Re:Satya Nadella: DREAMers make our country and communities ...
by amagaeru on Friday September 01, 2017 @08:06PM
(#15153301)
Though I agree with your comments on the complexity and inherent difficulty of a merit-based system, it doesn't make a lot of sense to plop 'civil disobedience' in there.
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/civil
Illegal immigrants are not citizens.
Or were you talking about the coyotes with US citizenship? Most wouldn't call that civil disobedience.
As to the “merit” argument: designing merit-based systems is hard. Merit is neither totally ordered nor easily perceived - see, for instance, any amount of research about the effectiveness of interviewing processes. (TL;DR: it’s really low; most interviewers make up their minds in the first few seconds of an interaction; without blind interview practices, decisions are often biased.)
To put it bluntly, I very much do not share that faith. I consider it rather more likely that any “merit-based” system instituted would be used to give the appearance of legitimacy to racial profiling in immigration policy.