What are the chances that the self reported 18-24 group is full of younger teenagers and kids?
Just like the age checks on Youtube or Steam.
I'm 101 years old, per Valve's superior analytics :)
How? Clicking an ad would lead you to a CAPTCHA before going to the target site?
That's some funny pseudo code. The assumption being they can write an is_bot function that is reliable.
if (is_bot_probability >= 90%) { charge = 0 }
Lots of grade school aged kids have an alternate Facebook - one for parents/grandparents/relatives, one more locked down for their friends.
Folks who have to be on FB for work often make a second, work-only account. I still see plenty of small businesses running a "personal" profile instead of a page.
I've mostly seen this with occultists and LBGT community, though I have seen a few artists do the same just to keep fans and intimate folks separate. Understandable, since simply saying one has had a bad day at work can be taken as a personal insult by some (I've seen it happen).
I don't rely on those numbers for anything critical as getting benchmarks from a live test is really the best way to go about it.
I would never trust the numbers reported in any ad interface to accurately reflect reality. But, why should I care if it reflects objective reality? I'm only trying to get X conversions for $Y.
For me, building the "fraud" or poor accounting into my economic model is how you play the game. I don't care if FB sends me 500 visits at $1 each, with 20% bots. I just care that I spent $500, for $conversion_result.
People who do branding campaigns may feel differently because they're reporting on how many humans saw their message. I don't think that's a big deal, but I also think branding campaigns are a waste of money anyhow.
However branding campaigns definitely can work, they are just hard as hell to measure somewhat accurately without LOTS of budget, fancy software, focus groups and statistical modeling. You need a large amount of data to notice the needle moving, and that just isn't always feasible.
Assuming that Facebook isn't lying, and they actually see as many accounts as they claim to reach this data would suggest that at least 25% of the accounts on Facebook are alt accounts or bot accounts. And that is assuming that everyone in the target demographic who was in the census is on Facebook. Facebook must be greater than 25% bots.