News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by Jaruzel on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @04:29AM (#15173391)
From the article:

  The free and open internet as we know it is under attack. 
Yes, not only from those agencies listed, but from Doxxers, Spammers, RevengePorners, and various other online trollers.

We will never have a 'free and open internet' until humanity grows up and people like the above evolve into more socially-inclusive human beings.

Unfortunately, I can never see that happening. What will happen is the slow loss of anonymity across the internet, where all new signups require id verification or the use of a 3rd party 'trusted' authentication provider.

On one hand, I think this may be a good thing - regardless of where you do it, you should be liable for any offensive behaviour you do that upsets other people. However on the other hand where do all the whistle blowers and free speech advocates go? It's a tricky balance, but one things for sure, anonymous online trolling is the reason why we can't have nice [internet] things...

Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by beaconstudios on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @07:46AM (#15174237)
I'm not sure I agree that "upsetting people" is a cause that needs policing by private companies, especially when people can choose to act upset about virtually anything. If two people get into a heated argument and one calls the other a dick or something like that, should that person be kicked off the internet?
Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by soundwave106 on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @12:12PM (#15176571)
Well, should the government tell said private company not to kick this person off of their servers, use their bandwidth, etc?

That's really what this boils down to, as the only "solution" I can think of for this issue is essentially... government regulation. Telling corporations that they have to support things on their platform they necessarily may not want to support, often for business reasons.

For instance, take Twitter. Business reports often mention things like a reputation for harassment and trolling as a big concern towards their growth, because a lot of people aren't going to sign up if their user experience is poor. If they think it would be more profitable to "censor" people engaged in harassment or trolling and try to get rid of that reputation, why would they not do so? No different than other forms of "censorship" they try and do (often poorly, I might add) to improve user experience (eg: kicking off spamming bots, putting up restrictions for pornographic or graphic content, kicking off impersonators, preventing private information from being posted, etc.)

If they want to kick someone off for heated arguments and curse words, that's their choice too. That doesn't seem like something a profit-oriented large company like Twitter would do, but I've been in forums where moderators would indeed ban people for these sort of reasons and/or remove heated posts before things turned into a shitstorm.

As long as there is room for any sort of corporations or organizations with all kinds of content policies, I don't see an issue with this arrangement. If you don't like a place's content policy, you can go elsewhere. To me this certainly is preferred versus a world where a government dictates exactly what content policy everyone should have.

There is, I think, an argument to be made that the consolidation of Internet social media and its overwhelming private corporate nature may have the potential to stifle marginal voices by also consolidating content policy. That's the gist I got from the article, and I would agree with the concern.

I just don't see a great solution for this concern at the moment without potentially causing something worse.

Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by beaconstudios on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @04:59PM (#15179072)
it only really becomes an issue in my mind when the censoring parties can effectively shut down a company or user entirely. Then you can't really say "go somewhere else", if there isn't somewhere else to go. If successive domain providers (and for smaller domains like .ai, there aren't that many) decide to kick someone from their service, that essentially grants them the ability to shut down companies whose speech they disagree with. The way we treat the internet in modern times, domain registrars are more akin to the water company than a private enterprise because they provide a constrained resource that one simply cannot substitute for something else.
Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by madshiva on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @07:05AM (#15174037)
Trolling is not the issue. It has been taken by Media to promote online harassment, etc in a bad way. Troll was about amusement, joke. People now don't see any benefit but troll are benefit, they teach people to don't listen anybody on the Internet and to not respond with so much emotion.

Now people are weak, emotionally weak, so easily offended.

Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by happyrock on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @08:04AM (#15174336)
> Now people are weak, emotionally weak, so easily offended.

Or, more likely, they play up their "offendedness" and victimhood in order to gain the moral high ground over their opponents. People didn't just suddenly become easier to offend -- it has a payoff for them in political leverage.

Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by thex10 on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @09:19AM (#15174782)
> Now people are weak, emotionally weak, so easily offended.

Back in the day white Americans would throw a goddamn hissy fit if negroes drank out of the same public water fountain. They were so offended by the presence of these folks doing normal human things, and so incapable of handling their emotional responses to it, that beatings and murders and other violence were hardly unheard of.

I encourage you to take your "people these days are so weak and easily offended" hot take and throw it in the garbage, where it belongs.

Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by chippy on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @09:27AM (#15174838)
Agreed, and this lends more weight to the parent comment - "you should be liable for any offensive behaviour you do that upsets other people"

If we allow people to be liable for who and what they offend then we run the risk of allowing beatings and other violence. There is a real reason why Free Speech in the USA is associated with the Civil Rights movement.

Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by TeMPOraL on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @09:31AM (#15174881)
This only highlights that being offended is a sign of one's emotional immaturity. It's not a good thing to base any policing on.
Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by pjc50 on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @08:16AM (#15174392)
> teach people to don't listen anybody on the Internet

That is in its own way bad for free speech; what use is speech if nobody is listening?

Harassment can genuinely make the internet or parts of it unusable for some people. I bet Diane Abbot doesn't open her Twitter Mentions, for example. http://metro.co.uk/2017/09/04/almost-half-of-all-abuse-targe...

> and to not respond with so much emotion

Desensitisation is not the solution either.

Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by jerf on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @08:28AM (#15174457)
"That is in its own way bad for free speech; what use is speech if nobody is listening?"

I think if you carefully sit down and work out what "free speech" really means, it also comes to encompass the right to not have to listen to things you don't want to listen to, via avoidance. (Not via taking it all down, and there are some intricacies I'm skipping over because this is an HN comment and not a blogspew; for instance in "public spaces" there is a certain element of not necessarily being able to just "turn off" someone on a soap box, but still.) This manifests because of the way some people will insist that you must listen to them and that if their particular content doesn't show up in some feed somewhere, they're being censored.

"Harassment can genuinely make the internet or parts of it unusable for some people. "

True. However, the "boil the ocean" solution that everyone seems to be reaching for of some form of eliminating all the bad behavior on the internet is not feasible, even before we get into the fundamental ambiguity of what "bad behavior" is, and the IMHO observable fact that once you start down this road you get the twin problems of A: people deliberately skewing the definition of "bad behavior" in their favor and B: people deliberately getting more and more theatrically sensitive to "bad behavior" in proportion to its decreasing presence, for several reasons.

I think what we're really looking at here is increasingly undeniable evidence that this form of community does not scale. Twitter is fundamentally unscalable. Tiny little Gab may well have already passed its community scaling event horizon. Facebook shards the world much more carefully and still probably is past its scaling event horizon, too. Reddit shards the world in a different way, but its mega-subreddits also often pass the community event horizon. Basically, I'd say that any company it is whose ambition it is to create "one global community", even one broken up like Facebook's or Reddit's, is doomed to failure at scale.

(HN itself may already be on the large side of what can be sustained. It has, I believe, two full time moderators and curators of the community, so when you look at HN you have to keep in mind that that's where this site is; already at "full time moderator" status. If you put up a new "free speech!" HN-2 and promise not to moderate anything, what you see here on the real HN is probably literally unattainable to you.)

Given the choice between Free Speech and Facebook/Twitter/Gab/etc., I'll take Free Speech. We're going to have to figure out some other mechanism for online communication that doesn't involve trying to pour every single person who speaks a given language into one small room. Many of the people reading this probably have personal experience as to how bad that idea can be if it just includes their direct family or circle of friends, let alone millions of people.

(I've actually believed this sort of thing for a long time, and I live it. HN is probably the largest community I actually participate in. I participate in several subreddits, but pretty much only ones that are cut off from the "main body" of Reddit entirely. Even my blog has been affected; I know what it would have taken to "be successful" in that space over a decade ago, and I found myself reluctant to put the work in to do that, just because I realized I don't actually want to build a community and be responsible for it.)

Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by nippples on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @07:16AM (#15174073)
> Doxxers, Spammers, RevengePorners, and various other online trollers

They do not all fit one same category and we cannot have one-approach-fits-all

* RevengePorners: Clear cut criminal behavior, have the service cooperate with prosecution.

* Spammers: Depends on whether they're leading you into malware. Filters have gone a long way in dealing with that specific thing. In some legislations plain spamming may be criminal too.

* Doxxers: Grey area of law tbh, when paired with threats could easily categorize into criminal behavior.

* Trolls: Take the internet less seriously, be more conservative about sharing your identity online and lurk more. Of all things I don't understand why the current zeitgeist is "take all trolling as seriously as possible and give them stupidly large amounts of power and act surprised when trolling only gets worse".

Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by pjc50 on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @08:17AM (#15174402)
> Clear cut criminal behavior, have the service cooperate with prosecution.

Surprisingly, this isn't illegal in very many jurisdictions. One of the first to ban it was Scotland, this year.

Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by teddyh on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @06:47AM (#15173944)
> However on the other hand where do all the whistle blowers and free speech advocates go?

