News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by delegate on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @09:45AM (#15183593)
Bitcoin and other crypto require a well functioning internet infrastructure, otherwise it's just data on a hard-drive.

Disconnect a country from the Internet (or filter the traffic) and you're forking the chain. Spend on both networks by buying other (unfiltered) crypto. There are states (even large ISPs) that can do that.

Also, the first thing to go in case of global conflict is the global Internet. Countries will try to damage opponent's internet links to gain strategic advantage.

Crypto currencies will be useless in this case, losing all of their value.

There's always the concern of a bug in the protocol, a solution to the hash function or plain old human stupidity that can crash the currency.

I guess my point is: be careful, this is still very much experimental, don't invest everything you have in them.

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by gldalmaso on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @10:08AM (#15183769)
I think you have a valid point, but, ultimately aren't all or most trades digital today?

Are countries exchanging actual loads of gold and/or cash around? If the answer is no, then isn't it all just data on a hard-drive?

In that case damaging internet links will have the same effect all around, though information can probably still go in/out in different ways with some effort. Is there some aspect of crypto currency that makes it different (honest question)?

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by simias on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @10:42AM (#15184053)
The difference IMO is that gold has intrinsic value by virtue of being rare and shiny. I guess the idea is that even if civilization collapses and we return to the stone age gold will still be valuable. Since the use of gold as currency can be traced back at least to 600BCE[1] there's a good reason to believe that.

Bitcoins however doesn't really have a intrinsic "rest" value. Anybody can (and many do) spawn a new blockchain out of thin air. Ironically Bitcoin is entirely about trust at the core. The trust that the other participants in the bitcoin economy won't lose faith in the currency and dump it. That trust is the only thing that gives the coin value.

[1] http://rg.ancients.info/lion/article.html

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by acdha on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @11:04AM (#15184224)
Similarly, national currencies have a value because governments collect taxes and pay for things using those currencies so there's a considerable inertial force encouraging their usage.

That doesn't mean that failure is impossible but it smooths out a lot of minor fluctuations whereas, as you pointed out, if a Bitcoin competitor took off tomorrow there's no pressure not to adopt it instead other than the sunk costs which a small percentage of the general population has.

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by ericb on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @01:08PM (#15185267)
I don't think it is that simple. Bitcoin has 3 main advantages that can't be easily taken away from it that make things harder for competitors:

1 - Distribution (Metcalfe's law):

Metcalfe's law states that the value of a telecommunications network is proportional to the square of the number of connected users of the system (n2).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metcalfe%27s_law

2- Schelling Point

Bitcoin is the natural Schelling point for those drawn to the advantages of cryptographic money.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Focal_point_(game_theory)

3 - Most battle-tested codebase. No cryptocurrency has been successfully operating for as long.

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by acdha on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @03:28PM (#15186430)
That's arguing that the past will be like the future when things are still really early. Statistically almost nobody owns or uses Bitcoin, especially when you subtract the Bitcoin proponents who do most of their transactions using something like a credit card which actually uses local currency via Visa or where Bitcoin is converted into real currency immediately by the recipient, and who thus would have very little switching converting to something else.

Ask how long either #1 or 2 would hold true if, say, a couple of large banks, Visa/Mastercard, Apple and/or Google, etc. launched a currency accessible to their existing customer bases. I'd give that a couple of days before Bitcoin would be a rounding error in the daily transaction volume.

The big long-term reason I expect that to happen is the deflation model baked into Bitcoin: every player which didn't acquire a substantial holding years ago has a huge incentive to find an alternative which doesn't mean they're putting effort into making someone else rich. Right now there's very little mainstream demand for Bitcoin but if that change it's hard to believe the finance people wouldn't be obsessed with ways to capture that revenue going to a third-party.

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by ericb on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @09:37PM (#15188537)
Coinbase has 10 million users, most of whom are there for bitcoin.
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by acdha on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @11:03PM (#15188879)
How many of them are active? How many hold non-trivial balances? Most importantly, how many sales would legal merchants lose if those users jumped ship or lost interest?

