News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by etplayer on Sunday September 03, 2017 @10:08AM (#15161474)
I think it's a shame that the HN article title was changed from something which is clearly expounded by the video i.e Communism, and mentioned several times even with quotes by proto-Communists and Communists themselves, and the attack on private property. Copyright is merely used as an expemplary in the talk. Why was the title changed? Is it that Communism is seen as "click bait" or too radical for the HN audience that it must thus be tuned down to something with less flare?
Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by sctb on Sunday September 03, 2017 @01:19PM (#15162583)
This is a tough call. As far as I can tell, the original title isn't misleading or click-bait so we've put it back. Unfortunately it looks like there's no redemption for this predictable generic flamefest that took the place of an actual discussion, though.
Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by laretluval on Sunday September 03, 2017 @10:54AM (#15161715)
Probably because they like to avoid political flamewars in the comments, like the one happening in this thread.
Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by dang on Monday September 04, 2017 @02:11AM (#15166065)
To add to what sctb said: obviously the word 'communism' in such a title is flamebait; one might wish otherwise, but the internet is what it is. Moreover, generic ideological battle is off topic for HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. You yourself have badly violated the site rules by perpetuating it in this thread. Would you please not do that again? I presume there are other places on the internet where it's welcome, but it isn't here.
Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by drops on Sunday September 03, 2017 @10:15AM (#15161513)
Because Communism is cancer.
Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by dang on Monday September 04, 2017 @02:20AM (#15166101)
This breaks the HN guidelines badly. Please read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and refrain from posting like this here again.

Somebody opening the gates of hell a crack is no reason to fling them wide open.

Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by etplayer on Sunday September 03, 2017 @10:17AM (#15161527)
Why do you say this?
Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by drops on Sunday September 03, 2017 @10:29AM (#15161581)
Because I live in a country that was under Communism for almost 90 years and actually experienced how bad it is first-hand.
Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by s_kilk on Sunday September 03, 2017 @10:38AM (#15161628)
I've lived under Capitalism for over 30 years, and have first-hand experience of how bad it is.
Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by janus28 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @10:49AM (#15161687)
Speak for yourself. Also you have the option to move to socialist/communist countries whenever you see fit, they exist. Don't force your horrible ideology on the rest of us (which communism literally calls for).
Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by Broken_Hippo on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:40AM (#15161985)
"Also you have the option to move to socialist/communist countries whenever you see fit, they exist."

Actually, most folks don't really have that option. Not legally, anyway. And honestly, I think your statement is pushing a horrible ideology on others as well - capitalist societies have the same sort of hangups on closed-mindedness you fault communism on, evidenced by people's outcry that national health care is a socialist policy. It makes actual fixes nearly impossible.

More to the first point, it is expensive for folks to move, and expensive to find housing and work enough to meet immigration requirements. Even planning for schooling is expensive. Not to mention the fact that in many professions, you need to speak the local language. It is even an expensive prospect when you are moving for marriage (I've been through it, and it is still expensive). Sometimes the education from the US isn't quite good enough to transfer to the same job. Not really an option for large swaths of population making minimum wage or slightly more. Not when a flat tire messes up your finances for weeks or more.

This advice is as bad as telling jobless folks they should just move to a part of the country with jobs. It isn't reasonable or practical.

I was freaking lucky to be able to move out of the states and into a socialist democracy (Norway).

Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by BeetleB on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:25AM (#15161892)
>Speak for yourself. Also you have the option to move to socialist/communist countries whenever you see fit, they exist. Don't force your horrible ideology on the rest of us (which communism literally calls for).

A perfect case of strawman.

In his comment, GP was never advocating that communism is particularly good. He was merely using the same logic as his parent.

Also, moving to different countries is not straightforward. The statement does not even come close to being an argument for anything, and does not contribute to the discussion.

Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by friedman23 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:38AM (#15161968)
Thank you for calling it a strawman when the person I was arguing just admitted that communism does call for forced confiscation of property. You people are delusional.
Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by BeetleB on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:53AM (#15162073)
>Thank you for calling it a strawman when the person I was arguing just admitted that communism does call for forced confiscation of property.

Yes, it is a strawman, when you attribute something to someone who did not say it. That he agrees with you or not doesn't have bearing on what makes an argument a strawman. The discussion of property arose after you made your comment.

>You people are delusional.

Very consistent with strawman-like behavior. Tell me how I am delusional. Not the other commenters in the thread. Me. In what way am I delusional?

Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by s_kilk on Sunday September 03, 2017 @10:52AM (#15161706)
> Don't force your horrible ideology on the rest of us (which communism literally calls for).

