why those future persons need a spokesman, a long term selfish bastard/algorithm, who is able to veto on short-term behavior that is ultimative self-destructive.

The problem here is, that with such a control mechanism, its easy to go idealistic and try to "patch" humanity up while your at it- ending up with something, somialhinn, socialism. So the patching up process, known as government, needs a reality check to prevent a run-a-way - and balances, to prevent a lock-out of the living from base resources and short term solutions on the way to long term solutions. Some flaws might be unfixable, and only work arounds will prevent them from flaring up again and again.

For example i can not get this generation to worry about the earth of tomorrows temperature.

The obvious solution would be to have a Future-Gen-House-of-Parliament veto on all usage of coal and oil. Leading to a total standstill. Thus the future-gen, could be bargained with- give us oil for another generation, and we will trade you in Carbon-Emission-Taxes and the development of fusion.

I dont claim to have a answer here, but it would be nice if there was some modeling software on how to build a better government here- including a simulation on how to reign in corroding elements like financially well endowed industries and tax-strained voters.

Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by rabidrat on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @11:57PM (#15189044)
I love this idea. We have representatives for space, so why shouldn't we have representatives for time as well? A representative for the past would be welcome as well. Maybe preservationists try to hold on to the past, and conservatives hold down the present, while progressivists spend on the future.
Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by dvdhnt on Thursday September 07, 2017 @01:53AM (#15189412)
This would be impossible. We can't accurately speculate what values will be important to future people any more than we can discern what a cow is thinking.
Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by rabidrat on Thursday September 07, 2017 @11:16AM (#15192599)
Oh, good point! We should definitely have representatives for other species too.
Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by stcredzero on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @05:56PM (#15187444)
A kid born in the year 10,000 is a stranger to me. Sure, people can feel concerned about his fate, just as people can feel concerned about a stranger in a foreign country, but most people just don't. We're all selfish bastards.

There is quite a bit of mental variation. One of the rarest qualities I have found in people is the ability to connect abstractions to feelings. I once dated a woman who would sometimes get angry at me because she was mistaken. That is fine, as we are all human, sometimes one makes mistakes. However, she would stay angry at me even when I exonerated myself factually. I should've taken that as an early sign and bailed out of that relationship much sooner!

When hiring someone for a startup or choosing a co-founder, I would recommend that one look for this quality.

This is related to something I heard on "Fresh Air." The author of this book had a "bad boss" character who kept on calling things a "dog whistle." As far as he was concerned, a phenomenon he couldn't directly perceive might as well not exist. Such an idea strikes me as a degree of idiocy that makes me angry. The physical phenomenon of sound waves at higher than 20 kHz is a physical fact! Denying the truth of an objective fact because of a shortsighted prioritization of one's limited subjective point of view -- this is exactly the kind of thing that can get one in trouble, if one is doing substantive knowledge work!

Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by kakarot on Thursday September 07, 2017 @11:35AM (#15192799)
To provide a bit of contrast, I have near-zero interest in the human condition over the next few generations (with the exception of the development of a few technologies) and am only really interested in where humanity could be in another 10,000 years and how I can help to make sure we get there.

Everybody's different, it doesn't do well to derive generalizations of society from your own internal conclusions.

Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by musage on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @06:06PM (#15187517)
I care about others because I care about the person I am.

> A kid born in the year 10,000 is a stranger to me.

And if treated with a modicum of attention and love, it will be much wiser than you before it even enters school. Rationalizing having given up, and pretending everybody has, comes way after that.

Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by notyourday on Thursday September 07, 2017 @01:51PM (#15194154)
> I care about others because I care about the person I am.

When someone says that I ask them "Have you donated everything you made this month above the poverty level in your country to some kids who can't afford to eat say in Bangladesh per chance or its equivalent?" They typically respond with a "No" followed by a very convoluted explanation why it is the empathy that matters as in their view situational empathy should stop the moment such actions inconvenience them.

Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by musage on Friday September 08, 2017 @07:48AM (#15199493)
> "Have you donated everything you made this month above the poverty level in your country to some kids who can't afford to eat say in Bangladesh per chance or its equivalent?"

> the moment such actions inconvenience them

That's "not even silly", the threshold for "inconvenience" begins way earlier. And "caring for others" doesn't mean not caring for oneself, I'm also one of those other people, if you will. And your need to somehow disprove the empathy, love and/or generosity of everybody else, with such cheap sophistry to boot, says more about you than about the people you know nothing about. If you're looking for convolution, you might want to also look into that.

And why does caring for others only requiring those who get oppressed, and not attacking their oppressors? Give a man a fish, and he has a fish. Denazify the world and he has a place to raise kids in. Everybody has their own views what caring and doing good means, and comforting a bullied person ranks way lower for me than dealing with the bully. I wouldn't answer "no" and squirm, I'd laugh in your face.

Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by jimmyk on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @05:02PM (#15187110)
Would it change things for you if that kid was your descendant?
Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by dionidium on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @06:20PM (#15187598)
That's an interesting question. My gut reaction is that it doesn't make any emotional difference to me.
[dead]
Re:Why the long-term future of humanity matters more than an... by pheldagryph on Thursday September 07, 2017 @08:52AM (#15191347)
> I think it is incredible arrogant to even assume that we can have any impact on future that distant.

If we're not impacting it... then who is?