Again, my point is simply that there's little holding anyone who hasn't made a huge investment specifically in Bitcoin. If you have $10 equivalent sitting in an account and CitiCoin™ launches next week with attractive terms and mainstream merchant acceptance, are you going to think twice about bailing? Alternately, if law enforcement cracks down on the money laundering, etc. and prices drop, how many people will lose interest if it won't make them rich?

A key point here: of the comparatively few merchants who accept BTC, how many do their business primarily in Bitcoin and don't quickly convert to something else? That's the only group with a significant commitment to continued use; everyone else can switch on a whim.

That's the difference between a pure fiat currency like Bitcoin and something backed by a national government. Bitcoin has no inherent value beyond voluntary group consensus, which means that a panic, messy fork, or disinterest has no natural floor on how far it can fall. In contrast, USD are backed by one of the major world economies, hundreds of millions of people need them to pay taxes, and billions of dollars are paid to government employees, contracts, benefits, etc. Again, that's not immunity from problems but it's a huge inertial weight moderating swings.

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by ericb on Thursday September 07, 2017 @10:21AM (#15192070)
The backing and even the existence of the United States is also simply a matter of group consensus. It is turtles all the way down, my friend. We're just debating whose delusions are bigger and better.
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by acdha on Friday September 08, 2017 @07:37AM (#15199447)
Do you actually believe that false equivalence? It's like saying your two-person startup is basically the same as IBM because they're both companies.
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by lostmsu on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @09:59PM (#15188620)
If you can carry gold to another country, nothing will stop you from bringing a USB flash with new, longer Bitcoin blockchain, which includes your transaction to send BTC to the receiver.
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by prostoalex on Thursday September 07, 2017 @02:32AM (#15189547)
That's after you convince the rest of the operating nodes in that country that the blockchain version on your USB is indeed the greatest, and everyone should just migrate to that.
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by amluto on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @11:09AM (#15184264)
Conventional digital currencyish things (e.g. credit cards) have at least some tolerance to network partitions. Current blockchains fail rather catastrophically if partitions occur.
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by sametmax on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @10:45AM (#15184072)
Banks datacenters holding money are off the grid, and they have material goods for backing part of it.

It doesn't mean they would not be affected by internet going down. They would be hit hard. But they would not disapear.

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by ballenf on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @09:59AM (#15183688)
The fork concern is real, but the double-spend on both forks is less so. It would require the double-spender to have access to both networks. Which isn't that hard to see.

But, it wouldn't take too many parties having access to both networks to prevent the fork in the first place. The miners who control such things are very highly incentivized to keep their operation on the main or largest fork.

The alternative for the miners would be doing work on a fork that has the distinct risk of being worthless as soon as the network issues resolve.

There are very distinct risks. But ones that have "real world" parallels. Think bars of gold becoming less valuable than antibiotics now worth pennies. Or Marlboros. In the shit-hits-the-fan scenario, values of everything goes crazy not just cryptocurrencies. $1000 smartphones without electricity or networks become paperweights.

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by chinathrow on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @10:37AM (#15184015)
> The fork concern is real, but the double-spend on both forks is less so. It would require the double-spender to have access to both networks. Which isn't that hard to see.

Not hard at all. Have a second uplink to the world wide net, e.g. via sat.

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by Taek on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @03:10PM (#15186294)
Thing is, as long as there is one honest person with a connection to both networks, they can easily serve as a relay between them, and keep both networks fully synchronized.

If an attacker is on both networks and trying to double-spend, it's extremely likely that someone honest is also on both networks who is successfully keeping the two networks fully synchronized. In this type of situation, you can make yourself safe just by waiting for 4-6 confirmations instead of the usual 0-2 confirmations.

