News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by mc32 on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @02:33AM (#15122520)
Maybe not looking down so much as differentiating from it. Kind of like you don't have to look down on coffee to sell tea instead cuz some people prefer tea.
Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by Viker on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @03:07AM (#15122631)
But why do people differentiate porn and Sex?

When we look at a professional football player play football, we never call it fake football. So why when it comes to sex we choose what is real and what is fake. I understand that very few people can have Sex like porn stars and very few women have the ability to look like porn starts. But why do we look down upon them and call them fake.

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by the_stc on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @03:10AM (#15122644)
Because it's staged and directed? If it was just recording people having sex, you'd be right. But there's a lot of editing and other work going on. If you watched a football game where directors came on and had the players redo a certain takedown then it'd be a closer comparison. Maybe compare to WWF wrestling?
Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by honestoHeminway on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @04:18AM (#15122876)
So if a video is uncut- Alfonso Cuarón style - its real?
Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by dagw on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @05:06AM (#15123030)
If the people are actually having sex, because they want to, and reacting to each other spontaneously according their desires, rather than according to a script or external direction, then sure.
Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by coldtea on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @06:09AM (#15123251)
Well, nobody calls leaked amateur/celebrity sex tapes "fake sex" in the sense they call porn that.
Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by coldtea on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @06:08AM (#15123245)
>But why do we look down upon them and call them fake.

For the same reason we call don't consider a role an actor portrays as "real".

Not only is the guy in the porn video not an actual plumber, but he probably could not care less about having sex with the lonesome busty housewife -- and especially not in front of a crew of 10, and following a specific formula until the final money shot.

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by rootlocus on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @04:26AM (#15122901)
I wouldn't equate porn actors with professional sports players. The large majority of online porn is repetitive, degrading and banal. I believe the quality of sex comes from intimacy and mutual pleasure / respect. The porn industry seems to think quality means harder, faster, longer, whatever.

Also, found on the website linked on the article: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FV8n_E_6Tpc

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by cnorthwood on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @06:44AM (#15123376)
But people do differentiate between sports like WWE wrestling, and professional football.
Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by dspillett on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @07:25AM (#15123524)
They are different. No one argues that the participants in WWE are not physically impressive (it takes considerable strength and control to perform some of their moves) but it isn't sport in the same sense as football or "real" wrestling because it is largely choreographed rather than truly competitive. I tend to think of it as ultra-violent ballet.

It is still a perfectly valid sport (caveat: depending, of course, on how you define sport itself which can be a subjective matter) but if categorising things is your bag then I think it belongs more with synchronised swimming than it does with professional football.

(personal context: I've never been a WWE fan, though recreationally I do partake in catch wrestling from which WWE can claim some heritage)

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by elorant on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @04:20AM (#15122881)
Because porn objectifies women. Today's porn doesn't have to do anything with sex, at least not the sex most people are used to do. There's no intimacy. Women look artificial with all these cosmetic surgeries. The whole thing looks artificial. Not to mention that it gives youngsters a very distorted view of how sex should be which is a whole other story by itself.
Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by coldtea on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @06:12AM (#15123268)
>Because porn objectifies women

That doesn't make sense as an accusation, as that's the whole point of the activity: to objectify women (and men).

Porn, like casual sex, is about seeing the other person, and being interested in them, for a single dimension: sexually. Which is totally fine. Who said you should be interested in the whole package deal every time?

Maybe not have sex unless it's a relationship/marriage either? Men AND women do enjoy casual sex without any further purpose all the time.

Employment also sees the other person in one dimension: professionally. Traffic cops see the person in one dimension: how well they drive. Credit card companies see a other person in one dimension: what they do with their bills. All of those are objectifications: the other is a means to something. It's just because of being prudish and/or misunderstood feminism that specifically seeing the other in terms of sex (for casual sex, porn, flirting, etc), is considered especially heinous.

>Women look artificial with all these cosmetic surgeries. The whole thing looks artificial. Not to mention that it gives youngsters a very distorted view of how sex should be which is a whole other story by itself.

That's more like why it's "fake" -- not the objectifying thing.