Not only those:

http://geekfeminism.wikia.com/wiki/Who_is_harmed_by_a_%22Rea...

Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by psyc on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @09:31AM (#15174870)
This is doublespeak.
Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by moomin on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @07:07AM (#15174042)
It's got to the point where "free speech" has become a dog whistle for the alt-right. Taking the concept back from them is going to be hard.
Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by angersock on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @10:20AM (#15175420)
> It's got to the point where "free speech" has become a dog whistle for the alt-right.

Because pride parades and Occupy protests don't benefit from free speech at all, right?

It's more concerning to see the meme of "I don't like what these people say so I'm going to add the 'dogwhistle' tag to it so other Right Thinking people will know to avoid/condemn it without engaging properly".

Free speech is critical to the success (such as it is) of the United States today. Deciding to self-cripple because some small groups we don't like are using it is absurd.

Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by moomin on Wednesday September 06, 2017 @05:59PM (#15187466)
You're kind of making my point for me. Occupy protestors regularly got assaulted and arrested. To the best of my knowledge, none of them murdered a woman with a car.

As I say, it's not about speech. Speech is just a dog-whistle for what this is really about.

[dead]
Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by dang on Saturday September 09, 2017 @01:09AM (#15205652)
> Why do you hate freedom?

Would you please (re)-read the site rules and follow them when commenting here? We've had to ask you this repeatedly. If you continue flouting the site rules, we're going to end up banning you.

Political/ideological/etc. flamewars are not what this site is for. Kindly take them elsewhere.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by moomin on Thursday September 07, 2017 @06:07AM (#15190371)
I'm glad we're clear that your support for black civil rights doesn't go as far as supporting Martin Luther King. And I'm also glad we're clear that you're prepared to give the benefit of the doubt to fascists. And that you think that a belief in fascism and white supremacy and a belief in Islam are appropriate things to compare.

And there's a difference between defending freedom and hating it, but I think it's clear you already know that as well.

Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by angersock on Thursday September 07, 2017 @12:57PM (#15193672)
> I'm glad we're clear that your support for black civil rights doesn't go as far as supporting Martin Luther King.

Where did you get this from? Black-bloc refers to this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_bloc . If anything, my support is exactly for folks like MLK (and even Malcolm X) as opposed to the domestic terrorism of other groups at the time.

> And I'm also glad we're clear that you're prepared to give the benefit of the doubt to fascists.

As I also gave the benefit of doubt to communists!

> And that you think that a belief in fascism and white supremacy and a belief in Islam are appropriate things to compare.

Do you not follow world events? There is indeed a subset of Muslims who believe that non-Muslims are infidels and are fit to be killed or taken advantage of, much as there is a subset of whites who believe that non-whites are fit to be killed or taken advantage of. And some extremists of those subsets apparently use cars to kill gatherings of people. It's a pretty apt comparison.

> And there's a difference between defending freedom and hating it, but I think it's clear you already know that as well.

Well, yeah--defending freedom usually requires us to deal with real facts critically and to be able to engage with our opponents directly instead of putting words in their mouths.

Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by patrickg_zill on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @07:22AM (#15174102)
Yes, taking back the concept of free speech is especially difficult, when you don't believe in it yourself.
Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by moomin on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @08:50AM (#15174591)
Doesn't seem to have stopped the alt-right.
Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by 0xBA5ED on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @08:30AM (#15174466)
Sounds like you're saying one particular group should control the concept of free speech at the expense of another group or groups.
Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by moomin on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @08:51AM (#15174601)
Nah, I'm saying that we need to talk about free speech in the context of diverse viewpoints and needs and stop prioritising fascists. It's ok, I knew this would be controversial.
Re:We Are At War For A Free And Open Internet by anon1385 on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @09:14AM (#15174749)
That's not a new thing. The fascist Oswald Mosley complained about a lack of free speech when he was repeatedly prevented from speaking and marching in predominantly Jewish parts of London in the 30s by large violent crowds[1]. Post war there were very organised groups dedicated to disrupting fascist "free speech", like 43 Group which was made up of Jewish ex-servicemen[2]. Again in the 60s Mosley cited "free speech" when his fascist rallies were violently disrupted[3].

Fascists have been using "free speech" as a shield since the beginning, and similarly liberals were handwringing about the fascists right to "free speech" while fascists beat up and killed Jews and other minorities and burned down synagogs. The liberals were wrong in the 30s to tolerate fascism and they're wrong now.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Cable_Street being the most famous example [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/43_Group [3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RRS4NR_BZ1w and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y-Ef3WYWJYc for example