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by ballenf on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @11:05AM (#15184233)
Which is my point: if an interconnect is possible, miners are going to have a very high incentive to use it as well. Not just double-spenders. And it wouldn't take many miners doing it to prevent the fork in the first place.
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by kbody on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @11:07AM (#15184252)
I'll focus on one thing that's fitting and haven't been mentioned. It's about Opendime ( https://opendime.com/ ) which brands itself as a Bitcoin credit stick.

It's like a USB stick but it stores inside a Bitcoin private key that's not revealed to the user unless they visibly break a part of the stick. This basically allows you to "load" bitcoins on the stick and give to others while being relatively certain of the "transaction" while of course being offline.

I assume it's probably possible in theory that with an electronic microscope or something similar a skilled engineer will be able to read that private key, but I haven't read of any reports that it has happened yet, but it all depends on the value contained to make it worth the effort and even then we won't know.

This basically allows off-chain & off-internet transacting which is really cool and enables the use in some more cases.

Personally I know that Bitcoin is not perfect, it has strengths and weaknesses but it's good enough for a lot of use-cases at the moment and it will keep getting better. There are quite a lot of talented engineers & cryptographers actively working on Bitcoin and cryptocurrencies that will move things forward quite a lot. Unlike Gold, Bitcoin can be upgraded to do more thing and evolve, be it Bitcoin or some other cryptocurrency, unless we live on an age of having govs ban a technology it will find its place on our daily lives.

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by cesarb on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @11:40AM (#15184510)
So, it's a real life version of Shadowrun's Credsticks? (http://shadowrun.wikia.com/wiki/Credstick)
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by kbody on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @12:28PM (#15184917)
Indeed, iirc that was the idea/inspiration.
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by nullc on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @10:04AM (#15183731)
> Bitcoin and other crypto require a well functioning internet infrastructure, otherwise it's just data on a hard-drive. Disconnect a country from the Internet (or filter the traffic) and you're forking the chain.

Less so than in the past: https://blockstream.com/satellite/menu/

> I guess my point is: be careful, this is still very much experimental, don't invest everything you have in them.

Well, that much is obvious.

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by thisisit on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @10:53AM (#15184137)
I read about blockstream some time ago: https://www.coindesk.com/blockstream-using-satellites-beam-b...

Here Adam Back said: "With a perpetual generator out back with a satellite dish, a Raspberry Pi by the generator, a local wi-fi hot spot, and the necessary software set up, you could be transacting globally with bitcoin."

Anyone can explain me why is the need for a local wifi hot spot here? And how much does it normally cost to setup a satellite dish?

Not to mention countries do have the ability to jam satellite signals. Here's the first article I find on google search: http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/silencing-unwanted...

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by hossbeast on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @08:09PM (#15188179)
I assume that's just so you can run the wallet on your phone
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by simias on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @10:49AM (#15184105)
Having satellites broadcasting the blockchain is a good step to make the network resilient but it doesn't prevent governments messing with miners. A great disturbance would occur should china decide to unilaterally shutdown the miners on its territory for instance.

Furthermore unless I'm missing something these satellites broadcast the blockchain but don't relay new transactions. That means that if I'm stuck in some place without internet access I can use the satellite network to keep my copy of the blockchain up to date but I still can't make new transactions, effectively making it useless. I guess they could expand their services to allow for satellite transaction relay but that sounds very expensive.

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by kristineberth on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @11:26AM (#15184409)
> Disconnect a country from the Internet (or filter the traffic) and you're forking the chain.

Is this necessarily true? Forgive my ignorance but if we're talking Bitcoin, wouldn't the rest of the remaining miners around the world be able to account for this? And would the situation be meaningfully different in the country in question were China (or another of similar size/mining power)?

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by simias on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @11:58AM (#15184651)
I think you're replying to the wrong comment but to try and answer your question if a region is completely isolated from the rest of the bitcoin network one of two things can happen:

- If the region doesn't have a significant hash power (the case in most places in the world really) then the block rate will effectively go to zero, meaning that bitcoin will effectively "pause" here and be unusable until fresh blocks can be retrieved from the outside and new transactions broadcasted to the external miners.