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by peterwwillis on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @08:12AM (#15123722)
Mainstream porn is about objectification. At the birth of modern video pornography, pornography was a vehicle for a story. The story was the theme, and the sex took up a small portion of the total run time, because who wants to watch people fucking for two hours?

Objectification is a very specific thing as regards sex. To objectify is to render less than human, to make something inanimate, lifeless. To have a single task, to be used as a tool. As a thing to be achieved or gained or possessed, bought and sold; a commodity.

Mainstream heteronormative porn mainly espouses a chauvinistic male point of view. In that view, women are usually objects. And since the women are the main subject of such porn, there's no focus on the guy, either - so both often seem like objects.

Porn in itself is an object, similar to a painting or piece of music. And also like art, the point is not to objectify the subject - it's to identify with the subject. What one does after that is particular to the person. Maybe you fall in love with the person on the screen? Hate them? Imagine a past lover who looks similar? Not everyone sees porn subjects as objects. Sometimes people want beautiful art, or escape. They don't necessarily want to see two machines banging into one another for an hour.

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by coldtea on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @10:32AM (#15124528)
>Objectification is a very specific thing as regards sex. To objectify is to render less than human, to make something inanimate, lifeless. To have a single task, to be used as a tool.

And when you want to just fuck, whether you are a man or woman or anything else, that's exactly what you want.

When you want love and cuddling and connecting, that's another story (and you can even be the same person that in other instances wanted to just fuck. In fact usually that's the case).

But somehow those that want to just fuck, and thus seek in the other just that, are supposed to be made to feel guilty -- even if the other doesn't mind, and wants just that themselves.

>Mainstream heteronormative porn mainly espouses a chauvinistic male point of view.

That's the whole point. Porn is about pleasure. The "chauvinistic male point of view" provides pleasure to the majority (mainstream) of males.

Porn is not about expanding your mind and connecting with the Other and the magic of the universe. It's also not about empowering etc -- any more than cooking is about empowering eaters.

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by peterwwillis on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @11:19AM (#15124855)

  > > Objectification is a very specific thing as regards sex. To objectify
  > > is to render less than human, to make something inanimate, lifeless.
  > > To have a single task, to be used as a tool.
  
  > And when you want to just fuck, whether you are a man or woman or
  > anything else, that's exactly what you want.
"Just wanting to fuck" is not objectification. I can want to fuck someone without dehumanizing them. Implying that "just wanting to fuck" is the same as objectification, for everyone, all the time, is really not healthy.

  > But somehow those that want to just fuck, and thus seek in the other
  > just that, are supposed to be made to feel guilty -- even if the
  > other doesn't mind
I haven't mentioned guilt or shame at all. I think you're projecting something else into my comment.

  > That's the whole point. Porn is about pleasure. The 
  > "chauvinistic male point of view" provides pleasure to the majority
  > (mainstream) of males.
It's pleasurable to you. It's not so pleasurable to someone else if they become the subject of your objectification fantasy without agreeing to that. And it's not so pleasurable to large segments of society who then become targets of behaviors learned from watching only this kind of porn.

..... which is the entire point being addressed by the business mentioned at the top of the article. But anyway.....

  > Porn is not about expanding your mind and connecting with the Other
  > and the magic of the universe. It's also not about empowering etc
  > -- any more than cooking is about empowering eaters.
This is your view and personal opinion. It doesn't apply to everyone else.
Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by coldtea on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @11:39AM (#15133044)
>It's pleasurable to you. It's not so pleasurable to someone else if they become the subject of your objectification fantasy without agreeing to that.

Fantasies are personal. And if you mean the porn actors, they are paid and are into the whole thing (if they are not, that's of course another story). So what someone's fantasies are, is no business of anybody else -- and no one's agreement is required.

>And it's not so pleasurable to large segments of society who then become targets of behaviors learned from watching only this kind of porn.

Porn didn't exist when cavemen raped women. Besides, should we extend the same concern to video games, movies, literature, etc? How about we add violence to it? I, for one, wouldn't find it "pleasurable" to become target of behaviors someone learned in a street fighting video game or a FPS.

