If you could effectively put 100% tax on inheritance(which you can't in practice), it means your utility of leaving wealth around becomes 0. Now you want to spend that wealth as much as possible, and it turns into consumption. You would sell and spend everything you have for lavish expenses, which means a reduction in capital investment, which means slower economic growth.
I doubt hedonist consumption is what Keynes had in mind.
> inheritance taxes are necessary to provide equality of opportunity.
Lets take this to the extreme: lets say that your father could not provide you with anything but minimum substance until your coming of age (18?). Anything given to you by your parents would be taxed away. This means that you now cannot go to any college that is not provided to you by credit. But you have no assets and no income, so nobody will loan you any money. Plus, you don't have money for rent, so you need to work immediately to pay for your own place.
Maybe you feel sympathy for the millions of people that actually live that, but how is forcing everyone to go through that be better for society at large?
Or think what it would mean for the state to actually do that: what if you had to build any infrastructure built by a previous generation from scratch, because "its not fair the SF bridge is nicer than the Brookly bridge, its inherited".
The emotional answer I have against advocating inheritance tax is that the goal is not to be fair, its to be better. And certainly fair by destruction, by removing everything, is not better.
A tax on people that eat their brocoli would be highly impractical!
There are some definite difficulties in implementation. But even then, my argument is that it could be a really harmful tax if it could be applied at all.
One would have to balance the "harm" caused to the children of wealthy people for not inheriting wealth (mostly when they are around 50-60 yr old themselves), with the harm caused to society at large.
> One would have to balance the "harm" caused to the children of wealthy people for not inheriting wealth (mostly when they are around 50-60 yr old themselves), with the harm caused to society at large.
I wonder if we could think of other examples of how harming a minority of people can be good for society at large. But regardless of the moral standpoint of the remark you said, you also have to account the harm it does to society to make people spend extra time hiding their wealth and spending it more frivolously.
Many people spend inherited wealth frivolously. Business acumen isn't known to be genetically determined, whereas political influence is certainly affected by wealth and pedigree, see George Bush the first and the second.
There is harm to the donor to abolishing inheritance. I don't want to live in a world where "I farm this land, just as my father, his father, and his father for 5 generations has done." is not possible.
>I don't want to live in a world where "I farm this land, just as my father, his father, and his father for 5 generations has done." is not possible.
Why not? A man works hard to support himself but allowing four generations of free-riders seems like a pretty bad idea. It strikes me as a sort of neo-monarchism. In the past we had royalty blessed by god and passed through blood and now we have the economic elite blessed by capital and passed through blood.
Their offspring could benefit from a generous endowment of a proportion of this wealth, say 10%-20%.
Edit: and no sneaking about with Trusts, either.