- If the region has enough hash power to mine new blocks regularly the region will fork its chain. If it has more than 50% of the global hash rate this new chain will be the "real" one and will take over as soon as it's reunited with the rest of the network (invalidating the "outside" blockchain and all its transactions since the fork). If it has less than 50% hashrate then the opposite happens, as soon as the longer outside chain is received it'll invalidate the fork.

In both these situations bitcoin is effectively unusable in the minority fork since you know for a fact that the chain will be erased as soon as the network is reunited.

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by kristineberth on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @03:54PM (#15186620)
Gotcha, thank you for the explanation.
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by Taek on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @03:06PM (#15186257)
> Bitcoin and other crypto require a well functioning internet infrastructure, otherwise it's just data on a hard-drive.

Amazingly, not really. Bitcoin is a currency that's built to be disaster-proof, including world-ending scenarios like nuclear war between superpowers. You really just need 3 things:

1. A computer that can validate the chain.

2. The longest chain. This can be given to you via usb stick if the Internet is down.

3. Some way to send and receive blocks and transactions as the network continues building the longest chain.

A lot of work has gone into being able to achieve number 3 without full internet infrastructure. The example of a satellite beaming blocks to the world has already been brought up (though this is receive only, not send-capable for most people). However, people have also written software that can transmit blocks over HAM radio. You can't download the full blockchain over HAM relay, but you can relay blocks and transactions in real time, because the whole network is bottlenecked to about 2 MB per 10 minutes.

If you have wifi routers, you can set up point-to-point relay and broadcast systems as well. A point-to-point system can get well over 100 miles per hop. If the Interent were to suddenly fail, it may take a few weeks to connect everything together, but you could get Bitcoin up and running long before you could get anything like email working again.

> There are states (even large ISPs) that can do that.

While there are states that can split you from the main Internet, all you need is one relay that the state can't control to keep the Bitcoin network connected. It's not like a website where people have to keep asking a central server for data - once one person has relayed a block into an isolated network, the whole isolated network has that block. You can't keep the network isolated unless it's perfectly isolated, and on the scale of a country you are of course going to have people listening to the satellite broadcasts, setting up wifi relay points, or maybe even doing something less sophisticated like usb-smuggling which means it effectively takes a few days to be certain that a transaction has been confirmed by the broader network.

----------

TL;DR: Bitcoin is far more resilient than you give it credit, and it can survive the Internet going down. As long as you still have an ad-hoc way to transmit blocks to major areas, you can keep everyone fully in consensus. The infrastructure requirements of Bitcoin are far less than that of email, sms, or traditional website based, centralized infrastructure.

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by prostoalex on Thursday September 07, 2017 @02:37AM (#15189568)
> This can be given to you via usb stick if the Internet is down.

What's the verification mechanism if you're given two or three USB sticks all swearing they have the latest and greatest blockchain?

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by elevensies on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @11:01AM (#15184202)
This is something I've been wondering about. Maybe someone with more bitcoin expertise could answer.

Is there more mining capacity inside China than outside China?

If so, and the Chinese government used their well-known firewall against Bitcoin for a matter of days to weeks, would Chinese miners have the longer chain? And thus the chain?

I guess what I'm wondering is if the government of China has the ability to DOS Bitcoin as a payment system outside China at will.

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by cgore on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @11:18AM (#15184341)
My guess is that the Chinese miners are often well-connected in the middle-levels of the Chinese government, the parts that actually implement such policies, and only a few less-connected miners would actually get blocked, thus increasing the profitability of the miners with government connections.
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by elevensies on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @11:37AM (#15184484)
I'm wondering if it would benefit them to be cut off from the world, but not each other.

Lets say China creates a partition in the bitcoin network between inside China and outside China. My understanding is that when they remove the partition, the longest blockchain "wins". If there is more mining power inside China than outside, that gives them the power to deny everyone outside China the ability to do transactions for the duration of the partition.

