News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Comparing C and C++ usage and performance with a real wor... by rjzzleep on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:44AM (#15162017)
according to dan saks, who apparently to some people is famous c++ is faster than c (well in the test setup he describes below)

https://accu.org/content/conf2015/DanSaks-Embedded%20Program...

    Language   Design Implementation  Relative Performance
    either any inline 1 (fastest)
    C++ polystate non-inline 1.56 x fastest
    C++ bundled non-inline 1.65 x fastest
    C polystate non-inline 1.70 x fastest
    C bundled non-inline 1.79 x fastest
    C++ unbundled   non-inline 1.82 x fastest
    C unbundled   non-inline 1.95 x fastest
He furthermore argued that the biggest mistakes C++ developers did to kill the adoption of C++ for C programmers was to diverge from the previous line of "C++ is a better C" to "if you're using C++ as a better C you're doing it wrong"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D7Sd8A6_fYUI

(I have no skin in the game, I was just curious to see if it's worth looking at rust for embedded when I came across that talk)

Re:Comparing C and C++ usage and performance with a real wor... by WalterBright on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:55AM (#15162082)
Over in D-land we've embraced the concept of using D as a "better C" :-)

https://dlang.org/blog/2017/08/23/d-as-a-better-c/

This is not in the sense of tossing away C coded programs wholesale and rewriting it in D, but incrementally using D here and there for parts of a C program. That way, you've always got a working, usable program.

Re:Comparing C and C++ usage and performance with a real wor... by harry8 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @09:36PM (#15165051)

    if (existsCoffee)
        writeln("Drink coffee");
http://ddili.org/ders/d.en/if.html Sad that you adopted one of C's worst features. Why? Can you get rid of it and mandate the bracing every block?
Re:Comparing C and C++ usage and performance with a real wor... by WalterBright on Monday September 04, 2017 @02:59AM (#15166279)
My take on C's biggest mistake:

https://digitalmars.com/articles/b44.html

Re:Comparing C and C++ usage and performance with a real wor... by harry8 on Tuesday September 05, 2017 @12:28AM (#15172527)
Sure but there is just no reason at all to copy unbraced blocks. All you do is invite bugs for zero benefit.

Maybe there are bigger issues with C? But that's a different discussion. I want to know why you copied something as simultaneously horrendous and useless as unbraced blocks? If you just didn't think it through and that's the way languages syntactically similar to C have always done it, ok. I'm sure I've made worse mistakes. But please call it one way or the other.

Re:Comparing C and C++ usage and performance with a real wor... by humanrebar on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:28PM (#15162275)
> "if you're using C++ as a better C you're doing it wrong"

As far as correctness and safety goes, this is still true. It's difficult to scale systems-level programming to large teams. C++ gives the opportunity for more explicit semantics and more aggressive compile-time checks. C can scale well and can be used safely, but you need to do a lot more through convention (always call xyz_Create and xyz_Destroy in pairs!) and through runtime checks (calls to assert, unit testing).

D, Rust, OCaml, and a few other projects are interesting in this space since they provide some of the same benefits as C++ with respect to correctness and safety. Some are plausibly better in theory, though I'm not aware of huge, say, Rust projects that approach the size of huge C++ ones.

Re:Comparing C and C++ usage and performance with a real wor... by pcwalton on Sunday September 03, 2017 @01:30PM (#15162648)
> D, Rust, OCaml, and a few other projects are interesting in this space since they provide some of the same benefits as C++ with respect to correctness and safety.

Can you name a correctness and safety benefit that C++ has that these programming languages do not?

Re:Comparing C and C++ usage and performance with a real wor... by humanrebar on Sunday September 03, 2017 @02:04PM (#15162846)
I didn't mean to imply that C++ was safer somehow. I just meant that those languages are also competing in that feature space in a way that C doesn't.

And, on a pedantic level, C++ competitors can't provide exactly the same benefits of C++ because they took different approaches.

