News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by simias on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @10:42AM (#15184053)
The difference IMO is that gold has intrinsic value by virtue of being rare and shiny. I guess the idea is that even if civilization collapses and we return to the stone age gold will still be valuable. Since the use of gold as currency can be traced back at least to 600BCE[1] there's a good reason to believe that.

Bitcoins however doesn't really have a intrinsic "rest" value. Anybody can (and many do) spawn a new blockchain out of thin air. Ironically Bitcoin is entirely about trust at the core. The trust that the other participants in the bitcoin economy won't lose faith in the currency and dump it. That trust is the only thing that gives the coin value.

[1] http://rg.ancients.info/lion/article.html

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by acdha on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @11:04AM (#15184224)
Similarly, national currencies have a value because governments collect taxes and pay for things using those currencies so there's a considerable inertial force encouraging their usage.

That doesn't mean that failure is impossible but it smooths out a lot of minor fluctuations whereas, as you pointed out, if a Bitcoin competitor took off tomorrow there's no pressure not to adopt it instead other than the sunk costs which a small percentage of the general population has.

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by ericb on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @01:08PM (#15185267)
I don't think it is that simple. Bitcoin has 3 main advantages that can't be easily taken away from it that make things harder for competitors:

1 - Distribution (Metcalfe's law):

Metcalfe's law states that the value of a telecommunications network is proportional to the square of the number of connected users of the system (n2).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metcalfe%27s_law

2- Schelling Point

Bitcoin is the natural Schelling point for those drawn to the advantages of cryptographic money.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Focal_point_(game_theory)

3 - Most battle-tested codebase. No cryptocurrency has been successfully operating for as long.

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by acdha on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @03:28PM (#15186430)
That's arguing that the past will be like the future when things are still really early. Statistically almost nobody owns or uses Bitcoin, especially when you subtract the Bitcoin proponents who do most of their transactions using something like a credit card which actually uses local currency via Visa or where Bitcoin is converted into real currency immediately by the recipient, and who thus would have very little switching converting to something else.

Ask how long either #1 or 2 would hold true if, say, a couple of large banks, Visa/Mastercard, Apple and/or Google, etc. launched a currency accessible to their existing customer bases. I'd give that a couple of days before Bitcoin would be a rounding error in the daily transaction volume.

The big long-term reason I expect that to happen is the deflation model baked into Bitcoin: every player which didn't acquire a substantial holding years ago has a huge incentive to find an alternative which doesn't mean they're putting effort into making someone else rich. Right now there's very little mainstream demand for Bitcoin but if that change it's hard to believe the finance people wouldn't be obsessed with ways to capture that revenue going to a third-party.

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by ericb on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @09:37PM (#15188537)
Coinbase has 10 million users, most of whom are there for bitcoin.
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by acdha on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @11:03PM (#15188879)
How many of them are active? How many hold non-trivial balances? Most importantly, how many sales would legal merchants lose if those users jumped ship or lost interest?

Again, my point is simply that there's little holding anyone who hasn't made a huge investment specifically in Bitcoin. If you have $10 equivalent sitting in an account and CitiCoin™ launches next week with attractive terms and mainstream merchant acceptance, are you going to think twice about bailing? Alternately, if law enforcement cracks down on the money laundering, etc. and prices drop, how many people will lose interest if it won't make them rich?

A key point here: of the comparatively few merchants who accept BTC, how many do their business primarily in Bitcoin and don't quickly convert to something else? That's the only group with a significant commitment to continued use; everyone else can switch on a whim.

That's the difference between a pure fiat currency like Bitcoin and something backed by a national government. Bitcoin has no inherent value beyond voluntary group consensus, which means that a panic, messy fork, or disinterest has no natural floor on how far it can fall. In contrast, USD are backed by one of the major world economies, hundreds of millions of people need them to pay taxes, and billions of dollars are paid to government employees, contracts, benefits, etc. Again, that's not immunity from problems but it's a huge inertial weight moderating swings.

Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by ericb on Thursday September 07, 2017 @10:21AM (#15192070)
The backing and even the existence of the United States is also simply a matter of group consensus. It is turtles all the way down, my friend. We're just debating whose delusions are bigger and better.
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by acdha on Friday September 08, 2017 @07:37AM (#15199447)
Do you actually believe that false equivalence? It's like saying your two-person startup is basically the same as IBM because they're both companies.
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by lostmsu on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @09:59PM (#15188620)
If you can carry gold to another country, nothing will stop you from bringing a USB flash with new, longer Bitcoin blockchain, which includes your transaction to send BTC to the receiver.
Re:Bitcoin's Golden Future by prostoalex on Thursday September 07, 2017 @02:32AM (#15189547)
That's after you convince the rest of the operating nodes in that country that the blockchain version on your USB is indeed the greatest, and everyone should just migrate to that.