The network could be divided other ways, but I believe China is the only one who has the ability and incentive to do it. Although maybe you're right that the miners are connected enough to prevent it (I'm sure it would create chaos that would hurt them in the end). Although I don't know if the firewall is administered at the provincial level or the national level? I think it is much less likely for them to have national level connections since I believe the Chinese political system is controlled by ~100 people.

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by contingencies on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @11:26AM (#15184403)
AFAIK mining doesn't actually require connectivity until you want to reveal the block. It's unlikely anyone else will discover it quickly, so you can just have someone walk across a border (or get on a flight) and plug it in to the global network from elsewhere.
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by mason55 on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @11:35AM (#15184462)
Blocks are supposed to be found every 10 minutes (difficulty adjusts to maintain this average). Theoretically someone would find the next block 10 minutes after you found yours and they would broadcast it. Then the next block would be found on top of that one. So unless you could get your block broadcast in under 20 minutes your chain would end up as shorter than the other one and wouldn't be counted as the main chain and it would quickly die.
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by prostoalex on Thursday September 07, 2017 @02:41AM (#15189579)
The attack you're describing is analogous to 50%+1 attack.

The chain will fork, and after Bitcoin + Bitcoin Cash and Ethereum Classic + Ethereum it's reasonable to assume both versions will co-exist to some degree.

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by elevensies on Thursday September 07, 2017 @01:47PM (#15194121)
Yeah, I think that is the right way to think about it. I had always considered that in terms of mining power, not in term s of network control, but it is effectively the same incentives and consequences, just with different players.
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by VikingCoder on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @09:48AM (#15183608)
"Crypto currencies will be useless in this case, losing all of their value."

Pedantic nitpick - there are crytpocurrencies which are not distributed proof-of-work blockchains, and would not necessarily lose all of their value.

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by granda on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @09:59AM (#15183683)
Can you go into more detail?
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by VikingCoder on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @01:01PM (#15185199)
Maybe I'm just talking about digital currencies in general, I guess...
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by hamilyon2 on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @11:08AM (#15184254)
Fork wold decrease number of miners working on the main chain. Thus destroy some value, and bitcoin price may be more volatile in days of fork. But no more than that. I cannot imagine any exchange/buyer accepting transactions from anything but the longest chain, and existence of the longest chain cannot be kept secret in modern world.
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by prostoalex on Thursday September 07, 2017 @02:51AM (#15189627)
Ethereum Classic and Bitcoin Cash are still traded on exchanges.
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by decentralised on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @12:35PM (#15184973)
> a well functioning internet infrastructure

Not that much. Most refugee camps have cell coverage and people there use btc as it's the only money they have access to.

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by decentralised on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @01:03PM (#15185220)
Apparently it's not a good idea to point out that bitcoin not only survives, but thrives under harsh conditions here on HN.
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by decentralised on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @03:23PM (#15186393)
lol

And there's a satellite too now, so +1 resilience for Bitcoin!

https://www.blockstream.com/satellite/

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by smokeyj on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @10:12AM (#15183805)
Bitcoin is global. If you want to be sure your transaction is on the longest chain you can just wait for more confirmations. You could even receive confirmations over satellite now.

> I guess my point is: be careful, this is still very much experimental, don't invest everything you have in them.

Also experimental: Central banking and fiat currency. The lifetime of these non-crypto backed coins isn't that great either. Also they tend to be devalued in times of war. Not sure I'd want to be holding onto paper money.

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by Double_a_92 on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @10:21AM (#15183888)
> Also they tend to be devalued in times of war.

Yeah, a currency that strongly depends on a stable and free internet is much better in times of war. /s

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by smokeyj on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @02:37PM (#15186027)
Diversifying a portion of your mattress money into digital money isn't the worst idea. It's a hedge against hyperinflation that can be transported digitally.