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by elorant on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @06:23AM (#15123303)
Between having sex only if you intent to marry her and having sex without even kissing her once there is a whole world of difference. I don't know about you, but I can't have sex without kissing my partner, even if it's a one night stand. I mean come on, women aren't just objects of pleasure. They're human beings. What's wrong in treating them like so? Does it degrade the whole experience? I think not, quite the opposite. Treat women with respect. And then go and have sex as bizarre as you like or whatever.

In porn women are just objects. Or at least, in the mainstream str8 porn.

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by coldtea on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @07:43AM (#15123592)
>Between having sex only if you intent to marry her and having sex without even kissing her once there is a whole world of difference.

A world which is nobody's business between consenting adults.

>* I don't know about you, but I can't have sex without kissing my partner, even if it's a one night stand. I mean come on, women aren't just objects of pleasure.*

Is this based on the false premises that: (1) kissing isn't pleasurable as well, or (2) they don't kiss in porn?

>I mean come on, women aren't just objects of pleasure. They're human beings. What's wrong in treating them like so?

What's wrong is that it doesn't mean anything. Wanting to fuck someone (and just that) doesn't mean you treat them inhumanely or that there's no respect. What would respect entail? Asking about their life story?

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by rootlocus on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @08:59AM (#15123940)
> What would respect entail?

I hope you're not serious. Respect means knowing and respecting boundaries. It means ensuring the other person feels safe and comfortable.

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by coldtea on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @10:37AM (#15124566)
I hope you're serious yourself in return.

Where in seeking the other (or same) sex for pleasure and sex only did you see a lack of respect?

It's just a limited goal oriented interaction. It doesn't mean you beat them or cuss at them or threaten them or make them discomfortable.

It's like in some people's mind there's only love and cuddling and/or relationships where respect is possible, whereas casual sex is some unsafe and dangerous realm, if not close to rape.

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by lagadu on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @08:27AM (#15123803)
> Because porn objectifies women.

Next time I open a porn video that features no women at all, I'll be sure to take a moment to appreciate how it's objectifying women.

Regardless of your false statement, porn objectifies everyone involved. That's the point of porn in the same way that hooking up with someone for a night and going about your business the following day objectifies both of you. There's nothing wrong with being sexually interested in someone else and nothing else.

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by draugadrotten on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @04:52AM (#15122978)
> Because porn objectifies women

Gay porn invalidates your argument.

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by dagw on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @05:00AM (#15123011)
This isn't math. A counter-example doesn't invalidate the whole argument.
Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by tallanvor on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @05:13AM (#15123057)
It does if the argument is being made in absolutes.

You could say "some porn objectifies women", or even "most porn targeted at straight men objectifies women", but making the claim that porn in general objectifies women is patently false.

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by coldtea on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @06:21AM (#15123298)
>It does if the argument is being made in absolutes

Casual talk is not dealing in absolutes. We're not speaking in theorems and axioms. Even if someone says "people are idiots" they don't mean "X, for every X where X a person, is an idiot".

Note how they didn't even say "all porn": just "porn objectifies women". In casual speak even saying "all X does Y" is not necessarily intended to convey "absolutely all X". Just saying "X does Y" even less so.

>You could say "some porn objectifies women", or even "most porn targeted at straight men objectifies women", but making the claim that porn in general objectifies women is patently false.

No, it's perfectly OK (if a little beyond the point, see my other answer).

Here's how to read the phrase of the parent in casual conversation:

Porn objectifies women (when there are women in it -- DUH!). Most porn, that is -- some special snowflake outlier porn with women in it might not objectify them, and that's ok (DUH!). I'm talking about what generally happens, and what people actually get to see most of the time when they watch porn, not what some Peruvian feminist porn might show (DUH!). I also know there's animal porn, which obviously doesn't objectify women (DUH!)

In general, if how one interprets a conversational statement can be taken down by the addition of a few "DUH!", then probably this is not the interpretation intended by the original speaker. That's the "principle of charity".

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by eeZah7Ux on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @06:42AM (#15123365)
> Even if someone says "people are idiots"

You are cherry-picking an example when the speaker belongs to the category.

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by Chris2048 on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @06:36AM (#15123347)
> if someone says "people are idiots" they don't mean "X, for every X...

