News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Subscription App Paradox by TeMPOraL on Sunday September 03, 2017 @06:47AM (#15160762)
Apps are just a harbinger; this starts to happen everywhere else too. I dislike how our ever more efficient economy makes your capabilities and quality of life tied closer and closer to your instantaneous income. Instead of one-time purchases, more and more things are becoming money sinks now. This might be great for the perfect citizens - young, punctual, hard-working individuals steadily going up the corporate ladder - but it's incredibly annoying for everyone else. Any small hiccup in your cashflow, and suddenly you have to start cutting off parts of your life.

It's tolerable now, because you still can own most of the things. But will it be 10 years from now? When because of e.g. sudden health expenses, you're left wondering whether to cancel dishwashing or clotheswashing service for a month, so that you don't have to cancel the service that feeds your kid at school? Will everything you "have", and everything you can do, be solely determined by the allocation of your cashflow to various available services?

Re:The Subscription App Paradox by red_admiral on Sunday September 03, 2017 @08:47AM (#15161162)
I don't know if this is more of a European thing but it used to be the case that unless you were wealthy you rented your fridge, cooker, TV etc. or at least bought them on some kind of hire-purchase agreement.

In Switzerland you even used to pay a monthly subscription to the PTT to rent your landline phone, separately from your phone line subscription. If you paid a bit more per month you got one of the fancy models with buttons instead of a dial. [source in German: https://www.srf.ch/sendungen/kassensturz-espresso/themen/ser...]

The whole service economy thing looks to me like it's going back in the direction of the times when various versions of "servant" were a common occupation.

Re:The Subscription App Paradox by tauntz on Sunday September 03, 2017 @09:34AM (#15161329)
The concept of renting a fridge, TV or telephone is something that I haven't even heard of before and I also live in Europe (though, Eastern Europe). Might it only be a thing in Switzerland or in some Western European countries?
Re:The Subscription App Paradox by tonyedgecombe on Sunday September 03, 2017 @10:03AM (#15161455)
We used to have it in the UK, I think Rumbelows was one of the bigger vendors. Cheap consumer goods killed its business.
Re:The Subscription App Paradox by red_admiral on Sunday September 03, 2017 @10:28AM (#15161576)
I presume it's more of a western thing.
Re:The Subscription App Paradox by sweden on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:17PM (#15162206)
I have lived both in the south west of Europe and north of Europe and I have never heard of renting electronic appliances.
Re:The Subscription App Paradox by kartickv on Sunday September 03, 2017 @08:17AM (#15161055)
While your point about canceling clotheswashing service is fair, also think about the benefit. People can use the service that can't buy washing machines. This is a reality in India for working-class people. And even someone like me who could buy a washing machine for ₹40,000 would rather spend a few hundred rupees a month. If it breaks down, I don't lose any money, and someone else can deal with the hassle of getting it serviced. I had to throw away a washing machine a few years back because the company wouldn't repair it.

Don't look at only one side of the coin.

Re:The Subscription App Paradox by ksec on Sunday September 03, 2017 @11:00AM (#15161748)
On the other side, these "Services" aren't mostly there because they are cheaper. Washing Clothes by yourself along with Washing Machine is still magnitude cheaper for most countries. But it saves us time in doing it, or to be precise, we are lacking our time to do it because the economy is very good at extracting every single ounce left in your free time for work. And sometimes you have other priorities.

That is why we now even have meal prep services for families. Sometimes I wonder if this is what the economist called "Services Economy" that some / most country must transition into.

Re:The Subscription App Paradox by xkpd3 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @09:44AM (#15161375)
I can buy a used washing machine for cheap. Subscriptions are killing the second hand market, and this is intentional.
Re:The Subscription App Paradox by pbhjpbhj on Sunday September 03, 2017 @07:27AM (#15160885)
Ha, it's like capitalism come to the home: means of production (of clean dishes) being removed from the common man to afford greater profits to the capitalists; seize back the means of production (the dishwasher)!

Vive la Revolution!

Re:The Subscription App Paradox by aninhumer on Sunday September 03, 2017 @03:25PM (#15163328)
On the one hand I do worry about the loss of ownership, but on the other hand, I can't help wondering if it would make a lot of things more efficient.

Ultimately, there will always be some level ongoing cost to the clotheswashing service, but ownership can obfuscate that cost. Consumers are bad at buying cost efficient washing machines, and can end up spending a lot on replacements or repairs, but a serviced washing machine rental company is likely to be a lot more discerning.

And I'm not sure your concerns about instantaneous income are fair to apply here. If people are struggling to pay for a reasonable baseline of services, I think that's a wider economic problem, and I don't think a service model would make that any worse. If anything, being able to cancel your clotheswashing service is a choice that someone who bought their washing machine doesn't have.

Re:The Subscription App Paradox by fauigerzigerk on Sunday September 03, 2017 @07:27AM (#15160887)
That's an interesting point, but I doubt it's much worse than it is today if at all. Poor poeple can be in trouble when their car or washing machine gives up the ghost.

So they buy a new one on credit. The monthly instalments are quite similar to a subscription model. I'm not sure which one is more expensive.

Re:The Subscription App Paradox by mantas on Sunday September 03, 2017 @09:50AM (#15161395)
There's a huuuuge second-hand market for cars and washing machines and whatnot. You can easily get another run-down item for super cheap. Then there're repair services that refurbish old items. You'd be surprised what handy people can do. Yes, they wouldn't be as good as new, but they'd work pretty well.

With service-everything approach, there would be no second-hand market. Independent garages/repair shops wouldn't get much business either. Everybody would be stuck in rent market wether you like it or not/

Re:The Subscription App Paradox by fauigerzigerk on Sunday September 03, 2017 @10:12AM (#15161494)
True, I'm just saying that in terms of fixed monthly payments renting may not make a huge difference compared to buying on credit. More than half of all used cars in the US are bought using some sort of financing as well.

But I do agree that there are important differences.

Re:The Subscription App Paradox by mantas on Sunday September 03, 2017 @10:57AM (#15161734)
The main difference is wether you keep the item or return it. If it was purely service and everybody turned in their cars, there wouldn't be used market as we know it. Either those cars would be recycled or rented out for lower price again.
Re:The Subscription App Paradox by xorcist on Monday September 04, 2017 @04:18AM (#15166584)
I am convinced that is where we are heading. It's just that the market moves slowly. Cars are already chipped up, all we need to do is put keys in there, call it a protection mechanism and it can be made illegal to both re-sell and service the equipment without the proper license. This process can then be repeated for dishwashers and other capital intensive equipment.
Re:The Subscription App Paradox by mantas on Monday September 04, 2017 @08:17AM (#15167679)
If you look from that perspective, it can be applied to anything. Shoes can be chipped up easily too.

Market may be trying to move in that direction, but there's plenty of force against it. Like recent right-to-repair laws. Or people ditching subscription-only software for worse, but paid-once alternatives.

Re:The Subscription App Paradox by a13n on Sunday September 03, 2017 @08:02AM (#15161010)
I feel like basic income could solve this problem.
Re:The Subscription App Paradox by tonyedgecombe on Sunday September 03, 2017 @10:04AM (#15161460)
Why?
Re:The Subscription App Paradox by posguy on Sunday September 03, 2017 @07:00AM (#15160799)
If you can't afford to pay someone to do something, you either do it yourself or it doesn't happen. This isn't particularly new, and if you look at most people's lives, they just aren't paying for every new thing as a service, if they pay for any PaaS at all.
Re:The Subscription App Paradox by mantas on Sunday September 03, 2017 @09:51AM (#15161400)
Like go for a walk instead of driving or wash clothes by hand?