What's a key design difference among these languages? Well, C++ can mostly just #include a C header file and go with it. The other languages provide FFI mechanisms, but they each require declarations of the FFI to match the compiled C code. So theoretically there's a little more room for errors in that translation, though I doubt that's a big concern on the whole. Each of those languages have more mature module systems, which should more than make up for keeping FFI interfaces in sync with C headers.

Re:Comparing C and C++ usage and performance with a real wor... by red75prime on Sunday September 03, 2017 @01:53PM (#15162769)
Probably there are no such benefits. But taking the less serious approach, LLVM's -fsanitize=undefined could be thought of as the one.
Re:Comparing C and C++ usage and performance with a real wor... by khitchdee on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:42PM (#15162377)
Agreed. It's the size and type of the project that determines the choice of language more than the newness of the language. C++ was designed to meet the requirements of certain types of projects that were coming into vogue at the time it was designed. It was not a replacement for C.

Some of the structural advantages of C++ over C can be achieved in C by using generative programming for example and building in automatic mechanisms to ensure there are no memory leaks for example. In other words, the C++ approach to structuring programs is not the only way to achieve the benefits that that structuring implies. It's just really easy to do it that way.

Re:Comparing C and C++ usage and performance with a real wor... by humanrebar on Sunday September 03, 2017 @02:05PM (#15162854)
It's true that generative programming can make up for shortcomings of C. But you're pretty much writing in two languages at that point, C and whatever spec generated the rest of the C code. It's not an apples-to-apples comparison to C++.
Re:Comparing C and C++ usage and performance with a real wor... by khitchdee on Sunday September 03, 2017 @02:45PM (#15163083)
Well, some parts of the generative programming could be built into a tool and you probably wouldn't have to rewrite a generative program each time. So it's not really writing in 2 languages but using code generation to assist the programming process to reduce potential for error as a more flexible alternative to creating fixed constructs in a purpose built language.
Re:Comparing C and C++ usage and performance with a real wor... by humanrebar on Sunday September 03, 2017 @04:05PM (#15163558)
You can get 90% of that benefit by using snippets in your favorite editor. I guess you could consider that "code generation", but "generative programming" means, to me, "check in the specification, not the production code".
Re:Comparing C and C++ usage and performance with a real wor... by khitchdee on Sunday September 03, 2017 @08:30PM (#15164794)
You're assuming gnerative programming is used to completely replace direct programming. This doesn't have to be the case. It could also be used merely in an assistive role to supplement the ability to write code.
Re:Comparing C and C++ usage and performance with a real wor... by humanrebar on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:54PM (#15165613)
I'm not. That's what I'm referring to as "snippets", though other forms of scaffolding do apply. If your position is that people should use more sophisticated editing/authoring tools on a regular basis, that's not that controversial a statement.

I was just saying that full-blown code generation isn't merely writing in the same language but adopting a DSL as well, so we're not strictly comparing languages at that point.

Re:Comparing C and C++ usage and performance with a real wor... by khitchdee on Monday September 04, 2017 @03:06AM (#15166308)
Right. Code generation has typically been associated with DSLs.

Here's one way it could be done simply. Let's say you wanted to automate the process of memory allocation and deallocation. You would need a way to describe to the code generator the mepory requirments of your structure. For that you would need a description outside of C. But that description could be embedded into the comments of your code and your code generator be designed to parse those comments to determine what needed to be done.

Knuth also came up with the idea of Literate Programming in which the description of a program is embedded as Latex in the code. This could work in a similar way. So, while you would use a DSL, the description would be inline with your code so the authoring process would be integrated and not 2-stream.

Re:Comparing C and C++ usage and performance with a real wor... by pjmlp on Sunday September 03, 2017 @04:50PM (#15163828)
> It was not a replacement for C.

Sure it was for Bjarne, that is why he created it in first place.

After being forced to re-write his thesis from Simula to BCPL, he swore never having to deal with such low level languages again.

C with Classes was his solution to not having to write C directly, after he got his job at AT&T.