It can do, it depends on context. When a statement is ambiguous, you have to infer meaning from context.

> That's the "principle of charity".

What about the "principle of unambiguous speech"? If a conversational statement can be taken down with a few "DUH!", people will try harder to be precise in their communication.

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by coldtea on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @07:45AM (#15123607)
>It can do, it depends on context. When a statement is ambiguous, you have to infer meaning from context.

That's the whole art of casual conversation -- or any conversation for that matter, even the most rigorous scientific paper depends on millions of context-based assumptions.

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by Chris2048 on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @09:58AM (#15124287)
> even the most rigorous scientific paper

There is a lot of explicit convention in science, it is not the same as general "art of casual conversation"; Scientists will likely have explicit qualification, and provide stats and data. More so for Law, were stakes are arguably even higher.

Anyway, in this case you made a absolute claim ("they don't mean") that isn't necessarily true. They can mean that.

How do you demonstrate that this isn't true, if is so subjective (an "art")? The answer, would be to incentivise clear, unambiguous language; at least in technical, specific conversations.

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by coldtea on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @10:26AM (#15124479)
>Anyway, in this case you made a absolute claim ("they don't mean") that isn't necessarily true. They can mean that.

I made it in casual conversation myself. They can -- it's physically possible. But generally (statistically significantly) they don't.

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by Chris2048 on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @12:17PM (#15125316)
> But generally they don't

I don't think so, and neither did the original respondent.

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by coldtea on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @01:36PM (#15126045)
Well, you're allowed to your opinion.

But I've never seen anybody mention say something about members of a group, ethnicity, nationality, whatever, etc in casual conversation and really mean it absolutely applies to everybody in that set with no exceptions (e.g. "Scots are stingy" or "Californians are into health").

And when I say "never seen anybody", consistent with my rule, I mean "I only seen very few do that".

So, I'm sure you can find some counter-examples. But do you really believe what I say is not true in the large majority of cases?

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by Chris2048 on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @02:45PM (#15126628)
You didn't say "women are X", you said "porn is X", so it could be a categorical statement about the nature of porn.

I believe what is is less important that what can be. Bitcoin/freenet/bitorrent is used heavily for shady and/or illegal business - that needn't be the case in the future.

"porn objectifies women" is a fairly loaded term, that incorporates, on average, a lot of assumption about what that means, and why it is relevant. The context is a large effort by certain groups, trying to prove porn is "harmful" - the objectification argument is the latest round of arguments against porn.

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by coldtea on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @11:36AM (#15133013)
>You didn't say "women are X", you said "porn is X", so it could be a categorical statement about the nature of porn.

I fail to see the difference between "women are X" and "porn is X". Both are statements of the type "Y is X".

Furthermore, my point is that categorical statements in casual conversation mean "most, the majority etc", unlike categorical statements in formal logic.

>"porn objectifies women" is a fairly loaded term, that incorporates, on average, a lot of assumption about what that means, and why it is relevant. The context is a large effort by certain groups, trying to prove porn is "harmful" - the objectification argument is the latest round of arguments against porn.

Whether "porn objectifies women" is true or not is orthogonal to what I discussed here: that someone saying "porn objectifies women" doesn't mean "all porn ever made with no exception objectifies women" -- and thus their point can't be shut down with a mere counter-example (like several parent commenters here did).

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by Chris2048 on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @12:49PM (#15133703)
> I fail to see the difference..

But you said "something about members of a group". Y in the first case is a group (a population), Y in the second case is not.

Maybe statements about people, or groups of people, conventionally refer to the average, mean etc. but not necessarily about concepts such as "porn".

> orthogonal to what I discussed here..

Your last comment says "do you really believe.." so I stated my opinion in response to that.

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by briandear on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @06:53AM (#15123407)
Porn objectifies everyone.
Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by notyourday on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @08:04AM (#15123678)
> Because porn objectifies women.

Being sexually harassed at work objectifies women.

Re:The Difficulties of Running a Sex-Inspired Startup by wodenokoto on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @09:00AM (#15123944)
But if you are selling tea, you shouldn't be afraid of taking investment from traditional coffee businesses.