And Capitalism is totally non-coercive, right?

Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by etplayer on Sunday September 03, 2017 @10:52AM (#15161705)
The idea that "if you don't like it, leave" can be used to excuse any injustice, such as against the Jews in Nazi Germany. What's your point, exactly? It's a farcical notion and I hope you can see that it is counter to the idea of human progress to expound it.

>Don't force your horrible ideology on the rest of us (which communism literally calls for).

No, it doesn't. Communism calls for the liberation of people via the abolition of private property, itself a concept which is forced on everyone, including the owners of private property. This is like saying that the abolition of slavery "forces an ideology" on everyone because now nobody can own slaves. Again, it's farcical. Oscar Wilde and Kropotkin have explained the individualist nature of Communism.

Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by janus28 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:04AM (#15161774)
> The idea that "if you don't like it, leave" can be used to excuse any injustice, such as against the Jews in Nazi Germany.

That you need to bring up the Nazis shows how bad your argument is. Please just move to Venezuela or North Korea.

> No, it doesn't. Communism calls for the liberation of people via the abolition of private property

1. It calls for the forced confiscation of private property.

2. Explain how someone can be liberated by having their economic freedom removed?

Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by etplayer on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:09AM (#15161803)
The fact that you're telling me to move to Venezuela (capitalist economy) or North Korea (a country that doesn't even call itself Communist or even Socialist any more) shows just how bad your argument is. It was perfectly valid for me to bring up an example of a repressive regime as an immediately understood example of injustice. However I could have just as easily used the example of Bangladeshi sweatshop workers. Should they just shut up or move away?

Moving is irrelevant, too - everywhere has become private property, everywhere is rented or taxed. One cannot escape capitalism.

>1. It calls for the forced confiscation of private property.

Yes. What about it?

>2. Explain how someone can be liberated by having their economic freedom removed?

People's economic freedom is not removed, rather, it is provided in the first place - higher stage Communism is the refined ideal of the free association of people as producers and labourers in the economic sphere.

Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by friedman23 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:35AM (#15161945)
> The fact that you're telling me to move to Venezuela (capitalist economy) or North Korea (a country that doesn't even call itself Communist or even Socialist any more)

sure, keep telling yourself that

> Yes. What about it?

Thank you for admitting that communism does require force confiscation of property.

You need to understand that I wasn't arguing to convince you, I'm making statements to point out for anyone reading that when you say "liberation" you actually mean state police going door by door and confiscating any valuables you have. Maybe lynching some property owners along the way.

>People's economic freedom is not removed, rather, it is provided in the first place - higher stage Communism is the refined ideal of the free association of people as producers and labourers in the economic sphere.

Communism is supposed to be ownership of the means of production by the people. Can you sell what you supposedly own under communism? No, you cannot.

This means that

A. You don't actually own it the state does. (The state in this case can be whatever organizational body is being used to manage the means of production).

B. You do not have any economic freedom under communism because you cannot sell what you supposedly own. Even under communism you do not have the option to sell your own labor freely. What occurs is that you are assigned work that the government believes is needed.

Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by etplayer on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:47AM (#15162035)
>you actually mean state police going door by door and confiscating any valuables you have. Maybe lynching some property owners along the way.

You misunderstand the concept of property. I have written about it here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15160835 as an explanation.

>A. You don't actually own it the state does.

No; Communism is an anarchist ideology, and the workers through voluntary democratic institutions manage the means of production - so you, by extension manage the means of production.

>You do not have any economic freedom under communism because you cannot sell what you supposedly own.

No. These is no sale in Communism because the conceptions of freedom have changed, society adopts a different set of needs, namely, goods are not imbued with exchange value, as they are not commodities. It doesn't make sense to sell things in Communism. This is what Communism is - the bringing about of the condititions such that the current ones are obsolete. As Marx said, Communism is not an ideal to be achieved, but the constantly existing movement which abolishes the present state of things.

>Even under communism you do not have the option to sell your own labor freely.

This is a very good thing! You don't have to sell your labour to survive! And even if you wanted to, you can get higher returns by owning any more labour you do.

>What occurs is that you are assigned work that the government believes that you are most suited to.

Hilariously false. Please actually read Marx; I'll quote the relevant part here:

"He is a hunter, a fisherman, a herdsman, or a critical critic, and must remain so if he does not want to lose his means of livelihood; while in communist society, where nobody has one exclusive sphere of activity but each can become accomplished in any branch he wishes, society regulates the general production and thus makes it possible for me to do one thing today and another tomorrow, to hunt in the morning, fish in the afternoon, rear cattle in the evening, criticise after dinner, just as I have a mind, without ever becoming hunter, fisherman, herdsman or critic. This fixation of social activity, this consolidation of what we ourselves produce into an objective power above us, growing out of our control, thwarting our expectations, bringing to naught our calculations, is one of the chief factors in historical development up till now."

Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by friedman23 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:54AM (#15162076)
> No. These is no sale in Communism because the conceptions of freedom have changed

Oh yeah, the conception of freedom has changed so that slavery is freedom. It's amazing that there are people that actually fantasize about living under a dystopian government.

> Hilariously false. Please actually read Marx; I'll quote the relevant part here:

Marx says a lot of stuff in his worthless books, every implementation of communism has assigned labor.

Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by etplayer on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:58AM (#15162100)
>Oh yeah, the conception of freedom has changed so that slavery is freedom.

No; if anything, capitalism is the closest to slavery if we consider the case of the slave abolishing the ownership of slaves (the human component) of private property, the proletarian is the same in that he must actually abolish private property in general to be free.

>every implementation of communism has assigned labor.

Does capitalism not have assigned labour? You are free to move between jobs to some degree, but you are assigned labour in general, for without that assignment (by the capitalists) then you are liable to destitution or poverty or death or the charity of the State.

Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by friedman23 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:45PM (#15162405)
> Does capitalism not have assigned labour? You are free to move between jobs to some degree, but you are assigned labour in general, for without that assignment (by the capitalists)

Yes it does, and if you can't find a company that will let you do the job you want you can start your own business.

Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by etplayer on Sunday September 03, 2017 @10:43AM (#15161646)
You lived in a country that was under Party rule of an emulation of a Marxist-Leninist vanguard state which operated on the functions of private property, money and was clearly a class society, I'm guessing, unless you lived in revolutionary Catalonia.

I am currently living in a country that's still under capitalism and I'm experiencing how bad it is right now.

Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by janus28 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @10:50AM (#15161693)
Explain to me how bad it is and compare it with statistics on poverty from the best communist country you can find me.
Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by etplayer on Sunday September 03, 2017 @10:55AM (#15161726)
Just to take you up on this, I do not think that Cuba is a Communist country, but it reports very highly on poverty and especially in comparison to other countries in South America.

>Despite this, the poverty level reported by the government is one of the lowest in the developing world, ranking 6th out of 108 countries, 4th in Latin America and 48th among all countries.[0]

Further, I see it as bad for private property is tyranny, the labourer is deprived of the full value of what he creates, and the class society creates artificial necessity to provide wage labour or accumulate sufficient capital just in order to survive. For these reasons I see the system as barbaric, as with our resources it is clearly enough to do better. To say nothing of the horrendous exploitation of those in Bangladesh for example, this only being the most visible example of the exploitation Marx tells us about.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_Human_Dev...

Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by janus28 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:09AM (#15161795)
Thank you for pointing out how Cuba has regressed relatively to its peers. Cuba used to be the second wealthiest country in the Western Hemisphere.

Also that you need to lie about what your source says is sad. It's 68th among all countries.

Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by etplayer on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:10AM (#15161814)
The quote I used happened to be incongruent with the source I linked, so I'm sorry for that - I wasn't trying to be disingenuous. That said, you asked for statistics and I have provided them - Cuba in terms of poverty isn't as bad as most of its peers in South America.
Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by janus28 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:14AM (#15161828)
Cuba's poverty is only relatively good (ie not actually good) when you restrict its peers to the countries of South America.

But when you consider that when Cuba transitioned to communism it was a fully developed economy not a developing country you can understand how badly they have regressed.

Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by atom058 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:05PM (#15162146)
And of course, this regression has nothing to do with US sanctions during the period.

The world is probably not as black and white as we might think at first glance.

Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by friedman23 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @01:37PM (#15162686)
Oh yeah, Cuba definitely regressed because of the US embargoes. What's the excuse of every other communist country in the world again?
Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by BeetleB on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:21AM (#15161865)
>Because I live in a country that was under Communism for almost 90 years and actually experienced how bad it is first-hand.

That's as silly a reason as you can give. You don't think I can find a capitalist country that's as bad?

Re:Why Science is Better with Communism? The Case of Sci-Hub... by dang on Monday September 04, 2017 @02:23AM (#15166123)
Your account seems like it's teetering on the edge of using HN primarily for political and ideological battle. That's destructive of what HN is supposed to be for, so if you would please (re)-read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and walk back from that brink, we'd appreciate it. The same goes for any other account in this position, regardless of their politics.